Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2510.05472

Quantum Regression Theory and Efficient Computation of Response Functions for Non-Markovian Open Systems

Xiantao Li, Chunhao Wang

Published Oct 7, 2025• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Linear response functions are a cornerstone concept in physics as they enable efficient estimation of many dynamical properties. In addition to predicting dynamics of observables under perturbations without resimulating the system, these response functions lead to electric conductivity, magnetic susceptibility, dielectric constants, etc. Estimating two-time correlation functions is a key ingredient of measuring linear response functions. However, for open quantum systems, simulating the reduced density operator with a quantum master equation only yields \emph{one-point} observables and is insufficient for this task. In this paper, we develop a memoryless, system-only formulation of two-point correlations for open quantum systems that extends the standard quantum regression theorem (QRT) beyond the Markov limit. We further incorporate the spectral property of the bath and express the time propagators in the response function as the memoryless generators in Lindblad-type forms. The resulting expressions recast the total response function into evolutions generated by time-dependent Hamiltonian and Lindblad primitives together with the more challenging propagation of commutators and anti-commutators. In addition to the derivation of the new QRT, we present quantum algorithms for these primitives and obtain an estimator for two-time correlations whose cost scales poly-logarithmically in the system dimension and $1/ε^{1.25}$ in the target accuracy $ε$. The framework removes the separability (Born-Markov) assumption and offers a pathway to efficient computation of nonequilibrium properties from open quantum systems.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2510.05472

Related papers

Non-Markovian finite-temperature two-time correlation functions of system operators: Beyond the quantum regression theorem

Hsi‐Sheng Goan, Po‐Wen Chen, Chung-Chin Jian

An extremely useful evolution equation that allows systematically calculating the two-time correlation functions (CF's) of system operators for non-Markovian open (dissipative) quantum systems is derived. The derivation is based on perturbative quantum master equation approach, so non-Markovian open quantum system models that are not exactly solvable can use our derived evolution equation to easily obtain their two-time CF's of system operators, valid to second order in the system-environment interaction. Since the form and nature of the Hamiltonian are not specified in our derived evolution equation, our evolution equation is applicable for bosonic and/or fermionic environments and can be applied to a wide range of system-environment models with any factorized (separable) system-environment initial states (pure or mixed). When applied to a general model of a system coupled to a finite-temperature bosonic environment with a system coupling operator L in the system-environment interaction Hamiltonian, the resultant evolution equation is valid for both L = L(†) and L ≠ L(†) cases, in contrast to those evolution equations valid only for L = L(†) case in the literature. The derived equation that generalizes the quantum regression theorem (QRT) to the non-Markovian case will have broad applications in many different branches of physics. We then give conditions on which the QRT holds in the weak system-environment coupling case and apply the derived evolution equation to a problem of a two-level system (atom) coupled to the finite-temperature bosonic environment (electromagnetic fields) with L ≠ L(†).

arXiv:1103.1502•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Mar 28, 2011•42 citations

Beyond the Quantum Regression Theorem in Variational Polaron Master Equations: from Ohmic to Super-Ohmic Environments

Matias Bundgaard-Nielsen, Jake Iles-Smith

While the quantum regression theorem (QRT) is the standard tool for computing multi-time correlation functions in open quantum systems, it relies on system-bath separability and an environment that remains in equilibrium, assumptions that are violated once dynamical correlations develop. Using the projection operator formalism, we derive an extension to the QRT that explicitly incorporates these correlation-induced corrections, enabling us to capture multi-time correlation functions in non-Markovian regimes. We apply this framework to the variational polaron master equation for the spin-boson model in ohmic and super-ohmic regimes, where the polaron transformation mixes system-bath degrees of freedom to produce a non-thermal effective environment. Benchmarking against numerically exact tensor-network simulations, we demonstrate quantitative agreement for single- and two-time observables, including linear-response spectra, even at strong coupling. Our approach broadens the reach of analytic master equations to multi-time observables in strong-coupling and non-Markovian regimes, where environmental memory effects and system-bath correlations are crucial.

quant-pharXiv:2604.13541•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Apr 16, 2026•1 citation

