Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2511.07476

A Four-Level Ontological Framework for Quantum Field Theory: From Quantum Vacuum to Phenomenal Reality

Ali Reza Mirzaee

physics.hist-phquant-phSubmitted Nov 8, 2025• Announced Nov 11, 2025• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

One of the foundational challenges in both Quantum Field Theory and the philosophy of physics lies in the traditional binary classification of entities as either real or unreal. The classical view posits that material entities are real, while mental constructs or theoretical entities are unreal. However, quantum phenomena such as virtual particles challenge this simplistic dichotomy. These unobservable entities, by influencing measurable phenomena, raise profound questions about the nature and modes of existence. To address this, we propose a four-level ontological hierarchy that spans from the quantum vacuum and the virtual level to the quantum level and phenomenal reality, providing a coherent continuum from potentiality to actualization. This framework not only clarifies the interpretation of quantum theory but also offers a unified perspective linking the unobservable with the observable. In QFT, virtual particles play a crucial role in mediating forces and in correcting the measurable properties of real particles. They arise within the mathematical structure of Feynman diagrams and, despite being unobservable, produce real, measurable effects such as the Lamb shift and the Casimir effect. Philosophically, this raises deep ontological questions: if unobservable entities affect measurable phenomena, can they truly be dismissed as unreal? Conversely, if they are real, what mode of existence do they possess? The traditional dichotomy of real versus unreal is thus insufficient for interpreting the ontological implications of quantum processes. To overcome these limitations, we propose a four-level ontological hierarchy.

Related papers

Quantum Mechanics Without Collapse

Andrii Myshko

We develop a structural reinterpretation of the foundational ontological problems of quantum mechanics within the program of Metamonism [1] and its physical extension Basic Ontodynamics [2]. Three ontological placeholders that have resisted satisfactory interpretation for a century — wave function collapse, wave-particle duality, and virtual particles — are identified as symptoms of a foundational gap: the absence of a structural account of what quantum objects are. The present framework proposes that quantum objects are activation regimes of the F-hierarchy at different degrees of F7 closure. The photon is F56 without F7 — an unclosed coherence regime. The electron is F56 with residual St closure. Wave-particle duality dissolves: there is one object at different closure states, not two natures. Collapse dissolves: measurement is a continuous F7 closure process driven by structural resonance, not a discontinuous transition. Virtual particles dissolve as ontological entities: interactions are direct F56 coherence redistributions through the shared background F123, with virtual particles as mathematical parametrizations of transient incomplete F7 closures. The uncertainty principle receives a structural reading: ∆x · ∆p and ∆E · ∆t are two aspects of the single constraint that F7 closure and F56 phase sharpness cannot be simultaneously maximal. Renormalization is identified as a symptom of ontological incompleteness: it compensates for the point particle idealization, the free propagator treatment of virtual particles, and the empty vacuum assumption— all of which the F-hierarchy framework replaces structurally. Five falsifiable predictions are stated: finite duration of atomic transitions, natural ultraviolet cutoff in vacuum fluctuations, vacuum birefringence at high laser intensity, confinement scale from F7 closure geometry, and renormalization group fixed points as F7 closure transitions. The paper is a programmatic contribution within Metamonism: it proposes a structurally unified ontological reading of quantum phenomena and establishes a research program in which the formal derivation of quantum mechanics from F-hierarchy dynamics becomes a well-posed task.

•Mar 7, 2026•0 citations

The formation of the conceptual foundations of quantum field theory

Tian Yu Cao

Quantum field theory (QFT) can be analyzed in terms of its mathematical structure, its conceptual system for physical descriptions, or its basic ontology. The analysis can be done logically or historically. In this chapter, only the genesis of the conceptual foundations of QFT relevant to its basic ontology will be treated; no discussion of its mathematical structures or its epistemological underpinnings will be given. Some conceptual problems, such as those related to probability and measurement, will be discussed, but only because of their relevance to the basic ontology of QFT, rather than their intrinsic philosophical interest. Here, by basic ontology I mean the irreducible entities that QFT is invented to describe. The often mentioned candidates for the basic ontology of QFT, in fact of the physical world, are the discrete particle and the continuous field. Another possible candidate (the spacetime point) has also been suggested recently (Redhead, 1983). Since the aim of this chapter is to analyze the historical process in which the conceptual foundations of QFT were laid down, rather than the logical structure of QFT which philosophers of the present day treat, no discussion of the last possibility will be given. The content of this chapter involves the formation and interpretation, in a roughly chronological order, of the concepts of the wave function, quantization, quantization of the field, the vacuum, interactions between fields, and renormalization. The first two topics will be discussed in relation to the quantization of the field, with their role being taken as the starting point of the conceptual development of QFT.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 13, 1997•0 citations

Virtual Particles as Relational Scaffolding: A Structural Interpretation of Quantum Fields

Denis Bailet

This paper argues that virtual particles are not physical entities but structural adjustments within a quantum field. Using a relation‑first framework, it reframes the vacuum as a generative environment that maintains coherence under constraint. Virtual particles are treated as local signatures of global relational updates, not objects that appear and disappear. This interpretation clarifies the Casimir effect, avoids reification, and aligns quantum field behavior with a broader relational ontology in which structure—not substance—does the explanatory work.

