Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2510.04238 · Physical review. E

Interplay of order and disorder in two-dimensional critical systems with mixed boundary conditions

Erich Eisenriegler

Published Jan 13, 2026• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In spin systems such as the Ising model, the local order and disorder can be characterized by the order-parameter and energy density profiles 〈σ(r_{1})〉 and 〈ε(r_{2})〉, respectively. Does increasing the order at r_{1} always decrease the disorder at r_{2}? Does increasing the disorder at r_{2} always decrease the order at r_{1}? The answer to these questions is contained in the cumulant response function 〈σ(r_{1})ε(r_{2})〉^{(cum)}. This correlation function vanishes in the unbounded bulk but not in systems with fixed-spin boundary conditions. Using the universal operator-product expansion of σ(r_{1})ε(r_{2}) and exact results for the Ising model, we analyze 〈σ(r_{1})ε(r_{2})〉^{(cum)} in two-dimensional critical systems defined on the x-y plane with mixed + and - boundary conditions. Particularly interesting behavior is found when either of the operators σ or ε is located on a "zero line" in the x-y plane, along which 〈σ(r)〉 vanishes. Results for half-plane, triangular, and rectangular geometries are presented.

DOI
10.1103/14gm-31hg

Related papers

Two-dimensional critical systems with mixed boundary conditions: Exact Ising results from conformal invariance and boundary-operator expansions

Theodore W. Burkhardt, Erich Eisenriegler

With conformal-invariance methods, Burkhardt, Guim, and Xue studied the critical Ising model, defined on the upper half plane y>0 with different boundary conditions a and b on the negative and positive x axes. For ab=-+ and f+, they determined the one- and two-point averages of the spin σ and energy ε. Here +,-, and f stand for spin-up, spin-down, and free-spin boundaries, respectively. The case +-+-+⋯, where the boundary condition switches between + and - at arbitrary points, ζ_{1},ζ_{2},⋯ on the x axis was also analyzed. In the first half of this paper a similar study is carried out for the alternating boundary condition +f+f+⋯ and the case -f+ of three different boundary conditions. Exact results for the one- and two-point averages of σ,ε, and the stress tensor T are derived with conformal-invariance methods. From the results for 〈T〉, the critical Casimir interaction with the boundary of a wedge-shaped inclusion is derived for mixed boundary conditions. In the second half of the paper, arbitrary two-dimensional critical systems with mixed boundary conditions are analyzed with boundary-operator expansions. Two distinct types of expansions-away from switching points of the boundary condition and at switching points-are considered. Using the expansions, we express the asymptotic behavior of two-point averages near boundaries in terms of one-point averages. We also consider the strip geometry with mixed boundary conditions and derive the distant-wall corrections to one-point averages near one edge due to the other edge. Finally we confirm the consistency of the predictions obtained with conformal-invariance methods and with boundary-operator expansions, in the the first and second halves of the paper.

arXiv:2008.04274•Physical review. E•Jan 19, 2021•3 citations

Critical behavior in rectangles with mixed boundaries

Erich Eisenriegler

Density profiles are investigated arising in a critical Ising model in two dimensions which is confined to a rectangular domain with uniform or mixed boundary conditions and arbitrary aspect ratio. For the cases in which the two vertical sides of the rectangle have up-spin boundary conditions + and the two horizontal sides with either down-spin boundary conditions - or with free-spin boundary conditions f, exact results are presented for the density profiles of the energy and the order parameter which display a surprisingly rich behavior. The new results follow by means of conformal transformations from known results in the half plane with +-+-+ and +f+f+ boundary conditions. The corners with mixed boundary conditions lead to interesting behavior, even in the limit of a half-infinite strip. The behavior near these corners can be described by a "corner-operator-expansion," which is discussed in the second part of the paper. The analytic predictions agree very well with simulations, with no adjustable parameters.

arXiv:2307.07831•Physical review. E•Oct 19, 2023•1 citation

Field theory of the two-dimensional Ising model: Conformal invariance, order and disorder, and bosonization

