Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2601.00708

Effects of Donor-Acceptor Quantum Coherence and Non-Markovian Bath on the Distance Dependence of Resonance Energy Transfer

Seogjoo J. Jang

quant-phphysics.bio-phphysics.chem-phphysics.opticsSubmitted Jan 2, 2026• Announced Jan 5, 2026
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Accurate information on the distance dependence of resonance energy transfer (RET) is crucial for its utilization as a spectroscopic ruler \re{of} nanometer scale distances. In this regard, understanding the effects of donor-acceptor quantum coherence and non-Markovian bath, which become significant at short distances, has significant implications. The present work investigates this issue theoretically by comparing results from a theory of coherent RET (CRET) with a nonequilibrium version of Förster's RET (FRET) theory, both accounting for non-Markovian bath effects. Even for a model where the donor-acceptor electronic coupling is of transition dipole interaction form, it is shown that the RET rate in general deviates from the inverse sixth power distance dependence as opposed to the prediction of the original FRET. It is shown that the donor-acceptor quantum coherence makes the \re{distance} dependence steeper than the sixth power although detailed manner of enhancement is sensitive to specific values of parameters. On the other hand, the non-Markovian bath effects make the \re{distance} dependence more moderate than the sixth power for both CRET and nonueqilibrium FRET because finite time scale of the bath causes the rate to be smaller than the prediction of original FRET. While these effects are \re{demonstrated clearly} in the population dynamics at sub-picosecond time scales, their contributions to the conventional RET efficiency are relatively minor. This indicates that the actual detection of such effects through conventional RET efficiency measurement requires either high precision or utilization of a donor with fast spontaneous decay rate of excitation.

Journal reference
ournal of Physical Chemistry C 123, 5767-5775 (2019)
DOI
10.1021/acs.jpcc.8b12481
Comments
11 pages, 5 figures

Related papers

Energy transfer and correlations in cavity-embedded donor-acceptor configurations

Michael Reitz, Francesca Mineo, Claudiu Genes

The rate of energy transfer in donor-acceptor systems can be manipulated via the common interaction with the confined electromagnetic modes of a micro-cavity. We analyze the competition between the near-field short range dipole-dipole energy exchange processes and the cavity mediated long-range interactions in a simplified model consisting of effective two-level quantum emitters that could be relevant for molecules in experiments under cryogenic conditions. We find that free-space collective incoherent interactions, typically associated with sub- and superradiance, can modify the traditional resonant energy transfer scaling with distance. The same holds true for cavity-mediated collective incoherent interactions in a weak-coupling but strong-cooperativity regime. In the strong coupling regime, we elucidate the effect of pumping into cavity polaritons and analytically identify an optimal energy flow regime characterized by equal donor/acceptor Hopfield coefficients in the middle polariton. Finally we quantify the build-up of quantum correlations in the donor-acceptor system via the two-qubit concurrence as a measure of entanglement.

arXiv:1802.00648•Scientific Reports•Jun 7, 2018•50 citations

Fundamental efficiency bound for quantum coherent energy transfer in nanophotonics

Cristian L. Cortes, Wenbo Sun, Zubin Jacob

We derive a unified quantum theory of coherent and incoherent energy transfer between two atoms (donor and acceptor) valid in arbitrary Markovian nanophotonic environments. Our theory predicts a fundamental bound η m a x = γ a γ d + γ a for energy transfer efficiency arising from the spontaneous emission rates γ d and γ a of the donor and acceptor. We propose the control of the acceptor spontaneous emission rate as a new design principle for enhancing energy transfer efficiency. We predict an experiment using mirrors to enhance the efficiency bound by exploiting the dipole orientations of the donor and acceptor. Of fundamental interest, we show that while quantum coherence implies the ultimate efficiency bound has been reached, reaching the ultimate efficiency does not require quantum coherence. Our work paves the way towards nanophotonic analogues of efficiency-enhancing environments known in quantum biological systems.

