Scalable quantum characterization and error-mitigation workflows often rely on the assumption that relevant device noise and readout contamination can be adequately captured by low-weight, predominantly pairwise interactions. We report a compact hardware experiment designed to operationally distinguish pairwise-only explanations from irreducible triplet-order predictive structure. The A1/A1b protocol implements a parity-structured binary label on a 133-qubit IBM superconducting processor (ibm_torino) and analyzes the resulting data through a classical M"obius decomposition of subset mutual informations. In the A1 baseline, we observe a macroscopic triplet correlation of f(123) = 0.72609 bits (p <= 1.0e-4, permutation floor). In the strict A1b loophole-reduction follow-up, role-symmetry averaging sharply suppresses singleton leakage, modestly reduces pairwise mismatch, and preserves a large irreducible triplet term of f(123) = 0.56521 bits. Crucially, a principled pairwise maximum-entropy baseline consistent with the empirical 1- and 2-body marginals implies only f(123) ~ 6.6e-6 bits, in strong contradiction with the observed hardware data. On A1b, a classifier built exclusively from pairwise features reaches only 0.617 held-out accuracy (chance 0.5), whereas a triplet-inclusive model reaches 0.910. These results provide a concise, open-data demonstration that pairwise benchmarking proxies can be fundamentally blind to higher-order contextual structure in present-day superconducting experiments.
Comments
5 pages, 2 tables. Executed on IBM Quantum (ibm_torino). Open-source Qiskit reproducibility artifacts available via Zenodo
Scalable quantum characterization and error-mitigation workflows often rely on the assumption that relevant device noise and readout contamination can be adequately captured by low-weight, predominantly pairwise interactions. We report a compact hardware experiment designed to operationally distinguish pairwise-only explanations from irreducible triplet-order predictive structure. The A1/A1b protocol implements a parity-structured binary label on a 133-qubit IBM superconducting processor (ibm_torino) and analyzes the resulting data through a classical M"obius decomposition of subset mutual informations. In the A1 baseline, we observe a macroscopic triplet correlation of f(123) = 0.72609 bits (p <= 1.0e-4, permutation floor). In the strict A1b loophole-reduction follow-up, role-symmetry averaging sharply suppresses singleton leakage, modestly reduces pairwise mismatch, and preserves a large irreducible triplet term of f(123) = 0.56521 bits. Crucially, a principled pairwise maximum-entropy baseline consistent with the empirical 1- and 2-body marginals implies only f(123) ~ 6.6e-6 bits, in strong contradiction with the observed hardware data. On A1b, a classifier built exclusively from pairwise features reaches only 0.617 held-out accuracy (chance 0.5), whereas a triplet-inclusive model reaches 0.910. These results provide a concise, open-data demonstration that pairwise benchmarking proxies can be fundamentally blind to higher-order contextual structure in present-day superconducting experiments.
Standard device characterization protocols, such as Randomized Benchmarking (RB), typically report averaged, independent error rates per qubit. However, these methods are largely blind to correlated errors between neighbouring qubits: errors that fundamentally break the independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) noise assumptions relied upon by most quantum error correction (QEC) decoders and error mitigation strategies. In this paper, we present a measurement approach using parity-circuit canaries to estimate pairwise error correlations on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) devices. By applying spectral kernel analysis to the resulting correlation matrices, we can quantitatively assess the validity of the independent error assumption. We first validate our approach by emulating the canary protocol on publicly available surface code data from IBM Quantum hardware (ibm_fez). We then extend this proof-of-concept with directly measured, purpose-built canary circuits executed on the same backend, reproduced across independent sessions, controlled for physical adjacency and measurement batching, and shown to be inconsistent with pure estimation noise. The direct measurements confirm a significant, structural spectral violation that is not explained by neighbour-to-neighbour crosstalk alone, is present between arbitrary, chip-wide qubit pairs rather than a specific subset, and reproduces on a second, independent Heron r2 device (ibm_kingston), pointing to a mechanism inherent to the architecture rather than one installation. A three-condition diagnostic further localizes the effect specifically to the two-qubit entangling gate, showing no significant deviation from independence in isolated readout or in simultaneous single-qubit control pulses alone, and a targeted test rules out a simple, load-dependent shared-coupler-electronics mechanism. A circuit-depth scan using repeated entangling gates argues against simple depth-accumulation as the source of the larger violation seen in the original emulated proof-of-concept. Replacing the fixed entangling gate with a continuously parameterized controlled rotation shows that the correlation strength scales with the degree of entanglement produced, not merely with the entangling gate's presence, a relationship that reproduces in direction across three independent Heron r2 devices while varying substantially in absolute magnitude between them. The results also reveal a previously unreported dependence of the excess correlation on the instantaneous marginal error rate, underscoring the need for correlation-aware, dynamically calibrated diagnostics in fault-tolerant quantum computing.