D. Boyanovsky

In this paper we review the critical Ising model by using the properties of conformal invariance. We use the known mapping of the Ising model to a theory of Majorana fermions and recognize that the self-duality property appears as a double degeneracy of the periodic ground state. The Ising model is doubled obtaining an Ashkin-Teller model (two Ising models coupled with a four-spin coupling) at the decoupling point. Using the bosonization technique this model is mapped onto the Gaussian model at a particular value of the temperature (K=1/\ensuremath{\pi}). This allows us to give the expressions for products of order, disorder, and energy operators of both Ising models in terms of operators in the Gaussian model. We compute several correlation functions of order, disorder, energy and spinor operators and show that they reproduce the operator product expansions predicted by conformal invariance. We explicitly discuss the physics by which the correlation functions obtained from the Gaussian model (a theory with conformal anomaly c=1) reproduce those of the Ising model (c=1/2). This provides a proof of Kadanoff and Brown's equivalences and conjectures. We provide a simple prescription to compute all n-point correlation functions at criticality, including mixed correlations of order, disorder, energy, and spinor operators. A bosonized form of the continuum limit of the transfer matrix for the critical Ising model is constructed. It is nonlocal and contains both spin-wave and vortex operators of the Gaussian model.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Apr 1, 1989•39 citations

Theory of Toeplitz Determinants and the Spin Correlations of the Two-Dimensional Ising Model. V

Barry M. McCoy, Tai Tsun Wu

In a previous paper of this series, we studied $\mathfrak{P}(\overline{\ensuremath{\sigma}})$, the probability that the average boundary spin for a half-plane of Ising spins is $\overline{\ensuremath{\sigma}}$. We extend our study of such functions by generalizing the previous derivation to any magnetic system and using them to relate the magnetic behavior at the critical isotherm to the spin-spin correlations at the critical temperature. We also clarify the meaning of the secondary maxima previously found in $\mathfrak{P}(\overline{\ensuremath{\sigma}})$ by a more accurate calculation and by examining the magnetization on interior rows of the half-plane. These considerations show that $\mathfrak{P}(\overline{\ensuremath{\sigma}})$ is more properly to be considered as the sum of two separate spin probability functions. The various ways in which the thermodynamic limit may be taken and the effects that these different limiting procedures have on $\mathfrak{P}(\overline{\ensuremath{\sigma}})$ are discussed in detail. The influence of boundary conditions on spin probability functions is studied by reversing the sign of one column of horizontal bonds. We compute the additional free energy resulting from the misfit bonds and use this to show that $\mathfrak{P}(\overline{\ensuremath{\sigma}})$ is no longer bimodal but is rectangular for $|\overline{\ensuremath{\sigma}}|$ less than the boundary spontaneous magnetization. Finally, we present in graphical form numerical integrations of the boundary magnetization and susceptibility.

Physical Review•Oct 10, 1968•29 citations

Critical properties of an altered Ising model

A. C. Brown

A modified two-dimensional Ising model is studied. In this model the nearest-neighbor interactions are changed along an infinite line imbedded in the lattice. We show that the effect of this alteration can be represented by the action of a marginal operator on the critical Ising model. This marginal operator is seen to change the decays of correlation in the lattices near the altered line. We find that the magnetization index $\ensuremath{\beta}$ is changed, while the index $\ensuremath{\nu}$ remains fixed. The expected crossover of the correlation functions to bulk behavior is also observed. We calculate the critical index for the disorder variable and predict the following relation between the index for the order and disorder variables: $\sqrt{2{x}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}+\sqrt{2{x}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}}=1$.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jan 1, 1982•22 citations

Bulk and surface properties in the critical phase of the two-dimensionalXYmodel

Bertrand Berche

Monte Carlo simulations of the two-dimensional XY model are performed in a square geometry with various boundary conditions (BC). Using conformal mappings we deduce the exponent η σ ( T ) of the order parameter correlation function and its surface analogue η ∥ ( T ) as a function of the temperature in the critical (low-temperature) phase of the model. The temperature dependence of both exponents is obtained numerically with a good accuracy up to the Kosterlitz–Thouless transition temperature. The bulk exponent follows from simulations of correlation functions with periodic boundary conditions or order parameter profiles with open boundary conditions and with symmetry breaking surface fields. At very low temperatures, η σ ( T ) is found in pretty good agreement with the linear temperature-dependence of Berezinskii's spin-wave approximation. We also show some evidence that there are no noticeable logarithmic corrections to the behaviour of the order parameter density profile at the Kosterlitz–Thouless (KT) transition temperature, while these corrections exist for the correlation function. At the KT transition the value η σ ( T KT ) = 1/4 is accurately recovered. The exponent associated with the surface correlations is similarly obtained after a slight modification of the boundary conditions: the correlation function is computed with free BC, and the profile with mixed fixed–free BC. It exhibits a monotonic behaviour with temperature, starting linearly according to the spin-wave approximation and increasing up to a value η ∥ ( T KT ) ≃ 1/2 at the Kosterlitz–Thouless transition temperature. The thermal exponent η ε ( T ) is also computed and we give some evidence that it keeps a constant value in agreement with the marginality condition of the temperature field below the KT transition.