•Feb 23, 2026•0 citations

A Field-First Interpretation of Wave-Particle Duality

Srikar R

This preprint presents a field-first interpretation of wave-particle duality grounded in the ontology of Quantum Field Theory (QFT). The framework treats quantum fields as the fundamental ontology of physical reality, while particles are understood as excitation states of their respective fields. Wave-like phenomena, including interference, diffraction, tunneling, and coherence effects, are interpreted as arising from the propagation and interaction dynamics of these excitations rather than from an independent wave ontology. The central thesis is that wave-particle duality does not represent two distinct physical realities, but rather different observational regimes of a single field-based process. Localized interactions appear particle-like, while propagation and interference phenomena appear wave-like. This interpretation is fully consistent with the existing mathematical formalism of Quantum Field Theory and does not introduce new physical laws or modifications to established quantum mechanics. The purpose of this work is interpretive and conceptual. It aims to provide a clearer ontological framework for understanding the relationship between quantum fields, particles, and wave-like behavior while reducing the conceptual ambiguity traditionally associated with wave-particle duality. This document represents the initial preprint release of the field-first interpretation framework.

•May 31, 2026•0 citations

Light, Correlation, and the Emergence of Reality. An Ontological Interpretation of Quantum Fields

Manfred Albert Hörz

This article presents an ontological interpretation of quantum fields, arguing that light and correlation form the foundational processes through which physical reality emerges. By shifting the focus from particle‑based metaphysics to relational and field‑based structures, the work explores how coherence, interaction, and the dynamics of correlation generate the phenomena we describe as ‘reality’. The article integrates conceptual analysis with insights from quantum field theory to propose a unified ontological framework.

•Feb 11, 2026•0 citations

Are Virtual Particles Less Real?

Gregg S. Jaeger

The question of whether virtual quantum particles exist is considered here in light of previous critical analysis and under the assumption that there are particles in the world as described by quantum field theory. The relationship of the classification of particles to quantum-field-theoretic calculations and the diagrammatic aids that are often used in them is clarified. It is pointed out that the distinction between virtual particles and others and, therefore, judgments regarding their reality have been made on basis of these methods rather than on their physical characteristics. As such, it has obscured the question of their existence. It is here argued that the most influential arguments against the existence of virtual particles but not other particles fail because they either are arguments against the existence of particles in general rather than virtual particles per se, or are dependent on the imposition of classical intuitions on quantum systems, or are simply beside the point. Several reasons are then provided for considering virtual particles real, such as their descriptive, explanatory, and predictive value, and a clearer characterization of virtuality—one in terms of intermediate states—that also applies beyond perturbation theory is provided. It is also pointed out that in the role of force mediators, they serve to preclude action-at-a-distance between interacting particles. For these reasons, it is concluded that virtual particles are as real as other quantum particles.

