Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2511.22451

From Simulation to Experiment: Benchmarking Machine-Learning Models for Quantum-Dot State Recognition

Valeria Díaz Moreno, Ryan P Khalili, Daniel Schug, Patrick J. Walsh, Donovan L. Buterakos, Justyna P. Zwolak

Published Nov 27, 2025• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Machine-learning models for quantum-dot state recognition are commonly trained using synthetic data, where large labeled datasets can be generated efficiently. However, strong performance on simulated data does not guarantee equally strong performance in experiments. Here, we benchmark five neural network architectures for quantum-dot state recognition using a shared synthetic training dataset and independent synthetic and experimental test sets. We compare convolutional and fully connected neural networks, a mixture density network, a vision transformer, and a U-Net across multiple training set sizes and two input normalization schemes. We find that model performance and rankings are closely preserved when moving from held-out synthetic patches to previously unseen simulated devices, but change substantially when the same models are evaluated on experimental data. In particular, the architecture achieving the highest synthetic performance is not the one that performs best experimentally. Input normalization further affects training behavior and, for some architectures, synthetic-to-experimental transfer. These results show that synthetic benchmark performance alone is insufficient to select models for experimental deployment and highlight the need to jointly evaluate architecture, preprocessing, data efficiency, model complexity, and experimental transfer when developing machine-learning tools for automated quantum-dot characterization and control.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2511.22451

Related papers

Machine learning techniques for state recognition and auto-tuning in quantum dots

Sandesh S. Kalantre, Justyna P. Zwolak, Stephen Ragole +4 more

Abstract Recent progress in building large-scale quantum devices for exploring quantum computing and simulation has relied upon effective tools for achieving and maintaining good experimental parameters, i.e., tuning up devices. In many cases, including quantum dot-based architectures, the parameter space grows substantially with the number of qubits, and may become a limit to scalability. Fortunately, machine learning techniques for pattern recognition and image classification, using so-called deep neural networks, have shown surprising successes for computer-aided understanding of complex systems. We propose a new paradigm for fully automated experimental initialization through a closed-loop system relying on machine learning and optimization techniques. We use deep convolutional neural networks to characterize states and charge configurations of semiconductor quantum dot arrays when only measurements of a current−voltage characteristic of transport are available. For simplicity, we model a semiconductor nanowire connected to leads and capacitively coupled to depletion gates using the Thomas−Fermi approximation and Coulomb blockade physics. We then generate labeled training data for the neural networks, and find at least 90 % accuracy for charge and state identification for single and double dots. Using these characterization networks, we can then optimize the parameter space to achieve a desired configuration of the array, a technique we call “auto-tuning”. Finally, we show how such techniques can be implemented in an experimental setting by applying our approach to an experimental dataset, and outline further problems in this domain, from using charge sensing data to extensions to full one- and two-dimensional arrays, that can be tackled with machine learning.

arXiv:1712.04914•npj Quantum Information•Jan 14, 2019•122 citations

Evaluation of synthetic and experimental training data in supervised machine learning applied to charge-state detection of quantum dots

Jana Darulová, Matthias Troyer, Maja C. Cassidy

Abstract Automated tuning of gate-defined quantum dots is a requirement for large-scale semiconductor-based qubit initialisation. An essential step of these tuning procedures is charge-state detection based on charge stability diagrams. Using supervised machine learning to perform this task requires a large dataset for models to train on. In order to avoid hand labelling experimental data, synthetic data has been explored as an alternative. While providing a significant increase in the size of the training dataset compared to using experimental data, using synthetic data means that classifiers are trained on data sourced from a different distribution than the experimental data that is part of the tuning process. Here we evaluate the prediction accuracy of a range of machine learning models trained on simulated and experimental data, and their ability to generalise to experimental charge stability diagrams in two-dimensional electron gas and nanowire devices. We find that classifiers perform best on either purely experimental or a combination of synthetic and experimental training data, and that adding common experimental noise signatures to the synthetic data does not dramatically improve the classification accuracy. These results suggest that experimental training data as well as realistic quantum dot simulations and noise models are essential in charge-state detection using supervised machine learning.

