Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2604.18720

Exponentially-improved effective descriptions of physical bosonic systems

Varun Upreti, Nicolás Quesada, Ulysse Chabaud

quant-phSubmitted Apr 20, 2026• Announced Apr 22, 2026• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The effective description of a bosonic quantum system identifies the minimum finite dimension required to capture its essential dynamics. This effective dimension plays an important role in the complexity of classical and quantum algorithms for learning and simulating bosonic systems. While generic bosonic states require a dimension scaling as $1/ε^2$ for a precision of approximation $ε$, here we identify a natural energy condition which allows us to improve this scaling exponentially to $\log(1/ε)$. We then prove that most bosonic quantum states satisfy this condition, and in particular those produced by combining Gaussian dynamics with generic energy-preserving dynamics, which include the output states of universal bosonic quantum circuits. We apply this finding to enhance learning algorithms for bosonic quantum states and we further obtain new classical simulation algorithms for a large class of bosonic systems. Finally, using efficient decompositions of Kerr gates as sums of Gaussian gates, we significantly refine these classical simulation algorithms for universal bosonic quantum circuits. Our results demonstrate that physical bosonic systems are significantly more well-behaved than previously assumed, allowing for efficient descriptions even at high precision.

Comments
11 pages main text, 26 pages supplementary material and 1 figure

Related papers

Bounding the computational power of bosonic systems

Varun Upreti, Dorian Rudolph, Ulysse Chabaud

Abstract Bosonic quantum systems operate in an infinite-dimensional Hilbert space, unlike discrete-variable quantum systems. This distinct mathematical structure leads to fundamental differences in quantum information processing, such as exponentially greater complexity of state tomography 1 and factoring in constant space 2 . Yet, it remains unclear whether this structural difference may translate to a practical computational advantage over finite-dimensional quantum computers. Here we take a step towards answering this question by showing that universal bosonic quantum computations can be simulated in polynomial space (and exponential time) on a classical computer, improving the previous best upper bound requiring exponential memory 3 . In complexity-theoretic terms, we improve the best upper bound on CVBQP with at most exponential energy from EXPSPACE to PSPACE. This result is achieved using a simulation strategy based on finite energy cutoffs and approximate coherent state decompositions. While we propose ways to potentially refine this bound, we also present arguments supporting the plausibility of an exponential computational advantage of bosonic quantum computers over their discrete-variable counterparts. Furthermore, we emphasize the role of circuit energy as a resource and discuss why it may act as the fundamental bottleneck in realizing this advantage in practice.

arXiv:2503.03600•npj Quantum Information•May 15, 2026•14 citations

Effective descriptions of bosonic systems can be considered complete

Francesco Arzani, Robert I. Booth, Ulysse Chabaud

Bosonic statistics give rise to remarkable phenomena, from the Hong-Ou-Mandel effect to Bose-Einstein condensation, with applications spanning fundamental science to quantum technologies. Modeling bosonic systems relies heavily on effective descriptions: typically, truncating their infinite-dimensional state space or restricting their dynamics to a simple class of Hamiltonians, such as polynomials of canonical operators. However, many natural bosonic Hamiltonians do not belong to these simple classes, and some quantum effects harnessed by bosonic computers inherently require infinite-dimensional spaces. Can we trust that results obtained with such simplifying assumptions capture real effects? We solve this outstanding problem, showing that these effective descriptions do correctly capture the physics of bosonic systems. Our technical contributions are twofold: firstly, we prove that any physical bosonic unitary evolution can be accurately approximated by a finite-dimensional unitary evolution; secondly, we show that any finite-dimensional unitary evolution can be generated exactly by a bosonic Hamiltonian that is a polynomial of canonical operators. Beyond their fundamental significance, our results have implications for classical and quantum simulations of bosonic systems, provide universal methods for engineering bosonic quantum states and Hamiltonians, show that polynomial Hamiltonians generate universal gate sets for quantum computing over bosonic modes, and lead to a bosonic Solovay-Kitaev theorem.

arXiv:2501.13857•Nature Communications•Nov 6, 2025•22 citations

A physical and universal model of bosonic computations with Solovay-Kitaev theorem

