Abstract Recent advances in quantum sensing—optical clocks at 5.5 × 10 − 19 systematic uncertainty, frequency-dependent squeezing below the standard quantum limit, quantum magnetometers approaching fundamental sensitivity limits—raise a natural question: can these technologies detect gravitational waves directly, or enhance existing detectors beyond current capabilities? We show that the answer is primarily determined by the coupling mechanism between the gravitational wave and the sensor. Starting from the tidal Hamiltonian in Fermi normal coordinates, we identify three physically distinct mechanisms by which a gravitational wave couples directly to a quantum system, and derive their transducer gains within linearized general relativity and non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Internal atomic coupling (tidal distortion of electronic wavefunctions) yields a transducer gain G A = 2.4 × 10 − 20 , with vanishing first-order energy shifts for all J = 0 clock states—a ∼ 10 35 deficit relative to laser interferometry that exceeds any projected quantum enhancement. Center-of-mass coupling (Doppler shifts from geodesic motion) reaches strain sensitivities of ∼ 10 − 18 , still 10 4 above LISA requirements. Light propagation coupling (phase accumulation over macroscopic baselines) provides the enormous transducer gain that makes laser interferometry—and atom interferometry—viable. For detectors exploiting this third mechanism, we quantify how much improvement quantum sensors can provide through the detector’s noise architecture: LISA’s noise budget is predominantly classical, limiting combined quantum enhancement to E ≈ 1.04 , while ground-based detectors in the shot-noise-dominated regime achieve E = 1.6 – 2.1 . Atom interferometers exploit the same light-propagation mechanism to target the 0.01–10 Hz band between the LISA and LIGO ranges.
Abstract Recent advances in quantum sensing—optical clocks at 5.5 × 10 − 19 systematic uncertainty, frequency-dependent squeezing below the standard quantum limit, quantum magnetometers approaching fundamental sensitivity limits—raise a natural question: can these technologies detect gravitational waves directly, or enhance existing detectors beyond current capabilities? We show that the answer is primarily determined by the coupling mechanism between the gravitational wave and the sensor. Starting from the tidal Hamiltonian in Fermi normal coordinates, we identify three physically distinct mechanisms by which a gravitational wave couples directly to a quantum system, and derive their transducer gains within linearized general relativity and non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Internal atomic coupling (tidal distortion of electronic wavefunctions) yields a transducer gain G A = 2.4 × 10 − 20 , with vanishing first-order energy shifts for all J = 0 clock states—a ∼ 10 35 deficit relative to laser interferometry that exceeds any projected quantum enhancement. Center-of-mass coupling (Doppler shifts from geodesic motion) reaches strain sensitivities of ∼ 10 − 18 , still 10 4 above LISA requirements. Light propagation coupling (phase accumulation over macroscopic baselines) provides the enormous transducer gain that makes laser interferometry—and atom interferometry—viable. For detectors exploiting this third mechanism, we quantify how much improvement quantum sensors can provide through the detector’s noise architecture: LISA’s noise budget is predominantly classical, limiting combined quantum enhancement to E ≈ 1.04 , while ground-based detectors in the shot-noise-dominated regime achieve E = 1.6 – 2.1 . Atom interferometers exploit the same light-propagation mechanism to target the 0.01–10 Hz band between the LISA and LIGO ranges.
Interferometric gravitational wave detectors (such as advanced LIGO) employ high-power solid-state lasers to maximize their detection sensitivity and hence their reach into the universe. These sophisticated light sources are ultra-stabilized with regard to output power, emission frequency and beam geometry; this is crucial to obtain low detector noise. However, even when all laser noise is reduced as far as technically possible, unavoidable quantum noise of the laser still remains. This is a consequence of the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, the basis of quantum mechanics: in this case, it is fundamentally impossible to simultaneously reduce both the phase noise and the amplitude noise of a laser to arbitrarily low levels. This fact manifests in the detector noise budget as two distinct noise sources—photon shot noise and quantum radiation pressure noise—which together form a lower boundary for current-day gravitational wave detector sensitivities, the standard quantum limit of interferometry. To overcome this limit, various techniques are being proposed, among them different uses of non-classical light and alternative interferometer topologies. This article explains how quantum noise enters and manifests in an interferometric gravitational wave detector, and gives an overview of some of the schemes proposed to overcome this seemingly fundamental limitation, all aimed at the goal of higher gravitational wave event detection rates. This article is part of a discussion meeting issue ‘The promises of gravitational-wave astronomy’.