arXiv:2005.08131•Machine Learning Science and Technology•Jun 30, 2021•22 citations

Benchmarking the Quantum Frontier: Evaluating QML Models on Core Learning Tasks

Priyanka Samarth, Sadhana Shashidhar, Sakshi Rajani +2 more

Advancements in quantum computing have sparked a systematic evaluation of quantum machine learning (QML) models, focusing on their behavior and performance across diverse learning tasks such as classification, regression, generative modeling, and feature compression. The primary focus is on assessing the performance and behavior of various QML architectures-including Quantum Neural Networks (QNNs), Quantum Support Vector Classifiers (QSVCs), Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs), Quantum Convolutional Neural Networks (QCNNs), and Quantum Autoencoders (QAEs)-implemented using Qiskit's machine learning library. This evaluation is conducted using an existing benchmarking framework that ensures consistent experimental conditions and supports flexible evaluation strategies. To provide additional context and insight, these quantum models are compared against classical counterparts using widely adopted implementations. Experiments are carried out on a range of datasets, including structured and low-dimensional examples like Bars and Stripes, as well as more complex datasets like Downscaled MNIST and synthetic Hyperplanes. By providing a standardized evaluation of these models within the Qiskit framework, this study establishes a reproducible performance baseline and highlights key challenges for QML systems in the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era.

International Conference on AI-ML Systems (AIMLSystems)•Oct 8, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Similarity Testing with Convolutional Neural Networks

Yadong Wu, Yan Zhu, Ge Bai +2 more

The task of testing whether two uncharacterized quantum devices behave in the same way is crucial for benchmarking near-term quantum computers and quantum simulators, but has so far remained open for continuous variable quantum systems. In this Letter, we develop a machine learning algorithm for comparing unknown continuous variable states using limited and noisy data. The algorithm works on non-Gaussian quantum states for which similarity testing could not be achieved with previous techniques. Our approach is based on a convolutional neural network that assesses the similarity of quantum states based on a lower-dimensional state representation built from measurement data. The network can be trained off-line with classically simulated data from a fiducial set of states sharing structural similarities with the states to be tested, with experimental data generated by measurements on the fiducial states, or with a combination of simulated and experimental data. We test the performance of the model on noisy cat states and states generated by arbitrary selective number-dependent phase gates. Our network can also be applied to the problem of comparing continuous variable states across different experimental platforms, with different sets of achievable measurements, and to the problem of experimentally testing whether two states are equivalent up to Gaussian unitary transformations.

arXiv:2211.01668•Physical Review Letters•May 22, 2023•16 citations

Benchmarking Encoding Families in Quantum Neural Networks Under Fixed Circuit Area for Frequency Spectrum and Trainability

Martyna Czuba, Patrick Holzer, Hein Zay Yar Oo

Quantum Neural Networks (QNNs) offer a promising framework for integrating quantum computing principles into machine learning, yet their practical capabilities and limitations remain insufficiently studied. In this work, we systematically investigate the trainability and approximation properties of QNNs by benchmarking diverse circuit architectures and encoding strategies across synthetic and real-world datasets. We analyze several ansätze, including Hamming, binary, exponential, ternary, turnpike and Golomb, by evaluating their ability to learn synthetic data modeled as random finite Fourier series. To assess real-world applicability, we further evaluate QNNs on two time-series classification tasks: a Fischertechnik pneumatic leak detection dataset and the publicly available NASA bearing fault dataset. Our experiments show that while broader frequency spectra can theoretically enhance expressivity, practical trainability is strongly influenced by architectural factors such as qubit count and circuit depth. Notably, we find that QNNs perform best when the frequency spectrum is tailored to the target function's complexity but remains as compact as possible. Moreover, architectures with identical frequency spectra can differ in trainability, with configurations using more qubits and fewer layers generally performing better, except in the single-layer case. These findings provide guidelines for selecting QNN ansätze and offer new insights into the interplay between expressivity and trainability in quantum machine learning.

