Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2603.09128 · Journal of Algebra and Its Applications

On the Existence of Algebraic Equiangular Lines

Igor Van Loo, Frédérique Oggier

quant-phmath.NTSubmitted Mar 10, 2026• Announced Mar 11, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider real and complex equiangular lines, generated by unit vectors. We show that, for an arbitrary dimension $d$, if there exists a set of $d^2$ equiangular unit vectors in $\mathbb{C}^d$, then there must exist a set of $d^2$ equiangular unit vectors with all of their coefficients in a number field. This result is motivated by the question of constructing SIC-POVMs in quantum physics and conjectures around them. We discuss applications of our techniques to the case of real equiangular lines and consequences of the above results.

DOI
10.1142/S0219498828500508
Comments
21 pages, 1 Table

Related papers

Some non-standard ways to generate SIC-POVMs in dimensions 2 and 3

Gary McConnell

The notion of Symmetric Informationally Complete Positive Operator-Valued Measures (SIC-POVMs) arose in physics as a kind of optimal measurement basis for quantum systems. However the question of their existence is equivalent to that of the existence of a maximal set of \emph{complex equiangular lines}. That is to say, given a complex Hilbert space of dimension $d$, what is the maximal number of (complex) lines one can find which all make a common (real) angle with one another, in the sense that the inner products between unit vectors spanning those lines all have a common absolute value? A maximal set would consist of $d^2$ lines all with a common angle of $\arccos{\frac{1}{\sqrt{d+1}}}$. The same question has been posed in the real case and some partial answers are known. But at the time of writing no unifying theoretical result has been found in the real or the complex case: some sporadic low-dimensional numerical constructions have been converted into algebraic solutions but beyond this very little is known. It is conjectured that such structures always arise as orbits of certain fiducial vectors under the action of the Weyl (or generalised Pauli) group. In this paper we point out some new construction methods in the lowest dimensions ($d=2$ and $d=3$). We should mention that the SIC-POVMs so constructed are all unitarily equivalent to previously known SIC-POVMs.

arXiv:1402.7330•Feb 28, 2014•2 citations

SIC-POVMs and the Stark Conjectures

Gene S. Kopp

Abstract The existence of $d^2$ pairwise equiangular complex lines [equivalently, a symmetric informationally complete positive operator-valued measure (SIC-POVM)] in $d$-dimensional Hilbert space is known only for finitely many dimensions $d$. We prove that, if there exists a set of real units in a certain ray class field (depending on $d$) satisfying certain algebraic properties, a SIC-POVM exists, when $d$ is an odd prime congruent to 2 modulo 3. We give an explicit analytic formula that we expect to yield such a set of units. Our construction uses values of derivatives of zeta functions at $s=0$ and is closely connected to the Stark conjectures over real quadratic fields. We verify numerically that our construction yields SIC-POVMs in dimensions 5, 11, 17, and 23, and we give the first exact SIC-POVM in dimension 23.

arXiv:1807.05877•International Mathematics Research Notices•Jun 19, 2019•58 citations

SIC-POVMs from Stark units: Dimensions n2 + 3 = 4p, p prime

Ingemar Bengtsson, Markus Grassl, Gary McConnell

The existence problem for maximal sets of equiangular lines (or SICs) in complex Hilbert space of dimension d remains largely open. In a previous publication we gave a conjectural algorithm for how to construct a SIC if d = n2 + 3 = p, a prime number. Perhaps the most surprising number-theoretical aspect of that algorithm is the appearance of Stark units in a key role: a single Stark unit from a ray class field extension of a real quadratic field serves as a seed from which the SIC is constructed. The algorithm can be modified to apply to all dimensions d = n2 + 3. Here we focus on the case when d = n2 + 3 = 4p, p prime, for two reasons. First, special measures have to be taken on the Hilbert space side of the problem when the dimension is even. Second, the degrees of the relevant ray class fields are “smooth” in a sense that facilitates exact calculations. As a result the algorithm becomes easier to explain. We give solutions for 17 different dimensions of this form, reaching d = 39 604. Several improvements relative to our previous publication are reported, but we cannot offer a proof that the algorithm works for any dimensions where it has not been tested.

arXiv:2403.02872•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Aug 1, 2025•15 citations

A Conjecture on Almost Flat SIC-POVMs

Ingemar Bengtsson, Markus Grassl

A well supported conjecture states that SIC-POVMs -- maximal sets of complex equiangular lines -- with anti-unitary symmetry give rise to an identity expressing some of its overlaps as squares of the (rescaled) components of a suitably chosen fiducial vector. In number theoretical terms the identity essentially expresses Stark units as sums of products of pairs of square roots of Stark units. We investigate whether the identity is enough to determine these Stark units. The answer is no, but the failure might be quite mild.

