Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2508.06606 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Classical fracton spin liquid and Hilbert space fragmentation in a 2D spin- 1 / 2 model

Nils Niggemann, Meghadeepa Adhikary, Yannik Schaden, Johannes Reuther

Published Feb 23, 2026• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Classical U(1) fracton spin liquids feature an extensive ground state degeneracy and follow an effective description in terms of a tensor Gauss's law where charges, so-called fractons, have restricted mobility. Here we introduce a simple spin model that realizes such a state by straightforward discretization of the higher-rank gauge theory on a square lattice. The simplicity of this construction offers direct insights into the system's fundamental fractonic properties, such as real-space fracton configurations, height-field representation of the classical ground state manifold as well as properties of local and nonlocal fluctuations within the fracton-free subspace. By sampling classical Ising states from the extensive ground state manifold, we show that the effective tensor Gauss's law remains intact when explicitly enforcing the spin-1/2 length constraint, demonstrating the existence of a classical Ising fracton spin liquid. However, we observe that perturbative quantum effects are insufficient to efficiently tunnel between classical ground states, leading to severe Hilbert space fragmentation which obscures fractonic quantum behavior. Specifically, by simulating the spin-1/2 quantum model with Green's function Monte Carlo as a function of the Rokhsar-Kivelson potential, we find that the system supports either magnetic long-range order or a classical spin liquid. Our findings highlight the crucial role of Hilbert-space fragmentation in fractonic spin systems but also indicate ways to mitigate such effects via increasing the spin magnitude to S = 1 , investigated in a companion paper.

DOI
10.1103/b2q3-mgvf

Related papers

Gapless fracton quantum spin liquid and emergent photons in a 2D spin-1 model

Nils Niggemann, Meghadeepa Adhikary, Yannik Schaden +1 more

Gapless fracton quantum spin liquids are exotic phases of matter described by higher-rank U(1) gauge theories, which host gapped and immobile fracton matter excitations as well as gapless photons. Despite well-known field theories, no spin models beyond purely classical systems have been identified to realize these phases. Using error-controlled Green function Monte Carlo, here we investigate a square lattice spin-1 model that shows precise signatures of a fracton quantum spin liquid without indications of conventional ordering. Specifically, the magnetic response exhibits characteristic patterns of suppressed pinch points that accurately match the prediction of a rank-2 U(1) field theory and reveals the existence of emergent photon excitations in 2+1 spacetime dimensions. Remarkably, this type of fracton quantum spin liquid is not only identified in the system's ground state but also in generic low-energy sectors of a strongly fragmented Hilbert space.

arXiv:2508.06605•Nature Communications•Jul 11, 2026•3 citations

Subdimensional particle structure of higher rank U (1) spin liquid

Michael Pretko

Spin liquids are conventionally described by gauge theories with a vector gauge field. However, there exists a wider class of spin liquids with higher rank tensors as the gauge variable. In this work, we focus on (3+1)-dimensional spin liquids described by U(1) symmetric tensor gauge theories, which have recently been shown to be stable gapless spin liquids. We investigate the particle structure of these tensor gauge theories and find that they have deep connections with the “fracton” models recently discovered by Vijay, Haah, and Fu. Tensor gauge theories have more conservation laws than the simple charge conservation law of rank 1 theories. These conservation laws place severe restrictions on the motion of particles. Particles in some models are fully immobile (fractons), while other models have particles restricted to motion along lower-dimensional subspaces.