Dorian Rudolph, Arsalan Motamedi, Dhruva Sambrani +4 more

Bosonic quantum systems are among the leading architectures for quantum information processing, offering continuous-variable degrees of freedom with strong error-correction capabilities. However, standard bosonic quantum computation models such as the Lloyd-Braunstein [Lloyd and Braunstein, 1999] and hybrid oscillator-qubit models [Brenner, Dias, and Koenig, 2025; Liu et al., 2026] permit dramatic energy growth, leading to unphysical computational power and the breakdown of fundamental algorithmic tools such as universal and efficient compilation [Brenner et al., 2026; Rudolph et al., 2025]. To address this, we introduce a new model of bosonic quantum computation, Bosonic Energy-Preserving Quantum Computation (BEQC), in which energy is treated as a computational resource. Namely, energy is supplied solely through input coherent states, and all gates are generated by energy-preserving Hamiltonians. Thus, by construction, dramatic energy growth is impossible, making the model physically grounded. We next show that BEQC is a computationally robust and universal model in many respects, including: (1. Computational power) BEQC efficiently simulates all polynomial-energy computations in existing models, and exactly recovers BQP in the polynomial energy setting. It further admits several complexity-theoretic upper bounds when varying the energy, precision, and space parameters of the model. (2. Universal gate sets and state synthesis) BEQC has natural universal gate sets based on linear optics and Kerr interactions. In particular, we obtain a Solovay-Kitaev theorem which circumvents previous no-go results. We give various applications, including (a) a protocol for engineering GKP states with rigorous preparation guarantees, (b) Fock state preparation to exponential precision, and (c) native Fock space simulation of any qubit-based unitary.

quant-pharXiv:2609.40226•Oct 1, 2026•1 citation

Exponentially improved efficient machine learning for quantum many-body states with provable guarantees

Yanming Che, Clemens Gneiting, Franco Nori

Solving the ground state and the ground-state properties of quantum many-body systems is generically a hard task for classical algorithms. For a family of Hamiltonians defined on an m -dimensional space of physical parameters, the ground state and its properties at an arbitrary parameter configuration can be predicted via a machine learning protocol up to a prescribed prediction error ɛ , provided that a sample set (of size N ) of the states can be efficiently prepared and measured. In a recent work [Huang , ], a rigorous guarantee for such a generalization was proved. Unfortunately, an exponential scaling for the provable sample complexity, N = m O ( 1 ɛ ) , was found to be universal for generic gapped Hamiltonians. This result applies to the situation where the dimension of the parameter space is large, while the scaling with the accuracy is not an urgent factor, not entering the realm of more precise learning and prediction. In this work, we consider an alternative relevant scenario, where the effective dimension m is a finite, not necessarily large constant, while the scaling with the prediction error becomes the central concern. By jointly preserving the fundamental properties of density matrices in the learning protocol and utilizing the continuity of quantum states in the parameter range of interest, we rigorously obtain a polynomial sample complexity for predicting quantum many-body states and their properties, with respect to the prediction error ɛ and the number of qubits, n , with N = poly ( ɛ − 1 , n , ln 1 δ ) , where poly denotes a polynomial function, and ( 1 − δ ) is the probability of success. Moreover, if restricted to learning local quantum-state properties, the number of samples can be further reduced to N = poly ( ɛ − 1 , ln n δ ) . Numerical demonstrations confirm our findings, and an alternative approach utilizing statistical learning theory with reproducing kernel Hilbert space achieves consistent results. The mere continuity assumption indicates that our results are not restricted to gapped Hamiltonian systems and properties within the same phase. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2304.04353•Physical Review Research•Jul 8, 2024•14 citations

Coherent-State Propagation: A Computational Framework for Simulating Bosonic Quantum Systems

Nikita Guseynov, Zoë Holmes, Armando Angrisani

We introduce coherent-state propagation, a computational framework for simulating bosonic systems. We focus on bosonic circuits composed of displaced linear optics augmented by Kerr nonlinearities, a universal model of bosonic quantum computation that is also physically motivated by driven Bose-Hubbard dynamics. The method works in the Schrödinger picture representing the evolving state as a sparse superposition of coherent states. We develop approximation strategies that keep the simulation cost tractable in physically relevant regimes, notably when the number of Kerr gates is small or the Kerr nonlinearities are weak, and prove rigorous guarantees for both observable estimation and sampling. In particular, bosonic circuits with logarithmically many Kerr gates admit quasi-polynomial-time classical simulation at exponentially small error in trace distance. We further identify a weak-nonlinearity regime in which the runtime is polynomial for arbitrarily small constant precision. We complement these results with numerical benchmarks on the Bose-Hubbard model with all-to-all connectivity. The method reproduces Fock-basis and matrix-product-state reference data, suggesting that it offers a useful route to the classical simulation of bosonic systems.

