Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2602.20347

A note on the conceptual problems on the Unruh effect

Hideyasu Yamashita

gr-qcmath-phquant-phSubmitted Feb 23, 2026• Announced Feb 25, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This brief note is written with a somewhat similar purpose to Earman's 2011 paper on the conceptual problems on the Unruh effect. However, we confine ourselves to Sewell's modular approach to the Unruh effect, which is based on the theorems of Tomita-Takesaki and Bisognano-Wichmann. This approach is rigorous, and has an advantage of being model-independent. However, we will see that a number of conceptual problems remain unsolved on this approach.

Comments
10 pages

Related papers

Consistent Histories Approach to the Unruh Effect

Duncan Noltingk

arXiv:gr-qc/0005063•International Journal of Theoretical Physics•Aug 1, 2001•4 citations

Entanglement Hamiltonians: From Field Theory to Lattice Models and Experiments

Marcello Dalmonte, Viktor Eisler, Marco Falconi +1 more

Abstract Results about entanglement (or modular) Hamiltonians of quantum many‐body systems in field theory and statistical mechanics models, and recent applications in the context of quantum information and quantum simulation, are reviewed. In the first part of the review, what is known about entanglement Hamiltonians of ground states (vacua) in quantum field theory is summarized, based on the Bisognano–Wichmann theorem and its extension to conformal field theory. This is complemented with a more rigorous mathematical discussion of the Bisognano–Wichmann theorem, within the framework of Tomita–Takesaki theorem of modular groups. The second part of the review is devoted to lattice models. There, exactly soluble cases are first considered and then the discussion is extended to non‐integrable models, whose entanglement Hamiltonian is often well captured by the lattice version of the Bisognano–Wichmann theorem. In the last part of the review, recently developed applications in quantum information processing that rely upon the specific properties of entanglement Hamiltonians in many‐body systems are summarized. These include protocols to measure entanglement spectra, and schemes to perform state tomography.

arXiv:2202.05045•Annalen der Physik•Aug 17, 2022•85 citations

Modular Lower Bounds on Reeh-Schlieder State Preparation

Javier Blanco-Romero, Florina Almenares Mendoza

The Reeh-Schlieder theorem says that every target vector can be approximated from the vacuum by an operator localized in an arbitrarily small spacetime region, but it gives no quantitative cost for doing so. This note isolates a standard Tomita-Takesaki estimate as a model-independent preparation bound. Targets with deeply negative modular energy require large local operators. After rescaling such an operator to a physical contraction, the same estimate becomes a lower bound on postselection overhead. In geometries where the modular Hamiltonian is known, the bound becomes explicit. Bisognano-Wichmann turns it into a boost energy statement for wedges, and the Casini-Huerta-Myers formula gives a stress-tensor version for bounded regions of conformal field theories. Local unitaries can only reach states of nonnegative modular energy. Negative modular sectors require nonunitary or postselected outcomes, giving a preparation cost bound that complements vacuum embezzlement in type III local algebras.

hep-thCross-listedarXiv:2605.18640•May 19, 2026•0 citations

On the Theory of the Zeeman Effect

G. GIANFRANCESCHI

Nature•Aug 1, 1925•0 citations

A short note on the Aharonov-Bohm effect

Daniel M. Greenberger

Foundations of Physics•Feb 1, 1991•1 citation

Finite-Precision Algebraic Quantum Field Theory: Quantum Parcels, Locality, Modular Structure and Factors

Abbas Edalat

We develop Interval Algebraic Quantum Field Theory (IAQFT), a finite-precision operational formulation of algebraic quantum field theory (AQFT). Physical experiments provide only finitely many observations at finite resolution and therefore determine regions of compatible states rather than uniquely specified point states. IAQFT represents this information by quantum parcels---non-empty convex weak$^*$ open regions of state space---with observational parcels determined by finitely many finite-precision expectation constraints. Exact AQFT states remain indispensable mathematical objects and are recovered under appropriate parcel refinement. We establish reduction to exact states, measurement update and no-signalling, and formulate locality through compatible parcel nets. In finite dimensions an exact Jacobian formula for invertible Lüders updates gives a volume-contraction criterion. Spacelike vacuum correlations and strict CHSH violations persist throughout sufficiently small observational parcels. Reeh--Schlieder cyclicity becomes finite-precision local reachability, while parcel equivalence of vacuum refinements implies vacuum GNS equivalence and hence does not evade Haag-type obstructions. Tomita--Takesaki modular automorphisms act on parcels, measurement update is modularly covariant, and modular conjugation induces a duality between normal parcels of an algebra and its commutant. State-dependent modular correlations are continuous under predual-norm variation of faithful normal states; shrinking parcels with vanishing KMS defect recover a KMS state. Bisognano--Wichmann yields a parcel formulation of the Unruh effect, recovering the exact KMS relation and Unruh temperature under refinement. Finally, limiting projection faces and their conjugation actions recover the Murray--von Neumann factor classification.

