Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2510.00804 · Physical Review A

Pre-distillation of magic states via composite schemes

Muhammad Erew, Moshe Goldstein, Yaron Oz, Haim Suchowski

Published May 29, 2026• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Magic state distillation (MSD) is a cornerstone of fault-tolerant quantum computing, enabling non-Clifford gates via state injection into stabilizer circuits. However, the substantial overhead of current MSD protocols remains a major obstacle to scalable implementations. We propose a general framework for pre-distillation, based on composite pulse sequences that suppress systematic errors in the generation of magic states. While most composite designs target simple gates such as X, Z, or Hadamard, our schemes directly implement the non-Clifford T gate with enhanced robustness to the targeted systematic errors. We develop composite sequences tailored to the dominant control imperfections in superconducting, trapped-ion, neutral-atom, and integrated photonic platforms. To quantify improvement in the implementation, we introduce an operationally motivated fidelity measure specifically tailored to the T gate: the T-magic error, which captures the gate's effectiveness in preparing high-fidelity magic states. We further show that the error in the channel arising from the injection of faulty magic states scales linearly with the leading-order error of the states. Within the systematic-error-dominated regimes considered, this approach lowers the number of required distillation levels by up to three across the platforms we study, translating to substantial qubit-overhead savings and offering a practical route toward more resource-efficient universal quantum computation.

DOI
10.1103/ngrr-863r

Related papers

A study of the robustness of magic state distillation against Clifford gate faults

Tomas Jochym-O’Connor

Quantum error correction and fault-tolerance are at the heart of any scalable quantum computation architecture. Developing a set of tools that satisfy the requirements of fault- tolerant schemes is thus of prime importance for future quantum information processing implementations. The Clifford gate set has the desired fault-tolerant properties, preventing bad propagation of errors within encoded qubits, for many quantum error correcting codes, yet does not provide full universal quantum computation. Preparation of magic states can enable universal quantum computation in conjunction with Clifford operations, however preparing magic states experimentally will be imperfect due to implementation errors. Thankfully, there exists a scheme to distill pure magic states from prepared noisy magic states using only operations from the Clifford group and measurement in the Z-basis, such a scheme is called magic state distillation [1]. This work investigates the robustness of magic state distillation to faults in state preparation and the application of the Clifford gates in the protocol. We establish that the distillation scheme is robust to perturbations in the initial state preparation and characterize the set of states in the Bloch sphere that converge to the T-type magic state in different fidelity regimes. Additionally, we show that magic state distillation is robust to low levels of gate noise and that performing the distillation scheme using noisy Clifford gates is a more efficient than using encoded fault-tolerant gates due to the large overhead in fault-tolerant quantum computing architectures.

•Sep 4, 2012•0 citations

Low-Overhead Magic State Distillation with Color Codes

Seok-Hyung Lee, Felix Thomsen, Nicholas Fazio +2 more

Fault-tolerant implementation of non-Clifford gates is a major challenge for achieving universal fault-tolerant quantum computing with quantum error-correcting codes. Magic state distillation is the most well-studied method for this but requires significant resources. Hence, it is crucial to tailor and optimize magic state distillation for specific codes from both logical- and physical-level perspectives. In this work, we perform such optimization for two-dimensional color codes, which are promising due to their higher encoding rates compared to surface codes, transversal implementation of Clifford gates, and efficient lattice surgery. We propose two carefully designed distillation schemes based on the 15-to-1 distillation circuit and lattice surgery, differing in their methods for handling faulty rotations. Our first scheme employs faulty T measurement, achieving infidelities of O ( p 3 ) for physical noise strength p . To achieve lower infidelities, our second scheme integrates distillation with “cultivation” (a distillation-free approach to fault tolerantly prepare magic states through transversal Clifford measurements). Our second scheme achieves significantly lower infidelities (e.g., approximately 2 × 10 − 16 at p = 10 − 3 ), surpassing the capabilities of both cultivation and single-level distillation. Notably, to reach a given target infidelity, our schemes require approximately 2 orders of magnitude fewer resources than the previous best magic-state-distillation schemes for color codes.

