Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2604.06412

Strong nonlocality with more imaginarity and less entanglement

Subrata Bera, Indranil Biswas, Atanu Bhunia, Indrani Chattopadhyay, Debasis Sarkar

quant-phSubmitted Apr 7, 2026• Announced Apr 9, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Complex numbers are central to the formulation of quantum mechanics, yet their role as a genuine resource is only beginning to be understood. In this work, we demonstrate that quantum states with intrinsically complex amplitudes provide a fundamental advantage in state discrimination. We construct a set of five orthogonal three qubit pure states and show that the set is strongly nonlocal if and only if it includes imaginary components. Such a set becomes locally indistinguishable not only under local measurements but also against bipartite joint measurements. This enhanced robustness makes imaginarity a valuable resource for quantum cryptography since information encoded in these states remains secure against collaborative group attacks. Our results highlight a new operational role of complex numbers in quantum theory and establish imaginarity as a key enabler of cryptographic security. However, we reconstruct the set by replacing the only product state with a biseparable state whose shared entanglement between two parties nullifies the effect of imaginarity in exhibiting strong nonlocality. In fact, we show how entangling correlations between two distant parties can dilute the effect of imaginarity, and conversely, how imaginarity itself can mimic the role of entanglement. Nevertheless, the set spans a locally indistinguishable subspace, while its complement, in turn, produces distillable genuine entanglement. Notably, this is the smallest possible Unextendible Biseparable Basis (UBB) that resolves the open problem regarding the existence of a UBB of cardinality $d^2+d-1$ in $d^{\otimes 3}$. Our construction yields a highly powerful set, rich in resources from multiple perspectives of quantum information theory, including many-copy discrimination, unambiguous identification, entanglement creation from product state, and non-entangling perturbations.

Comments
17 pages, 3 figures, latex2e, comments welcome

Related papers

Operational Resource Theory of Imaginarity

Kang‐Da Wu, Tulja Varun Kondra, Swapan Rana +5 more

Wave-particle duality is one of the basic features of quantum mechanics, giving rise to the use of complex numbers in describing states of quantum systems and their dynamics and interaction. Since the inception of quantum theory, it has been debated whether complex numbers are essential or whether an alternative consistent formulation is possible using real numbers only. Here, we attack this long-standing problem theoretically and experimentally, using the powerful tools of quantum resource theories. We show that, under reasonable assumptions, quantum states are easier to create and manipulate if they only have real elements. This gives an operational meaning to the resource theory of imaginarity. We identify and answer several important questions, which include the state-conversion problem for all qubit states and all pure states of any dimension and the approximate imaginarity distillation for all quantum states. As an application, we show that imaginarity plays a crucial role in state discrimination, that is, there exist real quantum states that can be perfectly distinguished via local operations and classical communication but that cannot be distinguished with any nonzero probability if one of the parties has no access to imaginarity. We confirm this phenomenon experimentally with linear optics, discriminating different two-photon quantum states by local projective measurements. Our results prove that complex numbers are an indispensable part of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2007.14847•Physical Review Letters•Mar 1, 2021•179 citations

Unextendible entangled bases and more nonlocality with less entanglement

Saronath Halder, Ujjwal Sen

We consider a general version of the phenomenon of more nonlocality with less entanglement within the framework of the unambiguous (i.e., conclusive) quantum state discrimination problem under local quantum operations and classical communication. We show that although the phenomenon was obtained before for two qutrits, it can also be observed for two qubits, whereas still being at the single-copy level. We establish that the phenomenon is intrinsically connected to the concept of unextendible entangled bases in the two-qubit case. In the process, we demonstrate a hierarchy of nonlocality among sets of two-qubit orthogonal pure states where the ``nonlocality'' is in the sense of a difference between global and local abilities of quantum state discrimination. We present a complete characterization of two-qubit pure orthogonal state sets of cardinality three with respect to their nonlocality in terms of unambiguous local distinguishability, the status for other cardinalities being already known. The results are potentially useful for secure quantum communication technologies with an optimal amount of resources.

