Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2601.06549 · Physical Review Letters

Gapped Topological Spin-Orbital Liquid on the Honeycomb Lattice

Masahiko G. Yamada

Published Sep 10, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We perform large-scale density matrix renormalization group simulations of the SU(4) Heisenberg model on the honeycomb lattice to address the long-standing question of its ground state in an unbiased and quantitatively controlled manner. We find reliable numerical evidence that the ground state is a gapped spin-orbital liquid, presumably with a Z_{4} topological order, characterized by a finite topological entanglement entropy close to ln(4), the absence of both SU(4) and lattice symmetry breaking, and a variationally optimized ground-state energy well below the previously proposed π-flux variational state. By exploiting full SU(4) symmetry and keeping up to 12 800 SU(4) multiplets, corresponding to more than 1×10^{6} U(1) states, we achieve unprecedented accuracy for two-dimensional SU(4) quantum magnets. Finite-size scaling of energies and entanglement entropies supports a robust gapped phase in the two-dimensional limit, while a gapless critical state on narrow cylinders is identified as a proximate remnant of a Dirac spin-orbital liquid. Our results find the SU(4) honeycomb Heisenberg model a realization of a gapped topological spin-orbital liquid and provide convincing numerical evidence for topological order in a highly symmetric two-dimensional quantum magnet.

DOI
10.1103/s5lx-7n3r

Related papers

Twisting the Dirac cones of the SU(4) spin-orbital liquid on the honeycomb lattice

Hui-Ke Jin, W. M. H. Natori, Johannes Knolle

By combining the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) method with Gutzwiller projected wave functions, we study the SU(4) symmetric spin-orbital model on the honeycomb lattice. We find that the ground states can be well described by a Gutzwiller projected $\ensuremath{\pi}$-flux state with Dirac-type gapless excitations at one quarter filling. Although these Dirac points are gapped by emergent gauge fluxes on finite cylinders, they govern the critical behavior in the thermodynamic limit. By inserting a $\ensuremath{\theta}=\ensuremath{\pi}$ spin flux to twist the boundary condition, we can shift the gapless sector to the ground state, which provides compelling evidence for the presence of a gapless Dirac spin-orbital liquid.

arXiv:2207.02239•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 1, 2023•14 citations

Spin liquid ground state of the spin- 1 2 square J 1 - J 2 Heisenberg model

Hong‐Chen Jiang, Hong Yao, Leon Balents

We perform highly accurate density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) simulations to investigate the ground-state properties of the spin-$1/2$ antiferromagnetic square lattice Heisenberg ${J}_{1}$-${J}_{2}$ model. Based on studies of numerous long cylinders with circumferences of up to 14 lattice spacings, we obtain strong evidence for a topological quantum spin liquid state in the region $0.41\ensuremath{\le}{J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\le}0.62$, separating conventional N\'eel and striped antiferromagnetic states for smaller and larger ${J}_{2}/{J}_{1}$, respectively. The quantum spin liquid is characterized numerically by the absence of magnetic or valence bond solid order, and nonzero singlet and triplet energy gaps. Furthermore, we positively identify its topological nature by measuring a nonzero topological entanglement entropy $\ensuremath{\gamma}=0.70\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.02$, extremely close to $\ensuremath{\gamma}=\mathrm{ln}(2)\ensuremath{\approx}0.69$ (expected for a ${Z}_{2}$ quantum spin liquid) and a nontrivial finite size dimerization effect depending upon the parity of the circumference of the cylinder. We also point out that a valence bond solid, and indeed any discrete symmetry breaking state, would be expected to show a constant correction to the entanglement entropy of opposite sign to the topological entanglement entropy.

arXiv:1112.2241•Physical Review B•Jul 18, 2012•383 citations

Nature of the Spin-Liquid Ground State of the S=1/2 Heisenberg Model on the Kagome Lattice

Stefan Depenbrock, Ian P. McCulloch, Ulrich Schollwöck

We perform a density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) study of the S=1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice to identify the conjectured spin liquid ground state. Exploiting SU(2) spin symmetry, which allows us to keep up to 16,000 DMRG states, we consider cylinders with circumferences up to 17 lattice spacings and find a spin liquid ground state with an estimated per site energy of -0.4386(5), a spin gap of 0.13(1), very short-range decay in spin, dimer and chiral correlation functions, and finite topological entanglement γ consistent with γ=log(2)2, ruling out gapless, chiral, or nontopological spin liquids in favor of a topological spin liquid of quantum dimension 2, with strong evidence for a gapped topological Z(2) spin liquid.

