Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2602.14105

Non-Hermitian Quantum Mechanics of Open Quantum Systems: Revisiting The One-Body Problem

Naomichi Hatano, Gonzalo Ordonez

quant-phmath-phnucl-thSubmitted Feb 15, 2026• Announced Feb 17, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We review analyses of open quantum systems. We show how non-Hermiticity arises in an open quantum system with an infinite environment, focusing on the one-body problem. One of the reasons for taking the present approach is that we can solve the problem completely, making it easier to see the structures of problems involving open quantum systems. We show that this results in the discovery of a new complete set, which is one of the main topics of the present article. Another reason for focusing on the one-body problem is that the theory permits the strong coupling between the system and the environment. In the current research landscape, it is valuable to revisit the one-body problem for open quantum systems, which can be solved accurately for arbitrary strengths of the system-environment couplings. A rigorous understanding of the problem structures in the present approach will be helpful when we tackle problems with many-body interactions. First, we consider potential scattering and directly define the resonant state as an eigenstate of the Schrödinger equation under the Siegert outgoing boundary condition. We show that the resonant eigenstate can have a complex energy eigenvalue, even though the Hamiltonian is seemingly Hermitian. Second, we introduce the Feshbach formalism, which eliminates the infinite degrees of freedom of the environment and represents its effect as a complex potential. The resulting effective Hamiltonian is explicitly non-Hermitian. By unifying these two ways of defining resonant states, we obtain a new complete set of bases for the scattering problem that contains all discrete eigenstates, including resonant states. We finally mention the non-Markovian dynamics of open quantum systems. We emphasize the time-reversal symmetry of the dynamics that continuously connects the past and the future. We can capture it using the new complete set that we develop here.

Comments
41 pages, 25 figures, a review article

Related papers

What is the resonant state in open quantum systems?

Naomichi Hatano

Abstract The article reviews the theory of open quantum system from a perspective of the non-Hermiticity that emerges from the environment with an infinite number of degrees of freedom. The non-Hermiticity produces resonant states with complex eigenvalues, resulting in peak structures in scattering amplitudes and transport coefficients. After introducing the definition of resonant states with complex eigenvalues, we answer typical questions regarding the non-Hermiticity of open quantum systems. What is the physical meaning of the complex eigenmomenta and eigenenergies? How and why do the resonant states break the time-reversal symmetry that the system observes? Can we make the probabilistic interpretation of the resonant states with diverging wave functions? What is the physical meaning of the divergence of the wave functions? We also present an alternative way of finding resonant states, namely the Feshbach formalism, in which we eliminate the infinite number of the environmental degrees of freedom. In this formalism, we attribute the non-Hermiticity to the introduction of the retarded and advanced Green’s functions.

arXiv:2106.15068•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Oct 1, 2021•8 citations

P T -symmetric, non-Hermitian quantum many-body physics—a methodological perspective

