Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2510.05224 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Superfluid weight in disordered flat-band superconductors as a competition between localization functionals

Kryštof Kolář, Tero Tapio Heikkilä, Päivi Törmä

Published Jun 18, 2026• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

According to Anderson's theorem, the gap of a time-reversal symmetric weak-coupling superconductor is unaffected by non-magnetic disorder. However, the superfluid weight (stiffness) is reduced in the disordered limit by a factor of $Δτ$, a product of the scattering time $τ$ and the superconducting order parameter $Δ$. Here we show that the opposite holds true in flat-band superconductors. While non-magnetic disorder does reduce the order parameter, we find that its direct effect on superfluid weight is mostly negligible. We show analytically that the effect of disorder is to lowest order given in terms of the difference between the intraband and interband parts of the localization functional of impurity wavefunctions, finding it to be typically vanishing.

DOI
10.1103/yxdx-92r8

Related papers

Universal suppression of superfluid weight by non-magnetic disorder in $s$-wave superconductors independent of quantum geometry and band dispersion

Alexander Lau, Sebastiano Peotta, Dmitry I. Pikulin +2 more

Motivated by the experimental progress in controlling the properties of the energy bands in superconductors, significant theoretical efforts have been devoted to study the effect of the quantum geometry and the flatness of the dispersion on the superfluid weight. In conventional superconductors, where the energy bands are wide and the Fermi energy is large, the contribution due to the quantum geometry is negligible, but in the opposite limit of flat-band superconductors the superfluid weight originates purely from the quantum geometry of Bloch wave functions. Here, we study how the energy band dispersion and the quantum geometry affect the disorder-induced suppression of the superfluid weight. In particular, we consider non-magnetic disorder and s-wave superconductivity. Surprisingly, we find that the disorder-dependence of the superfluid weight is universal across a variety of models, and independent of the quantum geometry and the flatness of the dispersion. Our results suggest that a flat-band superconductor is as resilient to disorder as a conventional superconductor.

arXiv:2203.01058•SciPost Physics•Oct 7, 2022•14 citations

Effects of forward disorder on quasi-one-dimensional superconductors

Giacomo Morpurgo, Thierry Giamarchi

We study the competition between disorder and singlet superconductivity in a quasi-one-dimensional (1D) system. We investigate the applicability of the Anderson theorem, namely that time-reversal conserving (nonmagnetic) disorder does not impact the critical temperature, by opposition to time-reversal breaking disorder (magnetic). To do so, we examine a quasi-1D system of spin 1/2 fermions with attractive interactions and forward scattering disorder using field theory (bosonization). By computing the superconducting critical temperature ( T c ), we find that, for nonmagnetic disorder, the Anderson theorem also holds in the quasi-1D geometry. In contrast, magnetic disorder has an impact on the critical temperature, which we investigate by deriving renormalization group equations describing the competition between disorder and interactions. Computing the critical temperature as a function of disorder strength, we observe different regimes depending on the strength of interactions. We discuss possible platforms where this can be observed in cold atoms and condensed matter. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2403.12597•Physical Review Research•Jun 17, 2024•2 citations

Obstructed Cooper pairs in flat band systems -- weakly-coherent superfluids and exact spin liquids