quant-pharXiv:2604.19625•Apr 22, 2026•6 citations

Robust exponential lower bounds for fermionic and bosonic Gaussian ranks

Fuchuan Wei, Kong-Wing Wu, Zhengwei Liu +1 more

The power and limitations of classical simulation are central to understanding quantum computational advantages. A leading simulation paradigm is based on coherent decomposition into classically tractable free states where the decomposition rank determines the simulation complexity. Proving strong lower bounds on this number is a notoriously difficult and mathematically rich problem, as exemplified by the qubit stabilizer rank problem. Here, we study the Gaussian version of this problem in both bosonic and fermionic systems and establish robust exponential lower bounds on Gaussian rank. In particular, we prove that for every pure non-Gaussian state on finitely many modes, with definite parity in the fermionic case, the approximate border Gaussian rank of its tensor powers grows at least exponentially at any fixed norm error below one. Our proofs combine reduction to four modes with Majorana spectral bounds for fermions, and Gaussian postselection with an entropy-based rank bound for bosons. As concrete examples, we derive explicit exponential lower bounds for the four-mode fermionic GHZ state and the bosonic single-photon state. The bosonic results require no assumption on the energy of the target state. Our results show that non-Gaussianity universally entails exponential Gaussian decomposition complexity, setting fundamental limitations on decomposition-based classical simulation of bosonic and fermionic systems.