Linear response theory for open systems: Quantum master equation approach

Masashi Ban, Sachiko Kitajima, Toshihico Arimitsu +1 more

A linear response theory for open quantum systems is formulated by means of the time-local and time-nonlocal quantum master equations, where a relevant quantum system interacts with a thermal reservoir as well as with an external classical field. A linear response function that characterizes how a relaxation process deviates from its intrinsic process by a weak external field is obtained by extracting the linear terms with respect to the external field from the quantum master equation. It consists of four parts. One represents the linear response of a quantum system when system-reservoir correlation at an initial time and correlation between reservoir states at different times are neglected. The others are correction terms due to these effects. The linear response function is compared with the Kubo formula in the usual linear response theory. To investigate the properties of the linear response of an open quantum system, an exactly solvable model for a stochastic dephasing of a two-level system is examined. Furthermore, the method for deriving the linear response function is applied for calculating two-time correlation functions of open quantum systems. It is shown that the quantum regression theorem is not valid for open quantum systems unless their reduced time evolution is Markovian.

Physical Review A•Feb 27, 2017•22 citations

Two-point measurement correlations beyond the quantum regression theorem

Leonardo Santos, Otfried Gühne, Stefan Nimmrichter

Temporal correlations are fundamental in quantum physics, yet their computation is often challenging. The regression theorem (or hypothesis) serves as a key tool in this context, offering a seemingly straightforward approach. However, it fails for systems strongly coupled to their surroundings, where memory effects become significant. Here, we extend the analysis of temporal correlations beyond the regression theorem, revealing what can be learned about open quantum systems when this hypothesis fails. We introduce robust, operationally meaningful methods to explore how the breakdown of the regression hypothesis can uncover fundamental quantum features of non-Markovian open systems, including entanglement, coherence, and quantum memory, namely, the fundamental impossibility of simulating memory in non-Markov processes with classical feedback mechanisms. Finally, we demonstrate how these quantum features are linked to microscopic properties such as the bath spectral density and heat flow.

arXiv:2507.06088•Jul 8, 2025•2 citations

Factorization rule for multitime correlations in non-Markovian open quantum systems

Thomas K. Bracht, Moritz Cygorek

Experiments performed on quantum systems often measure multitime correlation functions. When quantum systems are weakly coupled to their environment, the time evolution of such correlation functions can be reduced to that of the reduced density matrix by the quantum regression theorem (QRT). While no QRT is available for general non-Markovian open quantum systems, we show that for time-independent Hamiltonians and finite memory times $τ_c$, an exact factorization rule exists that relates higher-order multitime correlations to products of lower-order correlations. Consequently, all information needed to reconstruct $n$-time correlations is contained in a temporal volume of $\mathcal{O}(τ_c^n)$. On the example of quantum dots coupled to phonons, we demonstrate that this factorization makes numerical calculations of multitime correlations extremely efficient and even enables semianalytical solutions in systems where the standard QRT breaks down.

