Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2509.25331 · Physical Review Letters

Krylov Winding and Emergent Coherence in Operator Growth Dynamics

Rishik Perugu, Bryce Kobrin, Michael O. Flynn, Thomas Scaffidi

Published Feb 27, 2026• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The operator wave function provides a fine-grained description of quantum chaos and of the irreversible growth of simple operators into increasingly complex ones. Remarkably, at finite temperature, this wave function can acquire a phase that increases linearly with the operator's size, a phenomenon called size winding. Although size winding occurs naturally in a holographic setting, the emergence of a coherent phase in a scrambled operator remains mysterious from the standpoint of a thermalizing quantum many-body system. In this work, we elucidate this phenomenon by introducing the related concept of Krylov winding, whereby the operator wave function acquires a phase that winds linearly with the Krylov index. We show that Krylov winding is a generic feature of quantum chaotic systems and is a direct consequence of the universal operator growth bound hypothesis. It gives rise to size winding under two additional conditions: (i) a low-rank mapping between the Krylov and size bases, which ensures phase alignment among operators of the same size, and (ii) the saturation of the "chaos-operator growth" bound λ_{L}≤2α (with λ_{L} the Lyapunov exponent and α the growth rate), which ensures a linear phase dependence on size. For systems that do not saturate this bound, with h=λ_{L}/2α<1, the winding with Pauli size ℓ becomes superlinear, behaving as ℓ^{1/h}. We illustrate these results with two classes of microscopic models: the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model and its variants, and a disordered k-local spin model.

DOI
10.1103/bt23-4y1t

Related papers

Dissecting Quantum Many-Body Chaos in the Krylov Space

Liangyu Chen, Baoyuan Mu, Huajia Wang +1 more

The growth of simple operators is essential for the emergence of chaotic dynamics and quantum thermalization. Recent studies have proposed different measures, including the out-of-time-order correlator and Krylov complexity. It is established that the out-of-time-order correlator serves as the signature of quantum many-body chaos, while the Krylov complexity provides its upper bound. However, there exist nonchaotic systems in which Krylov complexity grows exponentially, indicating that the Krylov complexity itself is not a witness of many-body chaos. In this Letter, we introduce the missing ingredient called the Krylov metric K_{mn}, which probes the size of the Krylov basis. We propose that the universal criteria for fast scramblers include (i) the exponential growth of Krylov complexity, (ii) the diagonal elements K_{nn}∼n^{h} with h∈(0,1], and (iii) the negligibility of off-diagonal elements K_{mn} with m≠n. We further show that h=ϰ/2α is a ratio between the quantum Lyapunov exponent ϰ and the Krylov exponent α. This proposal is supported by both generic arguments and explicit examples, including solvable Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev models, Luttinger liquids, and many-body localized systems. Our results provide a refined understanding of how chaotic dynamics emerge from the Krylov space perspective.

arXiv:2404.08207•Physical Review Letters•May 15, 2025•23 citations

Universal chaotic dynamics from Krylov space

Johanna Erdmenger B, Shao-Kai Jian, Zhuo-Yu Xian

Abstract Krylov complexity measures the spread of the wavefunction in the Krylov basis, which is constructed using the Hamiltonian and an initial state. We investigate the evolution of the maximally entangled state in the Krylov basis for both chaotic and non-chaotic systems. For this purpose, we derive an Ehrenfest theorem for the Krylov complexity, which reveals its close relation to the spectrum. Our findings suggest that neither the linear growth nor the saturation of Krylov complexity is necessarily associated with chaos. However, for chaotic systems, we observe a universal rise-slope-ramp-plateau behavior in the transition probability from the initial state to one of the Krylov basis states. Moreover, a long ramp in the transition probability is a signal for spectral rigidity, characterizing quantum chaos. Also, this ramp is directly responsible for the late-time peak of Krylov complexity observed in the literature. On the other hand, for non-chaotic systems, this long ramp is absent. Therefore, our results help to clarify which features of the wave function time evolution in Krylov space characterize chaos. We exemplify this by considering the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model with two-body or four-body interactions.