arXiv:1709.04478•Optics Express•Aug 22, 2022•7 citations

Coherent fluorescence resonance energy transfer between two dipoles: Full quantum electrodynamics approach

В. В. Климов, Sergey K. Sekatskii, Giovanni Dietler

The quantum electrodynamical theory of coherent fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between two dipoles (free atoms, molecules or dopant centres in crystalline matrices at low temperature conditions) in an arbitrary non-dissipative environment is elaborated using a canonical quantization scheme. It is shown that population dynamics of both atoms can be expressed in terms of a classical Green function. This general theory corresponds well to the problem of description of controllable quantum manipulations under the donor-acceptor system (e.g. its application for FRET scanning near-field optical microscopy-based quantum computing). In addition, its usefulness is illustrated for the case of coherent FRET in free space and for the case when atoms are placed near an ideally conducting plane. The possibility of creating an entangled state of three atoms is demonstrated.

Journal of Modern Optics•May 8, 2004•11 citations

Operational bounds and diagnostics for coherence in energy transfer

Julia Liebert, Gregory D. Scholes

Excitation energy transfer in light-harvesting aggregates is highly efficient, yet whether quantum coherence plays an operational role in transport remains debated. A central challenge is that coherence is usually inferred from spectroscopic signatures, whereas transport performance is assessed through specific observables and depends on both the open system dynamics and the initial state preparation. Here we develop a resource theoretic approach that quantifies the maximum change that initial site-basis coherence can induce in a chosen readout under fixed reduced dynamics. The central quantity is the resource impact functional, which yields state independent, readout specific bounds on coherence-induced changes in signals and transport figures of merit. We apply the framework to two models. For a donor-acceptor dimer, we analyse coherence sensitivity across coupling and bath-timescale regimes and bound trapping efficiency and average transfer time in terms of the impact functional. For a multi-site chain with terminal trapping, we derive rigorous criteria that distinguish population placement from sensitivity to initial state site-basis coherence. These include upper bounds on the largest advantage over incoherent preparations, necessary delocalization requirements for achieving a prescribed improvement, and a simple pairwise sufficient condition that can be checked from local information. For quasi-local reduced dynamics, we further obtain a Lieb-Robinson-type bound that constrains when coherence prepared in a distant region can influence a localized readout at finite times. Together, these results provide operational diagnostics and rigorous bounds for benchmarking coherence effects and for identifying regimes in which they are necessarily negligible or potentially relevant in excitonic transport models.

quant-pharXiv:2603.09748•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Mar 11, 2026•2 citations

Quantum Correlations in Nanophotonics: From Long-range Dipole-dipole Interactions to Fundamental Efficiency Limits in Coherent Energy Transfer