arXiv:2409.07707•PRX Quantum•May 30, 2025•31 citations

The robustness of magic state distillation against errors in Clifford gates

Tomas Jochym-O’Connor, Ya-Fei Yu, Bassam Helou +1 more

Quantum error correction and fault-tolerance have provided the possibility for large scale quantum computations without a detrimental loss of quantum information. A very natural class of gates for fault-tolerant quantum computation is the Clifford gate set and as such their usefulness for universal quantum computation is of great interest. Clifford group gates augmented by magic state preparation give the possibility of simulating universal quantum computation. However, experimentally one cannot expect to perfectly prepare magic states. Nonetheless, it has been shown that by repeatedly applying operations from the Clifford group and measurements in the Pauli basis, the fidelity of noisy prepared magic states can be increased arbitrarily close to a pure magic state~\cite{Bravyi}. We investigate the robustness of magic state distillation to perturbations of the initial states to arbitrary locations in the Bloch sphere due to noise. Additionally, we consider a depolarizing noise model on the quantum gates in the decoding section of the distillation protocol and demonstrate its effect on the convergence rate and threshold value. Finally, we establish that faulty magic state distillation is more efficient than fault-tolerance-assisted magic state distillation at low error rates due to the large overhead in the number of quantum gates and qubits required in a fault-tolerance architecture. The ability to perform magic state distillation with noisy gates leads us to conclude that this could be a realistic scheme for future small-scale quantum computing devices as fault-tolerance need only be used in the final steps of the protocol.

arXiv:1205.6715•Quantum Information and Computation•May 1, 2013•25 citations

Zero-level $CCZ$ Distillation

Tomohiro Itogawa, Yutaka Hirano, Yutaro Akahoshi +1 more

Magic state distillation is a key component of fault-tolerant quantum computation, as it enables the implementation of non-Clifford gates such as the $T$ gate and the $CCZ$ gate via gate teleportation. However, conventional distillation protocols require a large number of logical qubits and introduce substantial spatial and temporal overhead, posing a significant bottleneck for scalable fault-tolerant quantum computation. In this work, we propose a zero-level distillation protocol that efficiently generates a high-fidelity logical $CCZ$ magic state using only physical qubits on a two-dimensional square lattice with nearest-neighbor interactions. Our method leverages the transversal $T/T^\dagger$ operation of the $[[ 8,3,2 ]]$ code to fault-tolerantly encode the state $\overline{CCZ}|+++\rangle$, which is subsequently teleported to three surface-code logical qubits via lattice surgery. To enable teleportation between codes with different distances, we introduce adaptively initialized teleportation (AIT), a tailored initialization procedure for the surface code. Numerical simulations demonstrate that the logical error rate scales as $p_L \simeq 300 \times p^2$ with respect to the physical error rate $p$. For example, the proposed method improves the logical error rate by approximately one and two orders of magnitude at $p = 10^{-3}$ and $p = 10^{-4}$, respectively, compared to conventional seven-$T$-gate approaches. The distillation circuit requires only 22 physical qubits, 3 logical qubits, and a circuit depth of 24, reducing the space-time overhead by a factor of approximately 5-10 compared to previous methods. This result highlights the practicality of $CCZ$-state distillation in early fault-tolerant quantum computation and offers a new direction toward resource-efficient physical-level magic state distillation beyond conventional $T$-state generation.