arXiv:1205.4858•Physical Review Letters•Aug 7, 2012•653 citations

Phase diagram of the spin- 12 J1 - J2 Heisenberg model on a honeycomb lattice

Shou-Shu Gong, D. N. Sheng, Olexei I. Motrunich +1 more

We use the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) algorithm to study the phase diagram of the spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ Heisenberg model on a honeycomb lattice with first (${J}_{1}$) and second (${J}_{2}$) neighbor antiferromagnetic interactions, where a ${Z}_{2}$ spin liquid region has been proposed. By implementing SU(2) symmetry in the DMRG code, we are able to obtain accurate results for long cylinders with a width slightly over 15 lattice spacings and a torus up to the size $N=2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}6\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}6$. With increasing ${J}_{2}$, we find a N\'eel phase with a vanishing spin gap and a plaquette valence-bond (PVB) phase with a nonzero spin gap. By extrapolating the square of the staggered magnetic moment ${m}_{s}^{2}$ on finite-size cylinders to the thermodynamic limit, we find the N\'eel order vanishing at ${J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\simeq}0.22$. For $0.25<{J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\le}0.35$, we find a possible PVB order, which shows a fast growing PVB decay length with increasing system width. For $0.22<{J}_{2}/{J}_{1}<0.25$, both spin and dimer orders vanish in the thermodynamic limit, which is consistent with a possible spin liquid phase. We present calculations of the topological entanglement entropy, compare the DMRG results with the variational Monte Carlo, and discuss possible scenarios in the thermodynamic limit for this region.

arXiv:1306.6067•Physical Review B•Oct 29, 2013•118 citations

Theory of Dirac Spin-Orbital Liquids: monopoles, anomalies, and applications to $SU(4)$ honeycomb models

Vladimir Calvera, Wang, Chong

Dirac spin liquids represent a class of highly-entangled quantum phases in two dimensional Mott insulators, featuring exotic properties such as critical correlation functions and absence of well-defined low energy quasi-particles. Existing numerical works suggest that the spin-orbital $SU(4)$ symmetric Kugel-Khomskii model of Mott insulators on the honeycomb lattice realizes a Dirac spin-orbital liquid, described at low energy by $(2+1)d$ quantum electrodynamics (QED$_3$) with $N_f=8$ Dirac fermions. We generalize methods previously developed for $SU(2)$ spin systems to analyze the symmetry properties and stability of the Dirac spin-orbital liquid. We conclude that the standard Dirac state in the $SU(4)$ honeycomb system, based on a simple parton mean-field ansatz, is intrinsically unstable at low energy due to the existence of a monopole perturbation that is allowed by physical symmetries and relevant under renormalization group flow. We propose two plausible alternative scenarios compatible with existing numerics. In the first scenario, we propose an alternative $U(1)$ Dirac spin-orbital liquid, which is similar to the standard one except for its monopole symmetry quantum numbers. This alternative $U(1)$ state represents a stable gapless phase. In the second scenario, we start from the standard $U(1)$ Dirac liquid and Higgs the $U(1)$ gauge symmetry down to $\mathbb{Z}_4$. The resulting $\mathbb{Z}_4$ Dirac spin-orbital liquid is stable. We also discuss the continuous quantum phase transitions from the $\mathbb{Z}_4$ Dirac liquids to conventional symmetry-breaking orders, described by the QED$_3$ theory with $N_f=8$ supplemented with a critical charge-$4$ Higgs field. We discuss possible ways to distinguish these scenarios in numerics. We also extend previous calculations of the quantum anomalies of QED$_3$ and match with generalized lattice Lieb-Schultz-Mattis constraints.

arXiv:2103.13405•Mar 24, 2021•23 citations

Tetramerization in a SU(4) Heisenberg model on the honeycomb lattice

Miklós Lajkó, Karlo Penc

The SU(4) Heisenberg model can serve as a low-energy model of the Mott insulating state in materials where the spins and orbitals are highly symmetric or in systems of alkaline-earth atoms on an optical lattice. Recently, it has been argued that on the honeycomb lattice, the model exhibits a unique spin-orbital liquid phase with an algebraic decay of correlations [P. Corboz et al., Phys. Rev. X 2, 041013 (2012)]. Here we study the instability of the algebraic spin-orbital liquid toward the spontaneous formation of SU(4) singlet plaquettes (tetramerization). Using a variational Monte Carlo approach to evaluate the projected wave function of fermions with $\ensuremath{\pi}$-flux state, we find that the algebraic liquid is robust and that a small finite value of the next-nearest exchange is needed to induce tetramerization. We also studied the phase diagram of a model which interpolates between the nearest-neighbor Heisenberg model and a Hamiltonian for which the singlet-plaquette-product state is an exact ground state.