•Mar 1, 2017•0 citations

2-form U(1) spin liquids: A classical model and quantum aspects

Kristian Tyn Kai Chung, Michel J. P. Gingras

We introduce a geometrically frustrated classical Ising model, dubbed the “spin-vorticity model,” whose ground-state manifold is a classical spin liquid: a 2-form Coulomb phase. We study the thermodynamics of this model both analytically and numerically, exposing the presence of algebraically decaying correlations and an extensive ground-state entropy, and give a comprehensive account of its ground-state properties and excitations. Each classical ground state may be decomposed into collections of closed two-dimensional membranes, supporting fractionalized string excitations attached to the edges of open membranes. At finite temperature, the model can then be described as a gas of closed strings in a background of fluctuating membranes. The emergent gauge structure of this spin liquid is naturally placed in the language of 2-form electrodynamics, which describes one-dimensional charged strings coupled to a rank-2 antisymmetric gauge field. After establishing the classical spin-vorticity model, we consider perturbing it with quantum exchange interactions, deriving an effective “membrane exchange” model of the quantum dynamics, analogous to ring exchange in quantum spin ice. We demonstrate the existence of a Rokhsar-Kivelson point where the quantum ground state is an equal-weight superposition of all classical ground-state configurations, i.e., a quantum spin liquid. The quantum aspects of this spin liquid are exposed by mapping the membrane exchange model to a strongly coupled frustrated 2-form U(1) lattice gauge theory. We further demonstrate how to quantize the string excitations by coupling a 1-form string field to the 2-form U(1) gauge field, thus mapping a quantum spin model to a 2-form U(1) gauge-Higgs model. We discuss the stability of the gapless deconfined phase of this gauge theory and the possibility of realizing a class of quantum phases of matter: 2-form U(1) quantum spin liquids.

arXiv:2310.17607•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 13, 2025•11 citations

Subdimensional particle structure of higher rank U ( 1 ) spin liquids

Michael Pretko

Quantum spin liquids can be well described in the language of gauge theory. While most theoretical effort has been focused on gauge theories with a familiar vector gauge field, there exists a stable class of quantum spin liquids described by higher-rank tensor gauge fields. Here, the authors focus on a class of stable three-dimensional spin liquids described by symmetric tensor $U$(1) gauge fields. They find that these spin liquids feature an exotic class of excitations that are restricted to motion along lower-dimensional subspaces, a phenomenon seen earlier in fracton models. They show how this subdimensional behavior follows naturally from a set of higher-moment charge conservation laws that place severe restrictions on particle motion. This work opens up an exciting new direction in the field of spin liquids.

arXiv:1604.05329•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 22, 2017•421 citations

Fracton excitations in classical frustrated kagome spin models

Max Hering, Han Yan, Johannes Reuther

Fractons are topological quasiparticles with limited mobility. While there exist a variety of models hosting these excitations, typical fracton systems require rather complicated many-particle interactions. Here, we discuss fracton behavior in the more common physical setting of classical kagome spin models with frustrated two-body interactions only. We investigate systems with different types of elementary spin degrees of freedom (three-state Potts, XY, and Heisenberg spins) which all exhibit characteristic subsystem symmetries and fractonlike excitations. The mobility constraints of isolated fractons and bound fracton pairs in the three-state Potts model are, however, strikingly different compared to the known type-I or type-II fracton models. One may still explain these properties in terms of type-I fracton behavior and construct an effective low-energy tensor gauge theory when considering the system as a two-dimensional cut of a three-dimensional cubic lattice model. Our extensive classical Monte Carlo simulations further indicate a crossover into a low-temperature glassy phase where the system gets trapped in metastable fracton states. Moving on to XY spins, we find that in addition to fractons the system hosts fractional vortex excitations. As a result of the restricted mobility of both types of defects, our classical Monte Carlo simulations do not indicate a Kosterlitz-Thouless transition but again show a crossover into a glassy low-temperature regime. Finally, the energy barriers associated with fractons vanish in the case of Heisenberg spins, such that defect states may continuously decay into a ground state. These decays, however, exhibit a power-law relaxation behavior which leads to slow equilibration dynamics at low temperatures.

arXiv:2012.08167•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 4, 2021•10 citations

