Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2603.29614

Thermalization in high-dimensional systems: the (weak) role of chaos

Marco Baldovin, Marco Cattaneo, Dario Lucente, Paolo Muratore-Ginanneschi, Angelo Vulpiani

Published Mar 31, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In their seminal work, Fermi, Pasta, Ulam and Tsingou explored the connection between statistical mechanics and dynamical properties, such as chaos and ergodicity. Even today, seventy years later, the topic is not fully understood: while most results of statistical mechanics require the ergodic hypothesis to be rigorously proved, there are many indications that these predictions, both in and out of equilibrium, hold even in the absence of a rigorous form of ergodicity. Motivated by the above considerations, in this work we reconsider the point of view that the relevant ingredients for the validity of statistical mechanics are the large number of degrees of freedom and the choice of extensive observables, while the details of the dynamics do not play an essential role. This is the idea behind Khinchin's famous proof of the typicality of macroscopic observables at equilibrium. We extend this perspective to the context of non equilibrium, by investigating the thermalization properties of both harmonic (integrable) and nonharmonic (chaotic) oscillator chains initially prepared in out-of-equilibrium conditions. In integrable systems, thermalization occurs, or not, depending on the observable. In the chaotic regime, instead, thermalization is reached by any observable, although the relaxation timescale might be larger than the observation time.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2603.29614

Related papers

Thermalization, Chaos and Hydrodynamics in Classical Hamiltonian Systems

Santhosh Ganapa

We will discuss various aspects of thermalization, chaos and hydrodynamics in one dimensional classical Hamiltonian systems. We study two problems. First, we will revisit the Fermi-Pasta-Ulam-Tsingou (FPUT) problem in order to understand what thermalization is and discuss what leads the system starting from a typical initial condition to a thermal state. Here we discuss the various possibilities like the role of averaging, the choice of observables, the choice of initial conditions and the role of chaos in thermalization. Then, we study the evolution of a blast wave in an alternate mass hard particle (AHP) gas and study the evolution of conserved fields in the system at short times. We find a good agreement with the Taylor-von Neumann-Sedov (TvNS) solution, which was studied during the Second World War in the context of atomic explosions, everywhere except near the core of the blast. We then model this behaviour by using the Navier-Stokes-Fourier (NSF) equations.

arXiv:2305.06327•May 10, 2023•0 citations

Equilibrium and Non-equilibrium Gross-Pitaevskii Lattice Dynamics: Interactions, Disorder, and Thermalization

Yağmur Katı

The interplay of fluctuations, ergodicity, and disorder in many-body interacting systems has been striking attention for half a century, pivoted on two celebrated phenomena: Anderson localization predicted in disordered media, and Fermi-Pasta-Ulam-Tsingou (FPUT) recurrence observed in a nonlinear system. The destruction of Anderson localization by nonlinearity and the recovery of ergodicity after long enough computational times lead to more questions. This thesis is devoted to contributing to the insight of the nonlinear system dynamics in and out of equilibrium. Focusing mainly on the GP lattice, we investigated elementary fluctuations close to zero temperature, localization properties, the chaotic subdiffusive regimes, and the non-equipartition of energy in non-Gibbs regime. Initially, we probe equilibrium dynamics in the ordered GP lattice and report a weakly non-ergodic dynamics, and an ergodic part in the non-Gibbs phase that implies the Gibbs distribution should be modified. Next, we include disorder in GP lattice, and build analytical expressions for the thermodynamic properties of the ground state, and identify a Lifshits glass regime where disorder dominates over the interactions. In the opposite strong interaction regime, we investigate the elementary excitations above the ground state and found a dramatic increase of the localization length of Bogoliubov modes (BM) with increasing particle density. Finally, we study non-equilibrium dynamics with disordered GP lattice by performing novel energy and norm density resolved wave packet spreading. In particular, we observed strong chaos spreading over several decades, and identified a Lifshits phase which shows a significant slowing down of sub-diffusive spreading.

arXiv:2109.07268•Sep 13, 2021•0 citations

The Fermi-Pasta-Ulam-Tsingou problem after 70 years: toward universal laws of thermalization in lattice systems in the thermodynamic limit

