Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2512.11476

Bell, Spinors, and the Impossibility of a Classical Spin-Vector Model

G. A. Koroteev

quant-phSubmitted Dec 12, 2025• Announced Dec 15, 2025• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We revisit the Bell--CHSH scenario for two spin-\(\tfrac{1}{2}\) particles and isolate the precise algebraic origin of the Bell contradiction. On the quantum side, spin-\(\tfrac{1}{2}\) is described by a noncommutative spinor (Clifford) algebra acting on the Hilbert space of two spin-\(\tfrac{1}{2}\) particles, with the singlet state yielding the usual correlation \(E(a,b) = -\,a\cdot b\) and Tsirelson's bound \(2\sqrt{2}\). On the classical side, the standard Bell assumptions amount to describing all measurement outcomes as \(\{\pm1\}\)-valued random variables on a single Kolmogorov probability space, i.e.\ elements of a commutative algebra \(\mathcal{C}(Λ)\). We show that there is no representation of the spinor algebra of spin-\(\tfrac{1}{2}\) (with its singlet state and locality structure) into any such commutative Kolmogorov algebra that preserves the \(\{\pm1\}\) spectra of local spin components and the singlet correlations entering the CHSH expression, under the standard Bell assumptions of locality (factorization) and measurement independence. In this sense, the Bell--CHSH contradiction is exhibited as an algebraic mismatch between a noncommutative spinor/Clifford description of spin and the classical assumption of a single global Kolmogorov space supporting all outcomes. In the language of quantum probability, this is a C\(^*\)-algebraic reformulation of the known fact that the singlet correlations admit no local hidden-variable model with jointly distributed outcomes on one probability space. We also give an explicit realization of the same spinor structure within the author's Quantum Index Algebra (QIA) framework, where locality appears as disjoint index slots and the singlet state as a simple index cocycle.

Comments
15 pages

Related papers

Bell's Theorem and Non-Commutative Measurement Algebras: A Topological Resolution via S³ × I Geometry

MYKHAYLO CHORNOMORCHENKO

Bell’s theorem is a foundational result in quantum theory, demonstrating that no local hidden-variable model satisfying certain assumptions can reproduce quantum correlations. While mathematically correct within its formal framework, the theorem implicitly relies on a specific representational choice: measurement outcomes are modeled as scalar, commutative variables (±1). This assumption, though natural for flat and static configurations, is not mandated by physical necessity. In this work, we examine the consequences of relaxing this representational constraint when measurement outcomes arise as projections of states with nontrivial topology. We show that when physical correlations are naturally organized as elements of an S³-valued structure — such as those associated with spin and rotational degrees of freedom — the induced measurement algebra becomes noncommutative. Under these conditions, the key algebraic factorizations employed in Bell-type derivations no longer apply. We construct an explicit local, realistic model in which observable correlations reproduce the quantum expectation E(a, b) = − cos θ and violate the CHSH bound S ≤ 2, without invoking non-local interactions or superluminal influences. The effective S³×I structure arises not as a fundamental substrate, but as the natural geometric form taken by the actualization of physical processes within an underlying relational framework. Importantly, this structure was not introduced to address quantum entanglement specifically; it emerged independently in the study of cosmological expansion, emergent gravity, and mass generation. Its relevance to Bell-type correlations follows as a consequence of geometry, not as an ad hoc modification. These results suggest that quantum entanglement may reflect topological features of physical realization rather than intrinsic non-locality. Possible experimental implications and connections to geometric and substrate-based approaches to fundamental physics

•Feb 9, 2026•0 citations

Invalidity of the Standard Locality Condition for Hidden-Variable Models of EPR-Bohm Experiments