quant-pharXiv:2605.22386•May 22, 2026•0 citations

Characterizzation of dynamical properties of non-Markovian open quantum systems

Giacomo Guarnieri

In the present Thesis we study the behavior of multi-time correlation functions and of thermodynamical quantities such as heat in open quantum systems undergoing an evolution generally affected by the presence of memory effects, i.e. non-Markovian. In the last decade, a large part of the scientific community in this field has dedicated its efforts to the understanding, precise definition and quantification of non-Markovianity in the quantum realm and now we have at our disposal several benchmark results and a plethora of different estimators that allow to determine the degree of non-Markovianity of a given dynamics. It comes therefore natural to investigate how other different dynamical quantities relate to such estimators also in order to understand the physical implications of memory effects on the statistics of observable quantities. In the first part of this work, a quantitative test of the violation of the so-called quantum regression theorem in presence of a non-Markovian dynamical regime is investigated. The quantum regression theorem represents a procedure that, whenever valid, allows to reconstruct two-time correlation functions of system's operators from the sole knowledge of the dynamics of mean values. It is worth stressing that two-time correlation functions are necessary in order to fully characterize the statistical properties of a quantum system, since they are able to catch aspects of the dynamics, such as fluorescence spectrum, in general not accessible looking at mean values. Despite their relevance however, obtaining two-time correlation functions often represents a formidable task, since the knowledge of the full "system+environment" dynamics is required, a generally too demanding request in the context of open quantum systems theory. The quantum regression theorem represents in this regard the easiest route to determine two-time correlation functions, this highlighting its importance. In this work we show that, in a pure-dephasing spin-boson model, the quantum regression theorem represents a stronger condition than non-Markovianity, in the sense that any presence of memory effects in the reduced dynamics inevitably results in violations to the former. These results have been published in [G.Guarnieri, A. Smirne, B. Vacchini, Phys. Rev. A 90, 022110 (2014)]. The second part of the Thesis is devoted to the characterization of heat ow at the microscopic level in open quantum systems, both finite and infinite dimensional. In particular we begin by studying the time behavior of its mean value in a non-Markovian dynamical regime, showing that, at variance with what happens in the Born-Markov semigroup limiting case, heat can backflow from the environment to the system. After providing a condition for the occurrence of such phenomenon and a measure for its amount for a given dynamics, the relationship with suitable non-Markovianity estimators is sought in two paradigmatic models, namely the spin-boson and the quantum brownian motion. The results, collected in [ G. Guarnieri, C. Uchiyama, B. Vacchini, Phys. Rev. A 93, 012118 (2016); G. Guarnieri, J. Nokkala, R. Schmidt, S. Maniscalco, B. Vacchini, Phys. Rev. A 94, 062101 (2016)], on the one hand allow for the identification of parameter-regions where the heat backflow is absent or maximum. On the other hand they show that the occurrence of heat backflow represents a stricter condition than non-Markovianity, in the sense that non-Markovianity allows for the observation of heat flowing back from the environment to the system and, vice versa, a Markovian dynamics prevents its occurrence. This Thesis concludes with the formulation of a new family of lower bounds to the mean dissipated heat in an environmental-assisted erasure-protocol scenario where Landauer's principle applies. As originally conceived for classical systems, this principle states that every irreversible erasure of information stored in a system inevitably carries along an amount of heat dissipated into the environment which is expended to perform the action. Within the framework recently put forward in [D. Reeb, M. M. Wolf, New J. Phys. 16, 103011 (2014)], which guarantees the validity of Landauer's principle in an open quantum systems scenario, we provide an asymptotically tight family of lower bounds to the dissipated heat which are also valid in the non-equilibrium setting. This construction is applied to an open system consisting of a three-level V-system, in which one transition is externally pumped by a laser field while the other is coupled through an XX-interaction to an environment consisting of a spin chain. Beside calculating all these quantities, an exact solution for the dynamics of such system is also provided. These results are collected in [G. Guarnieri, S. Campbell, J. Goold, S. Pigeon, M. Paternostro, B. Vacchini, in preparation].