arXiv:2303.12151•Journal of High Energy Physics•Aug 28, 2023•145 citations

Size winding mechanism beyond maximal chaos

Tian-Gang Zhou, Yingfei Gu, Pengfei Zhang

A bstract The concept of information scrambling elucidates the dispersion of local information in quantum many-body systems, offering insights into various physical phenomena such as wormhole teleportation. This phenomenon has spurred extensive theoretical and experimental investigations. Among these, the size-winding mechanism emerges as a valuable diagnostic tool for optimizing signal detection. In this work, we establish a computational framework for determining the winding size distribution in all-to-all interacting quantum systems, utilizing the scramblon effective theory. We obtain the winding size distribution for the large- q SYK model across the entire time domain, where potential late-time corrections can be crucial for finite- N systems. Notably, we unveil that the manifestation of size winding results from a universal phase factor in the scramblon propagator, highlighting the significance of the Lyapunov exponent. These findings contribute to a sharp and precise connection between operator dynamics and the phenomenon of wormhole teleportation.

arXiv:2401.09524•Journal of High Energy Physics•Nov 7, 2024•7 citations

Dynamical Transition of Operator Size Growth in Quantum Systems Embedded in an Environment

Pengfei Zhang, Zhenhua Yu

In closed generic many-body systems, unitary evolution disperses local quantum information into highly nonlocal objects, resulting in thermalization. Such a process is called information scrambling, whose swiftness is quantified by the operator size growth. However, the impact of couplings to the environment on the process of information scrambling remains unexplored for quantum systems embedded within an environment. Here we predict a dynamical transition in quantum systems with all-to-all interactions accompanied by an environment, which separates two phases. In the dissipative phase, information scrambling halts as the operator size decays with time, while in the scrambling phase, dispersion of information persists, and the operator size grows and saturates to an O(N) value in the long-time limit with N the number of degrees of freedom of the systems. The transition is driven by the competition between the system's intrinsic and environment propelled scramblings and the environment-induced dissipation. Our prediction is derived from a general argument based on epidemiological models and demonstrated analytically via solvable Brownian Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev models. We provide further evidence which suggests that the transition is generic to quantum chaotic systems when coupled to an environment. Our study sheds light on the fundamental behavior of quantum systems in the presence of an environment.

arXiv:2211.03535•Physical Review Letters•Jun 20, 2023•33 citations

Operator Krylov complexity in random matrix theory

Tang Haifeng

Krylov complexity, as a novel measure of operator complexity under Heisenberg evolution, exhibits many interesting universal behaviors and also bounds many other complexity measures. In this work, we study Krylov complexity $\mathcal{K}(t)$ in Random Matrix Theory (RMT). In large $N$ limit: (1) For infinite temperature, we analytically show that the Lanczos coefficient $\{b_n\}$ saturate to constant plateau $\lim\limits_{n\rightarrow\infty}b_n=b$, rendering a linear growing complexity $\mathcal{K}(t)\sim t$, in contrast to the exponential-in-time growth in chaotic local systems in thermodynamic limit. After numerically comparing this plateau value $b$ to a large class of chaotic local quantum systems, we find that up to small fluctuations, it actually bounds the $\{b_n\}$ in chaotic local quantum systems. Therefore we conjecture that in chaotic local quantum systems after scrambling time, the speed of linear growth of Krylov complexity cannot be larger than that in RMT. (2) For low temperature, we analytically show that $b_n$ will first exhibit linear growth with $n$, whose slope saturates the famous chaos bound. After hitting the same plateau $b$, $b_n$ will then remain constant. This indicates $\mathcal{K}(t)\sim e^{2πt/β}$ before scrambling time $t_*\sim O(β\logβ)$, and after that it will grow linearly in time, with the same speed as in infinite temperature. We finally remark on the effect of finite $N$ corrections.