James L. Beck

John Bell and others used a locality condition to establish inequalities that they believe must be satisfied by any local hidden-variable model for the spin probability distribution for two entangled particles in a Bohm-EPR experiment. We show that this condition is invalid because it contradicts the product rule of probability theory for any model that exhibits the expected property of perfect correlation. This breaks the connection between Bell inequalities and the existence of any local hidden-variable model of interest. As already known, these inequalities give necessary conditions for the existence of third/fourth-order joint probability distributions for the spin outcomes from three/four separate Bohm-EPR experimental set-ups that are consistent with the second-order joint spin distributions for each experiment after marginalization. If a Bell inequality is violated, as quantum mechanics theory predicts and experiments show can happen, then at least one third-order joint probability is negative. However, this does not imply anything about the existence of local hidden-variable models for the second-order joint probability distributions for the spin outcomes of a single experiment. The locality condition does seem reasonable under the widely-applied frequentist interpretation of the spin probability distributions that views them as real properties of a random process that are manifested through their relative frequency of occurrence, which gives conditioning in the probabilities for the spin outcomes a causal role. In contrast, under the Bayesian interpretation of probability, probabilistic conditioning on one particle's spin outcome in the product rule is viewed as information to make probabilistic predictions of the other particle's spin outcome. There is nothing causal and so no reason to develop a locality condition.

•Oct 1, 2019•1 citation

Bell Disentangled

Zeerak Mansoor Khan

Abstract This is a proof of existence by construction of an Ontologically Local StochasticHidden Variable (OLSHV) model for Bell-type spin- 1/2 particle pair experiments. Themodel is built from five ontological elements — a source, two particles, and two de-tectors — each carrying a local hidden variable. Non-locality, superluminal signaling,superdeterminism, and retro-causality are structurally excluded by construction. Key quantum features — the Born rule, non-Kolmogorov quasi-probability, ensem-ble correlation, and the Tsirelson bound — emerge from two physical principles alone:Locality and Rotational Symmetry. The Werner state visibility V is derived from firstprinciples; its observation in Bell-type experiments constitutes experimental evidencefor this model. We also predict a period-π oscillation of the ensemble correlationunder simultaneous detector rotation, not predicted by standard quantum theory. Bell’s theorem rules out local hidden variables with Kolmogorov probability struc-ture — not local hidden variables with quantum non-Kolmogorov quasi-probability.This construction demonstrates that local quantum hidden variables exist, reproducequantum correlations exactly, derive the Werner state visibility from first principles,and predict a testable oscillation invisible to existing CHSH-type Bell tests.

•Nov 10, 2026•0 citations

Entanglement and quantum nonlocality demystified

Marian Kupczyński

Quantum nonlocality is presented often as the most remarkable and inexplicable phenomenon known to modern science. It has been known already for a long time that the probabilistic models used to prove Bell and Clauser-Horn-Shimony-Holt inequalities (BI-CHSH) for spin polarization correlation experiments (SPCE) are incompatible with the experimental protocols of SPCE. In particular these models use the same common probability space, joint probability distributions and/or conditional independence to describe coincidence experiments in incompatible experimental settings. Strangely enough these results are not known or simply neglected. This is why we will once again reanalyze Bell locality assumptions and show that they have nothing to do with the notion of Einsteinian locality therefore their violation should not be called quantum nonlocality but rather quantum non-Kolmogorovness or quantum contextuality. Moreover if local variables describing the measuring instruments are correctly taken into account then BI-CHSH can no longer be proven and one can easily construct non-signaling probabilistic models able to reproduce the predictions of QT. The violation of BI-CHSH is considered usually as a proof that a quantum state is entangled. Since BI-CHSH are violated also in some experiments from outside the domain of quantum physics therefore the entanglement is not exclusively a quantum phenomenon. In order to further demystify these notions we show that one can prepare two macroscopic systems in such a way that simple realizable local experiments on these systems violate BI. In view of these arguments the further testing of BI-CHSH inequalities in search for the loopholes does not seem to be necessary.

arXiv:1205.4636•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2012•31 citations