Tamaghna Hazra, Verma, Nishchhal, Schmalian, Jörg

Superconductivity in a partially filled flat band presents a vexing conceptual hurdle because the absence of a Fermi surface precludes a weak-coupling regime where one can extend insights from the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer picture of a Fermi surface instability. We approach the strongly correlated problem of flat band superconductivity from the strong coupling limit of local attractive interactions on line-graph lattices, whose non-interacting bandstructures host exactly flat bands due to frustrated hopping. In this limit, the pair kinetic energy which sets the superfluid stiffness is expected to scale inversely with the pair binding interaction. Here we demonstrate a striking counterexample. We show that when doped charges propagate on the line-graph of a lattice with strong pairing interaction and broken time-reversal symmetry, they bind into obstructed Cooper pairs whose motion is frustrated by destructive interference. As a result, the leading-order pair kinetic energy vanishes identically in the strong-coupling expansion, producing a flat bosonic band of compact localised pair states, zero superfluid stiffness at leading order, and an extensively degenerate many-body ground state manifold. At quarter filling, the frustrated pair dynamics maps onto a quantum dimer model which has a $d$-wave resonating-valence-bond ground state when time-reversal is broken. The pairing Hamiltonian in this limit thus has a topologically ordered spin liquid ground state which becomes exact at the analytically solvable Rokhsar-Kivelson point with long-range entanglement and deconfined holon excitations. Interestingly, we find exact compact localised eigenstates and extensive degeneracies in the many-body eigenstates of this emergent dimer model. Our results establish a disorder-free mechanism for interaction-driven localisation, in which strong pairing collapses the kinetic energy of Cooper pairs.

arXiv:2411.17815•Nov 26, 2024•1 citation

Superconductivity in the kagome Hubbard model under the flat-band-preserving disorder

Jicheol Kim, Dong-Hee Kim

We investigate the disordered flat-band superconductivity within the attractive Hubbard model on the kagome lattice by contrasting the flat-band-preserving disorder [Phys. Rev. B 98, 235109 (2018)] with the random hopping disorder that breaks the flat-band degeneracy. Through Bogoliubov-de Gennes mean-field calculations, we find that the superfluid weight is much more robust under the flat-band-preserving disorder, while the system eventually undergoes a transition to an insulator as disorder becomes strong enough. The almost linear interaction-dependence of the superfluid weight in the weak coupling limit found with the flat-band-preserving disorder confirms the persistent flat-band signature, whereas the exponential behavior of a dispersive-band character arises with the random hopping counterpart. In addition, in the exact diagonalization of the one-particle density matrix, we identify an occupation spectrum structure attributed to the flat-band states, demonstrating the connection between the resilient flat band and the enhanced robustness of superconductivity.

arXiv:2601.00540•Jan 2, 2026•0 citations

Distribution of the order parameter in strongly disordered superconductors: An analytic theory

Anton V. Khvalyuk, M. V. Feigel’man

We developed an analytic theory of inhomogeneous superconducting pairing in strongly disordered materials, which are moderately close to superconducting-insulator transition. Single-electron eigenstates are assumed to be Anderson localized, with a large localization volume. Superconductivity develops due to coherent delocalization of originally localized preformed Cooper pairs. The key assumption of the theory is that each such pair is coupled to a large number $Z\ensuremath{\gg}1$ of similar neighboring pairs. We derived integral equations for the probability distribution $P(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}})$ of local superconducting order parameter $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}(\mathbit{r})$ and analyzed their solutions in the limit of small dimensionless Cooper coupling constant $\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremath{\ll}1$. The shape of the order-parameter distribution is found to depend crucially upon the effective number of nearest neighbors ${Z}_{\text{eff}}=2{\ensuremath{\nu}}_{0}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{0}Z$, with ${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{0}$ being the single-particle density of states at the Fermi level. The solution we provide is valid both at large and small ${Z}_{\text{eff}}$; the latter case is nontrivial as the function $P(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}})$ is heavily non-Gaussian. One of our key findings is the discovery of a broad range of parameters where the distribution function $P(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}})$ is non-Gaussian but also noncritical (in the sense of superconductor-insulator transition criticality). The analytic results are supplemented by numerical data and good agreement between them is observed.

arXiv:2106.11848•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 15, 2021•6 citations