Weicheng Fu, Zhen Wang, Wei Lin +4 more

The Fermi--Pasta--Ulam--Tsingou (FPUT) problem provides a paradigmatic framework for understanding thermalization in weakly nonlinear many-body Hamiltonian systems. This focused review summarizes major developments in near-integrable dynamics, wave resonances, and phonon kinetic theory, emphasizing recent results on thermalization-time scaling in nonlinear lattices. A coherent picture emerges in the thermodynamic limit based on the eigenmode properties of an appropriate integrable reference system. If the reference system has extended eigenmodes and the leading resonant or quasi-resonant processes form a sufficiently connected network, the thermalization time follows $T_{\mathrm{eq}}\propto g^{-2}$, where $g$ measures the effective deviation from integrability. This scaling is found broadly in ordered and weakly disordered lattices and is robust to dimensionality, interaction potential, integrability-breaking mechanism, and multimode initial conditions. Identifying the correct integrable reference is essential; in some one-dimensional FPUT-type lattices with cubic interactions, the nearby Toda lattice, rather than the harmonic chain, provides the proper reference. If all reference eigenmodes are localized, spatial-overlap constraints progressively fragment low-order resonance networks as $g$ decreases, and thermalization becomes controlled by higher-order processes. Numerical studies reveal successive regimes $T_{\mathrm{eq}}\propto g^{-γ}$ with $γ=2,4,6$, together with weak system-size dependence. Whether this hierarchy persists asymptotically and whether a finite thermalization threshold exists remain open questions. We also discuss finite-size effects, strongly nonintegrable dynamics, heat transport, localization, and higher-dimensional lattices.

arXiv:2603.23347•Mar 24, 2026•0 citations

Entanglement and relaxation in exactly solvable models

Oleg Valentinovich Lychkovskiy

A system put in contact with a large heat bath normally thermalizes. This means that the state of the system ρℐ(t) approaches an equilibrium state ρ eq ℐ , the latter depending only on macroscopic characteristics of the bath (e.g. temperature), but not on the initial state of the system. The above statement is the cornerstone of the equilibrium statistical mechanics; its validity and its domain of applicability are central questions in the studies of the foundations of statistical mechanics. In the present contribution we discuss the recently proven general theorems about thermalization and demonstrate how they work in exactly solvable models. In particular, we review a necessary condition for the system initial state independence (ISI) of ρ eq ℐ , which was proven in our previous work, and apply it for two exactly solvable models, the XX spin chain and a central spin model with a special interaction with the environment. In the latter case we are able to prove the absence of the system ISI. Also the Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis is discussed. It is pointed out that although it is supposed to be generically true in essentially not-integrable (chaotic) quantum systems, it is how-ever also valid in the integrable XX model.

Optics and Spectroscopy•Nov 1, 2011•1 citation

Quantum and classical chaos through adiabatic transformations

Hyeongjin Kim

The study of non-equilibrium dynamics is central to understanding how macroscopic irreversibility and thermal behavior emerge from microscopic reversible dynamics. A quintessential phenomenon that commonly occurs in non-equilibrium dynamics is the emergence of chaos. Chaos, whose theory originates from classical dynamics, is traditionally understood through a system's exponential sensitivity to initial conditions through microscopic dynamics. However, this definition does not fully capture classical and quantum many-body systems. This dissertation establishes and explores adiabatic transformations as a unifying framework for understanding chaos, integrability, and thermalization across both regimes. First, we show that the complexity of adiabatic transformations, which preserve classical time-averaged trajectories and quantum eigenstates under Hamiltonian deformations, serves as a measure of chaos. Physically, this measure quantifies the response of observables through their long-time instabilities and irregularities as manifested by their low-frequency noise. The applications of adiabatic transformations go beyond serving as a diagnostic of chaos, as they can be used to obtain a deeper understanding of the nature of chaos: a theme that drives the rest of this dissertation. Second, we uncover the geometric structure of integrability and chaos. By constructing adiabatic flows that minimize eigenstate deformations in quantum many-body systems parameterized by two independent couplings, we reveal that integrability acts as an attractor of these flows. This provides an a priori method for identifying integrable regions in complex many-body systems. Third, we investigate the timescales of thermalization and chaos in many-spin systems by studying the response of observables. We uncover a novel phenomenon, denoted as deconfined chaos, in the central spin model with XX interactions, where chaotic instabilities and thermalization occur on the same timescale. Fourth, we establish a correspondence between temperature and integrability-breaking perturbation for both classical and quantum many-spin systems. Therefore, we demonstrate that chaos is not determined solely by microscopic terms but can be renormalized by macroscopic thermodynamic temperature.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Non-equilibrium Dynamics, Thermalization and Entropy Production