Quantum mechanical EPRBA covariance and classical proba- bility

Johannes F. Geurdes

In the debate of the foundations of quantum theory (QM), Bell’s theorem [1] is an important milestone. Based on Einstein’s criticism of completeness [2], Bell formulated an expression for the correlation between distant spin measurements such as described by Bohm [3]. In Bell’s expression, hidden variables to restore locality and causality to the theory (LHV’s) are introduced through a probability (mass) density function and through their influence upon the elementary measurement functions in the two separate wings (denoted by the Aand the B-wing) of the experiment. Many experiments and theoretical developments arose from Bell’s original paper. The most important experiment was performed by Aspect [4]. Aspect’s results were interpreted as a confirmation of the completeness of quantum mechanics. From that point, QM was considered a non-local theory. In a previous paper [5] the present author argued that there was insufficient ground for this conclusion. The author would like to point that merely an appeal to the simplicity and apparent logical truth of Bell’s theorem is advanced to support the exclusive non-locality interpretation. Beyond that, there is no proof that experimental results must exclusively be interpreted in this manner. According to the author the inequalities of Bell were given the status of theorem without sufficient supportive evidence save simplicity. In this paper it will be demonstrated that such a conclusive supportive argument of Bell’s theorem does not exist because an approximate classical model is possible. The principles of the proposed model can also be expressed in numerical terms. This enables numerical simulation of the experiments on a computer. Let us shortly describe a typical idealized Bell experiment. In such an experiment, from a single source, two particles with opposite spin are sent into opposite directions. For instance, we could think of a positron and an electron arising from para-Positronium that are drawn apart by dipole radiation. Subsequently, in the respective wings of the experimental set-up, the spin of the individual particle is measured with a SternGerlach magnet. The measurements are found to be correlated with the, unitary, parameter vectors of the magnets, a = (a1, a2, a3),b = (b1, b2, b3). It is well-known that the QM correlation for singlet state electron and positron is equal to,

•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

A Probability Model for the Bell Experiment

Kees van Hee, Kees van Berkel, J. de Graaf

The Bell inequality constrains the outcomes of measurements on pairs of distant entangled particles. The Bell contradiction states that the Bell inequality is inconsistent with the calculated outcomes of these quantum experiments. This contradiction led many to question the underlying assumptions, viz. so-called realism and locality. The probability model underlying the Bell inequality is generally left implicit. We propose an explicit probability model for the CHSH version of the Bell experiment. This model has only two simultaneously observable detector settings per measurement, and therefore does not assume realism. The quantum expectation now becomes a conditional expectation, given the two detector settings. This probability model is in full agreement with both quantum mechanics and experiments. As a result, the model satisfies the Bell inequality; there are no so-called violations. We extend this model to include a hidden variable. This extended model is not Bell-separable. This non-separability implies that the model is non-deterministic or non-local (or both).

