Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2602.19908

Heat flow through the quantum heat valve coupled to ohmic baths via a master equation approach

Antti Vaaranta, Marco Cattaneo, Paolo Muratore-Ginanneschi, Jukka Pekola

quant-phcond-mat.mes-hallSubmitted Feb 23, 2026• Announced Feb 24, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We provide a theoretical model for the non-equilibrium steady state heat flow through a quantum heat valve. The model is based on a master equation approach, where the partial secular approximation has been carefully performed in order to obtain accurate results. Our study assumes an ohmic spectral density for the two thermal baths of the model. This is in contrast with previous treatments of the quantum heat valve, where the baths have been assumed as being structured with a peaked spectral density near the resonance frequency of the resonator. These studies have also taken the resonator to be a part of the open quantum system of interest, which results in double counting of the resonator, as the latter appears both in the spectral density of the bath and as a part of the open system. Although this model accounts for the observations in a satisfactory way, it raises issues regarding its physical interpretation. Our method solves this conceptual problem. We apply it to describe an experiment on a quantum heat valve, showing that it successfully captures the experimental results and improves upon the previous theoretical model, which suffered from the resonator double-counting issue. Our findings confirm that the careful application of the master equation approach, in particular when it comes to the secular approximation, is a useful tool for explaining realistic experimental setups.

Journal reference
J. Low Temp. Phys. 222, 93 (2026)
DOI
10.1007/s10909-026-03426-3

Related papers

Quantum-parametric-oscillator heat engines in squeezed thermal baths: Foundational theoretical issues

Onat Arısoy, Jen-Tsung Hsiang, B. L. Hu

In this paper we examine some foundational issues of a class of quantum engines where the system consists of a single quantum parametric oscillator, operating in an Otto cycle consisting of four stages of two alternating phases: the isentropic phase is detached from any bath (thus a closed system) where the natural frequency of the oscillator is changed from one value to another, and the isothermal phase where the system (now rendered open) is put in contact with one or two squeezed baths of different temperatures, whose nonequilibrium dynamics follows the Hu-Paz-Zhang (HPZ) master equation for quantum Brownian motion. The HPZ equation is an exact non-Markovian equation which preserves the positivity of the density operator and is valid for (1) all temperatures, (2) arbitrary spectral density of the bath, and (3) arbitrary coupling strength between the system and the bath. Taking advantage of these properties we examine some key foundational issues of theories of quantum open and squeezed systems for these two phases of the quantum Otto engines. This includes (1) the non-Markovian regimes for non-Ohmic, low-temperature baths, (2) what to expect in nonadiabatic frequency modulations, (3) strong system-bath coupling, as well as (4) the proper junction conditions between these two phases. Our aim here is not to present ways for attaining higher efficiency but to build a more solid theoretical foundation for quantum engines of continuous variables covering a broader range of parameter spaces that we hope are of use for exploring such possibilities.

arXiv:2106.12325•Physical review. E•Jan 7, 2022•9 citations

Application of a non-linear thermodynamic master equation to three-level quantum systems

Panagiotis V. Alatas

In this Master’s thesis, we have focused on the description of three-level quantum systems through master equations for their density matrix, involving a recently proposed non-linear thermodynamic one. The first part is focused on a three-level system interacting with two heat baths, a hot and a cold one. We investigated the rate of heat flow from the hot to the cold bath through the quantum system, and how the steady-state is approached. Additional calculations here refer to the rate of entropy production and the evolution of all elements of the density matrix of the system from an arbitrary initial state to their equilibrium or steady-state value. The results are compared against those of a linear, Lindblad-type master equation designed so that for a quantum system interacting with only one heat bath, the same final Gibbs steady state is attained. In the second part of this thesis, we focus on the electromagnetically induced transparency (EIT), a phenomenon typically achievable only in atoms with specific energy structures. For a three level system (to which the present study has focused), for example, EIT requires two dipole allowed transitions (the 1-3 and the 2-3) and one forbidden (the 1-2). The phenomenon is observed when a strong laser (termed the control laser) is tuned to the resonant frequency of the upper two levels. Then, as a weak probe laser is scanned in frequency across the other transition, the medium is observed to exhibit both: a) transparency at what was the maximal absorption in the absence of the coupling field, and b) large dispersion effects at the atomic resonance. We discuss the Hamiltonian describing the phenomenon and we present results from two types of master equations: a) an empirically modified Von-Neumann one allowing for decays from each energy state, and b) a typical Lindblad one, with time-dependent operators. In the first case, an analytical solution is possible, which has been confirmed through a direct solution of the full master equation. In the second case, only numerical results can be obtained. We present and compare results from the two master equations for the susceptibility of the system with respect to the probe field, and we discuss them in light also of available experimental data for this very important phenomenon.

