Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2603.10206 · The Philosophical Magazine A Journal of Theoretical Experimental and Applied Physics

Are quantum trajectories suitable for semiclassical approximations?

Alfredo M. Ozorio de Almeida

quant-phSubmitted Mar 10, 2026• Announced Mar 12, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The quantum trajectories in the de Broglie-Bohm formulation of quantum mechanics depend on an additional quantum potential derived from the full wave solution of Schrödinger's equation. The task of supplying collectively all the correct quantum results strongly alters the characteristics of the corresponding classical trajectories, which underlie semiclassical approximations to the evolving wave function. Both classical and quantum trajectories are here considered to be conservative with no influence of an external environment, even though this is the source of eventual classicality in quantum systems, that is, decoherence. The concept of integrability, closely correspondent in classical and quantum mechanics, is not preserved by the quantum trajectories. General systems, in which classical chaotic motion participates, are much harder to treat semiclassically, but quantum trajectories can be chaotic even for integrable systems. This discrepancy between the character of classical and quantum trajectories in the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation does not clarify the singular classical-quantum transition.

Journal reference
Philosophical Magazine, 1-10 (2026)
DOI
10.1080/14786435.2026.2627728

Related papers

Quantum initial value representations using approximate Bohmian trajectories

Eric R. Bittner

Quantum trajectories, originating from the de Broglie–Bohm hydrodynamic description of quantum mechanics, are used to construct time-correlation functions in an initial value representation. The formulation is fully quantum mechanical and the resulting equations for the correlation functions are similar in form to their semiclassical analogs but do not require the computation of the stability or monodromy matrix or conjugate points. We then move to a local trajectory description by evolving the cumulants of the wave function along each individual path. The resulting equations of motion are an infinite hierarchy, which we truncate at a given order. We show that time-correlation functions computed using these approximate quantum trajectories can be used to accurately compute the eigenvalue spectrum for various potential systems.

arXiv:quant-ph/0304012•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 3, 2003•36 citations

The theory of the Double Solution: Dynamical issues in quantum systems in the semiclassical regime

A. Matzkin

The "dynamical mismatch" observed in quantum systems in the semiclassical regime challenge the Pilot wave model. Indeed the dynamics and properties of such systems depend on the trajectories of the classically equivalent system, whereas the de Broglie-Bohm trajectories are generically non-classical.\ In this work we examine the situation for the model favoured by de Broglie, the theory of the Double Solution (DS). We will see that the original DS model applied to semiclassical systems is also prone to the dynamical mismatch.\ However we will argue that the DS theory can be modified in order to yield propagation of the singularity in accord with the underlying classical dynamics of semiclassical systems.

arXiv:1611.02340•Nov 7, 2016•1 citation

Order in de Broglie–Bohm quantum mechanics

G Contopoulos, N Delis, C Efthymiopoulos

A usual assumption in the so-called de Broglie–Bohm approach to quantum dynamics is that the quantum trajectories subject to typical 'guiding' wavefunctions turn to be quite irregular, i.e. chaotic (in the dynamical systems' sense). In this paper, we consider mainly cases in which the quantum trajectories are ordered , i.e. they have zero Lyapunov characteristic numbers. We use perturbative methods to establish the existence of such trajectories from a theoretical point of view, while we analyze their properties via numerical experiments. Using a 2D harmonic oscillator system, we first establish conditions under which a trajectory can be shown to avoid close encounters with a moving nodal point, thus avoiding the source of chaos in this system. We then consider series expansions for trajectories both in the interior and the exterior of the domain covered by nodal lines, probing the domain of convergence as well as how successful the series are in comparison with numerical computations or regular trajectories. We then examine a Hénon–Heiles system possessing regular trajectories, thus generalizing previous results. Finally, we explore a key issue of physical interest in the context of the de Broglie–Bohm formalism, namely the influence of order on the so-called quantum relaxation effect. We show that the existence of regular trajectories poses restrictions on the quantum relaxation process and give examples in which the relaxation is suppressed even when we consider initial ensembles of only chaotic trajectories, provided, however, that the system as a whole is characterized by a certain degree of order.

arXiv:1203.5598•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Apr 3, 2012•24 citations