arXiv:2312.17416•Dec 29, 2023•19 citations

Operator growth in open quantum systems: lessons from the dissipative SYK

Budhaditya Bhattacharjee, Xiangyu Cao, Pratik Nandy +1 more

A bstract We study the operator growth in open quantum systems with dephasing dissipation terms, extending the Krylov complexity formalism of [1]. Our results are based on the study of the dissipative q -body Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK q ) model, governed by the Markovian dynamics. We introduce a notion of “operator size concentration” which allows a diagrammatic and combinatorial proof of the asymptotic linear behavior of the two sets of Lanczos coefficients ( a n and b n ) in the large q limit. Our results corroborate with the semi-analytics in finite q in the large N limit, and the numerical Arnoldi iteration in finite q and finite N limit. As a result, Krylov complexity exhibits exponential growth following a saturation at a time that grows logarithmically with the inverse dissipation strength. The growth of complexity is suppressed compared to the closed system results, yet it upper bounds the growth of the normalized out-of-time-ordered correlator (OTOC). We provide a plausible explanation of the results from the dual gravitational side.

arXiv:2212.06180•Journal of High Energy Physics•Mar 8, 2023•133 citations
The operator wave function provides a fine-grained description of quantum chaos and of the irreversible growth of simple operators into increasingly complex ones. Remarkably, at finite temperature, this wave function can acquire a phase that increases linearly with the operator's size, a phenomenon called size winding. Although size winding occurs naturally in a holographic setting, the emergence of a coherent phase in a scrambled operator remains mysterious from the standpoint of a thermalizing quantum many-body system. In this work, we elucidate this phenomenon by introducing the related concept of Krylov winding, whereby the operator wave function acquires a phase that winds linearly with the Krylov index. We show that Krylov winding is a generic feature of quantum chaotic systems and is a direct consequence of the universal operator growth bound hypothesis. It gives rise to size winding under two additional conditions: (i) a low-rank mapping between the Krylov and size bases, which ensures phase alignment among operators of the same size, and (ii) the saturation of the "chaos-operator growth" bound λ_{L}≤2α (with λ_{L} the Lyapunov exponent and α the growth rate), which ensures a linear phase dependence on size. For systems that do not saturate this bound, with h=λ_{L}/2α<1, the winding with Pauli size ℓ becomes superlinear, behaving as ℓ^{1/h}. We illustrate these results with two classes of microscopic models: the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model and its variants, and a disordered k-local spin model.
The growth of simple operators is essential for the emergence of chaotic dynamics and quantum thermalization. Recent studies have proposed different measures, including the out-of-time-order correlator and Krylov complexity. It is established that the out-of-time-order correlator serves as the signature of quantum many-body chaos, while the Krylov complexity provides its upper bound. However, there exist nonchaotic systems in which Krylov complexity grows exponentially, indicating that the Krylov complexity itself is not a witness of many-body chaos. In this Letter, we introduce the missing ingredient called the Krylov metric K_{mn}, which probes the size of the Krylov basis. We propose that the universal criteria for fast scramblers include (i) the exponential growth of Krylov complexity, (ii) the diagonal elements K_{nn}∼n^{h} with h∈(0,1], and (iii) the negligibility of off-diagonal elements K_{mn} with m≠n. We further show that h=ϰ/2α is a ratio between the quantum Lyapunov exponent ϰ and the Krylov exponent α. This proposal is supported by both generic arguments and explicit examples, including solvable Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev models, Luttinger liquids, and many-body localized systems. Our results provide a refined understanding of how chaotic dynamics emerge from the Krylov space perspective.
Abstract Krylov complexity measures the spread of the wavefunction in the Krylov basis, which is constructed using the Hamiltonian and an initial state. We investigate the evolution of the maximally entangled state in the Krylov basis for both chaotic and non-chaotic systems. For this purpose, we derive an Ehrenfest theorem for the Krylov complexity, which reveals its close relation to the spectrum. Our findings suggest that neither the linear growth nor the saturation of Krylov complexity is necessarily associated with chaos. However, for chaotic systems, we observe a universal rise-slope-ramp-plateau behavior in the transition probability from the initial state to one of the Krylov basis states. Moreover, a long ramp in the transition probability is a signal for spectral rigidity, characterizing quantum chaos. Also, this ramp is directly responsible for the late-time peak of Krylov complexity observed in the literature. On the other hand, for non-chaotic systems, this long ramp is absent. Therefore, our results help to clarify which features of the wave function time evolution in Krylov space characterize chaos. We exemplify this by considering the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model with two-body or four-body interactions.