Gravitational waves manifest as a time varying straining of space: they arise from the accelerating motions of large bodies of mass and propagate across the universe at the speed of light as ripples in the fabric of space-time, a fleetingly weak effect so far eluding direct detection. The detection of gravitation waves is expected to yield a rich vein to observational astronomy, complementing existing electromagnetic surveys and revealing a hitherto unexplored range of phenomena. First generation interferometric gravitational wave detectors, notably Enhanced LIGO, achieved strain sensitivities of one part in ten to power twenty-one per square-root-Hertz at 100 Hz with an expected detection rate of 2-3 events per year. Commissioning of a new generation of Advanced LIGO interferometric detectors has concluded recently with a resultant ten-fold sensitivity improvement. Overall their potential event detection space has increased by a factor of 1000. The quantum nature of light within these detectors now limits their sensitivity over most of their frequency range. This quantum noise limit is driven by the vacuum quadrature fluctuations propagated through their open detection ports and represents a fundamental noise floor to their strain sensitivity. This thesis addresses two distinct approaches to quantum noise improvement for future upgrades to advanced detectors. The first addresses the issue of quantum noise by adopting a quantum non-demolition approach to detector readout variables, the so-called `speed-meter’ design. Such a modified instrument samples test mass momentum, a quantity for which time separated measurements commute and are therefore not bound by Heisenberg-like limits. A novel polarisation-folded sloshing cavity type speed-meter is proposed where readout fields are stored and delayed in the orthogonal polarisation of the interferometer’s arms cavities. Here frequency dependence is selected to cancel position like measurements so that only test mass momentum information remains. A quantum noise propagation model is developed and a sensitivity performance is demonstrated that beats the standard quantum limit below 100 Hz over a broad range of frequencies. A second approach to achieve quantum noise enhancement in advanced detectors involves injection of quadrature-squeezed states in the place of vacuum. This dissertation details the development of a prototype squeezed vacuum source suitable to the demanding enhancement requirements for an Advanced LIGO squeezing installation. The construction of a doubly resonant, bow-tie cavity source is presented. This employs a novel monolithic all-glass cavity construction and is vacuum compatible. This design demonstrates the viability of building a cavity using optical contacting as a construction technique for attaching mounting prisms to highly polished fused-silica breadboards. Such a design can be expected to have excellent length noise stability, provide low intrinsic phase noise and would be suitable to mount on seismic isolation stages within the LIGO vacuum envelope. Further, the travelling wave cavity design should provide excellent 50 dB intrinsic backscatter isolation. We demonstrate the first operation of such a complex non-linear device under vacuum, producing 8.6 dB of measured vacuum squeezing down to 10 Hz across the advanced LIGO ‘audio-band’ detection range.
Among the revolutionary predictions of Einstein’s theory of general relativity is the existence of gravitational waves, which are perturbations in the fabric of spacetime that travel at the speed of light. The first indirect evidence pointing to their existence came from the observation of the Hulse-Taylor pulsar in 1974[4]. More recently, gravitational wave observatories like the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatory (LIGO) and Virgo have been built with the purpose of detecting gravitational waves (GW) directly, providing not only further evidence in support of general relativity, but also a whole new way of viewing the cosmos. The strain produced by a passing gravitational wave (namely, the relative change in the length of the matter a gravitational wave passes through) is so small that the best sensitivity achieved by the detectors has not produced a positive detection as of today. With a clear understanding that there should be gravitational waves, scientists are working on improving the sensitivity of the detectors to increase the likelihood of a detection. One of the main sources of noise for the next generation gravitational wave detectors, such as advanced LIGO, is shot noise. Shot noise dominates the noise spectrum above a few hundred Hz. This noise is due to uncertainties in quantum statistics, according to the generalized uncertainty principle. There are two ways to reduce the shot noise. The first way is to increase the intensity of the
The ability to directly detect gravitational waves will open a completely new branch of astronomy to view the Universe, one that is inaccessible to electromagnetic-based astronomy. First generation ground-based interferometric gravitational-wave detectors have achieved strain sensitivities of order one part in ten to the twenty-one, at 100 Hz detection frequency. A new generation of detectors are under construction, designed to improve on the sensitivity of the first-generation detectors by a factor of 10. The quantum nature of light will broadly limit the sensitivity of these new instruments. This quantum noise will originate from the quantum vacuum fluctuations that enter the unused port of the interferometer. One of the most promising options for reducing the quantum noise impact and further increasing the sensitivity is applying quantum squeezed vacuum states. These