quant-pharXiv:2603.27671•Mar 31, 2026•1 citation

Autotuning of Double-Dot Devices In Situ with Machine Learning

Justyna P. Zwolak, Thomas McJunkin, Sandesh S. Kalantre +7 more

A primary obstacle in scaling up quantum computing platforms based on semiconductor quantum dots (QDs) is the full automation of initialization and control. Using ideas from machine learning (ML), pattern recognition, and optimization, the authors implement an autotuning protocol that needs no human intervention to navigate between QD states in real time. A convolutional neural network identifies QD states from $i\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}n$ $s\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}i\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}t\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}u$ measurements; importantly, the network is trained exclusively on simulated data, and the scans used are significantly smaller that in manual tuning, and hence much faster. This development is critical to moving up to larger numbers of quantum dots.

arXiv:1909.08030•Physical Review Applied•Mar 31, 2020•88 citations
Machine-learning models for quantum-dot state recognition are commonly trained using synthetic data, where large labeled datasets can be generated efficiently. However, strong performance on simulated data does not guarantee equally strong performance in experiments. Here, we benchmark five neural network architectures for quantum-dot state recognition using a shared synthetic training dataset and independent synthetic and experimental test sets. We compare convolutional and fully connected neural networks, a mixture density network, a vision transformer, and a U-Net across multiple training set sizes and two input normalization schemes. We find that model performance and rankings are closely preserved when moving from held-out synthetic patches to previously unseen simulated devices, but change substantially when the same models are evaluated on experimental data. In particular, the architecture achieving the highest synthetic performance is not the one that performs best experimentally. Input normalization further affects training behavior and, for some architectures, synthetic-to-experimental transfer. These results show that synthetic benchmark performance alone is insufficient to select models for experimental deployment and highlight the need to jointly evaluate architecture, preprocessing, data efficiency, model complexity, and experimental transfer when developing machine-learning tools for automated quantum-dot characterization and control.
Abstract Recent progress in building large-scale quantum devices for exploring quantum computing and simulation has relied upon effective tools for achieving and maintaining good experimental parameters, i.e., tuning up devices. In many cases, including quantum dot-based architectures, the parameter space grows substantially with the number of qubits, and may become a limit to scalability. Fortunately, machine learning techniques for pattern recognition and image classification, using so-called deep neural networks, have shown surprising successes for computer-aided understanding of complex systems. We propose a new paradigm for fully automated experimental initialization through a closed-loop system relying on machine learning and optimization techniques. We use deep convolutional neural networks to characterize states and charge configurations of semiconductor quantum dot arrays when only measurements of a current−voltage characteristic of transport are available. For simplicity, we model a semiconductor nanowire connected to leads and capacitively coupled to depletion gates using the Thomas−Fermi approximation and Coulomb blockade physics. We then generate labeled training data for the neural networks, and find at least 90 % accuracy for charge and state identification for single and double dots. Using these characterization networks, we can then optimize the parameter space to achieve a desired configuration of the array, a technique we call “auto-tuning”. Finally, we show how such techniques can be implemented in an experimental setting by applying our approach to an experimental dataset, and outline further problems in this domain, from using charge sensing data to extensions to full one- and two-dimensional arrays, that can be tackled with machine learning.
Abstract Automated tuning of gate-defined quantum dots is a requirement for large-scale semiconductor-based qubit initialisation. An essential step of these tuning procedures is charge-state detection based on charge stability diagrams. Using supervised machine learning to perform this task requires a large dataset for models to train on. In order to avoid hand labelling experimental data, synthetic data has been explored as an alternative. While providing a significant increase in the size of the training dataset compared to using experimental data, using synthetic data means that classifiers are trained on data sourced from a different distribution than the experimental data that is part of the tuning process. Here we evaluate the prediction accuracy of a range of machine learning models trained on simulated and experimental data, and their ability to generalise to experimental charge stability diagrams in two-dimensional electron gas and nanowire devices. We find that classifiers perform best on either purely experimental or a combination of synthetic and experimental training data, and that adding common experimental noise signatures to the synthetic data does not dramatically improve the classification accuracy. These results suggest that experimental training data as well as realistic quantum dot simulations and noise models are essential in charge-state detection using supervised machine learning.