Context: This manuscript belongs to the empirical hardware-validation track of the DAGI (Directed Acyclic Graph Interpretation) research program at Whytics. It provides direct experimental evidence for high-order informational thresholding, a concept central to the framework's treatment of emergent spacetime and black hole information. Abstract: The Directed Acyclic Graph Interpretation (DAGI) framework predicts that certain globally coherent variables are not locally accessible, but instead reside in irreducible high-order information structures (synergy) that become available only when sufficiently many degrees of freedom are jointly accessed. Motivated by Page-time transitions in black-hole information and by entanglement-wedge thresholds in holographic quantum error correction, we design a deliberately minimal "threshold-lock" circuit family whose measurement statistics implement a synergy-only encoding of a binary label K: all 1- and 2-bit marginals of the early radiation are (ideally) independent of K while the 3-bit prefix jointly reveals K. We execute this experiment on IBM Quantum ibm_torino with n=6 measured qubits and 2048 shots per key, alongside a "leaky" control in which low-order information is intentionally present. Using a Möbius/DAGI decomposition of the mutual information over the prefix subset lattice, we observe a sharp Page-like turn-on for the locked variant, with cumulative positive synergy dominated entirely by an intrinsic order-3 term. A bootstrap reliability sweep confirms that the locked order-3 synergy mass is statistically stable, while the leaky order-3 signal remains unstable. These results constitute a compact, falsifiable hardware demonstration that DAGI can detect and distinguish high-order, thresholded information release from low-order leakage in real quantum measurement data, supporting the use of DAGI Möbius diagnostics as experimental probes of Page-like information transitions and as design tools for DAG-inspired QECCs. Key Highlights: Hardware-Verified Thresholds: Demonstrates a distinct Page-curve-like accessibility transition on a superconducting IBM Quantum processor. Synergy vs. Leakage: Proves the efficacy of the DAGI Möbius decomposition in distinguishing true irreducible high-order synergy from low-order hardware leakage. Holographic Analogs: Provides an operational, circuit-level analog for entanglement-wedge reconstruction phenomena utilized in emergent gravity and holographic error correction.
The DAGI program uses M\"obius inversion on partially ordered sets to decompose an information observable into irreducible contributions. A central methodological question is whether the Boolean powerset is merely a convenient default, or whether the poset should be engineered to match the physical accessibility structure of the experiment. We report a hardware validation of the latter claim on IBM Quantum hardware (\texttt{ibm\_torino}). In repetition-code memory circuits with mid-circuit measurement and reset, we compare two decompositions computed on exactly the same detector-window data: a truncated subset lattice (all detector subsets with ∣S∣≤3) and a reachability-defined causal-cone poset (truncated past cones with rmax=3). Controlled contexts increase two-qubit exposure using barrier-separated canceling two-qubit operations while preserving the ideal logical circuit. Across a single-patch pilot and two multi-patch extensions (P=4 and P=8 far-separated parallel patches), the detector windows contain measurable context signal. The strongest positive result is not raw classification accuracy but \emph{region stability}: top cone-poset regions selected by M\"obius magnitude are highly patch-invariant, whereas subset-lattice top terms are nearly random-like across patches. For P=4 and P=8, normalized top-region Jaccard stability is $\Jnorm_{\cone}=0.505$ and 0.603, while $\Jnorm_{\sub}=0.008$ and −0.001. Out-of-patch classifiers remain only weakly above chance, but multinomial logistic calibration reduces expected calibration error to 0.035--0.079 and removes a large Naive-Bayes calibration artifact. This weak classification is expected: predicting a global two-qubit-load context from one local 12-detector window is a low-SNR domain-generalization task. The mutual information statistic in this experiment is interpreted as an operational proxy for the context-modulated correlated-error footprint, not as a direct measurement of pure topological synergy. We therefore state a conservative conclusion: causal-cone posets expose reusable, patch-invariant macro-region signatures in this repetition-code hardware setting; they are not yet shown to improve logical decoding or to dominate arbitrary subsets in all predictive tasks. The accompanying dataset bundle contains raw detector windows, QPY circuits, explicit poset definitions, fold outputs, and paper-ready tables.