arXiv:2302.05174•Quantum Reports•Feb 14, 2026•1 citation
We revisit the Bell--CHSH scenario for two spin-(\tfrac{1}{2}) particles and isolate the precise algebraic origin of the Bell contradiction. On the quantum side, spin-(\tfrac{1}{2}) is described by a noncommutative spinor (Clifford) algebra acting on the Hilbert space of two spin-(\tfrac{1}{2}) particles, with the singlet state yielding the usual correlation (E(a,b) = -,a\cdot b) and Tsirelson's bound (2\sqrt{2}). On the classical side, the standard Bell assumptions amount to describing all measurement outcomes as ({\pm1})-valued random variables on a single Kolmogorov probability space, i.e.\ elements of a commutative algebra (\mathcal{C}(Λ)).
We show that there is no representation of the spinor algebra of spin-(\tfrac{1}{2}) (with its singlet state and locality structure) into any such commutative Kolmogorov algebra that preserves the ({\pm1}) spectra of local spin components and the singlet correlations entering the CHSH expression, under the standard Bell assumptions of locality (factorization) and measurement independence. In this sense, the Bell--CHSH contradiction is exhibited as an algebraic mismatch between a noncommutative spinor/Clifford description of spin and the classical assumption of a single global Kolmogorov space supporting all outcomes. In the language of quantum probability, this is a C(^*)-algebraic reformulation of the known fact that the singlet correlations admit no local hidden-variable model with jointly distributed outcomes on one probability space.
We also give an explicit realization of the same spinor structure within the author's Quantum Index Algebra (QIA) framework, where locality appears as disjoint index slots and the singlet state as a simple index cocycle.
Bell’s theorem is a foundational result in quantum theory, demonstrating that no local hidden-variable model satisfying certain assumptions can reproduce quantum correlations. While mathematically correct within its formal framework, the theorem implicitly relies on a specific representational choice: measurement outcomes are modeled as scalar, commutative variables (±1). This assumption, though natural for flat and static configurations, is not mandated by physical necessity. In this work, we examine the consequences of relaxing this representational constraint when measurement outcomes arise as projections of states with nontrivial topology. We show that when physical correlations are naturally organized as elements of an S³-valued structure — such as those associated with spin and rotational degrees of freedom — the induced measurement algebra becomes noncommutative. Under these conditions, the key algebraic factorizations employed in Bell-type derivations no longer apply. We construct an explicit local, realistic model in which observable correlations reproduce the quantum expectation E(a, b) = − cos θ and violate the CHSH bound S ≤ 2, without invoking non-local interactions or superluminal influences. The effective S³×I structure arises not as a fundamental substrate, but as the natural geometric form taken by the actualization of physical processes within an underlying relational framework. Importantly, this structure was not introduced to address quantum entanglement specifically; it emerged independently in the study of cosmological expansion, emergent gravity, and mass generation. Its relevance to Bell-type correlations follows as a consequence of geometry, not as an ad hoc modification. These results suggest that quantum entanglement may reflect topological features of physical realization rather than intrinsic non-locality. Possible experimental implications and connections to geometric and substrate-based approaches to fundamental physics
John Bell and others used a locality condition to establish inequalities that they believe must be satisfied by any local hidden-variable model for the spin probability distribution for two entangled particles in a Bohm-EPR experiment. We show that this condition is invalid because it contradicts the product rule of probability theory for any model that exhibits the expected property of perfect correlation. This breaks the connection between Bell inequalities and the existence of any local hidden-variable model of interest. As already known, these inequalities give necessary conditions for the existence of third/fourth-order joint probability distributions for the spin outcomes from three/four separate Bohm-EPR experimental set-ups that are consistent with the second-order joint spin distributions for each experiment after marginalization. If a Bell inequality is violated, as quantum mechanics theory predicts and experiments show can happen, then at least one third-order joint probability is negative. However, this does not imply anything about the existence of local hidden-variable models for the second-order joint probability distributions for the spin outcomes of a single experiment. The locality condition does seem reasonable under the widely-applied frequentist interpretation of the spin probability distributions that views them as real properties of a random process that are manifested through their relative frequency of occurrence, which gives conditioning in the probabilities for the spin outcomes a causal role. In contrast, under the Bayesian interpretation of probability, probabilistic conditioning on one particle's spin outcome in the product rule is viewed as information to make probabilistic predictions of the other particle's spin outcome. There is nothing causal and so no reason to develop a locality condition.