V. Meden, Lukas Grunwald, Dante Marvin Kennes

We review the methodology to theoretically treat parity-time- (PT-) symmetric, non-Hermitian quantum many-body systems. They are realized as open quantum systems withPTsymmetry and couplings to the environment which are compatible.PT-symmetric non-Hermitian quantum systems show a variety of fascinating properties which single them out among generic open systems. The study of the latter has a long history in quantum theory. These studies are based on the Hermiticity of the combined system-reservoir setup and were developed by the atomic, molecular, and optical physics as well as the condensed matter physics communities. The interest of the mathematical physics community inPT-symmetric, non-Hermitian systems led to a new perspective and the development of the elegant mathematical formalisms ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics, which do not make any reference to the environment. In the mathematical physics research, the focus is mainly on the remarkable spectral properties of the Hamiltonians and the characteristics of the corresponding single-particle eigenstates. Despite being non-Hermitian, the Hamiltonians can show parameter regimes, in which all eigenvalues are real. To investigate emergent quantum many-body phenomena in condensed matter physics and to make contact to experiments one, however, needs to study expectation values of observables and correlation functions. One furthermore, has to investigate statistical ensembles and not only eigenstates. The adoption of the concepts ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics by parts of the condensed matter community led to a controversial status of the methodology. There is no consensus on fundamental issues, such as, what a proper observable is, how expectation values are supposed to be computed, and what adequate equilibrium statistical ensembles and their corresponding density matrices are. With the technological progress in engineering and controlling open quantum many-body systems it is high time to reconcile the Hermitian with thePT-symmetric and biorthogonal perspectives. We comprehensively review the different approaches, including the overreaching idea of pseudo-Hermiticity. To motivate the Hermitian perspective, which we propagate here, we mainly focus on the ancilla approach. It allows to embed a non-Hermitian system into a larger, Hermitian one. In contrast to other techniques, e.g. master equations, it does not rely on any approximations. We discuss the peculiarities ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics. In these, what is considered to be an observable depends on the Hamiltonian or the selected (biorthonormal) basis. Crucially in addition, what is denoted as an 'expectation value' lacks a direct probabilistic interpretation, and what is viewed as the canonical density matrix is non-stationary and non-Hermitian. Furthermore, the non-unitarity of the time evolution is hidden within the formalism. We pick up several model Hamiltonians, which so far were either investigated from the Hermitian perspective or from thePT-symmetric and biorthogonal one, and study them within the respective alternative framework. This includes a simple two-level, single-particle problem but also a many-body lattice model showing quantum critical behavior. Comparing the outcome of the two types of computations shows that the Hermitian approach, which, admittedly, is in parts clumsy, always leads to results which are physically sensible. In the rare cases, in which a comparison to experimental data is possible, they furthermore agree to these. In contrast, the mathematically elegantPT-symmetric and biorthogonal approaches lead to results which, are partly difficult to interpret physically. We thus conclude that the Hermitian methodology should be employed. However, to fully appreciate the physics ofPT-symmetric, non-Hermitian quantum many-body systems, it is also important to be aware of the main concepts ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics. Our conclusion has far reaching consequences for the application of Green function methods, functional integrals, and generating functionals, which are at the heart of a large number of many-body methods. They cannot be transferred in their established forms to treatPT-symmetric, non-Hermitian quantum systems. It can be considered as an irony of fate that these methods are available only within the mathematical formalisms ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2303.05956•Reports on Progress in Physics•Oct 23, 2023•47 citations

Effective Hamiltonians and non-Hermitian physics

Ugo Sébastien Lair, David Guéry-Odelin

Abstract Every realistic quantum system is coupled to an environment. Including the environment restores a closed, Hermitian description, but at the cost of an intractably large Hilbert space. The Feshbach–Löwdin projection eliminates the unwanted degrees of freedom exactly, yielding an effective Hamiltonian H eff on the relevant subspace alone—which generically becomes non-Hermitian when the eliminated subspace contains an energetically accessible continuum and outgoing boundary conditions are imposed. We illustrate this through a minimal model: a particle in a box with a delta barrier at its center. Direct elimination of one half-well reduces all information about the discarded sector to a single boundary parameter β ; the same result is then rederived via the Green’s function and Dyson equation, offering a pedagogical illustration of how boundary data enter the Green’s-function formalism and relating β to a self-energy term. Whether β is real or complex determines whether H eff is Hermitian or not, and the full range of behavior—from Hermitian dynamics through finite-width resonances to the counterintuitive quantum Zeno effect—follows from this single parameter.

arXiv:2611.05268•European Journal of Physics•Aug 25, 2026•0 citations

Feshbach Resonances: The Branching of Quantum Mechanics into Hermitian and Non-Hermitian Formalisms

Nimrod Moiseyev

As has been shown long time ago by Feshbach, the exact energy spectrum of the full problem can be obtained by solving two different self-energy problems. In spite of the fact that the two effective Hamiltonians are derived in very similar ways in one case, the exact energy spectrum of the full problem can be either real or complex (depending on the boundary conditions), whereas the exact energy spectrum associated with the second effective Hamiltonian has to be complex (excluding bound states in the continuum). The focus of this paper is on the fact that in both cases the complex eigenvalues result from the same requirement of an out-going boundary condition. The branching of quantum mechanics to standard (Hermitian) formalism and non-Hermitian formalism is associated with the decision to express the exact energy spectrum with one of the two possible self-consistent like problems where the use of the Green operator imposes an outgoing boundary condition on the solutions of the time-independent Schrodinger equation. Our analysis is made for the case where an ABC molecule has sufficient energy to dissociate to A + BC but not to A + B + C and not to AB + C or to AC + B.