•Jan 3, 2014•0 citations

Master equation for a particle coupled to a two-level reservoir

Paulo C. Marques, A. H. Castro Neto

We study the quantum dissipative dynamics of a particle coupled linearly to a set of two-level systems (the heat bath) via the master equation method, which we extract from the path integral formalism independently from the form of the bath spectral density. We compare our results with the standard models based on bosonic heat baths, showing their main differences and similarities. In particular, we study special forms for the spectral density of the bath which give results quite different from the standard models.

arXiv:cond-mat/9409072•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Oct 15, 1995•1 citation

Numerical implementation of the partial secular approximation and unified master equation in structured open quantum systems

Antti Vaaranta, Marco Cattaneo

The Markovian dynamics of open quantum systems is typically described through Lindblad equations, which are derived from the Redfield equation via the full secular approximation. The latter neglects the rotating terms in the master equation corresponding to pairs of jump operators with different Bohr frequencies. However, for many physical systems this approximation breaks down, and thus a more accurate treatment of the slowly rotating terms is required. Indeed, more precise physical results can be obtained by performing the partial secular approximation, which takes into account the relevant time scale associated with each pair of jump operators and compares it with the time scale arising from the system-environment coupling. In this work, we introduce a general code for performing the partial secular approximation in the Redfield equation for structured open quantum systems. The code can be applied to a generic Hamiltonian of any multipartite system coupled to bosonic baths. Moreover, it can also reproduce the unified master equation , which captures the same physical behavior as the Redfield equation under the partial secular approximation, but is mathematically guaranteed to generate a completely positive dynamical map. Finally, the code can compute both the local and global version of the master equation for the same physical problem. We illustrate the code by studying the steady-state heat flow in a structured open quantum system composed of two superconducting qubits, each coupled to a bosonic mode, which in turn interacts with a thermal bath. The results in this work can be employed for the numerical study of a wide range of complex open quantum systems.

arXiv:2508.17970•Computer Physics Communications•Nov 21, 2025•2 citations

The Effective Hamiltonian Method in the Thermodynamics of Two Resonantly Interacting Quantum Oscillators

Andrew I. Trubilko, Ashat M. Basharov

Abstract We investigate the classical problem of two resonantly interacting oscillators each of which is coupled to “its own” heat bath based on the effective Hamiltonian method and the quantum stochastic differential equation (in contrast to the well-known “global” and “local” approaches). We show that in the second order of the algebraic perturbation theory, each of the oscillators turns out to be also coupled to the “foreign” heat bath. We calculate the steady-state heat flows and prove that there is no heat flow from the cold heat bath to the hot one, as evidenced by some results of the local approach.

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics•Sep 1, 2019•12 citations

Heat transport in driven quantum systems: Comparison between the Floquet-Redfield equation and the master equation in the instantaneous eigenbasis

Luca Magazzù, Christoforus Dimas Satrya, Aleksandr S. Strelnikov +2 more

We provide a comprehensive study of heat transport in periodically driven quantum systems using a master equation approach in the Floquet basis. Starting from the exact, formal expressions, we obtain, within the weak coupling regime of system-bath coupling, a generalized Floquet-Redfield master equation which does not involve Markovian or secular approximations and the corresponding formula for the heat current. From this approach we derive the standard, full secular master equation. Moreover, we present a master equation for the driven spin-boson model in the instantaneous eigenbasis. The different approaches are compared by applying them to the steady-state heat transport in the driven spin-boson model. An analytical solution is provided for the master equation in the instantaneous eigenbasis which reproduces the numerics and explains the features of the heat current as a function of the drive parameters.