Advancements in quantum computing have sparked a systematic evaluation of quantum machine learning (QML) models, focusing on their behavior and performance across diverse learning tasks such as classification, regression, generative modeling, and feature compression. The primary focus is on assessing the performance and behavior of various QML architectures-including Quantum Neural Networks (QNNs), Quantum Support Vector Classifiers (QSVCs), Quantum Generative Adversarial Networks (QGANs), Quantum Convolutional Neural Networks (QCNNs), and Quantum Autoencoders (QAEs)-implemented using Qiskit's machine learning library. This evaluation is conducted using an existing benchmarking framework that ensures consistent experimental conditions and supports flexible evaluation strategies. To provide additional context and insight, these quantum models are compared against classical counterparts using widely adopted implementations. Experiments are carried out on a range of datasets, including structured and low-dimensional examples like Bars and Stripes, as well as more complex datasets like Downscaled MNIST and synthetic Hyperplanes. By providing a standardized evaluation of these models within the Qiskit framework, this study establishes a reproducible performance baseline and highlights key challenges for QML systems in the noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) era.
The task of testing whether two uncharacterized quantum devices behave in the same way is crucial for benchmarking near-term quantum computers and quantum simulators, but has so far remained open for continuous variable quantum systems. In this Letter, we develop a machine learning algorithm for comparing unknown continuous variable states using limited and noisy data. The algorithm works on non-Gaussian quantum states for which similarity testing could not be achieved with previous techniques. Our approach is based on a convolutional neural network that assesses the similarity of quantum states based on a lower-dimensional state representation built from measurement data. The network can be trained off-line with classically simulated data from a fiducial set of states sharing structural similarities with the states to be tested, with experimental data generated by measurements on the fiducial states, or with a combination of simulated and experimental data. We test the performance of the model on noisy cat states and states generated by arbitrary selective number-dependent phase gates. Our network can also be applied to the problem of comparing continuous variable states across different experimental platforms, with different sets of achievable measurements, and to the problem of experimentally testing whether two states are equivalent up to Gaussian unitary transformations.
Quantum Neural Networks (QNNs) offer a promising framework for integrating quantum computing principles into machine learning, yet their practical capabilities and limitations remain insufficiently studied. In this work, we systematically investigate the trainability and approximation properties of QNNs by benchmarking diverse circuit architectures and encoding strategies across synthetic and real-world datasets. We analyze several ansätze, including Hamming, binary, exponential, ternary, turnpike and Golomb, by evaluating their ability to learn synthetic data modeled as random finite Fourier series. To assess real-world applicability, we further evaluate QNNs on two time-series classification tasks: a Fischertechnik pneumatic leak detection dataset and the publicly available NASA bearing fault dataset. Our experiments show that while broader frequency spectra can theoretically enhance expressivity, practical trainability is strongly influenced by architectural factors such as qubit count and circuit depth. Notably, we find that QNNs perform best when the frequency spectrum is tailored to the target function's complexity but remains as compact as possible. Moreover, architectures with identical frequency spectra can differ in trainability, with configurations using more qubits and fewer layers generally performing better, except in the single-layer case. These findings provide guidelines for selecting QNN ansätze and offer new insights into the interplay between expressivity and trainability in quantum machine learning.
A primary obstacle in scaling up quantum computing platforms based on semiconductor quantum dots (QDs) is the full automation of initialization and control. Using ideas from machine learning (ML), pattern recognition, and optimization, the authors implement an autotuning protocol that needs no human intervention to navigate between QD states in real time. A convolutional neural network identifies QD states from $i\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}n$ $s\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}i\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}t\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}u$ measurements; importantly, the network is trained exclusively on simulated data, and the scans used are significantly smaller that in manual tuning, and hence much faster. This development is critical to moving up to larger numbers of quantum dots.