Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2509.06086 · Physical Review Applied

From membership-privacy leakage to quantum machine unlearning

Junjian Su, Runze He, Guanghui Li, Su‐Juan Qin, Zhimin He, Haozhen Situ, Fei Gao

Published Mar 23, 2026• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum machine learning (QML) has the potential to achieve quantum advantage for specific tasks by combining quantum computation with classical machine learning (ML). In classical ML, a significant challenge is membership-privacy leakage, whereby an attacker can infer from model outputs whether specific data were used in training. When specific data are required to be withdrawn, removing their influence from the trained model becomes necessary. Machine unlearning (MU) addresses this issue by enabling the model to forget the withdrawn data, thereby preventing membership-privacy leakage. However, this leakage remains underexplored in QML. This raises two research questions: do QML models leak membership privacy about their training data, and can MU methods efficiently mitigate such leakage in QML models? We investigate these questions using two quantum neural network (QNN) architectures, a basic QNN and a hybrid QNN, evaluated in noiseless simulations and cloud quantum device demonstrations. To answer the first question, we analyze how quantum constraints shape membership-privacy leakage in QML and then formalize a realistic gray-box threat model accordingly. Based on this, we design a membership inference attack (MIA) tailored to QNN outputs, and our results provide clear evidence of membership leakage in both QNNs. To answer the second question, we propose a quantum machine unlearning (QMU) framework, comprising three MU mechanisms. Evaluations on two QNN architectures show that QMU removes the influence of the withdrawn data while preserving accuracy for retained data. A comparative analysis further characterizes the three MU mechanisms with respect to data dependence, computational cost, and robustness.

DOI
10.1103/mdfc-pgsl

Related papers

Auditing Hybrid Quantum Machine Unlearning for Membership Attacks

Abhiram Manuguri, Tanish Mittal, Theshani Nuradha Piliththuwasam Gallage

Some machine learning models are known to memorize their training data, exposing them to membership inference at- tacks (MIAs) that infer whether a particular data sample was used during training. Such leakage poses serious privacy risks in sensitive domains such as security and healthcare, where membership alone can reveal protected information about an individual. Machine unlearning has been proposed as a remedy, allowing a model to “forget” withdrawn data with- out retraining from scratch. There is some evidence from re- cent works that quantum architectures such as hybrid quan- tum neural networks (HQNNs) along with unlearning meth- ods may be robust to MIAs. In this work, we audit gradient- ascent-based unlearning in HQNNs to assess how effectively forgetting happens when the model is subjected to a range of membership inference attacks. By training an HQNN that combines classical convolutional pre-processing, amplitude encoding, and a parameterized quantum circuit, and apply- ing class-level unlearning to forget a target class, we evalu- ate the unlearned model against metric-based attacks (loss, confidence, entropy, and modified entropy), and quantum at- tacks constructed from a variational quantum circuit and a quantum support vector machine. Our results show that the apparent success of unlearning is highly metric- and attack- dependent. In particular, fixed-threshold-based metric attacks seem to classify almost all forgotten class samples as non- members after unlearning. However, class-conditional area under the curve (AUC) remains above random guessing and relatively higher compared to the original model, indicating that the membership signal does not completely disappear for both the forgotten and retained classes. We observe a similar behavior with quantum attack models, even though the strength of the attacks is relatively weaker compared to metric-based ones. These findings highlight the importance of evaluating quantum unlearning against a diverse set of attacks and performance measures before concluding that privacy is preserved, and lay a foundation for systematically auditing unlearning methods in quantum machine learning models.

