Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2510.06086

Identifying chiral topological order in microscopic spin models by modular commutator

Avijit Maity, Aman Kumar, Vikram Tripathi

Published Oct 7, 2025• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The chiral central charge $c_-$ is a key topological invariant of the edge characterizing the bulk two-dimensional chiral topological order, but its direct evaluation in microscopic spin models has long been a challenge, especially for non-abelian topological order. Building on the recently developed modular commutator formalism, we numerically obtain $c_-$ directly from single ground-state wave functions of two-dimensional interacting spin models that have chiral topological order. This provides a geometry-independent and bulk diagnostic of chirality. We study two nonintegrable systems -- the Zeeman-Kitaev honeycomb model and the kagome antiferromagnet -- both subjected to scalar spin chirality perturbations. We find that the modular commutator yields results consistent with the expected topological quantum field theories. We also compute the topological entanglement entropy which provides an independent diagnostic of the topological orders. Our work establishes modular commutators as a powerful numerical probe of chiral topological order in strongly correlated quantum magnets.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2510.06086

Related papers

Modular commutator in gapped quantum many-body systems

Isaac H. Kim, Bowen Shi, Kohtaro Kato +1 more

In Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 176402 (2022), we argued that the chiral central charge---a topologically protected quantity characterizing the edge theory of a gapped $(2+1)$-dimensional system---can be extracted from the bulk by using an order parameter called the modular commutator. In this paper, we reveal general properties of the modular commutator and strengthen its relationship with the chiral central charge. First, we identify connections between the modular commutator and conditional mutual information, time reversal, and modular flow. Second, we prove, within the framework of the entanglement bootstrap program, that two topologically ordered media connected by a gapped domain wall must have the same modular commutator in their respective bulk. Third, we numerically calculate the value of the modular commutator for a bosonic lattice Laughlin state for finite sizes and extrapolate to the infinite-volume limit. The result of this extrapolation is consistent with the proposed formula up to an error of about $0.7%$.

arXiv:2110.10400•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 26, 2022•50 citations

Momentum polarization: An entanglement measure of topological spin and chiral central charge

Hong-Hao Tu, Yi Zhang, Xiao-Liang Qi

Topologically ordered states are quantum states of matter with topological ground-state degeneracy and quasiparticles carrying fractional quantum numbers and fractional statistics. The topological spin ${\ensuremath{\theta}}_{a}=2\ensuremath{\pi}{h}_{a}$ is an important property of a topological quasiparticle, which is the Berry phase obtained in the adiabatic self-rotation of the quasiparticle by $2\ensuremath{\pi}$. For chiral topological states with robust chiral edge states, another fundamental topological property is the edge state chiral central charge $c$. In this paper we propose an approach to compute the topological spin and chiral central charge in lattice models by defining a quantity that we call the momentum polarization. Momentum polarization is defined on the cylinder geometry as a universal subleading term in the average value of a ``partial translation operator.'' We show that the momentum polarization is a quantum entanglement property which can be computed from the reduced density matrix, and our analytic derivation based on edge conformal field theory shows that the momentum polarization measures the combination ${h}_{a}\ensuremath{-}\frac{c}{24}$ of topological spin and central charge. Results are obtained for two example systems, the non-Abelian phase of the honeycomb lattice Kitaev model and the $\ensuremath{\nu}=1/2$ Laughlin state of a fractional Chern insulator described by a variational Monte Carlo wave function, which verify the analytic formula with high accuracy and further suggest that this result remains robust even when the edge states cannot be described by a conformal field theory. Our result provides an efficient approach to extract characteristic quantities of topological states of matter from finite size numerics.

arXiv:1212.6951•Physical Review B•Nov 13, 2013•117 citations

Rényi-like entanglement probe of the chiral central charge

Julian Gass, Michael Levin

We propose a ground state entanglement probe for gapped, two-dimensional quantum many-body systems that involves taking powers of reduced density matrices in a particular geometric configuration. This quantity, which we denote by $ω_{α,β}$, is parameterized by two positive real numbers $α, β$, and can be seen as a ``Rényi-like" generalization of the modular commutator -- another entanglement probe proposed as a way to compute the chiral central charge from a bulk wave function. We obtain analytic expressions for $ω_{α,β}$ for gapped ground states of non-interacting fermion Hamiltonians as well as ground states of string-net models. In both cases, we find that $ω_{α,β}$ takes a universal value related to the chiral central charge. For integer values of $α$ and $β$, our quantity $ω_{α,β}$ can be expressed as an expectation value of permutation operators acting on an appropriate replica system, providing a natural route to measuring $ω_{α,β}$ in numerical simulations and potentially, experiments.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2512.20608•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 24, 2025•7 citations