quant-pharXiv:2512.13201•Dec 16, 2025•2 citations

SIC-POVMs and orders of real quadratic fields

Gene S. Kopp, Jeffrey C. Lagarias

This paper concerns SIC-POVMs and their relationship to class field theory. SIC-POVMs are generalized quantum measurements (POVMs) described by d 2 equiangular complex lines through the origin in C d . Weyl–Heisenberg covariant SICs are those SIC-POVMs described by the orbit a single vector under a finite Weyl–Heisenberg group WH ( d ) . We relate known data on the structure and classification of Weyl–Heisenberg covariant SICs in low dimensions to arithmetic data attached to certain orders of real quadratic fields. For 4 ≤ d ≤ 90 , we show the number of known geometric equivalence classes of Weyl–Heisenberg covariant SICs in dimension d equals the cardinality of the ideal class monoid of (not necessarily invertible) ideal classes in the real quadratic order O Δ d of discriminant Δ d = ( d + 1 ) ( d − 3 ) ; we conjecture the equality extends to all d ≥ 4 . We prove that this conjecture implies the existence of more than one geometric equivalence class of Weyl–Heisenberg covariant SICs for every d > 22 . We conjecture that Galois multiplets of SICs may be put in one-to-one correspondence with the over-orders O ′ of O Δ d in such a way that the number of geometric classes in the multiplet equals the ring class number of O ′ . We test that conjecture against known data on exact SICs in low dimensions. We refine the “class field hypothesis” of Appleby, Flammia, McConnell, and Yard [8] to predict the exact class field over Q ( Δ d ) generated by the ratios of vector entries for the equiangular lines defining a Weyl–Heisenberg SIC. The refined conjectures use a recently developed class field theory for orders of number fields [36] . The refined class fields assigned to over-orders O ′ have a natural partial order under inclusion; the inclusions of these class fields fail to be strict in some cases. We characterize such cases and give a table of them for d < 500 .

arXiv:2407.08048•Journal of Number Theory•Jul 17, 2026•5 citations

Equiangular lines, projective symmetries and nice error frames

Tuan-Yow Chien

The existence of maximal sets of equiangular lines (SIC-POVMs) is of interest to the mathematics and physics communities due to their connection to quantum information theory, quantum cryptography, spherical 2-designs and cubature rules. This thesis looks at a way to recover analytic SIC-POVMs from numerical SIC-POVMs, including the discovery of a new analytic SIC-POVM in 17 dimensions. It also develops a way to comprehensively find nice error bases (used for finding SIC-POVMs). Finally, a general theory to classify sequences of vectors up to projective unitary equivalence is developed and applied to study the projective symmetry groups of sequences of vectors.