arXiv:cond-mat/0211584•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jan 8, 2003•24 citations
In spin systems such as the Ising model, the local order and disorder can be characterized by the order-parameter and energy density profiles 〈σ(r_{1})〉 and 〈ε(r_{2})〉, respectively. Does increasing the order at r_{1} always decrease the disorder at r_{2}? Does increasing the disorder at r_{2} always decrease the order at r_{1}? The answer to these questions is contained in the cumulant response function 〈σ(r_{1})ε(r_{2})〉^{(cum)}. This correlation function vanishes in the unbounded bulk but not in systems with fixed-spin boundary conditions. Using the universal operator-product expansion of σ(r_{1})ε(r_{2}) and exact results for the Ising model, we analyze 〈σ(r_{1})ε(r_{2})〉^{(cum)} in two-dimensional critical systems defined on the x-y plane with mixed + and - boundary conditions. Particularly interesting behavior is found when either of the operators σ or ε is located on a "zero line" in the x-y plane, along which 〈σ(r)〉 vanishes. Results for half-plane, triangular, and rectangular geometries are presented.
With conformal-invariance methods, Burkhardt, Guim, and Xue studied the critical Ising model, defined on the upper half plane y>0 with different boundary conditions a and b on the negative and positive x axes. For ab=-+ and f+, they determined the one- and two-point averages of the spin σ and energy ε. Here +,-, and f stand for spin-up, spin-down, and free-spin boundaries, respectively. The case +-+-+⋯, where the boundary condition switches between + and - at arbitrary points, ζ_{1},ζ_{2},⋯ on the x axis was also analyzed. In the first half of this paper a similar study is carried out for the alternating boundary condition +f+f+⋯ and the case -f+ of three different boundary conditions. Exact results for the one- and two-point averages of σ,ε, and the stress tensor T are derived with conformal-invariance methods. From the results for 〈T〉, the critical Casimir interaction with the boundary of a wedge-shaped inclusion is derived for mixed boundary conditions. In the second half of the paper, arbitrary two-dimensional critical systems with mixed boundary conditions are analyzed with boundary-operator expansions. Two distinct types of expansions-away from switching points of the boundary condition and at switching points-are considered. Using the expansions, we express the asymptotic behavior of two-point averages near boundaries in terms of one-point averages. We also consider the strip geometry with mixed boundary conditions and derive the distant-wall corrections to one-point averages near one edge due to the other edge. Finally we confirm the consistency of the predictions obtained with conformal-invariance methods and with boundary-operator expansions, in the the first and second halves of the paper.
Density profiles are investigated arising in a critical Ising model in two dimensions which is confined to a rectangular domain with uniform or mixed boundary conditions and arbitrary aspect ratio. For the cases in which the two vertical sides of the rectangle have up-spin boundary conditions + and the two horizontal sides with either down-spin boundary conditions - or with free-spin boundary conditions f, exact results are presented for the density profiles of the energy and the order parameter which display a surprisingly rich behavior. The new results follow by means of conformal transformations from known results in the half plane with +-+-+ and +f+f+ boundary conditions. The corners with mixed boundary conditions lead to interesting behavior, even in the limit of a half-infinite strip. The behavior near these corners can be described by a "corner-operator-expansion," which is discussed in the second part of the paper. The analytic predictions agree very well with simulations, with no adjustable parameters.
In this paper we review the critical Ising model by using the properties of conformal invariance. We use the known mapping of the Ising model to a theory of Majorana fermions and recognize that the self-duality property appears as a double degeneracy of the periodic ground state. The Ising model is doubled obtaining an Ashkin-Teller model (two Ising models coupled with a four-spin coupling) at the decoupling point. Using the bosonization technique this model is mapped onto the Gaussian model at a particular value of the temperature (K=1/\ensuremath{\pi}). This allows us to give the expressions for products of order, disorder, and energy operators of both Ising models in terms of operators in the Gaussian model. We compute several correlation functions of order, disorder, energy and spinor operators and show that they reproduce the operator product expansions predicted by conformal invariance. We explicitly discuss the physics by which the correlation functions obtained from the Gaussian model (a theory with conformal anomaly c=1) reproduce those of the Ising model (c=1/2). This provides a proof of Kadanoff and Brown's equivalences and conjectures. We provide a simple prescription to compute all n-point correlation functions at criticality, including mixed correlations of order, disorder, energy, and spinor operators. A bosonized form of the continuum limit of the transfer matrix for the critical Ising model is constructed. It is nonlocal and contains both spin-wave and vortex operators of the Gaussian model.