Measures of Chirality in Mixed-State Topological Phases

Shijun Sun, Bader Aldossari, Rasmit Devkota +1 more

What does it mean for a mixed-state topological phase to be chiral? Mathematically, chirality can be sharply characterized through the symmetry algebra of the mixed state. Physically, however, the question is far more subtle. In pure states, chirality in topological phase is tied to a web of familiar diagnostics, involving bulk-boundary correspondence, a gapless entanglement spectrum, a nontrivial modular commutator, and a quantized thermal Hall response. We show that none of these diagnostics remain reliable in mixed states. Instead, for decohered topological phases with a known error-free parent state, we propose two relative-entropy-based measures that can diagnose chirality, with one of them further extracting the chiral central charge. As a concrete example, we use these measures to analyze the $em^2$-decohered $\mathbb{Z}_3$ toric code, identifying the chirality transition to be in the random-bond Potts class for the particle-hole symmetric channel, and the polarized random bond Potts class for asymmetric channels. Our results emphasize how mixed-state topology demands intrinsically new diagnostics beyond direct analogues of pure-state probes.

quant-pharXiv:2606.26235•Jun 26, 2026•2 citations

Chiral spin liquid in a Z3 Kitaev model

Limei Chen, Tyler D. Ellison, Meng Cheng +2 more

We study a ${\mathbb{Z}}_{3}$ Kitaev model on the honeycomb lattice with nearest neighbor interactions. Based on matrix product state simulations and symmetry considerations, we find evidence that, with ferromagnetic isotropic couplings, the model realizes a chiral spin liquid, characterized by a possible $\mathrm{U}{(1)}_{12}$ chiral topological order. This is supported by simulations on both cylinder and strip geometries. On infinitely long cylinders with various widths, scaling analysis of entanglement entropy and maximal correlation length suggests that the model has a gapped two-dimensional bulk. The topological entanglement entropy is extracted and found to be in agreement with the $\mathrm{U}{(1)}_{12}$ topological order. On infinitely long strips with moderate widths, we find the model is critical with a central charge consistent with the chiral edge theory of the $\mathrm{U}{(1)}_{12}$ topological phase. We conclude by discussing several open questions.

arXiv:2302.05060•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 25, 2024•7 citations

Probing chiral topological states with permutation defects

Yarden Sheffer, Ruihua Fan, Ady Stern +2 more

The hallmark of two-dimensional chiral topological phases is the existence of anomalous gapless modes at the spatial boundary. Yet, the manifestation of this edge anomaly within the bulk ground-state wavefunction itself remains only partially understood. In this work, we introduce a family of multipartite entanglement measures that probe chirality directly from the bulk wavefunction. Our construction involves applying different permutations between replicas of the ground state wavefunction in neighboring spatial regions, creating "permutation defects" at the boundaries between these regions. We provide general arguments for the robustness of these measures and develop a field-theoretical framework to compute them systematically. While the standard topological field theory prescription misses the chiral contribution, our method correctly identifies it as the chiral conformal field theory partition function on high-genus Riemann surfaces. This feature is a consequence of the bulk-edge correspondence, which dictates that any regularization of the theory at the permutation defects must introduce gapless boundary modes. We numerically verify our results with both free-fermion and strongly-interacting chiral topological states and find excellent agreement. Our results enable the extraction of the chiral central charge and the Hall conductance using a finite number of wavefunction replicas, making these quantities accessible to Monte-Carlo numerical techniques and noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices.

