Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2512.21502

Quantum Mean-Fields Spin Systems in a Random External Field

Chokri Manai

math-phmath.PRquant-phSubmitted Dec 25, 2025• Announced Dec 26, 2025• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this work, we consider general exchangeable quantum mean-field Hamiltonian such as the prominent quantum Curie-Weiss model under the influence of a random external field. Despite being arguably the simplest class of disordered quantum systems, the random external field breaks the symmetry of the mean-field Hamiltonian and hence standard quantum de Finetti type or semiclassical arguments are not directly applicable. We introduce a novel strategy in this context, which can be seen as non-commutative large deviation analysis, allowing us to characterize the limiting free energy in terms of a simple and explicit variational formula. The proposed method is general enough to be used for other classes of mean-field models such as multi species Hamiltonians.

Comments
25 pages

Related papers

De Finetti theorems, mean-field limits and Bose-Einstein condensation

Nicolas Rougerie

These notes deal with the mean-field approximation for equilibrium states of N-body systems in classical and quantum statistical mechanics. A general strategy for the justification of effective models based on statistical independence assumptions is presented in details. The main tools are structure theorems {à} la de Finetti, describing the large N limits of admissible states for these systems. These rely on the symmetry under exchange of particles, due to their indiscernability. Emphasis is put on quantum aspects, in particular the mean-field approximation for the ground states of large bosonic systems, in relation with the Bose-Einstein condensation phenomenon. Topics covered in details include: the structure of reduced density matrices for large bosonic systems, Fock-space localization methods, derivation of effective energy functionals of Hartree or non-linear Schr{ö}dinger type, starting from the many-body Schr{ö}dinger Hamiltonian.

arXiv:1506.05263•Jun 17, 2015•82 citations

Statistical thermodynamics of the quantum spin-s XXZ Heisenberg model in the Weiss limit

J. Ricardo G. Mendonça

The statistical thermodynamics of the quantum spin- s XXZ Heisenberg model in the Weiss (mean-field) limit rests on the outer multiplicities of the irreducible representations in the Clebsch–Gordan decomposition of the n -fold spin- s tensor product, which determine the energy-level degeneracies and hence the partition function. Using known closed forms for these multiplicities in terms of generalized binomial coefficients of order 2 s + 1 , we write the exact finite-size partition function of the effective collective Hamiltonian and evaluate its thermodynamic limit by a large-deviation (Laplace) analysis validated against direct summations for systems of up to n = 10 4 spins. The free energy then follows from a two-parameter variational principle in the total spin and the magnetization per site. The ferromagnetic ordering is driven by the rotationally invariant part of the Hamiltonian, so that the Curie temperature T c = 1 3 J s ( s + 1 ) is independent of the anisotropy Δ, and the transition is of second order for every spin s , with classical mean-field exponents. The anisotropy reshapes the phase diagram: for Δ < 1 the field-driven first-order line of the isotropic ( Δ = 1 ) model opens into a dome of easy-plane ferromagnetic order, bounded by a continuous transition that restores the residual U(1) symmetry, and no first-order transitions or metastability occur throughout − 1 ≤ Δ < 1 ; the isotropic Curie-Weiss ferromagnet is recovered as Δ → 1. In two appendices we detail the asymptotics of the outer multiplicities down to the Gaussian-fluctuation prefactor and discuss the q -number and Jacobi-theta structures underlying the model, including the partial-theta-type structure that obstructs a standard theta-function reduction of the residual total-spin sum.

Nuclear Physics B•Oct 8, 2026•1 citation

The Quantum Random Energy Model is the Limit of Quantum $ p $-Spin Glasses

Abdelhak Kouraich, Chokri Manai, Simone Warzel

We consider the free energy of a class of spin glass models with $ p$-spin interactions in a transverse magnetic field. As $ p \to \infty $, the infinite system-size free energy is proven to converge to that of the quantum random energy model. This is accomplished by combining existing analytical techniques addressing the non-commutative properties of such quantum glasses, with the description of the typical geometry of extreme negative deviations of the classical $ p $-spin glass. We also review properties of the corresponding classical free energy and conjectures addressing $ 1/p $-corrections in the quantum case.

arXiv:2505.02458•May 5, 2025•4 citations

Mean-field models with short-range correlations

M. Ostilli

Given an arbitrary finite dimensional Hamiltonian H 0 , we consider the model H = H 0 +Δ H , where Δ H is a generic fully connected interaction. By using the strong law of large numbers, we easily prove that, for all such models, a generalized Curie-Weiss mean-field equation holds. Unlike traditional mean-field models, the term H 0 gives rise to short-range correlations and, furthermore, when H 0 has negative couplings, first-order phase transitions and inverse transition phenomena may take place even when only two-body interactions are present. The dependence from a non-uniform external field and finite-size effects are also explicitly calculated. Partially, these results were derived long ago by using min-max principles but remained almost unknown.