Entropy•Feb 2, 2019•46 citations
One of the foundational challenges in both Quantum Field Theory and the philosophy of physics lies in the traditional binary classification of entities as either real or unreal. The classical view posits that material entities are real, while mental constructs or theoretical entities are unreal. However, quantum phenomena such as virtual particles challenge this simplistic dichotomy. These unobservable entities, by influencing measurable phenomena, raise profound questions about the nature and modes of existence. To address this, we propose a four-level ontological hierarchy that spans from the quantum vacuum and the virtual level to the quantum level and phenomenal reality, providing a coherent continuum from potentiality to actualization. This framework not only clarifies the interpretation of quantum theory but also offers a unified perspective linking the unobservable with the observable. In QFT, virtual particles play a crucial role in mediating forces and in correcting the measurable properties of real particles. They arise within the mathematical structure of Feynman diagrams and, despite being unobservable, produce real, measurable effects such as the Lamb shift and the Casimir effect. Philosophically, this raises deep ontological questions: if unobservable entities affect measurable phenomena, can they truly be dismissed as unreal? Conversely, if they are real, what mode of existence do they possess? The traditional dichotomy of real versus unreal is thus insufficient for interpreting the ontological implications of quantum processes. To overcome these limitations, we propose a four-level ontological hierarchy.
We develop a structural reinterpretation of the foundational ontological problems of quantum mechanics within the program of Metamonism [1] and its physical extension Basic Ontodynamics [2]. Three ontological placeholders that have resisted satisfactory interpretation for a century — wave function collapse, wave-particle duality, and virtual particles — are identified as symptoms of a foundational gap: the absence of a structural account of what quantum objects are. The present framework proposes that quantum objects are activation regimes of the F-hierarchy at different degrees of F7 closure. The photon is F56 without F7 — an unclosed coherence regime. The electron is F56 with residual St closure. Wave-particle duality dissolves: there is one object at different closure states, not two natures. Collapse dissolves: measurement is a continuous F7 closure process driven by structural resonance, not a discontinuous transition. Virtual particles dissolve as ontological entities: interactions are direct F56 coherence redistributions through the shared background F123, with virtual particles as mathematical parametrizations of transient incomplete F7 closures. The uncertainty principle receives a structural reading: ∆x · ∆p and ∆E · ∆t are two aspects of the single constraint that F7 closure and F56 phase sharpness cannot be simultaneously maximal. Renormalization is identified as a symptom of ontological incompleteness: it compensates for the point particle idealization, the free propagator treatment of virtual particles, and the empty vacuum assumption— all of which the F-hierarchy framework replaces structurally. Five falsifiable predictions are stated: finite duration of atomic transitions, natural ultraviolet cutoff in vacuum fluctuations, vacuum birefringence at high laser intensity, confinement scale from F7 closure geometry, and renormalization group fixed points as F7 closure transitions. The paper is a programmatic contribution within Metamonism: it proposes a structurally unified ontological reading of quantum phenomena and establishes a research program in which the formal derivation of quantum mechanics from F-hierarchy dynamics becomes a well-posed task.
Quantum field theory (QFT) can be analyzed in terms of its mathematical structure, its conceptual system for physical descriptions, or its basic ontology. The analysis can be done logically or historically. In this chapter, only the genesis of the conceptual foundations of QFT relevant to its basic ontology will be treated; no discussion of its mathematical structures or its epistemological underpinnings will be given. Some conceptual problems, such as those related to probability and measurement, will be discussed, but only because of their relevance to the basic ontology of QFT, rather than their intrinsic philosophical interest. Here, by basic ontology I mean the irreducible entities that QFT is invented to describe. The often mentioned candidates for the basic ontology of QFT, in fact of the physical world, are the discrete particle and the continuous field. Another possible candidate (the spacetime point) has also been suggested recently (Redhead, 1983). Since the aim of this chapter is to analyze the historical process in which the conceptual foundations of QFT were laid down, rather than the logical structure of QFT which philosophers of the present day treat, no discussion of the last possibility will be given. The content of this chapter involves the formation and interpretation, in a roughly chronological order, of the concepts of the wave function, quantization, quantization of the field, the vacuum, interactions between fields, and renormalization. The first two topics will be discussed in relation to the quantization of the field, with their role being taken as the starting point of the conceptual development of QFT.
This paper argues that virtual particles are not physical entities but structural adjustments within a quantum field. Using a relation‑first framework, it reframes the vacuum as a generative environment that maintains coherence under constraint. Virtual particles are treated as local signatures of global relational updates, not objects that appear and disappear. This interpretation clarifies the Casimir effect, avoids reification, and aligns quantum field behavior with a broader relational ontology in which structure—not substance—does the explanatory work.
This preprint presents a field-first interpretation of wave-particle duality grounded in the ontology of Quantum Field Theory (QFT). The framework treats quantum fields as the fundamental ontology of physical reality, while particles are understood as excitation states of their respective fields. Wave-like phenomena, including interference, diffraction, tunneling, and coherence effects, are interpreted as arising from the propagation and interaction dynamics of these excitations rather than from an independent wave ontology. The central thesis is that wave-particle duality does not represent two distinct physical realities, but rather different observational regimes of a single field-based process. Localized interactions appear particle-like, while propagation and interference phenomena appear wave-like. This interpretation is fully consistent with the existing mathematical formalism of Quantum Field Theory and does not introduce new physical laws or modifications to established quantum mechanics. The purpose of this work is interpretive and conceptual. It aims to provide a clearer ontological framework for understanding the relationship between quantum fields, particles, and wave-like behavior while reducing the conceptual ambiguity traditionally associated with wave-particle duality. This document represents the initial preprint release of the field-first interpretation framework.
This article presents an ontological interpretation of quantum fields, arguing that light and correlation form the foundational processes through which physical reality emerges. By shifting the focus from particle‑based metaphysics to relational and field‑based structures, the work explores how coherence, interaction, and the dynamics of correlation generate the phenomena we describe as ‘reality’. The article integrates conceptual analysis with insights from quantum field theory to propose a unified ontological framework.
The question of whether virtual quantum particles exist is considered here in light of previous critical analysis and under the assumption that there are particles in the world as described by quantum field theory. The relationship of the classification of particles to quantum-field-theoretic calculations and the diagrammatic aids that are often used in them is clarified. It is pointed out that the distinction between virtual particles and others and, therefore, judgments regarding their reality have been made on basis of these methods rather than on their physical characteristics. As such, it has obscured the question of their existence. It is here argued that the most influential arguments against the existence of virtual particles but not other particles fail because they either are arguments against the existence of particles in general rather than virtual particles per se, or are dependent on the imposition of classical intuitions on quantum systems, or are simply beside the point. Several reasons are then provided for considering virtual particles real, such as their descriptive, explanatory, and predictive value, and a clearer characterization of virtuality—one in terms of intermediate states—that also applies beyond perturbation theory is provided. It is also pointed out that in the role of force mediators, they serve to preclude action-at-a-distance between interacting particles. For these reasons, it is concluded that virtual particles are as real as other quantum particles.