Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2511.07348

Classical gravity cannot mediate entanglement

Chiara Marletto, Jonathan Oppenheim, Vlatko Vedral, Elizabeth Wilson

quant-phgr-qcSubmitted Nov 10, 2025• Announced Nov 11, 2025
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In Nature, 646, 813 (2025), Aziz and Howl claim that classical (unquantised) gravity produces entanglement. We show that their model does not produce entanglement. Even if the model produced entanglement, it would be mediated by the quantised matter interaction, and not gravity. Hence entanglement mediated by gravity remains an unambiguous witness of gravity's quantum features.

Comments
6 pages

Related papers

Comment on Classical-Gravity--Quantum-Matter Claims About Gravity-Mediated Entanglement

Mikołaj Sienicki, Krzysztof Sienicki

A recent paper by Aziz and Howl (Nature 2025) argues that, once quantum matter is described at the level of quantum field theory and coupled to a classical gravitational field, higher order processes can generate entanglement between two spatially separated masses. A contemporaneous critical note (Marletto, Oppenheim, Vedral, Wilson, arXiv:2511.07348v1) shows that, in the actual nonrelativistic limit employed there, the interaction becomes ultra local, the total unitary factorizes, and no entanglement is generated from a product input. In this comment we (i) restate the core point of that critique, (ii) give a channel theoretic reformulation that makes the conclusion model independent, and (iii) clarify the distinction between activation of entanglement in already quantum matter and genuine mediation of entanglement by a classical field. Once these clarifications are in place, the standard BMV inference that observation of gravity mediated entanglement strongly indicates nonclassical gravitational degrees of freedom remains intact.

quant-pharXiv:2511.20717•Nov 26, 2025•2 citations

A demonstration that classical gravity does not produce entanglement

Mike D. Schneider, Nick Huggett, Niels Linnemann

Once again, dispute has arisen over the interpretation of proposed quantum information theory experiments to probe the quantum nature of gravity by testing for gravitationally induced entanglement (GIE) between two spatially separated massive particles ([2] vs. [16, 17]; further contributions in [11, 13]). The confusion appears to reside in interpreting applications of a Hamiltonian formalism. But classical gravity cannot mediate entanglement on independent grounds. A Newton-Cartan analysis shows that if gravity is classical, a mediator, and entanglement is observed as an outcome of performing a GIE experiment, something other than gravity must have supplied the (virtual) force needed during the experiment to produce the effect.

quant-pharXiv:2511.19242•Nov 25, 2025

Gravity-mediated entanglement via infinite-dimensional systems

Stefan L. Ludescher, Leon Loveridge, Thomas D. Galley +1 more

Abstract There has been a wave of recent interest in detecting the quantum nature of gravity with tabletop experiments that witness gravitationally mediated entanglement. Central to these proposals is the assumption that any mediator capable of generating entanglement must itself be nonclassical. However, previous arguments for this have modeled classical mediators as finite, discrete systems such as bits, which excludes physically relevant continuous and infinite-dimensional systems such as those of classical mechanics and field theory. In this work, we close this gap by modeling classical systems as commutative unital C ∗ -algebras, arguably encompassing all potentially physically relevant classical systems. We show that these systems cannot mediate entanglement between two quantum systems A and B , even if A and B are themselves infinite-dimensional or described by arbitrary unital C ∗ -algebras (as in quantum field theory), composed with an arbitrary C ∗ -tensor product. This result reinforces the conclusion that the observation of gravity-induced entanglement would require the gravitational field to possess inherently non-classical features.

arXiv:2507.13201•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Apr 28, 2026•8 citations

Entanglement of quantum systems via a classical mediator in hybrid van Hove theory

Sebastian Ulbricht, Andrés Darío Bermúdez Manjarres, Marcel Reginatto

It is a matter of ongoing discussion whether quantum states can become entangled while only interacting via a classical mediator. This lively debate is deeply interwoven with the question of whether entanglement studies can prove the quantum nature of gravity. However, the answer to this fundamental question depends crucially on which hybrid quantum-classical theory is used. In this Letter, we demonstrate that entanglement by a classical mediator is possible within the framework of hybrid van Hove theory, showing that existing no-go theorems on that matter do not universally apply to hybrid theories in general. After briefly recapitulating the key features of the hybrid van Hove theory, we show this using the example of two quantum spins coupled by a classical harmonic oscillator. By deriving the spin density matrix for this scenario and comparing it to its equivalent for a pure quantum system, we show that entanglement between the two spins is generated in both cases. Conclusively, this is illustrated by presenting the purity and concurrence of the spin-spin system as a decisive measure for entanglement. Our results further imply that quantum entanglement studies cannot rule out consistent quantum theories featuring classical gravity.

quant-pharXiv:2601.21555•Jan 30, 2026•1 citation

Classical Gravity Cannot Mediate Entanglement by Local Means

Chiara Marletto, Vlatko Vedral

We rebut a recent paper that claims that classical gravity can entangle two massive superpositions by local means. We refute the misconceptions appearing in this paper and confirm that the quantum features are necessary in the gravitational field if it can lead to entanglement by local propagation between distant masses.

arXiv:2510.19969•Oct 22, 2025•10 citations

Can classical theories of gravity produce entanglement?