arXiv:1112.0395•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Mar 1, 2012•4 citations

Effects of random external fields on the dynamics of the one-dimensional Blume-Capel model

Li Yin-Fang, Shen Yin-Yang, Xiang-Mu Kong

The dynamical properties of quantum spin systems have received a great deal of theoretical and experimental attention in the past decades. Only recently, has much attention been paid to the random quantum spin systems. In this paper the effect of random external field on the dynamics of one-dimensional Blume-Capel model with s = 1 in the high-temperature limit is investigated by using the recurrence relations method. The spin autocorrelation function as well as the corresponding spectral density of the system is calculated in the presence of the field that satisfies two types of distributions. When the single-ion anisotropy takes 0, for the bimodal distribution, the dynamics of the system behaves as a crossover from a central peak behavior to a collective mode one. For the Gaussian distribution, when the standard deviation is small, the dynamical behavior of the system also exhibits a crossover; when the standard deviation is large enough, the system only shows a disordered behavior. We also discuss the effect of the single-ion anisotropy on the dynamical property of the system, and find that the collective-mode behavior becomes weaker as the single-ion anisotropy exists.

Acta Physica Sinica•Jan 1, 2012•5 citations

Disorder-induced enhancement and critical scaling of spontaneous magnetization in random-field quantum spin systems

Anindita Bera, Debraj Rakshit, Maciej Lewenstein +3 more

We investigate the effect of a unidirectional quenched random field on the anisotropic quantum spin-1/2 $XY$ model, which magnetizes spontaneously in the absence of the random field. We adopt a mean-field approach for this analysis. In general, the models considered have Ising symmetry, and as such they exhibit ferromagnetic order in two and three dimensions in the presence of not too large disorder. Even in the special case when the model without disorder has $\text{U}(1)$ symmetry, a small $\text{U}(1)$-symmetry-breaking random field induces ferromagnetic long-range order in two dimensions. The mean-field approach, consequently, provides a rather good qualitative and even quantitative description when applied not too close to the criticality. We show that spontaneous magnetization persists even in the presence of the random field, but the magnitude of magnetization gets suppressed due to disorder, and the system magnetizes in the directions parallel and transverse to the random field. Our results are obtained via analytical calculations within a perturbative framework and by numerical simulations. Interestingly, we show that it is possible to enhance a component of magnetization in the presence of the disorder field provided that we apply an additional constant field in the $XY$ plane. Moreover, we derive generalized expressions for the critical temperature and the scalings of the magnetization near the critical point for the $XY$ spin system with arbitrary fixed quantum spin angular momentum.