squeezed states have lower noise in one quadrature than the vacuum state. By replacing the quantum vacuum fluctuations entering the interferometer with squeezed vacuum states, the quantum noise impact is reduced. This thesis firstly details the development of a squeezed light source that produces squeezed states applicable for enhancing interferometric gravitational-wave detectors. A doubly-resonant, travelling-wave bow-tie cavity squeezed light source is presented. For the first time, greater than 10 dB of quantum noise suppression across the gravitational-wave detection band is directly observed, and 11.6 dB of quantum noise suppression is observed above 200 Hz. This squeezing cavity design also has benefits with intrinsic isolation to backscattered light. Experiments that quantify this isolation are reported. The properties affecting squeezing magnitude and low-frequency squeezing measurement are discussed. In addition, a modified squeezing-ellipse-phase control technique for squeezed vacuum states is presented. This thesis secondly presents results from the LIGO Squeezed Light Injection Experiment, undertaken to test squeezed light injection into a 4 km interferometric gravitational-wave detector. The results of the experiment show the first measurement of squeezing-enhancement in a 4 km gravitational-wave detector, with 2.15 dB measured above 250 Hz. This represents the best sensitivity to gravitational waves yet achieved at these frequencies by any single gravitational-wave detector to date. An unknown area was whether the addition of a squeezer would introduce noise couplings that degrade the crucial low frequency sensitivity. The results demonstrate that injected squeezed states are compatible with low frequency gravitational-wave measurement. The characterisation of squeezing-injection optical losses and fluctuations of the squeezing angle are also reported. The knowledge and processes gained, from both the squeezed light source development work and the LIGO Squeezed Light Injection Experiment, will inform the design, planning and implementation of squeezed states in future gravitational-wave detectors.
Direct detection of gravitational waves will require earth based detectors to measure strains of the order 10−21, at frequencies of 100 Hz, a sensitivity that has been accomplished with the initial generation of LIGO interferometric gravitational wave detectors. A new generation of detectors currently under construction is designed improve on the sensitivity of the initial detectors by about a factor of 10. The quantum nature of light will limit the sensitivity of these Advanced LIGO interferometers at most frequencies; new approaches to reducing the quantum noise will be needed to improve the sensitivity further. This quantum noise originates from the vacuum fluctuations that enter the unused port of the interferometer and interfere with the laser light. Vacuum fluctuations have the minimum noise allowed by Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle, ∆X1∆X2 ≥ 1, where the two quadratures X1 and X2 are non-commuting observables responsible for the two forms of quantum noise, shot noise and radiation pressure noise. By replacing the vacuum fluctuations entering the interferometer with squeezed states, which have lower noise in one quadrature than the vacuum state, we have reduced the shot noise of a LIGO interferometer. The sensitivity to gravitational waves measured during this experiment represents the best sensitivity achieved to date at frequencies above 200 Hz, and possibly the first time that squeezing has been measured in an interferometer at frequencies below 700 Hz. The possibility that injection of squeezed states could introduce environmental noise couplings that would degrade the crucial but fragile low frequency sensitivity of a LIGO interferometer has been a major concern in planning to implement squeezing as part of baseline interferometer operations. These results demonstrate that squeezing is compatible with the low frequency sensitivity of a full scale gravitational wave interferometer. We also investigated the limits to the level of squeezing observed, including optical losses and fluctuations of the squeezing angle. The lessons learned should allow for responsible planning to implement squeezing in Advanced LIGO, either as an alternative to high power operation or an early upgrade to improve the sensitivity. This thesis is available at DSpace@MIT and has LIGO document number P1300006. Thesis Supervisor: Nergis Mavalvala Title: Professor of Physics
Gravitational waves are a predication of Einstein's theory of general relativity. After nearly 50 years of effort by the scientific community to construct a detector capable of directly measuring gravitational waves, we expect a breakthrough, the first ever direct measurement of a gravitational wave within the next 5 years. The Advanced LIGO detectors currently under construction are predicted to achieve not only the first detection but to open the field of gravitational-wave astronomy: as an observational window on astrophysics and with an impart on other areas such as cosmology, strong-field gravity, general relativity, and nuclear physics. \n \nThe Advanced LIGO detectors are large-scale laser interferometers that have been designed for very low technical noise so that quantum noise will be limiting their sensitivity over a wide range of their spectrum. Planning for future gravitational wave observatories is already underway and reducing the fundamental quantum noise is considered to be one of the main experimental challenges. My work over the last 4 years has focused on possible new techniques to reduce or circumvent the quantum noise in laser interferometers. \n