Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2512.20512 · International Journal of Theoretical Physics

Macroscopically distinguishable superposition in infinitely many degrees of freedom

J. Fransson, B. C. Sanders, A. P. Sowa

quant-phmath-phmath.FASubmitted Dec 23, 2025• Announced Dec 24, 2025• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the concept of macroscopically distinguishable superpositions within an infinite array of boson sites. Our approach is rigorous within the frame of Hilbert space theory. In this context, it is natural to differentiate between states -- and corresponding dynamics -- that involve only finitely many degrees of freedom, referred to as local, and those that are inherently nonlocal. Previous studies have shown that such systems can support nonlocal coherent states (NCS). In this work, we demonstrate that NCS can dynamically evolve into nonlocal cat states under the influence of a nonlocal Hamiltonian -- specifically, the square of the total number operator. Crucially, the resulting dynamics cannot be decomposed into local factors. Furthermore, we explore broader mathematical implications of these phenomena within the framework of generalized bosons. Our findings highlight that the concepts of coherent states and nonlocal cat states are not inherently bound together; rather, their fusion is a distinctive feature of standard bosons. Finally, we propose that if the generalized boson framework can be physically realized in engineered quantum systems, the phenomena described here may hold significant relevance for both physics and materials science.

Comments
14 pages, 2 figures; accepted in the International Journal of Theoretical Physics

Related papers

Nonlocal coherent states in an infinite array of boson sites

Artur Sowa, Jonas Fransson

A regular coherent state (CS) is a special type of quantum state for boson particles placed in a single site. The defining feature of the CS is that it is an eigenmode of the annihilation operator. The construction easily generalizes to the case of a finite number of sites. However, the challenge is altogether different when one considers an infinite array of sites. In this work we demonstrate a mathematically rigorous construction that resolves the latter case. The resulting nonlocal coherent states (NCS) are simultaneous eigenmodes for all of the infinitely many annihilation operators acting in the infinite array’s Fock space. Our construction fundamentally relies on Dirichlet series-based analysis and number theoretic arguments.

arXiv:2412.05991•Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its Applications•Apr 18, 2025•2 citations

Macroscopic quantum phenomena in interacting bosonic systems: Josephson flow in liquid 4He and multimode Schrodinger cat states

Tyler J. Volkoff

In this dissertation, I analyze certain problems in the following areas: 1) quantum dynamical phenomena in macroscopic systems of interacting, degenerate bosons (Parts II, III, and V), and 2) measures of macroscopicity for a large class of two-branch superposition states in separable Hilbert space (Part IV). Part I serves as an introduction to important concepts recurring in the later Parts. In Part II, a microscopic derivation of the effective action for the relative phase of driven, aperture-coupled reservoirs of weakly-interacting condensed bosons from a (3 + 1)D microscopic model with local U(1) gauge symmetry is presented. The effective theory is applied to the transition from linear to sinusoidal current vs. phase behavior observed in recent experiments on liquid 4He driven through nanoaperture arrays. Part III discusses path-integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) numerical simulations of quantum hydrodynamic properties of reservoirs of He II communicating through simple nanoaperture arrays. In addition to calculating the local superfluid density in these systems, new estimators for hydrodynamic observables and novel methods for extracting the length scale characterizing the decay of superfluidity at the system boundary from PIMC data are introduced with the aim of exploring the mechanism of superfluid weak-link formation in nanoscale containers.Part IV consists of an analysis of macroscopicity measures for a large class of Schrodinger cat states of N-mode photonic systems. For cat states of this class, it is shown that a well-known measure of superposition size based on the optimal distinguishability of the branches and another based on metrological usefulness of the superposition relative to its branches agree (i.e., designate the same superpositions as macroscopic) when the inner product of the branches of the superposition is sufficiently small. For certain superpositions in this class, a technique is presented for deriving a state-specific textit{metrological macroscopicity algebra} of observables. The dynamics of superposition size measures is also considered, leading to the notion of "distinguishability time,'' a generalization of the orthogonalization times of Mandelstam-Tamm and Margolus-Levitin. In Part V, an investigation of the nonequilibrium dynamics of a quantum dot-Josephson junction-quantum dot nanodevice is presented. The nonequilibrium action of the system is calculated by making use of the Keldysh formalism and a potential use of the device for transferring macroscopic superposition states between a spin-system and an s-wave superconductor is discussed.