Haye Hinrichsen B, Christian Gogolin, Peter Janotta

This paper addresses fundamental aspects of statistical mechanics such as the motivation of a classical state space with spontaneous transitions, the meaning of non-equilibrium in the context of thermalization, and the justification of these concepts from the quantum-mechanical point of view. After an introductory part we focus on the problem of entropy production in non-equilibrium systems. In particular, the generally accepted formula for entropy production in the environment is analyzed from a critical perspective. It is shown that this formula is only valid in the limit of separated time scales of the system's and the environmental degrees of freedom. Finally, we present an alternative simple proof of the fluctuation theorem.

arXiv:1102.0103•Journal of Physics Conference Series•May 1, 2011•16 citations
In their seminal work, Fermi, Pasta, Ulam and Tsingou explored the connection between statistical mechanics and dynamical properties, such as chaos and ergodicity. Even today, seventy years later, the topic is not fully understood: while most results of statistical mechanics require the ergodic hypothesis to be rigorously proved, there are many indications that these predictions, both in and out of equilibrium, hold even in the absence of a rigorous form of ergodicity. Motivated by the above considerations, in this work we reconsider the point of view that the relevant ingredients for the validity of statistical mechanics are the large number of degrees of freedom and the choice of extensive observables, while the details of the dynamics do not play an essential role. This is the idea behind Khinchin's famous proof of the typicality of macroscopic observables at equilibrium. We extend this perspective to the context of non equilibrium, by investigating the thermalization properties of both harmonic (integrable) and nonharmonic (chaotic) oscillator chains initially prepared in out-of-equilibrium conditions. In integrable systems, thermalization occurs, or not, depending on the observable. In the chaotic regime, instead, thermalization is reached by any observable, although the relaxation timescale might be larger than the observation time.
We will discuss various aspects of thermalization, chaos and hydrodynamics in one dimensional classical Hamiltonian systems. We study two problems. First, we will revisit the Fermi-Pasta-Ulam-Tsingou (FPUT) problem in order to understand what thermalization is and discuss what leads the system starting from a typical initial condition to a thermal state. Here we discuss the various possibilities like the role of averaging, the choice of observables, the choice of initial conditions and the role of chaos in thermalization. Then, we study the evolution of a blast wave in an alternate mass hard particle (AHP) gas and study the evolution of conserved fields in the system at short times. We find a good agreement with the Taylor-von Neumann-Sedov (TvNS) solution, which was studied during the Second World War in the context of atomic explosions, everywhere except near the core of the blast. We then model this behaviour by using the Navier-Stokes-Fourier (NSF) equations.
The interplay of fluctuations, ergodicity, and disorder in many-body interacting systems has been striking attention for half a century, pivoted on two celebrated phenomena: Anderson localization predicted in disordered media, and Fermi-Pasta-Ulam-Tsingou (FPUT) recurrence observed in a nonlinear system. The destruction of Anderson localization by nonlinearity and the recovery of ergodicity after long enough computational times lead to more questions. This thesis is devoted to contributing to the insight of the nonlinear system dynamics in and out of equilibrium. Focusing mainly on the GP lattice, we investigated elementary fluctuations close to zero temperature, localization properties, the chaotic subdiffusive regimes, and the non-equipartition of energy in non-Gibbs regime. Initially, we probe equilibrium dynamics in the ordered GP lattice and report a weakly non-ergodic dynamics, and an ergodic part in the non-Gibbs phase that implies the Gibbs distribution should be modified. Next, we include disorder in GP lattice, and build analytical expressions for the thermodynamic properties of the ground state, and identify a Lifshits glass regime where disorder dominates over the interactions. In the opposite strong interaction regime, we investigate the elementary excitations above the ground state and found a dramatic increase of the localization length of Bogoliubov modes (BM) with increasing particle density. Finally, we study non-equilibrium dynamics with disordered GP lattice by performing novel energy and norm density resolved wave packet spreading. In particular, we observed strong chaos spreading over several decades, and identified a Lifshits phase which shows a significant slowing down of sub-diffusive spreading.