Proceedings of the AAAI Symposium Series•Nov 6, 2026•0 citations

Characterizing Privacy Risks of Quantum Machine Learning with Emergent Quantum-Native Access

Liou Tang, James Joshi, Ashish Kundu

Quantum Machine Learning (QML) has shown rapid advances by utilizing quantum computing for machine learning tasks. Meanwhile, the privacy risks accompanying QML is also starting to be studied, which inherit privacy leakage channels from "classical" ML and also quantum-unique risks. Existing work on privacy-preserving QML largely focuses on a QML-as-a-service scenario, which generally assumes that the QML model owner provides only classical bit outputs to queries, while users (and adversaries) have only classical computing abilities. However, this view is increasingly challenged in a quantum-native world of quantum-capable users/adversaries, which may have access to both quantum computing abilities and access to quantum information output from service providers. In this paper, we aim to bridge this gap by examining membership inference attacks against QML models by demonstrating that increasing quantum access and quantum computing abilities provides provable theoretical privacy leakage and empirical adversarial gain. However, the probabilistic nature of QML introduces a gap between theoretical and empirical adversarial advantage. These results show that existing research on privacy leakage in QML models underestimates privacy leakage in emergent quantum-native access regimes, and we hope to establish a first step in examining potential privacy leakages for QML in the quantum-native world.

quant-pharXiv:2609.05702•Sep 8, 2026•0 citations

Private training in quantum machine learning

Tigran Sedrakyan, Frédéric Grosshans, Elham Kashefi

With the emergence of machine learning (ML) models trained on large datasets containing potentially sensitive data, a major question in AI safety is how to make learning private with respect to the training data. Similar to classical machine learning, quantum machine learning (QML) models are not devoid of privacy vulnerabilities. Differential privacy (DP) is a standard tool for training ML models on sensitive data, but its impact in QML remains poorly understood. In this work we study private training in hybrid variational QML models using a classical private DP-SGD optimizer applied to pipelines with classical inputs and outputs. We analyze the interplay between gradient clipping and calibrated noise addition in DP-SGD, and its impact on optimization and accuracy for noisy and noiseless quantum models. We first explain why quantum noise does not provide a satisfactory replacement for the calibrated noise in DP-SGD for ensuring privacy. We then show how the deterministic bounds on gradient norms for a wide class of quantum models translate into explicit control of the detrimental clipping bias introduced by DP-SGD. Finally, we formulate a numerical comparison protocol under fixed clipping threshold and privacy budget and evaluate it on synthetic and image-classification tasks for equivalent quantum and classical models. Our results suggest that quantum models can retain higher accuracy in private-training regimes where the formal privacy guarantee is ensured by a classical DP-SGD mechanism.

quant-pharXiv:2606.29293•International Conference on Intelligent Data Science Technologies and Applications (IDSTA)•Jun 30, 2026•1 citation

SQU: Sensitivity-Guided Quantum Machine Unlearning for Privacy-Preserving ML

Md Akmol Masud, Zannat Hossain Tamim, MD Musa Kalimullah Ratul +1 more

The Right to Be Forgotten (RTBF), as set out in regulations such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), mandates mechanisms to remove specific data points from trained machine learning models. Machine unlearning is a concept in deep learning that has received significant attention but remains underexplored in Quantum Machine Learning (QML). This paper presents a new model for adaptive data deletion in Variational Quantum Circuits (VQCs), called Sensitivity-Guided Quantum Unlearning (SQU). SQU combines gradient-based sensitivity analysis with a dynamic allocation of privacy budgets and targeted noise injection to eliminate the impact of high-impact samples, then fine-tunes the model on the remaining data. Experiments on three benchmark datasets, Breast Cancer, MNIST, and Fashion-MNIST, indicate that SQU successfully unlearns specified samples without diminishing the model's utility. On the Breast Cancer dataset, SQU matches the accuracy of the gold-standard retrain-from-scratch method (84.4%) while providing a quantifiable and significant privacy benefit, reducing the Membership Inference Attack (MIA) AUC by 0.67%. MNIST and Fashion-MNIST results also indicate that SQU has high utility (97.9% and 79.2%, respectively), consistent with the retraining results. A comparison with a classical neural network ($200 \times$more parameters) further demonstrates that the VQC's compact parameterization enables an exact, complete sensitivity analysis for unlearning — an advantage that is infeasible at the classical scale. In general, SQU provides a computationally efficient, regulatory-compliant solution for privacy-aware QML. Code is available at https://github.com/masud1901/Sensitivity-Guided-Quantum-Machine-Unlearning.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Photonics, Artificial Intelligence & Networking (QPAIN)•Apr 16, 2026•0 citations