quant-pharXiv:2605.21867•May 22, 2026•1 citation

Efficient Magic State Distillation by Zero-Level Distillation

Tomohiro Itogawa, Yugo Takada, Yutaka Hirano +1 more

Magic state distillation (MSD) is an essential element for universal fault-tolerant quantum computing, which distills a high-fidelity magic state from noisy magic states using ideal (error-corrected) Clifford operations. For ideal Clifford operations, it needs to be performed on the logical qubits and hence incurs a large spatiotemporal overhead, which is one of the major bottlenecks for the realization of fault-tolerant quantum computers (FTQCs). Here we propose zero-level distillation, which prepares a high-fidelity logical magic state at the physical level, namely , using physical qubits and nearest-neighbor two-qubit gates on a square lattice. We develop a zero-level distillation circuit and show that distillation can be made even more efficient than the conventional sophisticated approaches with logical level distillations. The key idea involves the Knill -type distillation using the Steane code and its careful mapping to the square-lattice architecture with error detection. The distilled magic state on the Steane-code state is then teleported or converted to surface codes. We numerically find that the error rate of the logical magic state scales as approximately 100 × p 2 in terms of the physical error rate p . For example, with a physical error rate of p = 10 − 4 ( 10 − 3 ), the logical error rate is reduced to p L = 10 − 6 ( 10 − 4 ), resulting in an improvement of 2 (1) orders of magnitude. This contributes to reducing both space and time overhead for early FTQC as well as full-fledged FTQC combined with conventional multilevel distillation protocols.

arXiv:2403.03991•PRX Quantum•May 22, 2025•63 citations

アヤマリタイセイリョウシケイサンノジツゲンニムケタコウリツテキナマホウジョウタイノセイセイトショウヒ

裕 平野, Yutaka Hirano

Quantum computation promises exponential or polynomial speedups over classical computation for a wide range of problems, including integer factoring, quantum chemistry, and linear-system solving.However, current quantum devices remain too noisy to execute complex algorithms reliably.Overcoming this noise and achieving quantum advantage require a fault-tolerant quantum computer (FTQC).The resource overhead associated with fault-tolerant operation is substantial, and reducing this overhead remains one of the central challenges.A major source of this overhead arises from the implementation of non-Clifford gates, which are essential for universal quantum computation.A non-Clifford gate such as the T gate is implemented using a special quantum state known as a magic state, which is prepared via a process called magic state distillation.Magic state distillation is resource-intensive and remains a major bottleneck in FTQC.Hence, reducing the distillation overhead is necessary to lower the overall FTQC overhead.The large overhead of magic state distillation has significantly influenced FTQC architectures.In particular, it has motivated compilation schemes optimized under the constraint of expensive magic state distillation.While reducing the distillation overhead is crucial, it is not sufficient; lowering the overall FTQC overhead also requires revisiting design choices guided by this constraint.Therefore, efficient methods are required not only for preparing magic states but also for consuming them.In this thesis, we reduce the overhead of fault-tolerant quantum computation by focusing on the preparation and consumption of magic states.In contrast to traditional logical-level distillation, physical-level distillation allows direct implementation with physical gates and has the potential to drastically reduce the distillation overhead.However, existing physical-level distillation protocols, such as zero-level distillation, cannot directly yield high-fidelity magic states.We propose two magic state distillation protocols that use physical-level distillation techniques to efficiently prepare high-fidelity magic states.The first protocol is a two-level distillation protocol using physical-level distillation as the first-level stage.The second protocol utilizes lattice surgery to reduce the spacetime overhead of a physical-level distillation protocol.The former targets a high-fidelity regime, whereas the latter targets an intermediate-fidelity regime-lower than the former, but higher than zero-level distillation.Next, we investigate FTQC architectures that can efficiently consume the magic states prepared by these protocols.Because magic state distillation is probabilistic, occasional failures can delay computation.Moreover, physical-level distillation protocols generally exhibit higher failure probabilities than logical-level ones.This delay is amplified by parallel execution, making it an i ii important consideration for FTQC using physical-level distillation protocols.We therefore propose a scheme to mitigate the negative performance impact caused by magic state distillation failures by introducing a pool of magic states for each distillation factory.The proposed distillation protocols allow the simultaneous preparation of many magic states.Leveraging this capability, we propose an FTQC compilation scheme optimized for highly parallel quantum algorithms.By performing magic state distillation locally and consuming magic states in parallel, the scheme enables highly parallel execution and consequently reduces the computational time overhead.Overall, this thesis presents a unified approach to reducing the overhead of fault-tolerant quantum computation.By improving both the preparation and consumption of magic states, it advances the design of resource-efficient FTQC architectures.These results demonstrate that efficient magic state preparation motivates efficient magic state consumption, and vice versa.Together, they bring us closer to the practical realization of fault-tolerant quantum computers.