Disorder and the Robustness of Superconductivity on the Flat Band

Si Min Chan, Benoît Grémaud, G. G. Batrouni

We study the interplay between on-site disorder and fermion pairing on the quasi one-dimensional flat band Creutz lattice. Both disorder and flat bands localize particles, but an attractive interaction results in pair formation and delocalization giving rise to superconductivity. In this work, we examine the attractive Hubbard model on the Creutz lattice to study the competition between these two effects and elucidate the properties of the superconducting phase and the localization quantum phase transition as the disorder strength is increased. Our main result is that flat band superconductivity is robust against disorder: The critical disorder strength, $W_c$, required to localize the fermion pairs and destroy superconductivity, is finite at any interaction strength, $U$, and is proportional to the superconducting weight, $D_s$, of the clean system. Using large scale density matrix renormalization group computations, we show that this transition is of the BKT form. In addition, even at very small interaction strength, the localization is not due to single fermion localization but to pair localization. For completeness, we briefly study this disorder-induced localization with mean field theory and show that $W_c$ can be accurately determined by using an appropriate scaling function.

arXiv:2506.07095•Jun 8, 2025•4 citations
According to Anderson's theorem, the gap of a time-reversal symmetric weak-coupling superconductor is unaffected by non-magnetic disorder. However, the superfluid weight (stiffness) is reduced in the disordered limit by a factor of ΔτΔτΔτ, a product of the scattering time τττ and the superconducting order parameter ΔΔΔ. Here we show that the opposite holds true in flat-band superconductors. While non-magnetic disorder does reduce the order parameter, we find that its direct effect on superfluid weight is mostly negligible. We show analytically that the effect of disorder is to lowest order given in terms of the difference between the intraband and interband parts of the localization functional of impurity wavefunctions, finding it to be typically vanishing.
Universal suppression of superfluid weight by non-magnetic disorder in sss-wave superconductors independent of quantum geometry and band dispersion
Motivated by the experimental progress in controlling the properties of the energy bands in superconductors, significant theoretical efforts have been devoted to study the effect of the quantum geometry and the flatness of the dispersion on the superfluid weight. In conventional superconductors, where the energy bands are wide and the Fermi energy is large, the contribution due to the quantum geometry is negligible, but in the opposite limit of flat-band superconductors the superfluid weight originates purely from the quantum geometry of Bloch wave functions. Here, we study how the energy band dispersion and the quantum geometry affect the disorder-induced suppression of the superfluid weight. In particular, we consider non-magnetic disorder and s-wave superconductivity. Surprisingly, we find that the disorder-dependence of the superfluid weight is universal across a variety of models, and independent of the quantum geometry and the flatness of the dispersion. Our results suggest that a flat-band superconductor is as resilient to disorder as a conventional superconductor.
We study the competition between disorder and singlet superconductivity in a quasi-one-dimensional (1D) system. We investigate the applicability of the Anderson theorem, namely that time-reversal conserving (nonmagnetic) disorder does not impact the critical temperature, by opposition to time-reversal breaking disorder (magnetic). To do so, we examine a quasi-1D system of spin 1/2 fermions with attractive interactions and forward scattering disorder using field theory (bosonization). By computing the superconducting critical temperature ( T c ), we find that, for nonmagnetic disorder, the Anderson theorem also holds in the quasi-1D geometry. In contrast, magnetic disorder has an impact on the critical temperature, which we investigate by deriving renormalization group equations describing the competition between disorder and interactions. Computing the critical temperature as a function of disorder strength, we observe different regimes depending on the strength of interactions. We discuss possible platforms where this can be observed in cold atoms and condensed matter. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