Delegated quantum neural networks for encrypted data

W. H. Sun, Yan Chang, Danchen Wang +2 more

Abstract Quantum machine learning is expected to utilize the potential advantages of quantum computing to advance the efficiency of machine learning. However, with the help of quantum cloud servers, ordinary users may confront the threat of privacy leakage of input data and models when performing the training or inference of quantum neural networks (QNNs). To address this problem, we present a new framework that allows the training and inference of delegated QNNs to be performed on encrypted data to protect the privacy of users’ data and models. This framework contains two models that are alternately trained: an encryptor and a predictor. The classical client first trains the encryptor defined by a classical neural network to map plaintext input data to vastly different ciphertext data. The ciphertext data is sent to the quantum cloud server to train the predictor defined by a QNN, which can indirectly predict the labels of plaintext data. With the trained encryptor and predictor, the client can send the encrypted data to the server for prediction and obtain almost equivalent prediction results. The proposed framework is applied to three types of QNN models, each dealing with low-dimensional tabular data, image data, and one-dimensional time series data, respectively. Experimental results show that the privacy protection method based on our framework can protect data and model privacy without degrading the performance of QNNs. The framework does not require users to have quantum capabilities and is suitable for protecting data and model privacy for various QNN models.

Physica Scripta•Mar 29, 2024•2 citations

Towards Robust Quantum Machine Learning

Saeefa Rubaiyet Nowmi, Jesus Lopez, Md Mahmudul Alam Imon +3 more

Quantum Machine Learning (QML) fuses quantum computing with machine learning to address complex tasks with potential speedups over classical methods. While QML models such as variational quantum classifiers (QVC), quantum multilayer perceptron(QMLP) models and quantum convolutional neural networks (QCNN) have demonstrated promise in applications like image recognition and malware classification, they remain vulnerable to adversarial threats. Inspired by the vulnerabilities in classical ML, this work systematically investigates how attacks-ranging from training-time poisoning and inferencetime evasion (e.g., quantum versions of FGSM and PGD) to deployment-time trigger attacks-manifest in quantum circuits. We explore how classical adversarial strategies adapt to quantum models through parameterized encodings, hybrid architectures, and probabilistic outputs. The poster evaluates different quantum classifiers under adversarial settings, comparing their robustness, trainability, and resilience to perturbations. Defense mechanisms such as randomized encoding, engineered noise channels, and quantum adversarial training are analyzed in relation to specific threat types. In addition, we assess how quantum models behave differently than classical counterparts under attack, and how quantum-specific design constraints can either exacerbate or mitigate these effects. Our ultimate goal is to define and construct robust QML systems that are both theoretically sound and practically secure. By synthesizing results across multiple QML architectures and threat models, this work provides actionable insight into the development of resilient quantum classifiers, paving the way toward trustworthy and scalable quantum machine learning.

IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE)•Aug 30, 2025•2 citations
Quantum machine learning (QML) has the potential to achieve quantum advantage for specific tasks by combining quantum computation with classical machine learning (ML). In classical ML, a significant challenge is membership-privacy leakage, whereby an attacker can infer from model outputs whether specific data were used in training. When specific data are required to be withdrawn, removing their influence from the trained model becomes necessary. Machine unlearning (MU) addresses this issue by enabling the model to forget the withdrawn data, thereby preventing membership-privacy leakage. However, this leakage remains underexplored in QML. This raises two research questions: do QML models leak membership privacy about their training data, and can MU methods efficiently mitigate such leakage in QML models? We investigate these questions using two quantum neural network (QNN) architectures, a basic QNN and a hybrid QNN, evaluated in noiseless simulations and cloud quantum device demonstrations. To answer the first question, we analyze how quantum constraints shape membership-privacy leakage in QML and then formalize a realistic gray-box threat model accordingly. Based on this, we design a membership inference attack (MIA) tailored to QNN outputs, and our results provide clear evidence of membership leakage in both QNNs. To answer the second question, we propose a quantum machine unlearning (QMU) framework, comprising three MU mechanisms. Evaluations on two QNN architectures show that QMU removes the influence of the withdrawn data while preserving accuracy for retained data. A comparative analysis further characterizes the three MU mechanisms with respect to data dependence, computational cost, and robustness.
Some machine learning models are known to memorize their training data, exposing them to membership inference at- tacks (MIAs) that infer whether a particular data sample was used during training. Such leakage poses serious privacy risks in sensitive domains such as security and healthcare, where membership alone can reveal protected information about an individual. Machine unlearning has been proposed as a remedy, allowing a model to “forget” withdrawn data with- out retraining from scratch. There is some evidence from re- cent works that quantum architectures such as hybrid quan- tum neural networks (HQNNs) along with unlearning meth- ods may be robust to MIAs. In this work, we audit gradient- ascent-based unlearning in HQNNs to assess how effectively forgetting happens when the model is subjected to a range of membership inference attacks. By training an HQNN that combines classical convolutional pre-processing, amplitude encoding, and a parameterized quantum circuit, and apply- ing class-level unlearning to forget a target class, we evalu- ate the unlearned model against metric-based attacks (loss, confidence, entropy, and modified entropy), and quantum at- tacks constructed from a variational quantum circuit and a quantum support vector machine. Our results show that the apparent success of unlearning is highly metric- and attack- dependent. In particular, fixed-threshold-based metric attacks seem to classify almost all forgotten class samples as non- members after unlearning. However, class-conditional area under the curve (AUC) remains above random guessing and relatively higher compared to the original model, indicating that the membership signal does not completely disappear for both the forgotten and retained classes. We observe a similar behavior with quantum attack models, even though the strength of the attacks is relatively weaker compared to metric-based ones. These findings highlight the importance of evaluating quantum unlearning against a diverse set of attacks and performance measures before concluding that privacy is preserved, and lay a foundation for systematically auditing unlearning methods in quantum machine learning models.
Quantum Machine Learning (QML) has shown rapid advances by utilizing quantum computing for machine learning tasks. Meanwhile, the privacy risks accompanying QML is also starting to be studied, which inherit privacy leakage channels from "classical" ML and also quantum-unique risks. Existing work on privacy-preserving QML largely focuses on a QML-as-a-service scenario, which generally assumes that the QML model owner provides only classical bit outputs to queries, while users (and adversaries) have only classical computing abilities. However, this view is increasingly challenged in a quantum-native world of quantum-capable users/adversaries, which may have access to both quantum computing abilities and access to quantum information output from service providers. In this paper, we aim to bridge this gap by examining membership inference attacks against QML models by demonstrating that increasing quantum access and quantum computing abilities provides provable theoretical privacy leakage and empirical adversarial gain. However, the probabilistic nature of QML introduces a gap between theoretical and empirical adversarial advantage. These results show that existing research on privacy leakage in QML models underestimates privacy leakage in emergent quantum-native access regimes, and we hope to establish a first step in examining potential privacy leakages for QML in the quantum-native world.