The Journal of Physical Chemistry A•Mar 19, 2009•4 citations

Non-Markovian open quantum many-body system dynamics

Regina Finsterhölzl

The study of open quantum systems forms one of the main problems of modern physics. This thesis aims at contributing to this field, and focuses on the investigation of non-Markovian dynamics of open quantum systems. Here, as a special case, quantum many-body systems provide for a rich field of research. With the ability to control them being of essential importance for the development of quantum technologies, the characterization of their dynamical properties has also drawn a lot of interest lately. One of the main methodological tasks in the study of open quantum systems is to reduce the infinite degrees of freedom of the total system. In order to achieve this, the thesis makes use of the tensor network method matrix product states and combines it with the picture of the quantum stochastic Schrödinger equation. However, when computing the dynamics of many-body systems of system size N, even the reduced system dynamics scale with 2N, making larger system sizes difficult to access. Therefore, especially when computing non-Markovian time-dynamics where the information backflow from the reservoir has to be taken into account, efficiently constructed algorithms are required. This thesis proposes these type of algorithms and demonstrates their application. They enable an access to larger system sizes, thus making it possible to investigate non-equilibrium steady-states of quantum many-body systems in a non-Markovian interaction for system sizes up to N=30. This thesis consists of three parts. The first part provides an introduction to the theory of open quantum systems and to the methodology for modeling them. The second part examines many-body system-reservoir interaction in the non-Markovian regime by investigating the case of fully coherent self-feedback. It uses the one-dimensional Heisenberg spin-1/2 chain as a paradigmatic and recently intensely studied many-body system. It is demonstrated that this gives rise to new conditions for the feedback phase and to highly non-trivial states within the system as well as to the possibility of partially characterizing the system non-invasively and storing excitation within it. Next, a novel approach to the boundary-driven Heisenberg chain is presented, where the chain is exposed to a coherent driving field, thus enabling a comparison to the well-studied incoherently driven model. The third part demonstrates the use of an external pump to control the feedback phase of a Lambda-type three-level system, where the external pump pulse is shown to be a new control parameter. The thesis concludes with the proposition to enhance the indistinguishability of two photons by feedback control.