In a previous paper of this series, we studied $\mathfrak{P}(\overline{\ensuremath{\sigma}})$, the probability that the average boundary spin for a half-plane of Ising spins is $\overline{\ensuremath{\sigma}}$. We extend our study of such functions by generalizing the previous derivation to any magnetic system and using them to relate the magnetic behavior at the critical isotherm to the spin-spin correlations at the critical temperature. We also clarify the meaning of the secondary maxima previously found in $\mathfrak{P}(\overline{\ensuremath{\sigma}})$ by a more accurate calculation and by examining the magnetization on interior rows of the half-plane. These considerations show that $\mathfrak{P}(\overline{\ensuremath{\sigma}})$ is more properly to be considered as the sum of two separate spin probability functions. The various ways in which the thermodynamic limit may be taken and the effects that these different limiting procedures have on $\mathfrak{P}(\overline{\ensuremath{\sigma}})$ are discussed in detail. The influence of boundary conditions on spin probability functions is studied by reversing the sign of one column of horizontal bonds. We compute the additional free energy resulting from the misfit bonds and use this to show that $\mathfrak{P}(\overline{\ensuremath{\sigma}})$ is no longer bimodal but is rectangular for $|\overline{\ensuremath{\sigma}}|$ less than the boundary spontaneous magnetization. Finally, we present in graphical form numerical integrations of the boundary magnetization and susceptibility.
A modified two-dimensional Ising model is studied. In this model the nearest-neighbor interactions are changed along an infinite line imbedded in the lattice. We show that the effect of this alteration can be represented by the action of a marginal operator on the critical Ising model. This marginal operator is seen to change the decays of correlation in the lattices near the altered line. We find that the magnetization index $\ensuremath{\beta}$ is changed, while the index $\ensuremath{\nu}$ remains fixed. The expected crossover of the correlation functions to bulk behavior is also observed. We calculate the critical index for the disorder variable and predict the following relation between the index for the order and disorder variables: $\sqrt{2{x}_{\ensuremath{\sigma}}}+\sqrt{2{x}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}}=1$.
Monte Carlo simulations of the two-dimensional XY model are performed in a square geometry with various boundary conditions (BC). Using conformal mappings we deduce the exponent η σ ( T ) of the order parameter correlation function and its surface analogue η ∥ ( T ) as a function of the temperature in the critical (low-temperature) phase of the model. The temperature dependence of both exponents is obtained numerically with a good accuracy up to the Kosterlitz–Thouless transition temperature. The bulk exponent follows from simulations of correlation functions with periodic boundary conditions or order parameter profiles with open boundary conditions and with symmetry breaking surface fields. At very low temperatures, η σ ( T ) is found in pretty good agreement with the linear temperature-dependence of Berezinskii's spin-wave approximation. We also show some evidence that there are no noticeable logarithmic corrections to the behaviour of the order parameter density profile at the Kosterlitz–Thouless (KT) transition temperature, while these corrections exist for the correlation function. At the KT transition the value η σ ( T KT ) = 1/4 is accurately recovered. The exponent associated with the surface correlations is similarly obtained after a slight modification of the boundary conditions: the correlation function is computed with free BC, and the profile with mixed fixed–free BC. It exhibits a monotonic behaviour with temperature, starting linearly according to the spin-wave approximation and increasing up to a value η ∥ ( T KT ) ≃ 1/2 at the Kosterlitz–Thouless transition temperature. The thermal exponent η ε ( T ) is also computed and we give some evidence that it keeps a constant value in agreement with the marginality condition of the temperature field below the KT transition.