•Mar 25, 2026•0 citations
Magic state distillation (MSD) is a cornerstone of fault-tolerant quantum computing, enabling non-Clifford gates via state injection into stabilizer circuits. However, the substantial overhead of current MSD protocols remains a major obstacle to scalable implementations. We propose a general framework for pre-distillation, based on composite pulse sequences that suppress systematic errors in the generation of magic states. While most composite designs target simple gates such as X, Z, or Hadamard, our schemes directly implement the non-Clifford T gate with enhanced robustness to the targeted systematic errors. We develop composite sequences tailored to the dominant control imperfections in superconducting, trapped-ion, neutral-atom, and integrated photonic platforms. To quantify improvement in the implementation, we introduce an operationally motivated fidelity measure specifically tailored to the T gate: the T-magic error, which captures the gate's effectiveness in preparing high-fidelity magic states. We further show that the error in the channel arising from the injection of faulty magic states scales linearly with the leading-order error of the states. Within the systematic-error-dominated regimes considered, this approach lowers the number of required distillation levels by up to three across the platforms we study, translating to substantial qubit-overhead savings and offering a practical route toward more resource-efficient universal quantum computation.
Quantum error correction and fault-tolerance are at the heart of any scalable quantum computation architecture. Developing a set of tools that satisfy the requirements of fault- tolerant schemes is thus of prime importance for future quantum information processing implementations. The Clifford gate set has the desired fault-tolerant properties, preventing bad propagation of errors within encoded qubits, for many quantum error correcting codes, yet does not provide full universal quantum computation. Preparation of magic states can enable universal quantum computation in conjunction with Clifford operations, however preparing magic states experimentally will be imperfect due to implementation errors. Thankfully, there exists a scheme to distill pure magic states from prepared noisy magic states using only operations from the Clifford group and measurement in the Z-basis, such a scheme is called magic state distillation [1]. This work investigates the robustness of magic state distillation to faults in state preparation and the application of the Clifford gates in the protocol. We establish that the distillation scheme is robust to perturbations in the initial state preparation and characterize the set of states in the Bloch sphere that converge to the T-type magic state in different fidelity regimes. Additionally, we show that magic state distillation is robust to low levels of gate noise and that performing the distillation scheme using noisy Clifford gates is a more efficient than using encoded fault-tolerant gates due to the large overhead in fault-tolerant quantum computing architectures.
Fault-tolerant implementation of non-Clifford gates is a major challenge for achieving universal fault-tolerant quantum computing with quantum error-correcting codes. Magic state distillation is the most well-studied method for this but requires significant resources. Hence, it is crucial to tailor and optimize magic state distillation for specific codes from both logical- and physical-level perspectives. In this work, we perform such optimization for two-dimensional color codes, which are promising due to their higher encoding rates compared to surface codes, transversal implementation of Clifford gates, and efficient lattice surgery. We propose two carefully designed distillation schemes based on the 15-to-1 distillation circuit and lattice surgery, differing in their methods for handling faulty rotations. Our first scheme employs faulty T measurement, achieving infidelities of O ( p 3 ) for physical noise strength p . To achieve lower infidelities, our second scheme integrates distillation with “cultivation” (a distillation-free approach to fault tolerantly prepare magic states through transversal Clifford measurements). Our second scheme achieves significantly lower infidelities (e.g., approximately 2 × 10 − 16 at p = 10 − 3 ), surpassing the capabilities of both cultivation and single-level distillation. Notably, to reach a given target infidelity, our schemes require approximately 2 orders of magnitude fewer resources than the previous best magic-state-distillation schemes for color codes.