arXiv:1303.6297•Physical Review B•Jun 27, 2013•25 citations
We perform large-scale density matrix renormalization group simulations of the SU(4) Heisenberg model on the honeycomb lattice to address the long-standing question of its ground state in an unbiased and quantitatively controlled manner. We find reliable numerical evidence that the ground state is a gapped spin-orbital liquid, presumably with a Z_{4} topological order, characterized by a finite topological entanglement entropy close to ln(4), the absence of both SU(4) and lattice symmetry breaking, and a variationally optimized ground-state energy well below the previously proposed π-flux variational state. By exploiting full SU(4) symmetry and keeping up to 12 800 SU(4) multiplets, corresponding to more than 1×10^{6} U(1) states, we achieve unprecedented accuracy for two-dimensional SU(4) quantum magnets. Finite-size scaling of energies and entanglement entropies supports a robust gapped phase in the two-dimensional limit, while a gapless critical state on narrow cylinders is identified as a proximate remnant of a Dirac spin-orbital liquid. Our results find the SU(4) honeycomb Heisenberg model a realization of a gapped topological spin-orbital liquid and provide convincing numerical evidence for topological order in a highly symmetric two-dimensional quantum magnet.
By combining the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) method with Gutzwiller projected wave functions, we study the SU(4) symmetric spin-orbital model on the honeycomb lattice. We find that the ground states can be well described by a Gutzwiller projected $\ensuremath{\pi}$-flux state with Dirac-type gapless excitations at one quarter filling. Although these Dirac points are gapped by emergent gauge fluxes on finite cylinders, they govern the critical behavior in the thermodynamic limit. By inserting a $\ensuremath{\theta}=\ensuremath{\pi}$ spin flux to twist the boundary condition, we can shift the gapless sector to the ground state, which provides compelling evidence for the presence of a gapless Dirac spin-orbital liquid.
We perform highly accurate density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) simulations to investigate the ground-state properties of the spin-1/21/21/2 antiferromagnetic square lattice Heisenberg J1{J}_{1}J1​-J2{J}_{2}J2​ model. Based on studies of numerous long cylinders with circumferences of up to 14 lattice spacings, we obtain strong evidence for a topological quantum spin liquid state in the region $0.41\ensuremath{\le}{J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\le}0.62$, separating conventional N\'eel and striped antiferromagnetic states for smaller and larger J2/J1{J}_{2}/{J}_{1}J2​/J1​, respectively. The quantum spin liquid is characterized numerically by the absence of magnetic or valence bond solid order, and nonzero singlet and triplet energy gaps. Furthermore, we positively identify its topological nature by measuring a nonzero topological entanglement entropy $\ensuremath{\gamma}=0.70\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.02$, extremely close to $\ensuremath{\gamma}=\mathrm{ln}(2)\ensuremath{\approx}0.69$ (expected for a Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ quantum spin liquid) and a nontrivial finite size dimerization effect depending upon the parity of the circumference of the cylinder. We also point out that a valence bond solid, and indeed any discrete symmetry breaking state, would be expected to show a constant correction to the entanglement entropy of opposite sign to the topological entanglement entropy.
We perform a density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) study of the S=1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnet on the kagome lattice to identify the conjectured spin liquid ground state. Exploiting SU(2) spin symmetry, which allows us to keep up to 16,000 DMRG states, we consider cylinders with circumferences up to 17 lattice spacings and find a spin liquid ground state with an estimated per site energy of -0.4386(5), a spin gap of 0.13(1), very short-range decay in spin, dimer and chiral correlation functions, and finite topological entanglement γ consistent with γ=log(2)2, ruling out gapless, chiral, or nontopological spin liquids in favor of a topological spin liquid of quantum dimension 2, with strong evidence for a gapped topological Z(2) spin liquid.