arXiv:2103.09140•Physical Review A•Mar 23, 2022•7 citations

Genuinely entangled subspaces and strongly nonlocal unextendible biseparable bases in four-partite systems

Huaqi Zhou, Ting Gao, Fengli Yan

A set of orthogonal pure states is an unextendible biseparable basis (UBB), which means that its complementary subspace contains only genuinely entangled states. UBBs thus serve as an effective tool for constructing genuinely entangled subspaces. If every state within such a subspace exhibits distillable entanglement across all bipartitions, it becomes particularly advantageous for applications in quantum information. In this paper, we mainly conduct research on the 4-qudit quantum systems, where the local dimension $d$ is not less than 3. We present an approach for constructing UBB and prove that the UBB established in this way is strongly nonlocal. We build several genuinely entangled subspaces and demonstrate the distillability of the genuinely entangled subspaces across all bipartitions. In addition, we also describe the specific orthonormal basis for some genuinely entangled subspaces. These results will not only contribute to the development of quantum nonlocality theory, but also provide a crucial theoretical foundation for practical quantum information processing tasks.

quant-pharXiv:2603.09040•Chinese Journal of Physics•Mar 11, 2026•0 citations

Strong quantum nonlocality: Unextendible biseparability beyond unextendible product basis

Atanu Bhunia, Subrata Bera, Indranil Biswas +2 more

An unextendible biseparable basis (UBB) is a set of orthogonal pure biseparable states which span a subspace of a given Hilbert space while the complementary subspace contains only genuinely entangled states. These biseparable bases are useful to produce genuinely entangled subspace in a multipartite system. Such a subspace could be more beneficial for information theoretic applications if we were able to extract distillable entanglement across every bipartition from each state of this subspace. In this paper, we have derived a rule for constructing such a class of UBB which exhibits the phenomenon of strong quantum nonlocality. This result positively answers the open problem raised by Agrawal et al. [Agrawal, Halder, and Banik, Genuinely entangled subspace with all-encompassing distillable entanglement across every bipartition, Phys. Rev. A 99, 032335 (2019)], that there exists a UBB which can demonstrate the phenomenon of strong quantum nonlocality in the perspective of the local irreducibility paradigm.

arXiv:2404.05882•Physical Review A•May 10, 2024•10 citations

Genuinely entangled subspaces beyond strongly nonlocal unextendible biseparable bases

Subrata Bera, Atanu Bhunia, Indranil Biswas +2 more

Quantum information theory reveals a clear distinction between local and nonlocal correlations through the entanglement across spatially separated subsystems. The orthogonal complement of an unextendible biseparable basis (UBB) consists entirely of genuine multipartite entangled states, representing the most robust form of such nonlocal correlations. In this letter, we provide a sufficient condition for any subspace to be genuinely entangled, enabling the systematic construction of high-dimensional genuinely entangled subspaces (GESs) from UBBs. Our construction yields the largest known GES ever obtained from a UBB. In fact, every state in this subspace is 1-distillable across every bipartition which is one of the crucial result we obtained. Furthermore, we prove that every UBB is indistinguishable under LOCC protocols, underscoring a distinct manifestation of quantum nonlocality. The UBBs we construct exhibit strong nonlocality in this scenario, making cryptographic protocols secure not only against LOCC-based attacks but also against coordinated group attacks. We introduce a no-go condition that certifies such an extreme form of nonlocality. All previously known UBBs satisfy this condition, which may lead to the misconception that strong nonlocality is an inherent property of every UBB. However, we construct a UBB that violates the no-go condition and exhibits locality across certain bipartitions, challenging conventional notions of unextendibility and nonlocality in multipartite quantum systems.