This preprint reports a cost-bounded reduced-Pauli entanglement and tomography check for promoted Phase 3 DLA-parity and Fisher-information-modified Kuramoto--XY circuit families. The purpose is to distinguish parity-sector leakage structure from layout, prepared-state, and readout artefacts in small superconducting-hardware experiments. The archived IBM execution used physical qubits [1,2,3,4] on ibm_marrakesh, 162 main circuits, four readout-calibration circuits, 2048 shots per main circuit, and 8192 shots per readout circuit. A preregistered reducer produced 54 observable rows; the manuscript reports measured-minus-exact deviations, identifies the largest transverse two-qubit correlator deviations, and compares readout-mitigated replay and same-day ibm_fez replication. The record includes manuscript source, bibliography, and PDF. The claim boundary is hardware-observation and artefact-reduction evidence for these named circuit families, not a backend-independent universal promotion.
Standard quantum circuit simulation represents amplitudes as double-precision complex numbers, so quantities such as entanglement entropy are computed only approximately. We revisit two well-known facts about the stabilizer formalism — that entanglement entropy of a stabilizer state is always an integer, and that the distance of a stabilizer code is a combinatorial quantity — and implement both exactly, using binary linear algebra over F2 on the stabilizer tableau, with no floating-point step anywhere in the computation. We verify the entropy formula against Qiskit's floating-point von Neumann entropy on canonical states and on 30 random Clifford circuits (all matches exact), reproduce the area-law entanglement of the 1D cluster state, and verify the code-distance procedure against three canonical quantum error-correcting codes (Steane, the 5-qubit code, and Shor's code), recovering their published distances exactly. As an illustration of the exact toolkit in use, we report an empirical scaling law for the depth at which entanglement saturates in a specific random-circuit model. Finally, since every result above concerns exact mathematics or exact simulation of noiseless Clifford circuits, we complement it with a small, honestly-labelled real-hardware comparison: the GHZ state on 3–7 qubits, run on IBM Quantum superconducting hardware, measured against the exact noiseless prediction our formalism computes, together with a quantitative check against a naive noise model built from the device's own published calibration data — which the data systematically contradicts by 18–21 percentage points, a discrepancy we report along with our best physical explanation for it. A second, independent hardware experiment measures the cluster state's own stabilizer generators directly, and identifies a single miscalibrated physical qubit as correlated with elevated error; a follow-up control experiment, forcing the circuit onto verified low-error qubits instead, confirms the effect is causal but partial (leakage drops by 1.84 percentage points, roughly a third of the excess) rather than the whole explanation, which we report at its true, unexaggerated size. Applying the naive noise model to the control circuit itself reverses its bias (now optimistic rather than pessimistic) by an amount consistent, to order of magnitude, with ordinary decoherence over the circuit's execution time — a physical effect the naive model was never built to capture.
Random unitaries scramble quantum information into highly nonlocal degrees of freedom, thereby providing protection from local noise. However, as demonstrated by Turkeshi and Sierant (Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 140401, 2024 and arXiv:2603.00235), this protection may fail once local noise grows sufficiently strong. These works describe a phase transition in a noisy random encoding-decoding circuit model between an error-protecting phase, in which encoded information is recoverable, and an error-vulnerable phase, in which encoded information is lost, with the transition occurring at a critical coherent noise angle αc≈1.14. Here, we present the first experimental observation of this transition, conducted on IBM's ibm_pittsburgh Heron r3 device for system sizes of up to N=26 qubits. We detect this transition via three order parameters: fidelity, Rényi-2 entanglement entropy, and stabilizer Rényi-2 entropy. For the latter two, we employ randomized measurement protocols to construct estimators, and for all three, we rely on zero-noise extrapolation and M3 SPAM error mitigation. We then jointly model the finite-size scaling collapse across all three order parameters with a Gaussian process regression, yielding a critical angle αc≈1.01, well below the theoretical value. Inputting noiseless simulated data into the same model yields αc≈1.05, implying that the discrepancy between experiment and theory is due to our encoding circuits, which are not deep enough to be truly Haar-random. Finally, we observe that the same model cannot adequately identify critical behavior in unmitigated, raw experimental data. This indicates that error mitigation techniques are crucial for detecting the transition on hardware.