quant-pharXiv:2607.24445•Jul 28, 2026•0 citations
This brief note is written with a somewhat similar purpose to Earman's 2011 paper on the conceptual problems on the Unruh effect. However, we confine ourselves to Sewell's modular approach to the Unruh effect, which is based on the theorems of Tomita-Takesaki and Bisognano-Wichmann. This approach is rigorous, and has an advantage of being model-independent. However, we will see that a number of conceptual problems remain unsolved on this approach.
Abstract Results about entanglement (or modular) Hamiltonians of quantum many‐body systems in field theory and statistical mechanics models, and recent applications in the context of quantum information and quantum simulation, are reviewed. In the first part of the review, what is known about entanglement Hamiltonians of ground states (vacua) in quantum field theory is summarized, based on the Bisognano–Wichmann theorem and its extension to conformal field theory. This is complemented with a more rigorous mathematical discussion of the Bisognano–Wichmann theorem, within the framework of Tomita–Takesaki theorem of modular groups. The second part of the review is devoted to lattice models. There, exactly soluble cases are first considered and then the discussion is extended to non‐integrable models, whose entanglement Hamiltonian is often well captured by the lattice version of the Bisognano–Wichmann theorem. In the last part of the review, recently developed applications in quantum information processing that rely upon the specific properties of entanglement Hamiltonians in many‐body systems are summarized. These include protocols to measure entanglement spectra, and schemes to perform state tomography.
The Reeh-Schlieder theorem says that every target vector can be approximated from the vacuum by an operator localized in an arbitrarily small spacetime region, but it gives no quantitative cost for doing so. This note isolates a standard Tomita-Takesaki estimate as a model-independent preparation bound. Targets with deeply negative modular energy require large local operators. After rescaling such an operator to a physical contraction, the same estimate becomes a lower bound on postselection overhead. In geometries where the modular Hamiltonian is known, the bound becomes explicit. Bisognano-Wichmann turns it into a boost energy statement for wedges, and the Casini-Huerta-Myers formula gives a stress-tensor version for bounded regions of conformal field theories. Local unitaries can only reach states of nonnegative modular energy. Negative modular sectors require nonunitary or postselected outcomes, giving a preparation cost bound that complements vacuum embezzlement in type III local algebras.
We develop Interval Algebraic Quantum Field Theory (IAQFT), a finite-precision operational formulation of algebraic quantum field theory (AQFT). Physical experiments provide only finitely many observations at finite resolution and therefore determine regions of compatible states rather than uniquely specified point states. IAQFT represents this information by quantum parcels---non-empty convex weak∗^*∗ open regions of state space---with observational parcels determined by finitely many finite-precision expectation constraints. Exact AQFT states remain indispensable mathematical objects and are recovered under appropriate parcel refinement. We establish reduction to exact states, measurement update and no-signalling, and formulate locality through compatible parcel nets. In finite dimensions an exact Jacobian formula for invertible Lüders updates gives a volume-contraction criterion. Spacelike vacuum correlations and strict CHSH violations persist throughout sufficiently small observational parcels. Reeh--Schlieder cyclicity becomes finite-precision local reachability, while parcel equivalence of vacuum refinements implies vacuum GNS equivalence and hence does not evade Haag-type obstructions. Tomita--Takesaki modular automorphisms act on parcels, measurement update is modularly covariant, and modular conjugation induces a duality between normal parcels of an algebra and its commutant. State-dependent modular correlations are continuous under predual-norm variation of faithful normal states; shrinking parcels with vanishing KMS defect recover a KMS state. Bisognano--Wichmann yields a parcel formulation of the Unruh effect, recovering the exact KMS relation and Unruh temperature under refinement. Finally, limiting projection faces and their conjugation actions recover the Murray--von Neumann factor classification.