•Jan 1, 2015•4 citations
We consider real and complex equiangular lines, generated by unit vectors. We show that, for an arbitrary dimension ddd, if there exists a set of d2d^2d2 equiangular unit vectors in Cd\mathbb{C}^dCd, then there must exist a set of d2d^2d2 equiangular unit vectors with all of their coefficients in a number field. This result is motivated by the question of constructing SIC-POVMs in quantum physics and conjectures around them. We discuss applications of our techniques to the case of real equiangular lines and consequences of the above results.
The notion of Symmetric Informationally Complete Positive Operator-Valued Measures (SIC-POVMs) arose in physics as a kind of optimal measurement basis for quantum systems. However the question of their existence is equivalent to that of the existence of a maximal set of \emph{complex equiangular lines}. That is to say, given a complex Hilbert space of dimension ddd, what is the maximal number of (complex) lines one can find which all make a common (real) angle with one another, in the sense that the inner products between unit vectors spanning those lines all have a common absolute value? A maximal set would consist of d2d^2d2 lines all with a common angle of arccos⁡1d+1\arccos{\frac{1}{\sqrt{d+1}}}arccosd+1​1​. The same question has been posed in the real case and some partial answers are known. But at the time of writing no unifying theoretical result has been found in the real or the complex case: some sporadic low-dimensional numerical constructions have been converted into algebraic solutions but beyond this very little is known. It is conjectured that such structures always arise as orbits of certain fiducial vectors under the action of the Weyl (or generalised Pauli) group. In this paper we point out some new construction methods in the lowest dimensions (d=2d=2d=2 and d=3d=3d=3). We should mention that the SIC-POVMs so constructed are all unitarily equivalent to previously known SIC-POVMs.
Abstract The existence of d2d^2d2 pairwise equiangular complex lines [equivalently, a symmetric informationally complete positive operator-valued measure (SIC-POVM)] in ddd-dimensional Hilbert space is known only for finitely many dimensions ddd. We prove that, if there exists a set of real units in a certain ray class field (depending on ddd) satisfying certain algebraic properties, a SIC-POVM exists, when ddd is an odd prime congruent to 2 modulo 3. We give an explicit analytic formula that we expect to yield such a set of units. Our construction uses values of derivatives of zeta functions at s=0s=0s=0 and is closely connected to the Stark conjectures over real quadratic fields. We verify numerically that our construction yields SIC-POVMs in dimensions 5, 11, 17, and 23, and we give the first exact SIC-POVM in dimension 23.
The existence problem for maximal sets of equiangular lines (or SICs) in complex Hilbert space of dimension d remains largely open. In a previous publication we gave a conjectural algorithm for how to construct a SIC if d = n2 + 3 = p, a prime number. Perhaps the most surprising number-theoretical aspect of that algorithm is the appearance of Stark units in a key role: a single Stark unit from a ray class field extension of a real quadratic field serves as a seed from which the SIC is constructed. The algorithm can be modified to apply to all dimensions d = n2 + 3. Here we focus on the case when d = n2 + 3 = 4p, p prime, for two reasons. First, special measures have to be taken on the Hilbert space side of the problem when the dimension is even. Second, the degrees of the relevant ray class fields are “smooth” in a sense that facilitates exact calculations. As a result the algorithm becomes easier to explain. We give solutions for 17 different dimensions of this form, reaching d = 39 604. Several improvements relative to our previous publication are reported, but we cannot offer a proof that the algorithm works for any dimensions where it has not been tested.
A well supported conjecture states that SIC-POVMs -- maximal sets of complex equiangular lines -- with anti-unitary symmetry give rise to an identity expressing some of its overlaps as squares of the (rescaled) components of a suitably chosen fiducial vector. In number theoretical terms the identity essentially expresses Stark units as sums of products of pairs of square roots of Stark units. We investigate whether the identity is enough to determine these Stark units. The answer is no, but the failure might be quite mild.
This paper concerns SIC-POVMs and their relationship to class field theory. SIC-POVMs are generalized quantum measurements (POVMs) described by d 2 equiangular complex lines through the origin in C d . Weyl–Heisenberg covariant SICs are those SIC-POVMs described by the orbit a single vector under a finite Weyl–Heisenberg group WH ( d ) . We relate known data on the structure and classification of Weyl–Heisenberg covariant SICs in low dimensions to arithmetic data attached to certain orders of real quadratic fields. For 4 ≤ d ≤ 90 , we show the number of known geometric equivalence classes of Weyl–Heisenberg covariant SICs in dimension d equals the cardinality of the ideal class monoid of (not necessarily invertible) ideal classes in the real quadratic order O Δ d of discriminant Δ d = ( d + 1 ) ( d − 3 ) ; we conjecture the equality extends to all d ≥ 4 . We prove that this conjecture implies the existence of more than one geometric equivalence class of Weyl–Heisenberg covariant SICs for every d > 22 . We conjecture that Galois multiplets of SICs may be put in one-to-one correspondence with the over-orders O ′ of O Δ d in such a way that the number of geometric classes in the multiplet equals the ring class number of O ′ . We test that conjecture against known data on exact SICs in low dimensions. We refine the “class field hypothesis” of Appleby, Flammia, McConnell, and Yard [8] to predict the exact class field over Q ( Δ d ) generated by the ratios of vector entries for the equiangular lines defining a Weyl–Heisenberg SIC. The refined conjectures use a recently developed class field theory for orders of number fields [36] . The refined class fields assigned to over-orders O ′ have a natural partial order under inclusion; the inclusions of these class fields fail to be strict in some cases. We characterize such cases and give a table of them for d < 500 .
The existence of maximal sets of equiangular lines (SIC-POVMs) is of interest to the mathematics and physics communities due to their connection to quantum information theory, quantum cryptography, spherical 2-designs and cubature rules. This thesis looks at a way to recover analytic SIC-POVMs from numerical SIC-POVMs, including the discovery of a new analytic SIC-POVM in 17 dimensions. It also develops a way to comprehensively find nice error bases (used for finding SIC-POVMs). Finally, a general theory to classify sequences of vectors up to projective unitary equivalence is developed and applied to study the projective symmetry groups of sequences of vectors.