Quantum error correction and fault-tolerance have provided the possibility for large scale quantum computations without a detrimental loss of quantum information. A very natural class of gates for fault-tolerant quantum computation is the Clifford gate set and as such their usefulness for universal quantum computation is of great interest. Clifford group gates augmented by magic state preparation give the possibility of simulating universal quantum computation. However, experimentally one cannot expect to perfectly prepare magic states. Nonetheless, it has been shown that by repeatedly applying operations from the Clifford group and measurements in the Pauli basis, the fidelity of noisy prepared magic states can be increased arbitrarily close to a pure magic state~\cite{Bravyi}. We investigate the robustness of magic state distillation to perturbations of the initial states to arbitrary locations in the Bloch sphere due to noise. Additionally, we consider a depolarizing noise model on the quantum gates in the decoding section of the distillation protocol and demonstrate its effect on the convergence rate and threshold value. Finally, we establish that faulty magic state distillation is more efficient than fault-tolerance-assisted magic state distillation at low error rates due to the large overhead in the number of quantum gates and qubits required in a fault-tolerance architecture. The ability to perform magic state distillation with noisy gates leads us to conclude that this could be a realistic scheme for future small-scale quantum computing devices as fault-tolerance need only be used in the final steps of the protocol.
Zero-level CCZCCZCCZ Distillation
Magic state distillation is a key component of fault-tolerant quantum computation, as it enables the implementation of non-Clifford gates such as the TTT gate and the CCZCCZCCZ gate via gate teleportation. However, conventional distillation protocols require a large number of logical qubits and introduce substantial spatial and temporal overhead, posing a significant bottleneck for scalable fault-tolerant quantum computation. In this work, we propose a zero-level distillation protocol that efficiently generates a high-fidelity logical CCZCCZCCZ magic state using only physical qubits on a two-dimensional square lattice with nearest-neighbor interactions. Our method leverages the transversal T/T†T/T^\daggerT/T† operation of the [[8,3,2]][[ 8,3,2 ]][[8,3,2]] code to fault-tolerantly encode the state CCZ‾∣+++⟩\overline{CCZ}|+++\rangleCCZ∣+++⟩, which is subsequently teleported to three surface-code logical qubits via lattice surgery. To enable teleportation between codes with different distances, we introduce adaptively initialized teleportation (AIT), a tailored initialization procedure for the surface code. Numerical simulations demonstrate that the logical error rate scales as pL≃300×p2p_L \simeq 300 \times p^2pL​≃300×p2 with respect to the physical error rate ppp. For example, the proposed method improves the logical error rate by approximately one and two orders of magnitude at p=10−3p = 10^{-3}p=10−3 and p=10−4p = 10^{-4}p=10−4, respectively, compared to conventional seven-TTT-gate approaches. The distillation circuit requires only 22 physical qubits, 3 logical qubits, and a circuit depth of 24, reducing the space-time overhead by a factor of approximately 5-10 compared to previous methods. This result highlights the practicality of CCZCCZCCZ-state distillation in early fault-tolerant quantum computation and offers a new direction toward resource-efficient physical-level magic state distillation beyond conventional TTT-state generation.
Magic state distillation (MSD) is an essential element for universal fault-tolerant quantum computing, which distills a high-fidelity magic state from noisy magic states using ideal (error-corrected) Clifford operations. For ideal Clifford operations, it needs to be performed on the logical qubits and hence incurs a large spatiotemporal overhead, which is one of the major bottlenecks for the realization of fault-tolerant quantum computers (FTQCs). Here we propose zero-level distillation, which prepares a high-fidelity logical magic state at the physical level, namely , using physical qubits and nearest-neighbor two-qubit gates on a square lattice. We develop a zero-level distillation circuit and show that distillation can be made even more efficient than the conventional sophisticated approaches with logical level distillations. The key idea involves the Knill -type distillation using the Steane code and its careful mapping to the square-lattice architecture with error detection. The distilled magic state on the Steane-code state is then teleported or converted to surface codes. We numerically find that the error rate of the logical magic state scales as approximately 100 × p 2 in terms of the physical error rate p . For example, with a physical error rate of p = 10 − 4 ( 10 − 3 ), the logical error rate is reduced to p L = 10 − 6 ( 10 − 4 ), resulting in an improvement of 2 (1) orders of magnitude. This contributes to reducing both space and time overhead for early FTQC as well as full-fledged FTQC combined with conventional multilevel distillation protocols.