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

Macroscopic superpositions require tremendous measurement devices

Michalis Skotiniotis, Wolfgang Dür, Pavel Sekatski

We consider fundamental limits on the detectable size of macroscopic quantum superpositions. We argue that a full quantum mechanical treatment of system plus measurement device is required, and that a (classical) reference frame for phase or direction needs to be established to certify the quantum state. When taking the size of such a classical reference frame into account, we show that to reliably distinguish a quantum superposition state from an incoherent mixture requires a measurement device that is quadratically bigger than the superposition state. Whereas for moderate system sizes such as generated in previous experiments this is not a stringent restriction, for macroscopic superpositions of the size of a cat the required effort quickly becomes intractable, requiring measurement devices of the size of the Earth. We illustrate our results using macroscopic superposition states of photons, spins, and position. Finally, we also show how this limitation can be circumvented by dealing with superpositions in relative degrees of freedom.

arXiv:1705.07053•Quantum•Nov 21, 2017•54 citations

Testing macroscopic local realism using local nonlinear dynamics and time settings

Manushan Thenabadu, G.-L. Cheng, T. Pham +3 more

We show how one may test macroscopic local realism where, differently from conventional Bell tests, all relevant measurements that lead to a violation of a Bell inequality need only distinguish between two macroscopically distinct states of the system being measured. Here, measurements give macroscopically distinct outcomes for some property of the system and do not resolve microscopically (of order $\ensuremath{\hbar}$). To obtain a quantifiable test, we define $N$-scopic local realism where the outcomes are separated by an amount $\ensuremath{\sim}N$. We show for $N$ up to 20 that violations of $N$-scopic local realism are predicted for entangled systems of $N$ bosons at each of two sites. We further demonstrate for arbitrarily large $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ the violation of $\ensuremath{\alpha}$-scopic local realism, for entangled superpositions of coherent states with amplitudes $\ensuremath{\sim}\phantom{\rule{1.0pt}{0ex}}\ensuremath{\alpha}$, infinitely separated in phase space, as $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$. To achieve the Bell violations, the two separated subsystems evolve dynamically according to a local nonlinear unitary interaction. The tests may be understood in two ways. First, they are macroscopic Bell tests involving spacelike separated measurement events, where the choice of measurement setting at each site corresponds to a choice between two different times of local interaction. The interaction may be seen as the unitary stage of a local measurement process. Second, the proposal is a strong version of a Leggett-Garg test of "macrorealism" that uses two trajectories, where the usual assumption of noninvasive measurability as applied to measurements at one site is replaced by that of macroscopic locality. For $N=1$, tests are feasible and give a way to demonstrate ``no classical trajectories'' without the assumption of noninvasive measurability, using instead that of locality.

arXiv:1906.04900•Physical Review A•Aug 5, 2020•14 citations

Macroscopicity of quantum superpositions on a one-parameter unitary path in Hilbert space

Tyler J. Volkoff, K. Birgitta Whaley

We analyze quantum states formed as superpositions of an initial pure product state and its image under local unitary evolution, using two measurement-based measures of superposition size: one based on the optimal quantum binary distinguishability of the branches of the superposition and another based on the ratio of the maximal quantum Fisher information of the superposition to that of its branches, i.e., the relative metrological usefulness of the superposition. A general formula for the effective sizes of these states according to the branch-distinguishability measure is obtained and applied to superposition states of $N$ quantum harmonic oscillators composed of Gaussian branches. Considering optimal distinguishability of pure states on a time-evolution path leads naturally to a notion of distinguishability time that generalizes the well-known orthogonalization times of Mandelstam and Tamm and Margolus and Levitin. We further show that the distinguishability time provides a compact operational expression for the superposition size measure based on the relative quantum Fisher information. By restricting the maximization procedure in the definition of this measure to an appropriate algebra of observables, we show that the superposition size of, e.g., NOON states and hierarchical cat states, can scale linearly with the number of elementary particles comprising the superposition state, implying precision scaling inversely with the total number of photons when these states are employed as probes in quantum parameter estimation of a 1-local Hamiltonian in this algebra.

arXiv:1407.3319•Physical Review A•Dec 18, 2014•9 citations

Quantum tetrachotomous states: Superposition of four coherent states on a line in phase space