With the emergence of machine learning (ML) models trained on large datasets containing potentially sensitive data, a major question in AI safety is how to make learning private with respect to the training data. Similar to classical machine learning, quantum machine learning (QML) models are not devoid of privacy vulnerabilities. Differential privacy (DP) is a standard tool for training ML models on sensitive data, but its impact in QML remains poorly understood. In this work we study private training in hybrid variational QML models using a classical private DP-SGD optimizer applied to pipelines with classical inputs and outputs. We analyze the interplay between gradient clipping and calibrated noise addition in DP-SGD, and its impact on optimization and accuracy for noisy and noiseless quantum models. We first explain why quantum noise does not provide a satisfactory replacement for the calibrated noise in DP-SGD for ensuring privacy. We then show how the deterministic bounds on gradient norms for a wide class of quantum models translate into explicit control of the detrimental clipping bias introduced by DP-SGD. Finally, we formulate a numerical comparison protocol under fixed clipping threshold and privacy budget and evaluate it on synthetic and image-classification tasks for equivalent quantum and classical models. Our results suggest that quantum models can retain higher accuracy in private-training regimes where the formal privacy guarantee is ensured by a classical DP-SGD mechanism.
The Right to Be Forgotten (RTBF), as set out in regulations such as the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), mandates mechanisms to remove specific data points from trained machine learning models. Machine unlearning is a concept in deep learning that has received significant attention but remains underexplored in Quantum Machine Learning (QML). This paper presents a new model for adaptive data deletion in Variational Quantum Circuits (VQCs), called Sensitivity-Guided Quantum Unlearning (SQU). SQU combines gradient-based sensitivity analysis with a dynamic allocation of privacy budgets and targeted noise injection to eliminate the impact of high-impact samples, then fine-tunes the model on the remaining data. Experiments on three benchmark datasets, Breast Cancer, MNIST, and Fashion-MNIST, indicate that SQU successfully unlearns specified samples without diminishing the model's utility. On the Breast Cancer dataset, SQU matches the accuracy of the gold-standard retrain-from-scratch method (84.4%) while providing a quantifiable and significant privacy benefit, reducing the Membership Inference Attack (MIA) AUC by 0.67%. MNIST and Fashion-MNIST results also indicate that SQU has high utility (97.9% and 79.2%, respectively), consistent with the retraining results. A comparison with a classical neural network (200×200 \times200×more parameters) further demonstrates that the VQC's compact parameterization enables an exact, complete sensitivity analysis for unlearning — an advantage that is infeasible at the classical scale. In general, SQU provides a computationally efficient, regulatory-compliant solution for privacy-aware QML. Code is available at https://github.com/masud1901/Sensitivity-Guided-Quantum-Machine-Unlearning.
Abstract Quantum machine learning is expected to utilize the potential advantages of quantum computing to advance the efficiency of machine learning. However, with the help of quantum cloud servers, ordinary users may confront the threat of privacy leakage of input data and models when performing the training or inference of quantum neural networks (QNNs). To address this problem, we present a new framework that allows the training and inference of delegated QNNs to be performed on encrypted data to protect the privacy of users’ data and models. This framework contains two models that are alternately trained: an encryptor and a predictor. The classical client first trains the encryptor defined by a classical neural network to map plaintext input data to vastly different ciphertext data. The ciphertext data is sent to the quantum cloud server to train the predictor defined by a QNN, which can indirectly predict the labels of plaintext data. With the trained encryptor and predictor, the client can send the encrypted data to the server for prediction and obtain almost equivalent prediction results. The proposed framework is applied to three types of QNN models, each dealing with low-dimensional tabular data, image data, and one-dimensional time series data, respectively. Experimental results show that the privacy protection method based on our framework can protect data and model privacy without degrading the performance of QNNs. The framework does not require users to have quantum capabilities and is suitable for protecting data and model privacy for various QNN models.
Quantum Machine Learning (QML) fuses quantum computing with machine learning to address complex tasks with potential speedups over classical methods. While QML models such as variational quantum classifiers (QVC), quantum multilayer perceptron(QMLP) models and quantum convolutional neural networks (QCNN) have demonstrated promise in applications like image recognition and malware classification, they remain vulnerable to adversarial threats. Inspired by the vulnerabilities in classical ML, this work systematically investigates how attacks-ranging from training-time poisoning and inferencetime evasion (e.g., quantum versions of FGSM and PGD) to deployment-time trigger attacks-manifest in quantum circuits. We explore how classical adversarial strategies adapt to quantum models through parameterized encodings, hybrid architectures, and probabilistic outputs. The poster evaluates different quantum classifiers under adversarial settings, comparing their robustness, trainability, and resilience to perturbations. Defense mechanisms such as randomized encoding, engineered noise channels, and quantum adversarial training are analyzed in relation to specific threat types. In addition, we assess how quantum models behave differently than classical counterparts under attack, and how quantum-specific design constraints can either exacerbate or mitigate these effects. Our ultimate goal is to define and construct robust QML systems that are both theoretically sound and practically secure. By synthesizing results across multiple QML architectures and threat models, this work provides actionable insight into the development of resilient quantum classifiers, paving the way toward trustworthy and scalable quantum machine learning.