quant-pharXiv:2610.02172•Oct 2, 2026•3 citations
The effective description of a bosonic quantum system identifies the minimum finite dimension required to capture its essential dynamics. This effective dimension plays an important role in the complexity of classical and quantum algorithms for learning and simulating bosonic systems. While generic bosonic states require a dimension scaling as 1/ε21/ε^21/ε2 for a precision of approximation εεε, here we identify a natural energy condition which allows us to improve this scaling exponentially to log⁡(1/ε)\log(1/ε)log(1/ε). We then prove that most bosonic quantum states satisfy this condition, and in particular those produced by combining Gaussian dynamics with generic energy-preserving dynamics, which include the output states of universal bosonic quantum circuits. We apply this finding to enhance learning algorithms for bosonic quantum states and we further obtain new classical simulation algorithms for a large class of bosonic systems. Finally, using efficient decompositions of Kerr gates as sums of Gaussian gates, we significantly refine these classical simulation algorithms for universal bosonic quantum circuits. Our results demonstrate that physical bosonic systems are significantly more well-behaved than previously assumed, allowing for efficient descriptions even at high precision.
Abstract Bosonic quantum systems operate in an infinite-dimensional Hilbert space, unlike discrete-variable quantum systems. This distinct mathematical structure leads to fundamental differences in quantum information processing, such as exponentially greater complexity of state tomography 1 and factoring in constant space 2 . Yet, it remains unclear whether this structural difference may translate to a practical computational advantage over finite-dimensional quantum computers. Here we take a step towards answering this question by showing that universal bosonic quantum computations can be simulated in polynomial space (and exponential time) on a classical computer, improving the previous best upper bound requiring exponential memory 3 . In complexity-theoretic terms, we improve the best upper bound on CVBQP with at most exponential energy from EXPSPACE to PSPACE. This result is achieved using a simulation strategy based on finite energy cutoffs and approximate coherent state decompositions. While we propose ways to potentially refine this bound, we also present arguments supporting the plausibility of an exponential computational advantage of bosonic quantum computers over their discrete-variable counterparts. Furthermore, we emphasize the role of circuit energy as a resource and discuss why it may act as the fundamental bottleneck in realizing this advantage in practice.
Bosonic statistics give rise to remarkable phenomena, from the Hong-Ou-Mandel effect to Bose-Einstein condensation, with applications spanning fundamental science to quantum technologies. Modeling bosonic systems relies heavily on effective descriptions: typically, truncating their infinite-dimensional state space or restricting their dynamics to a simple class of Hamiltonians, such as polynomials of canonical operators. However, many natural bosonic Hamiltonians do not belong to these simple classes, and some quantum effects harnessed by bosonic computers inherently require infinite-dimensional spaces. Can we trust that results obtained with such simplifying assumptions capture real effects? We solve this outstanding problem, showing that these effective descriptions do correctly capture the physics of bosonic systems. Our technical contributions are twofold: firstly, we prove that any physical bosonic unitary evolution can be accurately approximated by a finite-dimensional unitary evolution; secondly, we show that any finite-dimensional unitary evolution can be generated exactly by a bosonic Hamiltonian that is a polynomial of canonical operators. Beyond their fundamental significance, our results have implications for classical and quantum simulations of bosonic systems, provide universal methods for engineering bosonic quantum states and Hamiltonians, show that polynomial Hamiltonians generate universal gate sets for quantum computing over bosonic modes, and lead to a bosonic Solovay-Kitaev theorem.
Bosonic quantum systems are among the leading architectures for quantum information processing, offering continuous-variable degrees of freedom with strong error-correction capabilities. However, standard bosonic quantum computation models such as the Lloyd-Braunstein [Lloyd and Braunstein, 1999] and hybrid oscillator-qubit models [Brenner, Dias, and Koenig, 2025; Liu et al., 2026] permit dramatic energy growth, leading to unphysical computational power and the breakdown of fundamental algorithmic tools such as universal and efficient compilation [Brenner et al., 2026; Rudolph et al., 2025]. To address this, we introduce a new model of bosonic quantum computation, Bosonic Energy-Preserving Quantum Computation (BEQC), in which energy is treated as a computational resource. Namely, energy is supplied solely through input coherent states, and all gates are generated by energy-preserving Hamiltonians. Thus, by construction, dramatic energy growth is impossible, making the model physically grounded. We next show that BEQC is a computationally robust and universal model in many respects, including: (1. Computational power) BEQC efficiently simulates all polynomial-energy computations in existing models, and exactly recovers BQP in the polynomial energy setting. It further admits several complexity-theoretic upper bounds when varying the energy, precision, and space parameters of the model. (2. Universal gate sets and state synthesis) BEQC has natural universal gate sets based on linear optics and Kerr interactions. In particular, we obtain a Solovay-Kitaev theorem which circumvents previous no-go results. We give various applications, including (a) a protocol for engineering GKP states with rigorous preparation guarantees, (b) Fock state preparation to exponential precision, and (c) native Fock space simulation of any qubit-based unitary.
Solving the ground state and the ground-state properties of quantum many-body systems is generically a hard task for classical algorithms. For a family of Hamiltonians defined on an m -dimensional space of physical parameters, the ground state and its properties at an arbitrary parameter configuration can be predicted via a machine learning protocol up to a prescribed prediction error ɛ , provided that a sample set (of size N ) of the states can be efficiently prepared and measured. In a recent work [Huang , ], a rigorous guarantee for such a generalization was proved. Unfortunately, an exponential scaling for the provable sample complexity, N = m O ( 1 ɛ ) , was found to be universal for generic gapped Hamiltonians. This result applies to the situation where the dimension of the parameter space is large, while the scaling with the accuracy is not an urgent factor, not entering the realm of more precise learning and prediction. In this work, we consider an alternative relevant scenario, where the effective dimension m is a finite, not necessarily large constant, while the scaling with the prediction error becomes the central concern. By jointly preserving the fundamental properties of density matrices in the learning protocol and utilizing the continuity of quantum states in the parameter range of interest, we rigorously obtain a polynomial sample complexity for predicting quantum many-body states and their properties, with respect to the prediction error ɛ and the number of qubits, n , with N = poly ( ɛ − 1 , n , ln 1 δ ) , where poly denotes a polynomial function, and ( 1 − δ ) is the probability of success. Moreover, if restricted to learning local quantum-state properties, the number of samples can be further reduced to N = poly ( ɛ − 1 , ln n δ ) . Numerical demonstrations confirm our findings, and an alternative approach utilizing statistical learning theory with reproducing kernel Hilbert space achieves consistent results. The mere continuity assumption indicates that our results are not restricted to gapped Hamiltonian systems and properties within the same phase. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
We introduce coherent-state propagation, a computational framework for simulating bosonic systems. We focus on bosonic circuits composed of displaced linear optics augmented by Kerr nonlinearities, a universal model of bosonic quantum computation that is also physically motivated by driven Bose-Hubbard dynamics. The method works in the Schrödinger picture representing the evolving state as a sparse superposition of coherent states. We develop approximation strategies that keep the simulation cost tractable in physically relevant regimes, notably when the number of Kerr gates is small or the Kerr nonlinearities are weak, and prove rigorous guarantees for both observable estimation and sampling. In particular, bosonic circuits with logarithmically many Kerr gates admit quasi-polynomial-time classical simulation at exponentially small error in trace distance. We further identify a weak-nonlinearity regime in which the runtime is polynomial for arbitrarily small constant precision. We complement these results with numerical benchmarks on the Bose-Hubbard model with all-to-all connectivity. The method reproduces Fock-basis and matrix-product-state reference data, suggesting that it offers a useful route to the classical simulation of bosonic systems.
The power and limitations of classical simulation are central to understanding quantum computational advantages. A leading simulation paradigm is based on coherent decomposition into classically tractable free states where the decomposition rank determines the simulation complexity. Proving strong lower bounds on this number is a notoriously difficult and mathematically rich problem, as exemplified by the qubit stabilizer rank problem. Here, we study the Gaussian version of this problem in both bosonic and fermionic systems and establish robust exponential lower bounds on Gaussian rank. In particular, we prove that for every pure non-Gaussian state on finitely many modes, with definite parity in the fermionic case, the approximate border Gaussian rank of its tensor powers grows at least exponentially at any fixed norm error below one. Our proofs combine reduction to four modes with Majorana spectral bounds for fermions, and Gaussian postselection with an entropy-based rank bound for bosons. As concrete examples, we derive explicit exponential lower bounds for the four-mode fermionic GHZ state and the bosonic single-photon state. The bosonic results require no assumption on the energy of the target state. Our results show that non-Gaussianity universally entails exponential Gaussian decomposition complexity, setting fundamental limitations on decomposition-based classical simulation of bosonic and fermionic systems.