Namrata Shukla, Naeem Akhtar, Barry C. Sanders

The well-studied quantum optical Schr\"odinger cat state is a superposition of two distinguishable states, with quantum coherence between these macroscopically distinguishable states being of foundational and, in the context of quantum-information processing, practical use. We refer to these quantum-optical cat states as quantum dichotomous states, reflecting that the state is a superposition of two options, and we introduce the term quantum multichotomous state to refer to a superposition of multiple macroscopically distinguishable options. For a single degree of freedom, such as position, we construct the quantum multichotomous states as a superposition of Gaussian states on the position line in phase space. Using this nomenclature, a quantum tetrachotomous state (QTS) is a coherent superposition of four macroscopically distinguishable states. We define, analyze, and show how to create such states, and our focus on the QTSs is due to their exhibition of much richer phenomena than for the quantum dichotomous states. Our characterization of the QTS involves the Wigner function, its marginal distributions, and the photon-number distribution, and we discuss the QTS's approximate realization in a multiple-coupled-well system.

arXiv:1810.02117•Physical Review A•Jun 10, 2019•18 citations
We investigate the concept of macroscopically distinguishable superpositions within an infinite array of boson sites. Our approach is rigorous within the frame of Hilbert space theory. In this context, it is natural to differentiate between states -- and corresponding dynamics -- that involve only finitely many degrees of freedom, referred to as local, and those that are inherently nonlocal. Previous studies have shown that such systems can support nonlocal coherent states (NCS). In this work, we demonstrate that NCS can dynamically evolve into nonlocal cat states under the influence of a nonlocal Hamiltonian -- specifically, the square of the total number operator. Crucially, the resulting dynamics cannot be decomposed into local factors. Furthermore, we explore broader mathematical implications of these phenomena within the framework of generalized bosons. Our findings highlight that the concepts of coherent states and nonlocal cat states are not inherently bound together; rather, their fusion is a distinctive feature of standard bosons. Finally, we propose that if the generalized boson framework can be physically realized in engineered quantum systems, the phenomena described here may hold significant relevance for both physics and materials science.
A regular coherent state (CS) is a special type of quantum state for boson particles placed in a single site. The defining feature of the CS is that it is an eigenmode of the annihilation operator. The construction easily generalizes to the case of a finite number of sites. However, the challenge is altogether different when one considers an infinite array of sites. In this work we demonstrate a mathematically rigorous construction that resolves the latter case. The resulting nonlocal coherent states (NCS) are simultaneous eigenmodes for all of the infinitely many annihilation operators acting in the infinite array’s Fock space. Our construction fundamentally relies on Dirichlet series-based analysis and number theoretic arguments.
In this dissertation, I analyze certain problems in the following areas: 1) quantum dynamical phenomena in macroscopic systems of interacting, degenerate bosons (Parts II, III, and V), and 2) measures of macroscopicity for a large class of two-branch superposition states in separable Hilbert space (Part IV). Part I serves as an introduction to important concepts recurring in the later Parts. In Part II, a microscopic derivation of the effective action for the relative phase of driven, aperture-coupled reservoirs of weakly-interacting condensed bosons from a (3 + 1)D microscopic model with local U(1) gauge symmetry is presented. The effective theory is applied to the transition from linear to sinusoidal current vs. phase behavior observed in recent experiments on liquid 4He driven through nanoaperture arrays. Part III discusses path-integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) numerical simulations of quantum hydrodynamic properties of reservoirs of He II communicating through simple nanoaperture arrays. In addition to calculating the local superfluid density in these systems, new estimators for hydrodynamic observables and novel methods for extracting the length scale characterizing the decay of superfluidity at the system boundary from PIMC data are introduced with the aim of exploring the mechanism of superfluid weak-link formation in nanoscale containers.Part IV consists of an analysis of macroscopicity measures for a large class of Schrodinger cat states of N-mode photonic systems. For cat states of this class, it is shown that a well-known measure of superposition size based on the optimal distinguishability of the branches and another based on metrological usefulness of the superposition relative to its branches agree (i.e., designate the same superpositions as macroscopic) when the inner product of the branches of the superposition is sufficiently small. For certain superpositions in this class, a technique is presented for deriving a state-specific textit{metrological macroscopicity algebra} of observables. The dynamics of superposition size measures is also considered, leading to the notion of "distinguishability time,'' a generalization of the orthogonalization times of Mandelstam-Tamm and Margolus-Levitin. In Part V, an investigation of the nonequilibrium dynamics of a quantum dot-Josephson junction-quantum dot nanodevice is presented. The nonequilibrium action of the system is calculated by making use of the Keldysh formalism and a potential use of the device for transferring macroscopic superposition states between a spin-system and an s-wave superconductor is discussed.