Claudia P. Cortés

Quantum properties like coherence and entanglement can lead to enhanced performance characteristics in a wide range of applications including quantum computation, quantum memory storage, optical sensing, and energy harvesting. Entanglement is very sensitive to static and dynamical disorder. Similarly, the generation of highly-entangled states requires strong coupling or strong driving fields. Satisfying all of these requirements is generally quite difficult. In the first part of this thesis, we present an approach to overcome these limitations through the use of exotic light-matter states in hyperbolic media which provide a new approach to control quantum correlations and interatomic interactions. We reveal a class of excited-state, long-range interactions, referred to as Super-Coulombic interactions that are singular along a material-dependent resonance angle. In practical systems, the Super-Coulombic interaction achieves dipole-dipole coupling that is orders of magnitude larger than conventional approaches, while also occurring across a large frequency bandwidth making it robust to static energy-level disorder. This unique hyperbolic response is not only naturally occurring, found in materials like h-BN, BiTe2, BiSe2, and mono-layered black phosphorus, but can also be designed with artificial nanostructured materials (metamaterials) to create the desired hyperbolic dispersion across different parts of the electromagnetic spectrum. Our theoretical prediction motivated an intense search for the effect and was confirmed by an experimental demonstration at room temperature. To obtain agreement with experimental results, we present a rigorous theoretical framework that takes into account ensemble effects, finite-sized effects, and dimensional effects that arise from confined geometries ultimately modifying the Super-Coulombic spatial scaling law. In the second part of this thesis, we solve an outstanding theoretical problem dealing with the control of resonance energy transfer in nanophotonic environments in both the incoherent and coherent coupling limits. Resonance energy transfer is a fundamental process that is the subject of intense research across all sciences. For example, in chemistry for drug delivery and chemical monitoring, in engineering for photovoltatic and up-conversion devices, and in biology for exciton transport within photosynthetic complexes. First, we consider the disordered and weak coupling limit of resonance energy transfer often encountered in chemistry. We propose new design principles for enhancing and suppressing the energy transfer rate and efficiency quantitatively captured by a simple image dipole model. Our theory explains a wide range of experimental results which have been the subject of an ongoing debate for the past 15 years. Second, we present our recent result aimed at understanding the fundamental role of entanglement and quantum coherence in resonance energy transfer. To uncover the role of these effects, we develop a unified theory of energy transfer valid from the incoherent to quantum coherent coupling regimes. Ultimately, our theory reveals a fundamental bound ηmax = γa for energy transfer efficiency arising from γd+γa the spontaneous emission rates γd and γa of the donor and acceptor. This bound provides an upper limit to the efficiency of energy transfer regardless of quantum coherence or entanglement, suggesting new design principles for achieving near-unity energy transfer efficiency in coherent systems. The result has important implications for the two-chromophore model found in photosynthetic complexes and paves the way for nanophotonic analogues of efficiency-enhancing environments mimicking biological photosynthetic systems.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

Entangled Photon Resonance Energy Transfer in Arbitrary Media

Kobra Nasiri Avanaki, George Chappell Schatz

Inspired by the unique nonclassical character of two-photon interactions induced by entangled photons, we develop a new comprehensive Förster-type formulation for entangled-two-photon resonance energy transfer (E2P-RET) mediated by inhomogeneous, dispersive, and absorptive media with any space-dependent and frequency-dependent dielectric function and with any size of donor/acceptor. In our theoretical framework, two uncoupled particles are jointly excited by the temporally entangled field associated with two virtual photons that are produced by three-level radiative cascade decay in a donor particle. The temporal entanglement leads to frequency anticorrelation in the virtual photon’s field, and vanishing of one of the time-ordered excitation pathways. The underlying mechanism leads to more than 3 orders of magnitude enhancement in the E2P-RET rate compared with the uncorrelated photon case. With the power of our new formulation, we propose a way to characterize E2P-RET through an effective rate coefficient K E2P, introduced here. This coefficient shows how energy transfer can be enhanced or suppressed depending on rate parameters in the radiative cascade, and by varying the donor–acceptor frequency differences.