•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

The point where QM branches into two formalisms

Nimrod Moiseyev

Although the standard formalism of quantum mechanics is based on the requirement of the physical operators to be Hermitian, the use of non-Hermitian operators in the study of different types of phenomena is not uncommon. One of the most well-known non-Hermitian potentials is the optical potential where for any given choice of N channels the exact eigenvalue is a solution of a single-channel problem. The optical potential is a non-Hermitian, non-local and energy-dependent operator. In his book on scattering theory Taylor writes: “In practice, the optical potential is far too complicated for exact use in actual calculations”. It is often believed that the complex energies which are obtained by the use of optical potentials result from the approximations in the calculations. However, this is not true. The complex energy obtained by solving the one-channel problem with an optical potential is the exact eigenvalue of the original N-channel problem which is obtained by imposing outgoing boundary conditions on the eigenfunctions of the time-independent Schrödinger equation. In this chapter we wish to show that the study of the resonances in multi-channel problems (so-called Feshbach resonances) can be considered as the point where quantum mechanics branches into the standard (Hermitian) and non-standard (non-Hermitan) formalisms.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 17, 2011•0 citations
We review analyses of open quantum systems. We show how non-Hermiticity arises in an open quantum system with an infinite environment, focusing on the one-body problem. One of the reasons for taking the present approach is that we can solve the problem completely, making it easier to see the structures of problems involving open quantum systems. We show that this results in the discovery of a new complete set, which is one of the main topics of the present article. Another reason for focusing on the one-body problem is that the theory permits the strong coupling between the system and the environment. In the current research landscape, it is valuable to revisit the one-body problem for open quantum systems, which can be solved accurately for arbitrary strengths of the system-environment couplings. A rigorous understanding of the problem structures in the present approach will be helpful when we tackle problems with many-body interactions. First, we consider potential scattering and directly define the resonant state as an eigenstate of the Schrödinger equation under the Siegert outgoing boundary condition. We show that the resonant eigenstate can have a complex energy eigenvalue, even though the Hamiltonian is seemingly Hermitian. Second, we introduce the Feshbach formalism, which eliminates the infinite degrees of freedom of the environment and represents its effect as a complex potential. The resulting effective Hamiltonian is explicitly non-Hermitian. By unifying these two ways of defining resonant states, we obtain a new complete set of bases for the scattering problem that contains all discrete eigenstates, including resonant states. We finally mention the non-Markovian dynamics of open quantum systems. We emphasize the time-reversal symmetry of the dynamics that continuously connects the past and the future. We can capture it using the new complete set that we develop here.
Abstract The article reviews the theory of open quantum system from a perspective of the non-Hermiticity that emerges from the environment with an infinite number of degrees of freedom. The non-Hermiticity produces resonant states with complex eigenvalues, resulting in peak structures in scattering amplitudes and transport coefficients. After introducing the definition of resonant states with complex eigenvalues, we answer typical questions regarding the non-Hermiticity of open quantum systems. What is the physical meaning of the complex eigenmomenta and eigenenergies? How and why do the resonant states break the time-reversal symmetry that the system observes? Can we make the probabilistic interpretation of the resonant states with diverging wave functions? What is the physical meaning of the divergence of the wave functions? We also present an alternative way of finding resonant states, namely the Feshbach formalism, in which we eliminate the infinite number of the environmental degrees of freedom. In this formalism, we attribute the non-Hermiticity to the introduction of the retarded and advanced Green’s functions.
We review the methodology to theoretically treat parity-time- (PT-) symmetric, non-Hermitian quantum many-body systems. They are realized as open quantum systems withPTsymmetry and couplings to the environment which are compatible.PT-symmetric non-Hermitian quantum systems show a variety of fascinating properties which single them out among generic open systems. The study of the latter has a long history in quantum theory. These studies are based on the Hermiticity of the combined system-reservoir setup and were developed by the atomic, molecular, and optical physics as well as the condensed matter physics communities. The interest of the mathematical physics community inPT-symmetric, non-Hermitian systems led to a new perspective and the development of the elegant mathematical formalisms ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics, which do not make any reference to the environment. In the mathematical physics research, the focus is mainly on the remarkable spectral properties of the Hamiltonians and the characteristics of the corresponding single-particle eigenstates. Despite being non-Hermitian, the Hamiltonians can show parameter regimes, in which all eigenvalues are real. To investigate emergent quantum many-body phenomena in condensed matter physics and to make contact to experiments one, however, needs to study expectation values of observables and correlation functions. One furthermore, has to investigate statistical ensembles and not only eigenstates. The adoption of the concepts ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics by parts of the condensed matter community led to a controversial status of the methodology. There is no consensus on fundamental issues, such as, what a proper observable is, how expectation values are supposed to be computed, and what adequate equilibrium statistical ensembles and their corresponding density matrices are. With the technological progress in engineering and controlling open quantum many-body systems it is high time to reconcile the Hermitian with thePT-symmetric and biorthogonal perspectives. We comprehensively review the different approaches, including the overreaching idea of pseudo-Hermiticity. To motivate the Hermitian perspective, which we propagate here, we mainly focus on the ancilla approach. It allows to embed a non-Hermitian system into a larger, Hermitian one. In contrast to other techniques, e.g. master equations, it does not rely on any approximations. We discuss the peculiarities ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics. In these, what is considered to be an observable depends on the Hamiltonian or the selected (biorthonormal) basis. Crucially in addition, what is denoted as an 'expectation value' lacks a direct probabilistic interpretation, and what is viewed as the canonical density matrix is non-stationary and non-Hermitian. Furthermore, the non-unitarity of the time evolution is hidden within the formalism. We pick up several model Hamiltonians, which so far were either investigated from the Hermitian perspective or from thePT-symmetric and biorthogonal one, and study them within the