We consider fundamental limits on the detectable size of macroscopic quantum superpositions. We argue that a full quantum mechanical treatment of system plus measurement device is required, and that a (classical) reference frame for phase or direction needs to be established to certify the quantum state. When taking the size of such a classical reference frame into account, we show that to reliably distinguish a quantum superposition state from an incoherent mixture requires a measurement device that is quadratically bigger than the superposition state. Whereas for moderate system sizes such as generated in previous experiments this is not a stringent restriction, for macroscopic superpositions of the size of a cat the required effort quickly becomes intractable, requiring measurement devices of the size of the Earth. We illustrate our results using macroscopic superposition states of photons, spins, and position. Finally, we also show how this limitation can be circumvented by dealing with superpositions in relative degrees of freedom.
We show how one may test macroscopic local realism where, differently from conventional Bell tests, all relevant measurements that lead to a violation of a Bell inequality need only distinguish between two macroscopically distinct states of the system being measured. Here, measurements give macroscopically distinct outcomes for some property of the system and do not resolve microscopically (of order $\ensuremath{\hbar}$). To obtain a quantifiable test, we define NNN-scopic local realism where the outcomes are separated by an amount $\ensuremath{\sim}N$. We show for NNN up to 20 that violations of NNN-scopic local realism are predicted for entangled systems of NNN bosons at each of two sites. We further demonstrate for arbitrarily large $\ensuremath{\alpha}$ the violation of $\ensuremath{\alpha}$-scopic local realism, for entangled superpositions of coherent states with amplitudes $\ensuremath{\sim}\phantom{\rule{1.0pt}{0ex}}\ensuremath{\alpha}$, infinitely separated in phase space, as $\ensuremath{\alpha}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$. To achieve the Bell violations, the two separated subsystems evolve dynamically according to a local nonlinear unitary interaction. The tests may be understood in two ways. First, they are macroscopic Bell tests involving spacelike separated measurement events, where the choice of measurement setting at each site corresponds to a choice between two different times of local interaction. The interaction may be seen as the unitary stage of a local measurement process. Second, the proposal is a strong version of a Leggett-Garg test of "macrorealism" that uses two trajectories, where the usual assumption of noninvasive measurability as applied to measurements at one site is replaced by that of macroscopic locality. For N=1N=1N=1, tests are feasible and give a way to demonstrate ``no classical trajectories'' without the assumption of noninvasive measurability, using instead that of locality.
We analyze quantum states formed as superpositions of an initial pure product state and its image under local unitary evolution, using two measurement-based measures of superposition size: one based on the optimal quantum binary distinguishability of the branches of the superposition and another based on the ratio of the maximal quantum Fisher information of the superposition to that of its branches, i.e., the relative metrological usefulness of the superposition. A general formula for the effective sizes of these states according to the branch-distinguishability measure is obtained and applied to superposition states of NNN quantum harmonic oscillators composed of Gaussian branches. Considering optimal distinguishability of pure states on a time-evolution path leads naturally to a notion of distinguishability time that generalizes the well-known orthogonalization times of Mandelstam and Tamm and Margolus and Levitin. We further show that the distinguishability time provides a compact operational expression for the superposition size measure based on the relative quantum Fisher information. By restricting the maximization procedure in the definition of this measure to an appropriate algebra of observables, we show that the superposition size of, e.g., NOON states and hierarchical cat states, can scale linearly with the number of elementary particles comprising the superposition state, implying precision scaling inversely with the total number of photons when these states are employed as probes in quantum parameter estimation of a 1-local Hamiltonian in this algebra.
The well-studied quantum optical Schr\"odinger cat state is a superposition of two distinguishable states, with quantum coherence between these macroscopically distinguishable states being of foundational and, in the context of quantum-information processing, practical use. We refer to these quantum-optical cat states as quantum dichotomous states, reflecting that the state is a superposition of two options, and we introduce the term quantum multichotomous state to refer to a superposition of multiple macroscopically distinguishable options. For a single degree of freedom, such as position, we construct the quantum multichotomous states as a superposition of Gaussian states on the position line in phase space. Using this nomenclature, a quantum tetrachotomous state (QTS) is a coherent superposition of four macroscopically distinguishable states. We define, analyze, and show how to create such states, and our focus on the QTSs is due to their exhibition of much richer phenomena than for the quantum dichotomous states. Our characterization of the QTS involves the Wigner function, its marginal distributions, and the photon-number distribution, and we discuss the QTS's approximate realization in a multiple-coupled-well system.