arXiv:1509.00704•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 18, 2016•11 citations
In this work, we consider general exchangeable quantum mean-field Hamiltonian such as the prominent quantum Curie-Weiss model under the influence of a random external field. Despite being arguably the simplest class of disordered quantum systems, the random external field breaks the symmetry of the mean-field Hamiltonian and hence standard quantum de Finetti type or semiclassical arguments are not directly applicable. We introduce a novel strategy in this context, which can be seen as non-commutative large deviation analysis, allowing us to characterize the limiting free energy in terms of a simple and explicit variational formula. The proposed method is general enough to be used for other classes of mean-field models such as multi species Hamiltonians.
These notes deal with the mean-field approximation for equilibrium states of N-body systems in classical and quantum statistical mechanics. A general strategy for the justification of effective models based on statistical independence assumptions is presented in details. The main tools are structure theorems {à} la de Finetti, describing the large N limits of admissible states for these systems. These rely on the symmetry under exchange of particles, due to their indiscernability. Emphasis is put on quantum aspects, in particular the mean-field approximation for the ground states of large bosonic systems, in relation with the Bose-Einstein condensation phenomenon. Topics covered in details include: the structure of reduced density matrices for large bosonic systems, Fock-space localization methods, derivation of effective energy functionals of Hartree or non-linear Schr{ö}dinger type, starting from the many-body Schr{ö}dinger Hamiltonian.
The statistical thermodynamics of the quantum spin- s XXZ Heisenberg model in the Weiss (mean-field) limit rests on the outer multiplicities of the irreducible representations in the Clebsch–Gordan decomposition of the n -fold spin- s tensor product, which determine the energy-level degeneracies and hence the partition function. Using known closed forms for these multiplicities in terms of generalized binomial coefficients of order 2 s + 1 , we write the exact finite-size partition function of the effective collective Hamiltonian and evaluate its thermodynamic limit by a large-deviation (Laplace) analysis validated against direct summations for systems of up to n = 10 4 spins. The free energy then follows from a two-parameter variational principle in the total spin and the magnetization per site. The ferromagnetic ordering is driven by the rotationally invariant part of the Hamiltonian, so that the Curie temperature T c = 1 3 J s ( s + 1 ) is independent of the anisotropy Δ, and the transition is of second order for every spin s , with classical mean-field exponents. The anisotropy reshapes the phase diagram: for Δ < 1 the field-driven first-order line of the isotropic ( Δ = 1 ) model opens into a dome of easy-plane ferromagnetic order, bounded by a continuous transition that restores the residual U(1) symmetry, and no first-order transitions or metastability occur throughout − 1 ≤ Δ < 1 ; the isotropic Curie-Weiss ferromagnet is recovered as Δ → 1. In two appendices we detail the asymptotics of the outer multiplicities down to the Gaussian-fluctuation prefactor and discuss the q -number and Jacobi-theta structures underlying the model, including the partial-theta-type structure that obstructs a standard theta-function reduction of the residual total-spin sum.
We consider the free energy of a class of spin glass models with $ p$-spin interactions in a transverse magnetic field. As $ p \to \infty $, the infinite system-size free energy is proven to converge to that of the quantum random energy model. This is accomplished by combining existing analytical techniques addressing the non-commutative properties of such quantum glasses, with the description of the typical geometry of extreme negative deviations of the classical $ p $-spin glass. We also review properties of the corresponding classical free energy and conjectures addressing $ 1/p $-corrections in the quantum case.
Given an arbitrary finite dimensional Hamiltonian H 0 , we consider the model H = H 0 +Δ H , where Δ H is a generic fully connected interaction. By using the strong law of large numbers, we easily prove that, for all such models, a generalized Curie-Weiss mean-field equation holds. Unlike traditional mean-field models, the term H 0 gives rise to short-range correlations and, furthermore, when H 0 has negative couplings, first-order phase transitions and inverse transition phenomena may take place even when only two-body interactions are present. The dependence from a non-uniform external field and finite-size effects are also explicitly calculated. Partially, these results were derived long ago by using min-max principles but remained almost unknown.
The dynamical properties of quantum spin systems have received a great deal of theoretical and experimental attention in the past decades. Only recently, has much attention been paid to the random quantum spin systems. In this paper the effect of random external field on the dynamics of one-dimensional Blume-Capel model with s = 1 in the high-temperature limit is investigated by using the recurrence relations method. The spin autocorrelation function as well as the corresponding spectral density of the system is calculated in the presence of the field that satisfies two types of distributions. When the single-ion anisotropy takes 0, for the bimodal distribution, the dynamics of the system behaves as a crossover from a central peak behavior to a collective mode one. For the Gaussian distribution, when the standard deviation is small, the dynamical behavior of the system also exhibits a crossover; when the standard deviation is large enough, the system only shows a disordered behavior. We also discuss the effect of the single-ion anisotropy on the dynamical property of the system, and find that the collective-mode behavior becomes weaker as the single-ion anisotropy exists.
We investigate the effect of a unidirectional quenched random field on the anisotropic quantum spin-1/2 XYXYXY model, which magnetizes spontaneously in the absence of the random field. We adopt a mean-field approach for this analysis. In general, the models considered have Ising symmetry, and as such they exhibit ferromagnetic order in two and three dimensions in the presence of not too large disorder. Even in the special case when the model without disorder has U(1)\text{U}(1)U(1) symmetry, a small U(1)\text{U}(1)U(1)-symmetry-breaking random field induces ferromagnetic long-range order in two dimensions. The mean-field approach, consequently, provides a rather good qualitative and even quantitative description when applied not too close to the criticality. We show that spontaneous magnetization persists even in the presence of the random field, but the magnitude of magnetization gets suppressed due to disorder, and the system magnetizes in the directions parallel and transverse to the random field. Our results are obtained via analytical calculations within a perturbative framework and by numerical simulations. Interestingly, we show that it is possible to enhance a component of magnetization in the presence of the disorder field provided that we apply an additional constant field in the XYXYXY plane. Moreover, we derive generalized expressions for the critical temperature and the scalings of the magnetization near the critical point for the XYXYXY spin system with arbitrary fixed quantum spin angular momentum.