respective alternative framework. This includes a simple two-level, single-particle problem but also a many-body lattice model showing quantum critical behavior. Comparing the outcome of the two types of computations shows that the Hermitian approach, which, admittedly, is in parts clumsy, always leads to results which are physically sensible. In the rare cases, in which a comparison to experimental data is possible, they furthermore agree to these. In contrast, the mathematically elegantPT-symmetric and biorthogonal approaches lead to results which, are partly difficult to interpret physically. We thus conclude that the Hermitian methodology should be employed. However, to fully appreciate the physics ofPT-symmetric, non-Hermitian quantum many-body systems, it is also important to be aware of the main concepts ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics. Our conclusion has far reaching consequences for the application of Green function methods, functional integrals, and generating functionals, which are at the heart of a large number of many-body methods. They cannot be transferred in their established forms to treatPT-symmetric, non-Hermitian quantum systems. It can be considered as an irony of fate that these methods are available only within the mathematical formalisms ofPT-symmetric and biorthogonal quantum mechanics.
Abstract Every realistic quantum system is coupled to an environment. Including the environment restores a closed, Hermitian description, but at the cost of an intractably large Hilbert space. The Feshbach–Löwdin projection eliminates the unwanted degrees of freedom exactly, yielding an effective Hamiltonian H eff on the relevant subspace alone—which generically becomes non-Hermitian when the eliminated subspace contains an energetically accessible continuum and outgoing boundary conditions are imposed. We illustrate this through a minimal model: a particle in a box with a delta barrier at its center. Direct elimination of one half-well reduces all information about the discarded sector to a single boundary parameter β ; the same result is then rederived via the Green’s function and Dyson equation, offering a pedagogical illustration of how boundary data enter the Green’s-function formalism and relating β to a self-energy term. Whether β is real or complex determines whether H eff is Hermitian or not, and the full range of behavior—from Hermitian dynamics through finite-width resonances to the counterintuitive quantum Zeno effect—follows from this single parameter.
As has been shown long time ago by Feshbach, the exact energy spectrum of the full problem can be obtained by solving two different self-energy problems. In spite of the fact that the two effective Hamiltonians are derived in very similar ways in one case, the exact energy spectrum of the full problem can be either real or complex (depending on the boundary conditions), whereas the exact energy spectrum associated with the second effective Hamiltonian has to be complex (excluding bound states in the continuum). The focus of this paper is on the fact that in both cases the complex eigenvalues result from the same requirement of an out-going boundary condition. The branching of quantum mechanics to standard (Hermitian) formalism and non-Hermitian formalism is associated with the decision to express the exact energy spectrum with one of the two possible self-consistent like problems where the use of the Green operator imposes an outgoing boundary condition on the solutions of the time-independent Schrodinger equation. Our analysis is made for the case where an ABC molecule has sufficient energy to dissociate to A + BC but not to A + B + C and not to AB + C or to AC + B.
The study of open quantum systems forms one of the main problems of modern physics. This thesis aims at contributing to this field, and focuses on the investigation of non-Markovian dynamics of open quantum systems. Here, as a special case, quantum many-body systems provide for a rich field of research. With the ability to control them being of essential importance for the development of quantum technologies, the characterization of their dynamical properties has also drawn a lot of interest lately. One of the main methodological tasks in the study of open quantum systems is to reduce the infinite degrees of freedom of the total system. In order to achieve this, the thesis makes use of the tensor network method matrix product states and combines it with the picture of the quantum stochastic Schrödinger equation. However, when computing the dynamics of many-body systems of system size N, even the reduced system dynamics scale with 2N, making larger system sizes difficult to access. Therefore, especially when computing non-Markovian time-dynamics where the information backflow from the reservoir has to be taken into account, efficiently constructed algorithms are required. This thesis proposes these type of algorithms and demonstrates their application. They enable an access to larger system sizes, thus making it possible to investigate non-equilibrium steady-states of quantum many-body systems in a non-Markovian interaction for system sizes up to N=30. This thesis consists of three parts. The first part provides an introduction to the theory of open quantum systems and to the methodology for modeling them. The second part examines many-body system-reservoir interaction in the non-Markovian regime by investigating the case of fully coherent self-feedback. It uses the one-dimensional Heisenberg spin-1/2 chain as a paradigmatic and recently intensely studied many-body system. It is demonstrated that this gives rise to new conditions for the feedback phase and to highly non-trivial states within the system as well as to the possibility of partially characterizing the system non-invasively and storing excitation within it. Next, a novel approach to the boundary-driven Heisenberg chain is presented, where the chain is exposed to a coherent driving field, thus enabling a comparison to the well-studied incoherently driven model. The third part demonstrates the use of an external pump to control the feedback phase of a Lambda-type three-level system, where the external pump pulse is shown to be a new control parameter. The thesis concludes with the proposition to enhance the indistinguishability of two photons by feedback control.
Although the standard formalism of quantum mechanics is based on the requirement of the physical operators to be Hermitian, the use of non-Hermitian operators in the study of different types of phenomena is not uncommon. One of the most well-known non-Hermitian potentials is the optical potential where for any given choice of N channels the exact eigenvalue is a solution of a single-channel problem. The optical potential is a non-Hermitian, non-local and energy-dependent operator. In his book on scattering theory Taylor writes: “In practice, the optical potential is far too complicated for exact use in actual calculations”. It is often believed that the complex energies which are obtained by the use of optical potentials result from the approximations in the calculations. However, this is not true. The complex energy obtained by solving the one-channel problem with an optical potential is the exact eigenvalue of the original N-channel problem which is obtained by imposing outgoing boundary conditions on the eigenfunctions of the time-independent Schrödinger equation. In this chapter we wish to show that the study of the resonances in multi-channel problems (so-called Feshbach resonances) can be considered as the point where quantum mechanics branches into the standard (Hermitian) and non-standard (non-Hermitan) formalisms.