quant-pharXiv:2608.13308•Aug 14, 2026•0 citations
We provide a theoretical model for the non-equilibrium steady state heat flow through a quantum heat valve. The model is based on a master equation approach, where the partial secular approximation has been carefully performed in order to obtain accurate results. Our study assumes an ohmic spectral density for the two thermal baths of the model. This is in contrast with previous treatments of the quantum heat valve, where the baths have been assumed as being structured with a peaked spectral density near the resonance frequency of the resonator. These studies have also taken the resonator to be a part of the open quantum system of interest, which results in double counting of the resonator, as the latter appears both in the spectral density of the bath and as a part of the open system. Although this model accounts for the observations in a satisfactory way, it raises issues regarding its physical interpretation. Our method solves this conceptual problem. We apply it to describe an experiment on a quantum heat valve, showing that it successfully captures the experimental results and improves upon the previous theoretical model, which suffered from the resonator double-counting issue. Our findings confirm that the careful application of the master equation approach, in particular when it comes to the secular approximation, is a useful tool for explaining realistic experimental setups.
In this paper we examine some foundational issues of a class of quantum engines where the system consists of a single quantum parametric oscillator, operating in an Otto cycle consisting of four stages of two alternating phases: the isentropic phase is detached from any bath (thus a closed system) where the natural frequency of the oscillator is changed from one value to another, and the isothermal phase where the system (now rendered open) is put in contact with one or two squeezed baths of different temperatures, whose nonequilibrium dynamics follows the Hu-Paz-Zhang (HPZ) master equation for quantum Brownian motion. The HPZ equation is an exact non-Markovian equation which preserves the positivity of the density operator and is valid for (1) all temperatures, (2) arbitrary spectral density of the bath, and (3) arbitrary coupling strength between the system and the bath. Taking advantage of these properties we examine some key foundational issues of theories of quantum open and squeezed systems for these two phases of the quantum Otto engines. This includes (1) the non-Markovian regimes for non-Ohmic, low-temperature baths, (2) what to expect in nonadiabatic frequency modulations, (3) strong system-bath coupling, as well as (4) the proper junction conditions between these two phases. Our aim here is not to present ways for attaining higher efficiency but to build a more solid theoretical foundation for quantum engines of continuous variables covering a broader range of parameter spaces that we hope are of use for exploring such possibilities.
In this Master’s thesis, we have focused on the description of three-level quantum systems through master equations for their density matrix, involving a recently proposed non-linear thermodynamic one. The first part is focused on a three-level system interacting with two heat baths, a hot and a cold one. We investigated the rate of heat flow from the hot to the cold bath through the quantum system, and how the steady-state is approached. Additional calculations here refer to the rate of entropy production and the evolution of all elements of the density matrix of the system from an arbitrary initial state to their equilibrium or steady-state value. The results are compared against those of a linear, Lindblad-type master equation designed so that for a quantum system interacting with only one heat bath, the same final Gibbs steady state is attained. In the second part of this thesis, we focus on the electromagnetically induced transparency (EIT), a phenomenon typically achievable only in atoms with specific energy structures. For a three level system (to which the present study has focused), for example, EIT requires two dipole allowed transitions (the 1-3 and the 2-3) and one forbidden (the 1-2). The phenomenon is observed when a strong laser (termed the control laser) is tuned to the resonant frequency of the upper two levels. Then, as a weak probe laser is scanned in frequency across the other transition, the medium is observed to exhibit both: a) transparency at what was the maximal absorption in the absence of the coupling field, and b) large dispersion effects at the atomic resonance. We discuss the Hamiltonian describing the phenomenon and we present results from two types of master equations: a) an empirically modified Von-Neumann one allowing for decays from each energy state, and b) a typical Lindblad one, with time-dependent operators. In the first case, an analytical solution is possible, which has been confirmed through a direct solution of the full master equation. In the second case, only numerical results can be obtained. We present and compare results from the two master equations for the susceptibility of the system with respect to the probe field, and we discuss them in light also of available experimental data for this very important phenomenon.
We study the quantum dissipative dynamics of a particle coupled linearly to a set of two-level systems (the heat bath) via the master equation method, which we extract from the path integral formalism independently from the form of the bath spectral density. We compare our results with the standard models based on bosonic heat baths, showing their main differences and similarities. In particular, we study special forms for the spectral density of the bath which give results quite different from the standard models.
The Markovian dynamics of open quantum systems is typically described through Lindblad equations, which are derived from the Redfield equation via the full secular approximation. The latter neglects the rotating terms in the master equation corresponding to pairs of jump operators with different Bohr frequencies. However, for many physical systems this approximation breaks down, and thus a more accurate treatment of the slowly rotating terms is required. Indeed, more precise physical results can be obtained by performing the partial secular approximation, which takes into account the relevant time scale associated with each pair of jump operators and compares it with the time scale arising from the system-environment coupling. In this work, we introduce a general code for performing the partial secular approximation in the Redfield equation for structured open quantum systems. The code can be applied to a generic Hamiltonian of any multipartite system coupled to bosonic baths. Moreover, it can also reproduce the unified master equation , which captures the same physical behavior as the Redfield equation under the partial secular approximation, but is mathematically guaranteed to generate a completely positive dynamical map. Finally, the code can compute both the local and global version of the master equation for the same physical problem. We illustrate the code by studying the steady-state heat flow in a structured open quantum system composed of two superconducting qubits, each coupled to a bosonic mode, which in turn interacts with a thermal bath. The results in this work can be employed for the numerical study of a wide range of complex open quantum systems.
Abstract We investigate the classical problem of two resonantly interacting oscillators each of which is coupled to “its own” heat bath based on the effective Hamiltonian method and the quantum stochastic differential equation (in contrast to the well-known “global” and “local” approaches). We show that in the second order of the algebraic perturbation theory, each of the oscillators turns out to be also coupled to the “foreign” heat bath. We calculate the steady-state heat flows and prove that there is no heat flow from the cold heat bath to the hot one, as evidenced by some results of the local approach.
We provide a comprehensive study of heat transport in periodically driven quantum systems using a master equation approach in the Floquet basis. Starting from the exact, formal expressions, we obtain, within the weak coupling regime of system-bath coupling, a generalized Floquet-Redfield master equation which does not involve Markovian or secular approximations and the corresponding formula for the heat current. From this approach we derive the standard, full secular master equation. Moreover, we present a master equation for the driven spin-boson model in the instantaneous eigenbasis. The different approaches are compared by applying them to the steady-state heat transport in the driven spin-boson model. An analytical solution is provided for the master equation in the instantaneous eigenbasis which reproduces the numerics and explains the features of the heat current as a function of the drive parameters.