Non-dynamical quantum trajectories

Timothy M. Coffey

Commonly held opinion is that particle trajectory descriptions are incompatible with quantum mechanics. Louis de Broglie (1926) first proposed a way to include trajectories in quantum mechanics, but the idea was abandoned until David Bohm (1952) re-invented and improved the theory. Bohm interprets the particle trajectories as physically real; for example, an electron actually is a particle moving on a well defined trajectory with a position and momentum at all times. By design, Bohm's trajectories never make predictions that differ from standard quantum mechanics, and their existence cannot be experimentally verified. \n \n \n \nThree new methods to obtain Bohm's particle trajectories are presented. The methods are non-dynamical, and utilize none of Bohm's equations of motion; in fact, two of the methods have no equations for a particle's trajectory. Instead, all three methods use only the evolving probability density ρ=ψ*ψ to extract the trajectories. The first two methods rest upon probability conservation and density sampling, while the third method employs the informational or geometrical construction of centroidal Voronoi tessellations. In one-dimension all three methods are proved to be equivalent to Bohm's particle trajectories. For higher dimensional configuration spaces, the first two methods can be used in limited situations, but the last method can be applied in all cases. Typically, the resulting higher dimensional non-dynamical trajectories are also identical to Bohm. \n \n \n \nTogether the three methods point to a new interpretation of Bohm's particle trajectories, namely, the Bohm trajectories are simply a kinematic portrayal of the evolution of the probability density. In addition, the new methods can be used to measure Schrödinger's wave function and Planck's constant.

•Dec 1, 2010•0 citations

Local Measure of Quantum Effects in Quantum Dynamics

Vitaly A. Rassolov, Sophya V. Garashchuk

The Madelung-de Broglie-Bohm formulation of the Schrödinger equation casts the time-evolution of a wave function as dynamics of an ensemble of quantum, or Bohmian, trajectories, interacting via the nonlocal quantum potential. This trajectory perspective gives insight into the quantumness (or classicality) of a given system due to clear partitioning of the energy into classical and quantum components. Here, we propose a system-independent measure of the quantumness of dynamics, based on the energy time-change, referred to as "quantum power". This measure is local in the coordinate space. Based on applications to model chemical systems, we argue that during the transition from the quantum to classical regime, defined as compression of quantization, the quantum features in dynamics do not "disappear" but are pushed forward in time. This feature may be used to gauge the validity of the semiclassical and other approximate dynamics approaches in applications to anharmonic systems.

The Journal of Physical Chemistry A•May 20, 2021•2 citations

The de Broglie-Bohm Causal Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics and its Application to some Simple Systems

Caroline Colijn

The de Broglie-Bohm causal interpretation of quantum mechanics is discussed, and applied to the hydrogen atom in several contexts. Prominent critiques of the causal program are noted and responses are given; it is argued that the de Broglie-Bohm theory is of notable interest to physics. Using the causal theory, electron trajectories are found for the conventional Schrödinger, Pauli and Dirac hydrogen eigenstates. In the Schrödinger case, an additional term is used to account for the spin; this term was not present in the original formulation of the theory but is necessary for the theory to be embedded in a relativistic formulation. In the Schrödinger, Pauli and Dirac cases, the eigenstate trajectories are shown to be circular, with electron motion revolving around the z-axis. Electron trajectories are also found for the 1s-2p0 transition problem under the Schrödinger equation; it is shown that the transition can be characterized by a comparison of the trajectory to the relevant eigenstate trajectories. The structures of the computed trajectories are relevant to the question of the possible evolution of a quantum distribution towards the standard quantum distribution (quantum equilibrium); this process is known as quantum relaxation. The transition problem is generalized to include all possible transitions in hydrogen stimulated by semi-classical radiation, and all of the trajectories found are examined in light of their implications for the evolution of the distribution to the standard distribution. Several promising avenues for future research are discussed.