The Fermi--Pasta--Ulam--Tsingou (FPUT) problem provides a paradigmatic framework for understanding thermalization in weakly nonlinear many-body Hamiltonian systems. This focused review summarizes major developments in near-integrable dynamics, wave resonances, and phonon kinetic theory, emphasizing recent results on thermalization-time scaling in nonlinear lattices. A coherent picture emerges in the thermodynamic limit based on the eigenmode properties of an appropriate integrable reference system. If the reference system has extended eigenmodes and the leading resonant or quasi-resonant processes form a sufficiently connected network, the thermalization time follows Teq∝g−2T_{\mathrm{eq}}\propto g^{-2}Teq​∝g−2, where ggg measures the effective deviation from integrability. This scaling is found broadly in ordered and weakly disordered lattices and is robust to dimensionality, interaction potential, integrability-breaking mechanism, and multimode initial conditions. Identifying the correct integrable reference is essential; in some one-dimensional FPUT-type lattices with cubic interactions, the nearby Toda lattice, rather than the harmonic chain, provides the proper reference. If all reference eigenmodes are localized, spatial-overlap constraints progressively fragment low-order resonance networks as ggg decreases, and thermalization becomes controlled by higher-order processes. Numerical studies reveal successive regimes Teq∝g−γT_{\mathrm{eq}}\propto g^{-γ}Teq​∝g−γ with γ=2,4,6γ=2,4,6γ=2,4,6, together with weak system-size dependence. Whether this hierarchy persists asymptotically and whether a finite thermalization threshold exists remain open questions. We also discuss finite-size effects, strongly nonintegrable dynamics, heat transport, localization, and higher-dimensional lattices.
A system put in contact with a large heat bath normally thermalizes. This means that the state of the system ρℐ(t) approaches an equilibrium state ρ eq ℐ , the latter depending only on macroscopic characteristics of the bath (e.g. temperature), but not on the initial state of the system. The above statement is the cornerstone of the equilibrium statistical mechanics; its validity and its domain of applicability are central questions in the studies of the foundations of statistical mechanics. In the present contribution we discuss the recently proven general theorems about thermalization and demonstrate how they work in exactly solvable models. In particular, we review a necessary condition for the system initial state independence (ISI) of ρ eq ℐ , which was proven in our previous work, and apply it for two exactly solvable models, the XX spin chain and a central spin model with a special interaction with the environment. In the latter case we are able to prove the absence of the system ISI. Also the Eigenstate Thermalization Hypothesis is discussed. It is pointed out that although it is supposed to be generically true in essentially not-integrable (chaotic) quantum systems, it is how-ever also valid in the integrable XX model.
The study of non-equilibrium dynamics is central to understanding how macroscopic irreversibility and thermal behavior emerge from microscopic reversible dynamics. A quintessential phenomenon that commonly occurs in non-equilibrium dynamics is the emergence of chaos. Chaos, whose theory originates from classical dynamics, is traditionally understood through a system's exponential sensitivity to initial conditions through microscopic dynamics. However, this definition does not fully capture classical and quantum many-body systems. This dissertation establishes and explores adiabatic transformations as a unifying framework for understanding chaos, integrability, and thermalization across both regimes. First, we show that the complexity of adiabatic transformations, which preserve classical time-averaged trajectories and quantum eigenstates under Hamiltonian deformations, serves as a measure of chaos. Physically, this measure quantifies the response of observables through their long-time instabilities and irregularities as manifested by their low-frequency noise. The applications of adiabatic transformations go beyond serving as a diagnostic of chaos, as they can be used to obtain a deeper understanding of the nature of chaos: a theme that drives the rest of this dissertation. Second, we uncover the geometric structure of integrability and chaos. By constructing adiabatic flows that minimize eigenstate deformations in quantum many-body systems parameterized by two independent couplings, we reveal that integrability acts as an attractor of these flows. This provides an a priori method for identifying integrable regions in complex many-body systems. Third, we investigate the timescales of thermalization and chaos in many-spin systems by studying the response of observables. We uncover a novel phenomenon, denoted as deconfined chaos, in the central spin model with XX interactions, where chaotic instabilities and thermalization occur on the same timescale. Fourth, we establish a correspondence between temperature and integrability-breaking perturbation for both classical and quantum many-spin systems. Therefore, we demonstrate that chaos is not determined solely by microscopic terms but can be renormalized by macroscopic thermodynamic temperature.
This paper addresses fundamental aspects of statistical mechanics such as the motivation of a classical state space with spontaneous transitions, the meaning of non-equilibrium in the context of thermalization, and the justification of these concepts from the quantum-mechanical point of view. After an introductory part we focus on the problem of entropy production in non-equilibrium systems. In particular, the generally accepted formula for entropy production in the environment is analyzed from a critical perspective. It is shown that this formula is only valid in the limit of separated time scales of the system's and the environmental degrees of freedom. Finally, we present an alternative simple proof of the fluctuation theorem.