Quantum Liquids: Emergent Higher-Rank Gauge Theory and Fractons

Yizhi You

Fractons emerge from many-body systems, featuring subdimensional particles with restricted mobility. These particles have attracted interest for their roles across disciplines, including topological quantum codes, quantum field theory, emergent gravity, and quantum information. They display unique nonequilibrium behaviors such as nonergodicity and glassy dynamics. This review offers a structured overview of fracton phenomena, especially those of gapless fracton liquids, which enable collective modes similar to gauge fluctuations in Maxwell's electromagnetic framework, yet their phenomena are distinguished by a unique conservation law that restricts the mobility of individual charges and monopoles. We delve into the theoretical basis of three-dimensional (3D) fracton liquids, exploring emergent symmetric tensor gauge theories and their properties. We also discuss the material realization of fracton liquids in Yb-based pyrochlore lattices and other synthetic quantum matter platforms.

arXiv:2403.17074•Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics•Sep 17, 2024•10 citations
Classical U(1) fracton spin liquids feature an extensive ground state degeneracy and follow an effective description in terms of a tensor Gauss's law where charges, so-called fractons, have restricted mobility. Here we introduce a simple spin model that realizes such a state by straightforward discretization of the higher-rank gauge theory on a square lattice. The simplicity of this construction offers direct insights into the system's fundamental fractonic properties, such as real-space fracton configurations, height-field representation of the classical ground state manifold as well as properties of local and nonlocal fluctuations within the fracton-free subspace. By sampling classical Ising states from the extensive ground state manifold, we show that the effective tensor Gauss's law remains intact when explicitly enforcing the spin-1/2 length constraint, demonstrating the existence of a classical Ising fracton spin liquid. However, we observe that perturbative quantum effects are insufficient to efficiently tunnel between classical ground states, leading to severe Hilbert space fragmentation which obscures fractonic quantum behavior. Specifically, by simulating the spin-1/2 quantum model with Green's function Monte Carlo as a function of the Rokhsar-Kivelson potential, we find that the system supports either magnetic long-range order or a classical spin liquid. Our findings highlight the crucial role of Hilbert-space fragmentation in fractonic spin systems but also indicate ways to mitigate such effects via increasing the spin magnitude to S = 1 , investigated in a companion paper.
Gapless fracton quantum spin liquids are exotic phases of matter described by higher-rank U(1) gauge theories, which host gapped and immobile fracton matter excitations as well as gapless photons. Despite well-known field theories, no spin models beyond purely classical systems have been identified to realize these phases. Using error-controlled Green function Monte Carlo, here we investigate a square lattice spin-1 model that shows precise signatures of a fracton quantum spin liquid without indications of conventional ordering. Specifically, the magnetic response exhibits characteristic patterns of suppressed pinch points that accurately match the prediction of a rank-2 U(1) field theory and reveals the existence of emergent photon excitations in 2+1 spacetime dimensions. Remarkably, this type of fracton quantum spin liquid is not only identified in the system's ground state but also in generic low-energy sectors of a strongly fragmented Hilbert space.
Spin liquids are conventionally described by gauge theories with a vector gauge field. However, there exists a wider class of spin liquids with higher rank tensors as the gauge variable. In this work, we focus on (3+1)-dimensional spin liquids described by U(1) symmetric tensor gauge theories, which have recently been shown to be stable gapless spin liquids. We investigate the particle structure of these tensor gauge theories and find that they have deep connections with the “fracton” models recently discovered by Vijay, Haah, and Fu. Tensor gauge theories have more conservation laws than the simple charge conservation law of rank 1 theories. These conservation laws place severe restrictions on the motion of particles. Particles in some models are fully immobile (fractons), while other models have particles restricted to motion along lower-dimensional subspaces.