•Jan 19, 2017•0 citations
Linear response functions are a cornerstone concept in physics as they enable efficient estimation of many dynamical properties. In addition to predicting dynamics of observables under perturbations without resimulating the system, these response functions lead to electric conductivity, magnetic susceptibility, dielectric constants, etc. Estimating two-time correlation functions is a key ingredient of measuring linear response functions. However, for open quantum systems, simulating the reduced density operator with a quantum master equation only yields \emph{one-point} observables and is insufficient for this task. In this paper, we develop a memoryless, system-only formulation of two-point correlations for open quantum systems that extends the standard quantum regression theorem (QRT) beyond the Markov limit. We further incorporate the spectral property of the bath and express the time propagators in the response function as the memoryless generators in Lindblad-type forms. The resulting expressions recast the total response function into evolutions generated by time-dependent Hamiltonian and Lindblad primitives together with the more challenging propagation of commutators and anti-commutators. In addition to the derivation of the new QRT, we present quantum algorithms for these primitives and obtain an estimator for two-time correlations whose cost scales poly-logarithmically in the system dimension and 1/ε1.251/ε^{1.25}1/ε1.25 in the target accuracy εεε. The framework removes the separability (Born-Markov) assumption and offers a pathway to efficient computation of nonequilibrium properties from open quantum systems.
An extremely useful evolution equation that allows systematically calculating the two-time correlation functions (CF's) of system operators for non-Markovian open (dissipative) quantum systems is derived. The derivation is based on perturbative quantum master equation approach, so non-Markovian open quantum system models that are not exactly solvable can use our derived evolution equation to easily obtain their two-time CF's of system operators, valid to second order in the system-environment interaction. Since the form and nature of the Hamiltonian are not specified in our derived evolution equation, our evolution equation is applicable for bosonic and/or fermionic environments and can be applied to a wide range of system-environment models with any factorized (separable) system-environment initial states (pure or mixed). When applied to a general model of a system coupled to a finite-temperature bosonic environment with a system coupling operator L in the system-environment interaction Hamiltonian, the resultant evolution equation is valid for both L = L(†) and L ≠ L(†) cases, in contrast to those evolution equations valid only for L = L(†) case in the literature. The derived equation that generalizes the quantum regression theorem (QRT) to the non-Markovian case will have broad applications in many different branches of physics. We then give conditions on which the QRT holds in the weak system-environment coupling case and apply the derived evolution equation to a problem of a two-level system (atom) coupled to the finite-temperature bosonic environment (electromagnetic fields) with L ≠ L(†).
While the quantum regression theorem (QRT) is the standard tool for computing multi-time correlation functions in open quantum systems, it relies on system-bath separability and an environment that remains in equilibrium, assumptions that are violated once dynamical correlations develop. Using the projection operator formalism, we derive an extension to the QRT that explicitly incorporates these correlation-induced corrections, enabling us to capture multi-time correlation functions in non-Markovian regimes. We apply this framework to the variational polaron master equation for the spin-boson model in ohmic and super-ohmic regimes, where the polaron transformation mixes system-bath degrees of freedom to produce a non-thermal effective environment. Benchmarking against numerically exact tensor-network simulations, we demonstrate quantitative agreement for single- and two-time observables, including linear-response spectra, even at strong coupling. Our approach broadens the reach of analytic master equations to multi-time observables in strong-coupling and non-Markovian regimes, where environmental memory effects and system-bath correlations are crucial.
A linear response theory for open quantum systems is formulated by means of the time-local and time-nonlocal quantum master equations, where a relevant quantum system interacts with a thermal reservoir as well as with an external classical field. A linear response function that characterizes how a relaxation process deviates from its intrinsic process by a weak external field is obtained by extracting the linear terms with respect to the external field from the quantum master equation. It consists of four parts. One represents the linear response of a quantum system when system-reservoir correlation at an initial time and correlation between reservoir states at different times are neglected. The others are correction terms due to these effects. The linear response function is compared with the Kubo formula in the usual linear response theory. To investigate the properties of the linear response of an open quantum system, an exactly solvable model for a stochastic dephasing of a two-level system is examined. Furthermore, the method for deriving the linear response function is applied for calculating two-time correlation functions of open quantum systems. It is shown that the quantum regression theorem is not valid for open quantum systems unless their reduced time evolution is Markovian.
Temporal correlations are fundamental in quantum physics, yet their computation is often challenging. The regression theorem (or hypothesis) serves as a key tool in this context, offering a seemingly straightforward approach. However, it fails for systems strongly coupled to their surroundings, where memory effects become significant. Here, we extend the analysis of temporal correlations beyond the regression theorem, revealing what can be learned about open quantum systems when this hypothesis fails. We introduce robust, operationally meaningful methods to explore how the breakdown of the regression hypothesis can uncover fundamental quantum features of non-Markovian open systems, including entanglement, coherence, and quantum memory, namely, the fundamental impossibility of simulating memory in non-Markov processes with classical feedback mechanisms. Finally, we demonstrate how these quantum features are linked to microscopic properties such as the bath spectral density and heat flow.