Abstract This is a proof of existence by construction of an Ontologically Local StochasticHidden Variable (OLSHV) model for Bell-type spin- 1/2 particle pair experiments. Themodel is built from five ontological elements — a source, two particles, and two de-tectors — each carrying a local hidden variable. Non-locality, superluminal signaling,superdeterminism, and retro-causality are structurally excluded by construction. Key quantum features — the Born rule, non-Kolmogorov quasi-probability, ensem-ble correlation, and the Tsirelson bound — emerge from two physical principles alone:Locality and Rotational Symmetry. The Werner state visibility V is derived from firstprinciples; its observation in Bell-type experiments constitutes experimental evidencefor this model. We also predict a period-π oscillation of the ensemble correlationunder simultaneous detector rotation, not predicted by standard quantum theory. Bell’s theorem rules out local hidden variables with Kolmogorov probability struc-ture — not local hidden variables with quantum non-Kolmogorov quasi-probability.This construction demonstrates that local quantum hidden variables exist, reproducequantum correlations exactly, derive the Werner state visibility from first principles,and predict a testable oscillation invisible to existing CHSH-type Bell tests.
Quantum nonlocality is presented often as the most remarkable and inexplicable phenomenon known to modern science. It has been known already for a long time that the probabilistic models used to prove Bell and Clauser-Horn-Shimony-Holt inequalities (BI-CHSH) for spin polarization correlation experiments (SPCE) are incompatible with the experimental protocols of SPCE. In particular these models use the same common probability space, joint probability distributions and/or conditional independence to describe coincidence experiments in incompatible experimental settings. Strangely enough these results are not known or simply neglected. This is why we will once again reanalyze Bell locality assumptions and show that they have nothing to do with the notion of Einsteinian locality therefore their violation should not be called quantum nonlocality but rather quantum non-Kolmogorovness or quantum contextuality. Moreover if local variables describing the measuring instruments are correctly taken into account then BI-CHSH can no longer be proven and one can easily construct non-signaling probabilistic models able to reproduce the predictions of QT. The violation of BI-CHSH is considered usually as a proof that a quantum state is entangled. Since BI-CHSH are violated also in some experiments from outside the domain of quantum physics therefore the entanglement is not exclusively a quantum phenomenon. In order to further demystify these notions we show that one can prepare two macroscopic systems in such a way that simple realizable local experiments on these systems violate BI. In view of these arguments the further testing of BI-CHSH inequalities in search for the loopholes does not seem to be necessary.
In the debate of the foundations of quantum theory (QM), Bell’s theorem [1] is an important milestone. Based on Einstein’s criticism of completeness [2], Bell formulated an expression for the correlation between distant spin measurements such as described by Bohm [3]. In Bell’s expression, hidden variables to restore locality and causality to the theory (LHV’s) are introduced through a probability (mass) density function and through their influence upon the elementary measurement functions in the two separate wings (denoted by the Aand the B-wing) of the experiment. Many experiments and theoretical developments arose from Bell’s original paper. The most important experiment was performed by Aspect [4]. Aspect’s results were interpreted as a confirmation of the completeness of quantum mechanics. From that point, QM was considered a non-local theory. In a previous paper [5] the present author argued that there was insufficient ground for this conclusion. The author would like to point that merely an appeal to the simplicity and apparent logical truth of Bell’s theorem is advanced to support the exclusive non-locality interpretation. Beyond that, there is no proof that experimental results must exclusively be interpreted in this manner. According to the author the inequalities of Bell were given the status of theorem without sufficient supportive evidence save simplicity. In this paper it will be demonstrated that such a conclusive supportive argument of Bell’s theorem does not exist because an approximate classical model is possible. The principles of the proposed model can also be expressed in numerical terms. This enables numerical simulation of the experiments on a computer. Let us shortly describe a typical idealized Bell experiment. In such an experiment, from a single source, two particles with opposite spin are sent into opposite directions. For instance, we could think of a positron and an electron arising from para-Positronium that are drawn apart by dipole radiation. Subsequently, in the respective wings of the experimental set-up, the spin of the individual particle is measured with a SternGerlach magnet. The measurements are found to be correlated with the, unitary, parameter vectors of the magnets, a = (a1, a2, a3),b = (b1, b2, b3). It is well-known that the QM correlation for singlet state electron and positron is equal to,
The Bell inequality constrains the outcomes of measurements on pairs of distant entangled particles. The Bell contradiction states that the Bell inequality is inconsistent with the calculated outcomes of these quantum experiments. This contradiction led many to question the underlying assumptions, viz. so-called realism and locality. The probability model underlying the Bell inequality is generally left implicit. We propose an explicit probability model for the CHSH version of the Bell experiment. This model has only two simultaneously observable detector settings per measurement, and therefore does not assume realism. The quantum expectation now becomes a conditional expectation, given the two detector settings. This probability model is in full agreement with both quantum mechanics and experiments. As a result, the model satisfies the Bell inequality; there are no so-called violations. We extend this model to include a hidden variable. This extended model is not Bell-separable. This non-separability implies that the model is non-deterministic or non-local (or both).