We introduce a geometrically frustrated classical Ising model, dubbed the “spin-vorticity model,” whose ground-state manifold is a classical spin liquid: a 2-form Coulomb phase. We study the thermodynamics of this model both analytically and numerically, exposing the presence of algebraically decaying correlations and an extensive ground-state entropy, and give a comprehensive account of its ground-state properties and excitations. Each classical ground state may be decomposed into collections of closed two-dimensional membranes, supporting fractionalized string excitations attached to the edges of open membranes. At finite temperature, the model can then be described as a gas of closed strings in a background of fluctuating membranes. The emergent gauge structure of this spin liquid is naturally placed in the language of 2-form electrodynamics, which describes one-dimensional charged strings coupled to a rank-2 antisymmetric gauge field. After establishing the classical spin-vorticity model, we consider perturbing it with quantum exchange interactions, deriving an effective “membrane exchange” model of the quantum dynamics, analogous to ring exchange in quantum spin ice. We demonstrate the existence of a Rokhsar-Kivelson point where the quantum ground state is an equal-weight superposition of all classical ground-state configurations, i.e., a quantum spin liquid. The quantum aspects of this spin liquid are exposed by mapping the membrane exchange model to a strongly coupled frustrated 2-form U(1) lattice gauge theory. We further demonstrate how to quantize the string excitations by coupling a 1-form string field to the 2-form U(1) gauge field, thus mapping a quantum spin model to a 2-form U(1) gauge-Higgs model. We discuss the stability of the gapless deconfined phase of this gauge theory and the possibility of realizing a class of quantum phases of matter: 2-form U(1) quantum spin liquids.
Quantum spin liquids can be well described in the language of gauge theory. While most theoretical effort has been focused on gauge theories with a familiar vector gauge field, there exists a stable class of quantum spin liquids described by higher-rank tensor gauge fields. Here, the authors focus on a class of stable three-dimensional spin liquids described by symmetric tensor UUU(1) gauge fields. They find that these spin liquids feature an exotic class of excitations that are restricted to motion along lower-dimensional subspaces, a phenomenon seen earlier in fracton models. They show how this subdimensional behavior follows naturally from a set of higher-moment charge conservation laws that place severe restrictions on particle motion. This work opens up an exciting new direction in the field of spin liquids.
Fractons are topological quasiparticles with limited mobility. While there exist a variety of models hosting these excitations, typical fracton systems require rather complicated many-particle interactions. Here, we discuss fracton behavior in the more common physical setting of classical kagome spin models with frustrated two-body interactions only. We investigate systems with different types of elementary spin degrees of freedom (three-state Potts, XY, and Heisenberg spins) which all exhibit characteristic subsystem symmetries and fractonlike excitations. The mobility constraints of isolated fractons and bound fracton pairs in the three-state Potts model are, however, strikingly different compared to the known type-I or type-II fracton models. One may still explain these properties in terms of type-I fracton behavior and construct an effective low-energy tensor gauge theory when considering the system as a two-dimensional cut of a three-dimensional cubic lattice model. Our extensive classical Monte Carlo simulations further indicate a crossover into a low-temperature glassy phase where the system gets trapped in metastable fracton states. Moving on to XY spins, we find that in addition to fractons the system hosts fractional vortex excitations. As a result of the restricted mobility of both types of defects, our classical Monte Carlo simulations do not indicate a Kosterlitz-Thouless transition but again show a crossover into a glassy low-temperature regime. Finally, the energy barriers associated with fractons vanish in the case of Heisenberg spins, such that defect states may continuously decay into a ground state. These decays, however, exhibit a power-law relaxation behavior which leads to slow equilibration dynamics at low temperatures.
Fractons emerge from many-body systems, featuring subdimensional particles with restricted mobility. These particles have attracted interest for their roles across disciplines, including topological quantum codes, quantum field theory, emergent gravity, and quantum information. They display unique nonequilibrium behaviors such as nonergodicity and glassy dynamics. This review offers a structured overview of fracton phenomena, especially those of gapless fracton liquids, which enable collective modes similar to gauge fluctuations in Maxwell's electromagnetic framework, yet their phenomena are distinguished by a unique conservation law that restricts the mobility of individual charges and monopoles. We delve into the theoretical basis of three-dimensional (3D) fracton liquids, exploring emergent symmetric tensor gauge theories and their properties. We also discuss the material realization of fracton liquids in Yb-based pyrochlore lattices and other synthetic quantum matter platforms.