Superconductivity in a partially filled flat band presents a vexing conceptual hurdle because the absence of a Fermi surface precludes a weak-coupling regime where one can extend insights from the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer picture of a Fermi surface instability. We approach the strongly correlated problem of flat band superconductivity from the strong coupling limit of local attractive interactions on line-graph lattices, whose non-interacting bandstructures host exactly flat bands due to frustrated hopping. In this limit, the pair kinetic energy which sets the superfluid stiffness is expected to scale inversely with the pair binding interaction. Here we demonstrate a striking counterexample. We show that when doped charges propagate on the line-graph of a lattice with strong pairing interaction and broken time-reversal symmetry, they bind into obstructed Cooper pairs whose motion is frustrated by destructive interference. As a result, the leading-order pair kinetic energy vanishes identically in the strong-coupling expansion, producing a flat bosonic band of compact localised pair states, zero superfluid stiffness at leading order, and an extensively degenerate many-body ground state manifold. At quarter filling, the frustrated pair dynamics maps onto a quantum dimer model which has a ddd-wave resonating-valence-bond ground state when time-reversal is broken. The pairing Hamiltonian in this limit thus has a topologically ordered spin liquid ground state which becomes exact at the analytically solvable Rokhsar-Kivelson point with long-range entanglement and deconfined holon excitations. Interestingly, we find exact compact localised eigenstates and extensive degeneracies in the many-body eigenstates of this emergent dimer model. Our results establish a disorder-free mechanism for interaction-driven localisation, in which strong pairing collapses the kinetic energy of Cooper pairs.
We investigate the disordered flat-band superconductivity within the attractive Hubbard model on the kagome lattice by contrasting the flat-band-preserving disorder [Phys. Rev. B 98, 235109 (2018)] with the random hopping disorder that breaks the flat-band degeneracy. Through Bogoliubov-de Gennes mean-field calculations, we find that the superfluid weight is much more robust under the flat-band-preserving disorder, while the system eventually undergoes a transition to an insulator as disorder becomes strong enough. The almost linear interaction-dependence of the superfluid weight in the weak coupling limit found with the flat-band-preserving disorder confirms the persistent flat-band signature, whereas the exponential behavior of a dispersive-band character arises with the random hopping counterpart. In addition, in the exact diagonalization of the one-particle density matrix, we identify an occupation spectrum structure attributed to the flat-band states, demonstrating the connection between the resilient flat band and the enhanced robustness of superconductivity.
We developed an analytic theory of inhomogeneous superconducting pairing in strongly disordered materials, which are moderately close to superconducting-insulator transition. Single-electron eigenstates are assumed to be Anderson localized, with a large localization volume. Superconductivity develops due to coherent delocalization of originally localized preformed Cooper pairs. The key assumption of the theory is that each such pair is coupled to a large number $Z\ensuremath{\gg}1$ of similar neighboring pairs. We derived integral equations for the probability distribution $P(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}})$ of local superconducting order parameter $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}(\mathbit{r})$ and analyzed their solutions in the limit of small dimensionless Cooper coupling constant $\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremath{\ll}1$. The shape of the order-parameter distribution is found to depend crucially upon the effective number of nearest neighbors ${Z}_{\text{eff}}=2{\ensuremath{\nu}}_{0}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{0}Z$, with ${\ensuremath{\nu}}_{0}$ being the single-particle density of states at the Fermi level. The solution we provide is valid both at large and small Zeff{Z}_{\text{eff}}Zeff​; the latter case is nontrivial as the function $P(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}})$ is heavily non-Gaussian. One of our key findings is the discovery of a broad range of parameters where the distribution function $P(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}})$ is non-Gaussian but also noncritical (in the sense of superconductor-insulator transition criticality). The analytic results are supplemented by numerical data and good agreement between them is observed.
We study the interplay between on-site disorder and fermion pairing on the quasi one-dimensional flat band Creutz lattice. Both disorder and flat bands localize particles, but an attractive interaction results in pair formation and delocalization giving rise to superconductivity. In this work, we examine the attractive Hubbard model on the Creutz lattice to study the competition between these two effects and elucidate the properties of the superconducting phase and the localization quantum phase transition as the disorder strength is increased. Our main result is that flat band superconductivity is robust against disorder: The critical disorder strength, WcW_cWc​, required to localize the fermion pairs and destroy superconductivity, is finite at any interaction strength, UUU, and is proportional to the superconducting weight, DsD_sDs​, of the clean system. Using large scale density matrix renormalization group computations, we show that this transition is of the BKT form. In addition, even at very small interaction strength, the localization is not due to single fermion localization but to pair localization. For completeness, we briefly study this disorder-induced localization with mean field theory and show that WcW_cWc​ can be accurately determined by using an appropriate scaling function.