arXiv:1904.03806•The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters•May 22, 2019•10 citations
Accurate information on the distance dependence of resonance energy transfer (RET) is crucial for its utilization as a spectroscopic ruler \re{of} nanometer scale distances. In this regard, understanding the effects of donor-acceptor quantum coherence and non-Markovian bath, which become significant at short distances, has significant implications. The present work investigates this issue theoretically by comparing results from a theory of coherent RET (CRET) with a nonequilibrium version of Förster's RET (FRET) theory, both accounting for non-Markovian bath effects. Even for a model where the donor-acceptor electronic coupling is of transition dipole interaction form, it is shown that the RET rate in general deviates from the inverse sixth power distance dependence as opposed to the prediction of the original FRET. It is shown that the donor-acceptor quantum coherence makes the \re{distance} dependence steeper than the sixth power although detailed manner of enhancement is sensitive to specific values of parameters. On the other hand, the non-Markovian bath effects make the \re{distance} dependence more moderate than the sixth power for both CRET and nonueqilibrium FRET because finite time scale of the bath causes the rate to be smaller than the prediction of original FRET. While these effects are \re{demonstrated clearly} in the population dynamics at sub-picosecond time scales, their contributions to the conventional RET efficiency are relatively minor. This indicates that the actual detection of such effects through conventional RET efficiency measurement requires either high precision or utilization of a donor with fast spontaneous decay rate of excitation.
The rate of energy transfer in donor-acceptor systems can be manipulated via the common interaction with the confined electromagnetic modes of a micro-cavity. We analyze the competition between the near-field short range dipole-dipole energy exchange processes and the cavity mediated long-range interactions in a simplified model consisting of effective two-level quantum emitters that could be relevant for molecules in experiments under cryogenic conditions. We find that free-space collective incoherent interactions, typically associated with sub- and superradiance, can modify the traditional resonant energy transfer scaling with distance. The same holds true for cavity-mediated collective incoherent interactions in a weak-coupling but strong-cooperativity regime. In the strong coupling regime, we elucidate the effect of pumping into cavity polaritons and analytically identify an optimal energy flow regime characterized by equal donor/acceptor Hopfield coefficients in the middle polariton. Finally we quantify the build-up of quantum correlations in the donor-acceptor system via the two-qubit concurrence as a measure of entanglement.
We derive a unified quantum theory of coherent and incoherent energy transfer between two atoms (donor and acceptor) valid in arbitrary Markovian nanophotonic environments. Our theory predicts a fundamental bound η m a x = γ a γ d + γ a for energy transfer efficiency arising from the spontaneous emission rates γ d and γ a of the donor and acceptor. We propose the control of the acceptor spontaneous emission rate as a new design principle for enhancing energy transfer efficiency. We predict an experiment using mirrors to enhance the efficiency bound by exploiting the dipole orientations of the donor and acceptor. Of fundamental interest, we show that while quantum coherence implies the ultimate efficiency bound has been reached, reaching the ultimate efficiency does not require quantum coherence. Our work paves the way towards nanophotonic analogues of efficiency-enhancing environments known in quantum biological systems.
The quantum electrodynamical theory of coherent fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) between two dipoles (free atoms, molecules or dopant centres in crystalline matrices at low temperature conditions) in an arbitrary non-dissipative environment is elaborated using a canonical quantization scheme. It is shown that population dynamics of both atoms can be expressed in terms of a classical Green function. This general theory corresponds well to the problem of description of controllable quantum manipulations under the donor-acceptor system (e.g. its application for FRET scanning near-field optical microscopy-based quantum computing). In addition, its usefulness is illustrated for the case of coherent FRET in free space and for the case when atoms are placed near an ideally conducting plane. The possibility of creating an entangled state of three atoms is demonstrated.
Excitation energy transfer in light-harvesting aggregates is highly efficient, yet whether quantum coherence plays an operational role in transport remains debated. A central challenge is that coherence is usually inferred from spectroscopic signatures, whereas transport performance is assessed through specific observables and depends on both the open system dynamics and the initial state preparation. Here we develop a resource theoretic approach that quantifies the maximum change that initial site-basis coherence can induce in a chosen readout under fixed reduced dynamics. The central quantity is the resource impact functional, which yields state independent, readout specific bounds on coherence-induced changes in signals and transport figures of merit. We apply the framework to two models. For a donor-acceptor dimer, we analyse coherence sensitivity across coupling and bath-timescale regimes and bound trapping efficiency and average transfer time in terms of the impact functional. For a multi-site chain with terminal trapping, we derive rigorous criteria that distinguish population placement from sensitivity to initial state site-basis coherence. These include upper bounds on the largest advantage over incoherent preparations, necessary delocalization requirements for achieving a prescribed improvement, and a simple pairwise sufficient condition that can be checked from local information. For quasi-local reduced dynamics, we further obtain a Lieb-Robinson-type bound that constrains when coherence prepared in a distant region can influence a localized readout at finite times. Together, these results provide operational diagnostics and rigorous bounds for benchmarking coherence effects and for identifying regimes in which they are necessarily negligible or potentially relevant in excitonic transport models.