arXiv:2508.17154•Physical Review A•Apr 7, 2026•2 citations

Entanglement concentration via measurement:- role of imaginarity

Indranil Biswas, Subrata Bera, Ujjwal Sen +2 more

The role of complex numbers in quantum theory extends beyond mathematical convenience, having recently been formalized as a resource under the framework of the resource theory of imaginarity. Operationally, imaginarity translates into using fewer resources in optical setups. In this work, we investigate the operational advantage offered by complex-valued measurements in the entanglement of assistance protocol for three-qubit systems. We demonstrate that employing such measurement bases leads to a significant improvement in the concentration of bipartite entanglement with the aid of the third party. We further analyze a modified entanglement swapping protocol and show that a three-qubit complex measurement bases with certain symmetries outperform the standard GHZ-basis. This is also one example where a three-qubit non-maximally entangled basis surpasses a maximally entangled one in generating entanglement. Construction of the basis also addresses the open problems raised in [Phys. Rev. A. \textbf{108}, 022220 (2023)]. As an intriguing application, we show that using this approach in quantum network percolation on a honeycomb lattice reduces the required bond occupation probability by $22.7\%$ and, requirement of entanglement by $10.6\%$ in each bond.

quant-pharXiv:2604.12796•Physical Review A•Apr 15, 2026•2 citations
Complex numbers are central to the formulation of quantum mechanics, yet their role as a genuine resource is only beginning to be understood. In this work, we demonstrate that quantum states with intrinsically complex amplitudes provide a fundamental advantage in state discrimination. We construct a set of five orthogonal three qubit pure states and show that the set is strongly nonlocal if and only if it includes imaginary components. Such a set becomes locally indistinguishable not only under local measurements but also against bipartite joint measurements. This enhanced robustness makes imaginarity a valuable resource for quantum cryptography since information encoded in these states remains secure against collaborative group attacks. Our results highlight a new operational role of complex numbers in quantum theory and establish imaginarity as a key enabler of cryptographic security. However, we reconstruct the set by replacing the only product state with a biseparable state whose shared entanglement between two parties nullifies the effect of imaginarity in exhibiting strong nonlocality. In fact, we show how entangling correlations between two distant parties can dilute the effect of imaginarity, and conversely, how imaginarity itself can mimic the role of entanglement. Nevertheless, the set spans a locally indistinguishable subspace, while its complement, in turn, produces distillable genuine entanglement. Notably, this is the smallest possible Unextendible Biseparable Basis (UBB) that resolves the open problem regarding the existence of a UBB of cardinality d2+d−1d^2+d-1d2+d−1 in d⊗3d^{\otimes 3}d⊗3. Our construction yields a highly powerful set, rich in resources from multiple perspectives of quantum information theory, including many-copy discrimination, unambiguous identification, entanglement creation from product state, and non-entangling perturbations.
Wave-particle duality is one of the basic features of quantum mechanics, giving rise to the use of complex numbers in describing states of quantum systems and their dynamics and interaction. Since the inception of quantum theory, it has been debated whether complex numbers are essential or whether an alternative consistent formulation is possible using real numbers only. Here, we attack this long-standing problem theoretically and experimentally, using the powerful tools of quantum resource theories. We show that, under reasonable assumptions, quantum states are easier to create and manipulate if they only have real elements. This gives an operational meaning to the resource theory of imaginarity. We identify and answer several important questions, which include the state-conversion problem for all qubit states and all pure states of any dimension and the approximate imaginarity distillation for all quantum states. As an application, we show that imaginarity plays a crucial role in state discrimination, that is, there exist real quantum states that can be perfectly distinguished via local operations and classical communication but that cannot be distinguished with any nonzero probability if one of the parties has no access to imaginarity. We confirm this phenomenon experimentally with linear optics, discriminating different two-photon quantum states by local projective measurements. Our results prove that complex numbers are an indispensable part of quantum mechanics.
We consider a general version of the phenomenon of more nonlocality with less entanglement within the framework of the unambiguous (i.e., conclusive) quantum state discrimination problem under local quantum operations and classical communication. We show that although the phenomenon was obtained before for two qutrits, it can also be observed for two qubits, whereas still being at the single-copy level. We establish that the phenomenon is intrinsically connected to the concept of unextendible entangled bases in the two-qubit case. In the process, we demonstrate a hierarchy of nonlocality among sets of two-qubit orthogonal pure states where the ``nonlocality'' is in the sense of a difference between global and local abilities of quantum state discrimination. We present a complete characterization of two-qubit pure orthogonal state sets of cardinality three with respect to their nonlocality in terms of unambiguous local distinguishability, the status for other cardinalities being already known. The results are potentially useful for secure quantum communication technologies with an optimal amount of resources.