We use the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) algorithm to study the phase diagram of the spin-12\frac{1}{2}21​ Heisenberg model on a honeycomb lattice with first (J1{J}_{1}J1​) and second (J2{J}_{2}J2​) neighbor antiferromagnetic interactions, where a Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ spin liquid region has been proposed. By implementing SU(2) symmetry in the DMRG code, we are able to obtain accurate results for long cylinders with a width slightly over 15 lattice spacings and a torus up to the size $N=2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}6\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}6$. With increasing J2{J}_{2}J2​, we find a N\'eel phase with a vanishing spin gap and a plaquette valence-bond (PVB) phase with a nonzero spin gap. By extrapolating the square of the staggered magnetic moment ms2{m}_{s}^{2}ms2​ on finite-size cylinders to the thermodynamic limit, we find the N\'eel order vanishing at ${J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\simeq}0.22$. For $0.25<{J}_{2}/{J}_{1}\ensuremath{\le}0.35$, we find a possible PVB order, which shows a fast growing PVB decay length with increasing system width. For 0.22<J2/J1<0.250.22<{J}_{2}/{J}_{1}<0.250.22<J2​/J1​<0.25, both spin and dimer orders vanish in the thermodynamic limit, which is consistent with a possible spin liquid phase. We present calculations of the topological entanglement entropy, compare the DMRG results with the variational Monte Carlo, and discuss possible scenarios in the thermodynamic limit for this region.
Theory of Dirac Spin-Orbital Liquids: monopoles, anomalies, and applications to SU(4)SU(4)SU(4) honeycomb models
Dirac spin liquids represent a class of highly-entangled quantum phases in two dimensional Mott insulators, featuring exotic properties such as critical correlation functions and absence of well-defined low energy quasi-particles. Existing numerical works suggest that the spin-orbital SU(4)SU(4)SU(4) symmetric Kugel-Khomskii model of Mott insulators on the honeycomb lattice realizes a Dirac spin-orbital liquid, described at low energy by (2+1)d(2+1)d(2+1)d quantum electrodynamics (QED3_33​) with Nf=8N_f=8Nf​=8 Dirac fermions. We generalize methods previously developed for SU(2)SU(2)SU(2) spin systems to analyze the symmetry properties and stability of the Dirac spin-orbital liquid. We conclude that the standard Dirac state in the SU(4)SU(4)SU(4) honeycomb system, based on a simple parton mean-field ansatz, is intrinsically unstable at low energy due to the existence of a monopole perturbation that is allowed by physical symmetries and relevant under renormalization group flow. We propose two plausible alternative scenarios compatible with existing numerics. In the first scenario, we propose an alternative U(1)U(1)U(1) Dirac spin-orbital liquid, which is similar to the standard one except for its monopole symmetry quantum numbers. This alternative U(1)U(1)U(1) state represents a stable gapless phase. In the second scenario, we start from the standard U(1)U(1)U(1) Dirac liquid and Higgs the U(1)U(1)U(1) gauge symmetry down to Z4\mathbb{Z}_4Z4​. The resulting Z4\mathbb{Z}_4Z4​ Dirac spin-orbital liquid is stable. We also discuss the continuous quantum phase transitions from the Z4\mathbb{Z}_4Z4​ Dirac liquids to conventional symmetry-breaking orders, described by the QED3_33​ theory with Nf=8N_f=8Nf​=8 supplemented with a critical charge-444 Higgs field. We discuss possible ways to distinguish these scenarios in numerics. We also extend previous calculations of the quantum anomalies of QED3_33​ and match with generalized lattice Lieb-Schultz-Mattis constraints.
The SU(4) Heisenberg model can serve as a low-energy model of the Mott insulating state in materials where the spins and orbitals are highly symmetric or in systems of alkaline-earth atoms on an optical lattice. Recently, it has been argued that on the honeycomb lattice, the model exhibits a unique spin-orbital liquid phase with an algebraic decay of correlations [P. Corboz et al., Phys. Rev. X 2, 041013 (2012)]. Here we study the instability of the algebraic spin-orbital liquid toward the spontaneous formation of SU(4) singlet plaquettes (tetramerization). Using a variational Monte Carlo approach to evaluate the projected wave function of fermions with $\ensuremath{\pi}$-flux state, we find that the algebraic liquid is robust and that a small finite value of the next-nearest exchange is needed to induce tetramerization. We also studied the phase diagram of a model which interpolates between the nearest-neighbor Heisenberg model and a Hamiltonian for which the singlet-plaquette-product state is an exact ground state.