A bstract The concept of information scrambling elucidates the dispersion of local information in quantum many-body systems, offering insights into various physical phenomena such as wormhole teleportation. This phenomenon has spurred extensive theoretical and experimental investigations. Among these, the size-winding mechanism emerges as a valuable diagnostic tool for optimizing signal detection. In this work, we establish a computational framework for determining the winding size distribution in all-to-all interacting quantum systems, utilizing the scramblon effective theory. We obtain the winding size distribution for the large- q SYK model across the entire time domain, where potential late-time corrections can be crucial for finite- N systems. Notably, we unveil that the manifestation of size winding results from a universal phase factor in the scramblon propagator, highlighting the significance of the Lyapunov exponent. These findings contribute to a sharp and precise connection between operator dynamics and the phenomenon of wormhole teleportation.
In closed generic many-body systems, unitary evolution disperses local quantum information into highly nonlocal objects, resulting in thermalization. Such a process is called information scrambling, whose swiftness is quantified by the operator size growth. However, the impact of couplings to the environment on the process of information scrambling remains unexplored for quantum systems embedded within an environment. Here we predict a dynamical transition in quantum systems with all-to-all interactions accompanied by an environment, which separates two phases. In the dissipative phase, information scrambling halts as the operator size decays with time, while in the scrambling phase, dispersion of information persists, and the operator size grows and saturates to an O(N) value in the long-time limit with N the number of degrees of freedom of the systems. The transition is driven by the competition between the system's intrinsic and environment propelled scramblings and the environment-induced dissipation. Our prediction is derived from a general argument based on epidemiological models and demonstrated analytically via solvable Brownian Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev models. We provide further evidence which suggests that the transition is generic to quantum chaotic systems when coupled to an environment. Our study sheds light on the fundamental behavior of quantum systems in the presence of an environment.
Krylov complexity, as a novel measure of operator complexity under Heisenberg evolution, exhibits many interesting universal behaviors and also bounds many other complexity measures. In this work, we study Krylov complexity K(t)\mathcal{K}(t)K(t) in Random Matrix Theory (RMT). In large NNN limit: (1) For infinite temperature, we analytically show that the Lanczos coefficient {bn}\{b_n\}{bn​} saturate to constant plateau lim⁡n→∞bn=b\lim\limits_{n\rightarrow\infty}b_n=bn→∞lim​bn​=b, rendering a linear growing complexity K(t)∼t\mathcal{K}(t)\sim tK(t)∼t, in contrast to the exponential-in-time growth in chaotic local systems in thermodynamic limit. After numerically comparing this plateau value bbb to a large class of chaotic local quantum systems, we find that up to small fluctuations, it actually bounds the {bn}\{b_n\}{bn​} in chaotic local quantum systems. Therefore we conjecture that in chaotic local quantum systems after scrambling time, the speed of linear growth of Krylov complexity cannot be larger than that in RMT. (2) For low temperature, we analytically show that bnb_nbn​ will first exhibit linear growth with nnn, whose slope saturates the famous chaos bound. After hitting the same plateau bbb, bnb_nbn​ will then remain constant. This indicates K(t)∼e2πt/β\mathcal{K}(t)\sim e^{2πt/β}K(t)∼e2πt/β before scrambling time t∗∼O(βlog⁡β)t_*\sim O(β\logβ)t∗​∼O(βlogβ), and after that it will grow linearly in time, with the same speed as in infinite temperature. We finally remark on the effect of finite NNN corrections.
A bstract We study the operator growth in open quantum systems with dephasing dissipation terms, extending the Krylov complexity formalism of [1]. Our results are based on the study of the dissipative q -body Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK q ) model, governed by the Markovian dynamics. We introduce a notion of “operator size concentration” which allows a diagrammatic and combinatorial proof of the asymptotic linear behavior of the two sets of Lanczos coefficients ( a n and b n ) in the large q limit. Our results corroborate with the semi-analytics in finite q in the large N limit, and the numerical Arnoldi iteration in finite q and finite N limit. As a result, Krylov complexity exhibits exponential growth following a saturation at a time that grows logarithmically with the inverse dissipation strength. The growth of complexity is suppressed compared to the closed system results, yet it upper bounds the growth of the normalized out-of-time-ordered correlator (OTOC). We provide a plausible explanation of the results from the dual gravitational side.