A set of orthogonal pure states is an unextendible biseparable basis (UBB), which means that its complementary subspace contains only genuinely entangled states. UBBs thus serve as an effective tool for constructing genuinely entangled subspaces. If every state within such a subspace exhibits distillable entanglement across all bipartitions, it becomes particularly advantageous for applications in quantum information. In this paper, we mainly conduct research on the 4-qudit quantum systems, where the local dimension ddd is not less than 3. We present an approach for constructing UBB and prove that the UBB established in this way is strongly nonlocal. We build several genuinely entangled subspaces and demonstrate the distillability of the genuinely entangled subspaces across all bipartitions. In addition, we also describe the specific orthonormal basis for some genuinely entangled subspaces. These results will not only contribute to the development of quantum nonlocality theory, but also provide a crucial theoretical foundation for practical quantum information processing tasks.
An unextendible biseparable basis (UBB) is a set of orthogonal pure biseparable states which span a subspace of a given Hilbert space while the complementary subspace contains only genuinely entangled states. These biseparable bases are useful to produce genuinely entangled subspace in a multipartite system. Such a subspace could be more beneficial for information theoretic applications if we were able to extract distillable entanglement across every bipartition from each state of this subspace. In this paper, we have derived a rule for constructing such a class of UBB which exhibits the phenomenon of strong quantum nonlocality. This result positively answers the open problem raised by Agrawal et al. [Agrawal, Halder, and Banik, Genuinely entangled subspace with all-encompassing distillable entanglement across every bipartition, Phys. Rev. A 99, 032335 (2019)], that there exists a UBB which can demonstrate the phenomenon of strong quantum nonlocality in the perspective of the local irreducibility paradigm.
Quantum information theory reveals a clear distinction between local and nonlocal correlations through the entanglement across spatially separated subsystems. The orthogonal complement of an unextendible biseparable basis (UBB) consists entirely of genuine multipartite entangled states, representing the most robust form of such nonlocal correlations. In this letter, we provide a sufficient condition for any subspace to be genuinely entangled, enabling the systematic construction of high-dimensional genuinely entangled subspaces (GESs) from UBBs. Our construction yields the largest known GES ever obtained from a UBB. In fact, every state in this subspace is 1-distillable across every bipartition which is one of the crucial result we obtained. Furthermore, we prove that every UBB is indistinguishable under LOCC protocols, underscoring a distinct manifestation of quantum nonlocality. The UBBs we construct exhibit strong nonlocality in this scenario, making cryptographic protocols secure not only against LOCC-based attacks but also against coordinated group attacks. We introduce a no-go condition that certifies such an extreme form of nonlocality. All previously known UBBs satisfy this condition, which may lead to the misconception that strong nonlocality is an inherent property of every UBB. However, we construct a UBB that violates the no-go condition and exhibits locality across certain bipartitions, challenging conventional notions of unextendibility and nonlocality in multipartite quantum systems.
The role of complex numbers in quantum theory extends beyond mathematical convenience, having recently been formalized as a resource under the framework of the resource theory of imaginarity. Operationally, imaginarity translates into using fewer resources in optical setups. In this work, we investigate the operational advantage offered by complex-valued measurements in the entanglement of assistance protocol for three-qubit systems. We demonstrate that employing such measurement bases leads to a significant improvement in the concentration of bipartite entanglement with the aid of the third party. We further analyze a modified entanglement swapping protocol and show that a three-qubit complex measurement bases with certain symmetries outperform the standard GHZ-basis. This is also one example where a three-qubit non-maximally entangled basis surpasses a maximally entangled one in generating entanglement. Construction of the basis also addresses the open problems raised in [Phys. Rev. A. \textbf{108}, 022220 (2023)]. As an intriguing application, we show that using this approach in quantum network percolation on a honeycomb lattice reduces the required bond occupation probability by 22.7%22.7\%22.7% and, requirement of entanglement by 10.6%10.6\%10.6% in each bond.