Anirudh Gundhi, Giorgia Infantino, Angelo Bassi

A recent paper published in Nature [Nature,646,813(2025)] claims that quantum particles become entangled through their gravitational interaction, even when the gravitational potential is classical. Here we show that the entanglement found by the authors is a consequence of letting particles diffuse from one object to the other. When this is not allowed, the wavefunction remains factorized. In fact, noticing that entanglement is relative to a chosen partition of the Hilbert space, we show that the choice of partition implicitly made by the authors is such that entanglement arises as soon as particles diffuse, even when no interaction potential is present. Therefore, it is the free evolution, not the classical gravitational potential, which acts as the entangling mechanism in the scenario considered by the authors.

quant-pharXiv:2604.19696•Apr 22, 2026•5 citations
In Nature, 646, 813 (2025), Aziz and Howl claim that classical (unquantised) gravity produces entanglement. We show that their model does not produce entanglement. Even if the model produced entanglement, it would be mediated by the quantised matter interaction, and not gravity. Hence entanglement mediated by gravity remains an unambiguous witness of gravity's quantum features.
A recent paper by Aziz and Howl (Nature 2025) argues that, once quantum matter is described at the level of quantum field theory and coupled to a classical gravitational field, higher order processes can generate entanglement between two spatially separated masses. A contemporaneous critical note (Marletto, Oppenheim, Vedral, Wilson, arXiv:2511.07348v1) shows that, in the actual nonrelativistic limit employed there, the interaction becomes ultra local, the total unitary factorizes, and no entanglement is generated from a product input. In this comment we (i) restate the core point of that critique, (ii) give a channel theoretic reformulation that makes the conclusion model independent, and (iii) clarify the distinction between activation of entanglement in already quantum matter and genuine mediation of entanglement by a classical field. Once these clarifications are in place, the standard BMV inference that observation of gravity mediated entanglement strongly indicates nonclassical gravitational degrees of freedom remains intact.
Once again, dispute has arisen over the interpretation of proposed quantum information theory experiments to probe the quantum nature of gravity by testing for gravitationally induced entanglement (GIE) between two spatially separated massive particles ([2] vs. [16, 17]; further contributions in [11, 13]). The confusion appears to reside in interpreting applications of a Hamiltonian formalism. But classical gravity cannot mediate entanglement on independent grounds. A Newton-Cartan analysis shows that if gravity is classical, a mediator, and entanglement is observed as an outcome of performing a GIE experiment, something other than gravity must have supplied the (virtual) force needed during the experiment to produce the effect.
Abstract There has been a wave of recent interest in detecting the quantum nature of gravity with tabletop experiments that witness gravitationally mediated entanglement. Central to these proposals is the assumption that any mediator capable of generating entanglement must itself be nonclassical. However, previous arguments for this have modeled classical mediators as finite, discrete systems such as bits, which excludes physically relevant continuous and infinite-dimensional systems such as those of classical mechanics and field theory. In this work, we close this gap by modeling classical systems as commutative unital C ∗ -algebras, arguably encompassing all potentially physically relevant classical systems. We show that these systems cannot mediate entanglement between two quantum systems A and B , even if A and B are themselves infinite-dimensional or described by arbitrary unital C ∗ -algebras (as in quantum field theory), composed with an arbitrary C ∗ -tensor product. This result reinforces the conclusion that the observation of gravity-induced entanglement would require the gravitational field to possess inherently non-classical features.
It is a matter of ongoing discussion whether quantum states can become entangled while only interacting via a classical mediator. This lively debate is deeply interwoven with the question of whether entanglement studies can prove the quantum nature of gravity. However, the answer to this fundamental question depends crucially on which hybrid quantum-classical theory is used. In this Letter, we demonstrate that entanglement by a classical mediator is possible within the framework of hybrid van Hove theory, showing that existing no-go theorems on that matter do not universally apply to hybrid theories in general. After briefly recapitulating the key features of the hybrid van Hove theory, we show this using the example of two quantum spins coupled by a classical harmonic oscillator. By deriving the spin density matrix for this scenario and comparing it to its equivalent for a pure quantum system, we show that entanglement between the two spins is generated in both cases. Conclusively, this is illustrated by presenting the purity and concurrence of the spin-spin system as a decisive measure for entanglement. Our results further imply that quantum entanglement studies cannot rule out consistent quantum theories featuring classical gravity.
A recent paper published in Nature [Nature,646,813(2025)] claims that quantum particles become entangled through their gravitational interaction, even when the gravitational potential is classical. Here we show that the entanglement found by the authors is a consequence of letting particles diffuse from one object to the other. When this is not allowed, the wavefunction remains factorized. In fact, noticing that entanglement is relative to a chosen partition of the Hilbert space, we show that the choice of partition implicitly made by the authors is such that entanglement arises as soon as particles diffuse, even when no interaction potential is present. Therefore, it is the free evolution, not the classical gravitational potential, which acts as the entangling mechanism in the scenario considered by the authors.