•Jan 1, 2003•2 citations
The quantum trajectories in the de Broglie-Bohm formulation of quantum mechanics depend on an additional quantum potential derived from the full wave solution of Schrödinger's equation. The task of supplying collectively all the correct quantum results strongly alters the characteristics of the corresponding classical trajectories, which underlie semiclassical approximations to the evolving wave function. Both classical and quantum trajectories are here considered to be conservative with no influence of an external environment, even though this is the source of eventual classicality in quantum systems, that is, decoherence. The concept of integrability, closely correspondent in classical and quantum mechanics, is not preserved by the quantum trajectories. General systems, in which classical chaotic motion participates, are much harder to treat semiclassically, but quantum trajectories can be chaotic even for integrable systems. This discrepancy between the character of classical and quantum trajectories in the de Broglie-Bohm interpretation does not clarify the singular classical-quantum transition.
Quantum trajectories, originating from the de Broglie–Bohm hydrodynamic description of quantum mechanics, are used to construct time-correlation functions in an initial value representation. The formulation is fully quantum mechanical and the resulting equations for the correlation functions are similar in form to their semiclassical analogs but do not require the computation of the stability or monodromy matrix or conjugate points. We then move to a local trajectory description by evolving the cumulants of the wave function along each individual path. The resulting equations of motion are an infinite hierarchy, which we truncate at a given order. We show that time-correlation functions computed using these approximate quantum trajectories can be used to accurately compute the eigenvalue spectrum for various potential systems.
The "dynamical mismatch" observed in quantum systems in the semiclassical regime challenge the Pilot wave model. Indeed the dynamics and properties of such systems depend on the trajectories of the classically equivalent system, whereas the de Broglie-Bohm trajectories are generically non-classical.\ In this work we examine the situation for the model favoured by de Broglie, the theory of the Double Solution (DS). We will see that the original DS model applied to semiclassical systems is also prone to the dynamical mismatch.\ However we will argue that the DS theory can be modified in order to yield propagation of the singularity in accord with the underlying classical dynamics of semiclassical systems.
A usual assumption in the so-called de Broglie–Bohm approach to quantum dynamics is that the quantum trajectories subject to typical 'guiding' wavefunctions turn to be quite irregular, i.e. chaotic (in the dynamical systems' sense). In this paper, we consider mainly cases in which the quantum trajectories are ordered , i.e. they have zero Lyapunov characteristic numbers. We use perturbative methods to establish the existence of such trajectories from a theoretical point of view, while we analyze their properties via numerical experiments. Using a 2D harmonic oscillator system, we first establish conditions under which a trajectory can be shown to avoid close encounters with a moving nodal point, thus avoiding the source of chaos in this system. We then consider series expansions for trajectories both in the interior and the exterior of the domain covered by nodal lines, probing the domain of convergence as well as how successful the series are in comparison with numerical computations or regular trajectories. We then examine a Hénon–Heiles system possessing regular trajectories, thus generalizing previous results. Finally, we explore a key issue of physical interest in the context of the de Broglie–Bohm formalism, namely the influence of order on the so-called quantum relaxation effect. We show that the existence of regular trajectories poses restrictions on the quantum relaxation process and give examples in which the relaxation is suppressed even when we consider initial ensembles of only chaotic trajectories, provided, however, that the system as a whole is characterized by a certain degree of order.
Commonly held opinion is that particle trajectory descriptions are incompatible with quantum mechanics. Louis de Broglie (1926) first proposed a way to include trajectories in quantum mechanics, but the idea was abandoned until David Bohm (1952) re-invented and improved the theory. Bohm interprets the particle trajectories as physically real; for example, an electron actually is a particle moving on a well defined trajectory with a position and momentum at all times. By design, Bohm's trajectories never make predictions that differ from standard quantum mechanics, and their existence cannot be experimentally verified. \n \n \n \nThree new methods to obtain Bohm's particle trajectories are presented. The methods are non-dynamical, and utilize none of Bohm's equations of motion; in fact, two of the methods have no equations for a particle's trajectory. Instead, all three methods use only the evolving probability density ρ=ψ*ψ to extract the trajectories. The first two methods rest upon probability conservation and density sampling, while the third method employs the informational or geometrical construction of centroidal Voronoi tessellations. In one-dimension all three methods are proved to be equivalent to Bohm's particle trajectories. For higher dimensional configuration spaces, the first two methods can be used in limited situations, but the last method can be applied in all cases. Typically, the resulting higher dimensional non-dynamical trajectories are also identical to Bohm. \n \n \n \nTogether the three methods point to a new interpretation of Bohm's particle trajectories, namely, the Bohm trajectories are simply a kinematic portrayal of the evolution of the probability density. In addition, the new methods can be used to measure Schrödinger's wave function and Planck's constant.
The Madelung-de Broglie-Bohm formulation of the Schrödinger equation casts the time-evolution of a wave function as dynamics of an ensemble of quantum, or Bohmian, trajectories, interacting via the nonlocal quantum potential. This trajectory perspective gives insight into the quantumness (or classicality) of a given system due to clear partitioning of the energy into classical and quantum components. Here, we propose a system-independent measure of the quantumness of dynamics, based on the energy time-change, referred to as "quantum power". This measure is local in the coordinate space. Based on applications to model chemical systems, we argue that during the transition from the quantum to classical regime, defined as compression of quantization, the quantum features in dynamics do not "disappear" but are pushed forward in time. This feature may be used to gauge the validity of the semiclassical and other approximate dynamics approaches in applications to anharmonic systems.
The de Broglie-Bohm causal interpretation of quantum mechanics is discussed, and applied to the hydrogen atom in several contexts. Prominent critiques of the causal program are noted and responses are given; it is argued that the de Broglie-Bohm theory is of notable interest to physics. Using the causal theory, electron trajectories are found for the conventional Schrödinger, Pauli and Dirac hydrogen eigenstates. In the Schrödinger case, an additional term is used to account for the spin; this term was not present in the original formulation of the theory but is necessary for the theory to be embedded in a relativistic formulation. In the Schrödinger, Pauli and Dirac cases, the eigenstate trajectories are shown to be circular, with electron motion revolving around the z-axis. Electron trajectories are also found for the 1s-2p0 transition problem under the Schrödinger equation; it is shown that the transition can be characterized by a comparison of the trajectory to the relevant eigenstate trajectories. The structures of the computed trajectories are relevant to the question of the possible evolution of a quantum distribution towards the standard quantum distribution (quantum equilibrium); this process is known as quantum relaxation. The transition problem is generalized to include all possible transitions in hydrogen stimulated by semi-classical radiation, and all of the trajectories found are examined in light of their implications for the evolution of the distribution to the standard distribution. Several promising avenues for future research are discussed.