Experiments performed on quantum systems often measure multitime correlation functions. When quantum systems are weakly coupled to their environment, the time evolution of such correlation functions can be reduced to that of the reduced density matrix by the quantum regression theorem (QRT). While no QRT is available for general non-Markovian open quantum systems, we show that for time-independent Hamiltonians and finite memory times τcτ_cτc​, an exact factorization rule exists that relates higher-order multitime correlations to products of lower-order correlations. Consequently, all information needed to reconstruct nnn-time correlations is contained in a temporal volume of O(τcn)\mathcal{O}(τ_c^n)O(τcn​). On the example of quantum dots coupled to phonons, we demonstrate that this factorization makes numerical calculations of multitime correlations extremely efficient and even enables semianalytical solutions in systems where the standard QRT breaks down.
In the present Thesis we study the behavior of multi-time correlation functions and of thermodynamical quantities such as heat in open quantum systems undergoing an evolution generally affected by the presence of memory effects, i.e. non-Markovian. In the last decade, a large part of the scientific community in this field has dedicated its efforts to the understanding, precise definition and quantification of non-Markovianity in the quantum realm and now we have at our disposal several benchmark results and a plethora of different estimators that allow to determine the degree of non-Markovianity of a given dynamics. It comes therefore natural to investigate how other different dynamical quantities relate to such estimators also in order to understand the physical implications of memory effects on the statistics of observable quantities. In the first part of this work, a quantitative test of the violation of the so-called quantum regression theorem in presence of a non-Markovian dynamical regime is investigated. The quantum regression theorem represents a procedure that, whenever valid, allows to reconstruct two-time correlation functions of system's operators from the sole knowledge of the dynamics of mean values. It is worth stressing that two-time correlation functions are necessary in order to fully characterize the statistical properties of a quantum system, since they are able to catch aspects of the dynamics, such as fluorescence spectrum, in general not accessible looking at mean values. Despite their relevance however, obtaining two-time correlation functions often represents a formidable task, since the knowledge of the full "system+environment" dynamics is required, a generally too demanding request in the context of open quantum systems theory. The quantum regression theorem represents in this regard the easiest route to determine two-time correlation functions, this highlighting its importance. In this work we show that, in a pure-dephasing spin-boson model, the quantum regression theorem represents a stronger condition than non-Markovianity, in the sense that any presence of memory effects in the reduced dynamics inevitably results in violations to the former. These results have been published in [G.Guarnieri, A. Smirne, B. Vacchini, Phys. Rev. A 90, 022110 (2014)]. The second part of the Thesis is devoted to the characterization of heat ow at the microscopic level in open quantum systems, both finite and infinite dimensional. In particular we begin by studying the time behavior of its mean value in a non-Markovian dynamical regime, showing that, at variance with what happens in the Born-Markov semigroup limiting case, heat can backflow from the environment to the system. After providing a condition for the occurrence of such phenomenon and a measure for its amount for a given dynamics, the relationship with suitable non-Markovianity estimators is sought in two paradigmatic models, namely the spin-boson and the quantum brownian motion. The results, collected in [ G. Guarnieri, C. Uchiyama, B. Vacchini, Phys. Rev. A 93, 012118 (2016); G. Guarnieri, J. Nokkala, R. Schmidt, S. Maniscalco, B. Vacchini, Phys. Rev. A 94, 062101 (2016)], on the one hand allow for the identification of parameter-regions where the heat backflow is absent or maximum. On the other hand they show that the occurrence of heat backflow represents a stricter condition than non-Markovianity, in the sense that non-Markovianity allows for the observation of heat flowing back from the environment to the system and, vice versa, a Markovian dynamics prevents its occurrence. This Thesis concludes with the formulation of a new family of lower bounds to the mean dissipated heat in an environmental-assisted erasure-protocol scenario where Landauer's principle applies. As originally conceived for classical systems, this principle states that every irreversible erasure of information stored in a system inevitably carries along an amount of heat dissipated into the environment which is expended to perform the action. Within the framework recently put forward in [D. Reeb, M. M. Wolf, New J. Phys. 16, 103011 (2014)], which guarantees the validity of Landauer's principle in an open quantum systems scenario, we provide an asymptotically tight family of lower bounds to the dissipated heat which are also valid in the non-equilibrium setting. This construction is applied to an open system consisting of a three-level V-system, in which one transition is externally pumped by a laser field while the other is coupled through an XX-interaction to an environment consisting of a spin chain. Beside calculating all these quantities, an exact solution for the dynamics of such system is also provided. These results are collected in [G. Guarnieri, S. Campbell, J. Goold, S. Pigeon, M. Paternostro, B. Vacchini, in preparation].