Quantum properties like coherence and entanglement can lead to enhanced performance characteristics in a wide range of applications including quantum computation, quantum memory storage, optical sensing, and energy harvesting. Entanglement is very sensitive to static and dynamical disorder. Similarly, the generation of highly-entangled states requires strong coupling or strong driving fields. Satisfying all of these requirements is generally quite difficult. In the first part of this thesis, we present an approach to overcome these limitations through the use of exotic light-matter states in hyperbolic media which provide a new approach to control quantum correlations and interatomic interactions. We reveal a class of excited-state, long-range interactions, referred to as Super-Coulombic interactions that are singular along a material-dependent resonance angle. In practical systems, the Super-Coulombic interaction achieves dipole-dipole coupling that is orders of magnitude larger than conventional approaches, while also occurring across a large frequency bandwidth making it robust to static energy-level disorder. This unique hyperbolic response is not only naturally occurring, found in materials like h-BN, BiTe2, BiSe2, and mono-layered black phosphorus, but can also be designed with artificial nanostructured materials (metamaterials) to create the desired hyperbolic dispersion across different parts of the electromagnetic spectrum. Our theoretical prediction motivated an intense search for the effect and was confirmed by an experimental demonstration at room temperature. To obtain agreement with experimental results, we present a rigorous theoretical framework that takes into account ensemble effects, finite-sized effects, and dimensional effects that arise from confined geometries ultimately modifying the Super-Coulombic spatial scaling law. In the second part of this thesis, we solve an outstanding theoretical problem dealing with the control of resonance energy transfer in nanophotonic environments in both the incoherent and coherent coupling limits. Resonance energy transfer is a fundamental process that is the subject of intense research across all sciences. For example, in chemistry for drug delivery and chemical monitoring, in engineering for photovoltatic and up-conversion devices, and in biology for exciton transport within photosynthetic complexes. First, we consider the disordered and weak coupling limit of resonance energy transfer often encountered in chemistry. We propose new design principles for enhancing and suppressing the energy transfer rate and efficiency quantitatively captured by a simple image dipole model. Our theory explains a wide range of experimental results which have been the subject of an ongoing debate for the past 15 years. Second, we present our recent result aimed at understanding the fundamental role of entanglement and quantum coherence in resonance energy transfer. To uncover the role of these effects, we develop a unified theory of energy transfer valid from the incoherent to quantum coherent coupling regimes. Ultimately, our theory reveals a fundamental bound ηmax = γa for energy transfer efficiency arising from γd+γa the spontaneous emission rates γd and γa of the donor and acceptor. This bound provides an upper limit to the efficiency of energy transfer regardless of quantum coherence or entanglement, suggesting new design principles for achieving near-unity energy transfer efficiency in coherent systems. The result has important implications for the two-chromophore model found in photosynthetic complexes and paves the way for nanophotonic analogues of efficiency-enhancing environments mimicking biological photosynthetic systems.
Inspired by the unique nonclassical character of two-photon interactions induced by entangled photons, we develop a new comprehensive Förster-type formulation for entangled-two-photon resonance energy transfer (E2P-RET) mediated by inhomogeneous, dispersive, and absorptive media with any space-dependent and frequency-dependent dielectric function and with any size of donor/acceptor. In our theoretical framework, two uncoupled particles are jointly excited by the temporally entangled field associated with two virtual photons that are produced by three-level radiative cascade decay in a donor particle. The temporal entanglement leads to frequency anticorrelation in the virtual photon’s field, and vanishing of one of the time-ordered excitation pathways. The underlying mechanism leads to more than 3 orders of magnitude enhancement in the E2P-RET rate compared with the uncorrelated photon case. With the power of our new formulation, we propose a way to characterize E2P-RET through an effective rate coefficient K E2P, introduced here. This coefficient shows how energy transfer can be enhanced or suppressed depending on rate parameters in the radiative cascade, and by varying the donor–acceptor frequency differences.