Quantum computation promises exponential or polynomial speedups over classical computation for a wide range of problems, including integer factoring, quantum chemistry, and linear-system solving.However, current quantum devices remain too noisy to execute complex algorithms reliably.Overcoming this noise and achieving quantum advantage require a fault-tolerant quantum computer (FTQC).The resource overhead associated with fault-tolerant operation is substantial, and reducing this overhead remains one of the central challenges.A major source of this overhead arises from the implementation of non-Clifford gates, which are essential for universal quantum computation.A non-Clifford gate such as the T gate is implemented using a special quantum state known as a magic state, which is prepared via a process called magic state distillation.Magic state distillation is resource-intensive and remains a major bottleneck in FTQC.Hence, reducing the distillation overhead is necessary to lower the overall FTQC overhead.The large overhead of magic state distillation has significantly influenced FTQC architectures.In particular, it has motivated compilation schemes optimized under the constraint of expensive magic state distillation.While reducing the distillation overhead is crucial, it is not sufficient; lowering the overall FTQC overhead also requires revisiting design choices guided by this constraint.Therefore, efficient methods are required not only for preparing magic states but also for consuming them.In this thesis, we reduce the overhead of fault-tolerant quantum computation by focusing on the preparation and consumption of magic states.In contrast to traditional logical-level distillation, physical-level distillation allows direct implementation with physical gates and has the potential to drastically reduce the distillation overhead.However, existing physical-level distillation protocols, such as zero-level distillation, cannot directly yield high-fidelity magic states.We propose two magic state distillation protocols that use physical-level distillation techniques to efficiently prepare high-fidelity magic states.The first protocol is a two-level distillation protocol using physical-level distillation as the first-level stage.The second protocol utilizes lattice surgery to reduce the spacetime overhead of a physical-level distillation protocol.The former targets a high-fidelity regime, whereas the latter targets an intermediate-fidelity regime-lower than the former, but higher than zero-level distillation.Next, we investigate FTQC architectures that can efficiently consume the magic states prepared by these protocols.Because magic state distillation is probabilistic, occasional failures can delay computation.Moreover, physical-level distillation protocols generally exhibit higher failure probabilities than logical-level ones.This delay is amplified by parallel execution, making it an i ii important consideration for FTQC using physical-level distillation protocols.We therefore propose a scheme to mitigate the negative performance impact caused by magic state distillation failures by introducing a pool of magic states for each distillation factory.The proposed distillation protocols allow the simultaneous preparation of many magic states.Leveraging this capability, we propose an FTQC compilation scheme optimized for highly parallel quantum algorithms.By performing magic state distillation locally and consuming magic states in parallel, the scheme enables highly parallel execution and consequently reduces the computational time overhead.Overall, this thesis presents a unified approach to reducing the overhead of fault-tolerant quantum computation.By improving both the preparation and consumption of magic states, it advances the design of resource-efficient FTQC architectures.These results demonstrate that efficient magic state preparation motivates efficient magic state consumption, and vice versa.Together, they bring us closer to the practical realization of fault-tolerant quantum computers.