quant-pharXiv:2512.04649•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 5, 2025•6 citations
The chiral central charge c−c_-c−​ is a key topological invariant of the edge characterizing the bulk two-dimensional chiral topological order, but its direct evaluation in microscopic spin models has long been a challenge, especially for non-abelian topological order. Building on the recently developed modular commutator formalism, we numerically obtain c−c_-c−​ directly from single ground-state wave functions of two-dimensional interacting spin models that have chiral topological order. This provides a geometry-independent and bulk diagnostic of chirality. We study two nonintegrable systems -- the Zeeman-Kitaev honeycomb model and the kagome antiferromagnet -- both subjected to scalar spin chirality perturbations. We find that the modular commutator yields results consistent with the expected topological quantum field theories. We also compute the topological entanglement entropy which provides an independent diagnostic of the topological orders. Our work establishes modular commutators as a powerful numerical probe of chiral topological order in strongly correlated quantum magnets.
In Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 176402 (2022), we argued that the chiral central charge---a topologically protected quantity characterizing the edge theory of a gapped (2+1)(2+1)(2+1)-dimensional system---can be extracted from the bulk by using an order parameter called the modular commutator. In this paper, we reveal general properties of the modular commutator and strengthen its relationship with the chiral central charge. First, we identify connections between the modular commutator and conditional mutual information, time reversal, and modular flow. Second, we prove, within the framework of the entanglement bootstrap program, that two topologically ordered media connected by a gapped domain wall must have the same modular commutator in their respective bulk. Third, we numerically calculate the value of the modular commutator for a bosonic lattice Laughlin state for finite sizes and extrapolate to the infinite-volume limit. The result of this extrapolation is consistent with the proposed formula up to an error of about 0.70.7%0.7.
Topologically ordered states are quantum states of matter with topological ground-state degeneracy and quasiparticles carrying fractional quantum numbers and fractional statistics. The topological spin ${\ensuremath{\theta}}_{a}=2\ensuremath{\pi}{h}_{a}$ is an important property of a topological quasiparticle, which is the Berry phase obtained in the adiabatic self-rotation of the quasiparticle by $2\ensuremath{\pi}$. For chiral topological states with robust chiral edge states, another fundamental topological property is the edge state chiral central charge ccc. In this paper we propose an approach to compute the topological spin and chiral central charge in lattice models by defining a quantity that we call the momentum polarization. Momentum polarization is defined on the cylinder geometry as a universal subleading term in the average value of a ``partial translation operator.'' We show that the momentum polarization is a quantum entanglement property which can be computed from the reduced density matrix, and our analytic derivation based on edge conformal field theory shows that the momentum polarization measures the combination ${h}_{a}\ensuremath{-}\frac{c}{24}$ of topological spin and central charge. Results are obtained for two example systems, the non-Abelian phase of the honeycomb lattice Kitaev model and the $\ensuremath{\nu}=1/2$ Laughlin state of a fractional Chern insulator described by a variational Monte Carlo wave function, which verify the analytic formula with high accuracy and further suggest that this result remains robust even when the edge states cannot be described by a conformal field theory. Our result provides an efficient approach to extract characteristic quantities of topological states of matter from finite size numerics.
We propose a ground state entanglement probe for gapped, two-dimensional quantum many-body systems that involves taking powers of reduced density matrices in a particular geometric configuration. This quantity, which we denote by ωα,βω_{α,β}ωα,β​, is parameterized by two positive real numbers α,βα, βα,β, and can be seen as a ``Rényi-like" generalization of the modular commutator -- another entanglement probe proposed as a way to compute the chiral central charge from a bulk wave function. We obtain analytic expressions for ωα,βω_{α,β}ωα,β​ for gapped ground states of non-interacting fermion Hamiltonians as well as ground states of string-net models. In both cases, we find that ωα,βω_{α,β}ωα,β​ takes a universal value related to the chiral central charge. For integer values of ααα and βββ, our quantity ωα,βω_{α,β}ωα,β​ can be expressed as an expectation value of permutation operators acting on an appropriate replica system, providing a natural route to measuring ωα,βω_{α,β}ωα,β​ in numerical simulations and potentially, experiments.
What does it mean for a mixed-state topological phase to be chiral? Mathematically, chirality can be sharply characterized through the symmetry algebra of the mixed state. Physically, however, the question is far more subtle. In pure states, chirality in topological phase is tied to a web of familiar diagnostics, involving bulk-boundary correspondence, a gapless entanglement spectrum, a nontrivial modular commutator, and a quantized thermal Hall response. We show that none of these diagnostics remain reliable in mixed states. Instead, for decohered topological phases with a known error-free parent state, we propose two relative-entropy-based measures that can diagnose chirality, with one of them further extracting the chiral central charge. As a concrete example, we use these measures to analyze the em2em^2em2-decohered Z3\mathbb{Z}_3Z3​ toric code, identifying the chirality transition to be in the random-bond Potts class for the particle-hole symmetric channel, and the polarized random bond Potts class for asymmetric channels. Our results emphasize how mixed-state topology demands intrinsically new diagnostics beyond direct analogues of pure-state probes.
We study a Z3{\mathbb{Z}}_{3}Z3​ Kitaev model on the honeycomb lattice with nearest neighbor interactions. Based on matrix product state simulations and symmetry considerations, we find evidence that, with ferromagnetic isotropic couplings, the model realizes a chiral spin liquid, characterized by a possible U(1)12\mathrm{U}{(1)}_{12}U(1)12​ chiral topological order. This is supported by simulations on both cylinder and strip geometries. On infinitely long cylinders with various widths, scaling analysis of entanglement entropy and maximal correlation length suggests that the model has a gapped two-dimensional bulk. The topological entanglement entropy is extracted and found to be in agreement with the U(1)12\mathrm{U}{(1)}_{12}U(1)12​ topological order. On infinitely long strips with moderate widths, we find the model is critical with a central charge consistent with the chiral edge theory of the U(1)12\mathrm{U}{(1)}_{12}U(1)12​ topological phase. We conclude by discussing several open questions.
The hallmark of two-dimensional chiral topological phases is the existence of anomalous gapless modes at the spatial boundary. Yet, the manifestation of this edge anomaly within the bulk ground-state wavefunction itself remains only partially understood. In this work, we introduce a family of multipartite entanglement measures that probe chirality directly from the bulk wavefunction. Our construction involves applying different permutations between replicas of the ground state wavefunction in neighboring spatial regions, creating "permutation defects" at the boundaries between these regions. We provide general arguments for the robustness of these measures and develop a field-theoretical framework to compute them systematically. While the standard topological field theory prescription misses the chiral contribution, our method correctly identifies it as the chiral conformal field theory partition function on high-genus Riemann surfaces. This feature is a consequence of the bulk-edge correspondence, which dictates that any regularization of the theory at the permutation defects must introduce gapless boundary modes. We numerically verify our results with both free-fermion and strongly-interacting chiral topological states and find excellent agreement. Our results enable the extraction of the chiral central charge and the Hall conductance using a finite number of wavefunction replicas, making these quantities accessible to Monte-Carlo numerical techniques and noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices.