Quantum heuristics have shown promise in solving various optimization problems, including lattice protein folding. Equally relevant is the inverse problem, protein design, where one seeks sequences that fold to a given target structure. The latter problem is often split into two steps: (i) searching for sequences that minimize the energy in the target structure, and (ii) testing whether the generated sequences fold to the desired structure. Here, we investigate the utility of variational quantum algorithms for the first of these two steps on today’s noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices. We focus on the sequence optimization task, which is less resource-demanding than folding computations. We test the quantum approximate optimization algorithm and variants of it, with problem-informed quantum circuits, as well as the hardware-efficient ansatz, with problem-agnostic quantum circuits. While the former approach, with a careful choice of mixer, yields good results in noiseless simulations (success probability ≥ 0.95 in all instances), its performance drops drastically under noise. With the problem-agnostic circuits, which are more compatible with hardware constraints, improved performance is observed in noisy simulations, compared to their problem-informed counterparts. When running the problem-agnostic circuits on a real quantum device, with parameters taken from simulations, we obtain a significant success probability ( ≥ 0.2 ) in most instances.
Quantum heuristics have shown promise in solving various optimization problems, including lattice protein folding. Equally relevant is the inverse problem, protein design, where one seeks sequences that fold to a given target structure. The latter problem is often split into two steps: (i) searching for sequences that minimize the energy in the target structure, and (ii) testing whether the generated sequences fold to the desired structure. Here, we investigate the utility of variational quantum algorithms for the first of these two steps on today’s noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices. We focus on the sequence optimization task, which is less resource-demanding than folding computations. We test the quantum approximate optimization algorithm and variants of it, with problem-informed quantum circuits, as well as the hardware-efficient ansatz, with problem-agnostic quantum circuits. While the former approach, with a careful choice of mixer, yields good results in noiseless simulations (success probability ≥ 0.95 in all instances), its performance drops drastically under noise. With the problem-agnostic circuits, which are more compatible with hardware constraints, improved performance is observed in noisy simulations, compared to their problem-informed counterparts. When running the problem-agnostic circuits on a real quantum device, with parameters taken from simulations, we obtain a significant success probability ( ≥ 0.2 ) in most instances.
In the convergence of quantum computing and life science, we explore protein structure prediction and design on near-term intermediate-scale quantum devices. We investigate the algorithmic and resource constraints of today’s quantum computers, aiming to assess their potential in solving biologically relevant problems. We describe key variational quantum algorithms, including the problem-informed Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm and the problem-agnostic Hardware-Efficient Ansatz. Additionally, quantum walks are examined. The computationally complex coarse-grained lattice models in protein structure prediction and design are discussed. Quantum algorithms are then applied to these models to address the utility and limitations of today’s quantum computers. The thesis critically evaluates the limitations of quantum methods in comparison to classical approaches, highlighting the trade-offs between resource requirements in today’s quantum devices and the performance of quantum algorithms. Through this interdisciplinary investigation, the work contributes to understanding how quantum algorithms may advance computational biology in today’s quantum computing landscape.
Quantum computing has progressed from a theoretical concept to a practical experimental technology. By processing information according to quantum mechanics rather than classical rules, quantum computers may offer advantages for certain problems. Although a few algorithms have proven speedups, it remains unclear where quantum computers will be practically useful, especially since current devices are noisy, small, and not yet fault tolerant. This thesis explores quantum computing for biophysically motivated combinatorial problems, with a focus on lattice protein models. In these simplified models, a protein is represented as a chain on a discrete lattice. Despite their simplicity, lattice proteins retain important features of real proteins, such as such as the folding of a chain with exponentially many possible shapes to a unique minimum-energy structure and steric constraints.To run lattice protein problems on quantum hardware, they must first be formulated using binary variables and objective functions. The latter typically contain soft constraints needed to ensure physical solutions. In Papers~\I--\II, we developed and extended a coordinate-based mapping for lattice protein folding, enabling D-Wave's hybrid quantum-classical annealer to fold both 2D hydrophobic-polar and 3D Miyazawa-Jernigan lattice proteins. In Paper~\III, we adapted the approach to the gate-based paradigm and showed how quadratic soft constraints could be removed by a mixer developed for the maximum-independent-set problem. Papers~\IV--\V addressed lattice protein design using quantum annealing, quantum approximate optimization algorithm, quantum alternating operator ansatz and hardware-efficient ansatz, while Paper~\VI extended the framework to multi-chain thermodynamics and the reconstruction of densities of states and heat-capacity features.Together, these papers show how folding, design, and multi-chain thermodynamics can be formulated, implemented, and analyzed using present-day quantum and hybrid hardware. A recurring limitation is the treatment of soft constraints. In quantum annealing, their high connectivity leads to error accumulation. On gate-based hardware, they increase circuit depth and sensitivity to noise. At the same time, temporary constraint violations can provide useful freedom during optimization. Further progress will therefore require improved formulations, algorithms and hardware that reduce the cost of enforcing physical solutions while retaining this flexibility.
Accurately predicting protein structures from amino acid sequences remains a fundamental challenge in computational biology, with profound implications for understanding biological functions and enabling structure-based drug discovery. Quantum computing approaches based on coarse-grained lattice models combined with variational algorithms have been proposed as an initial step towards predicting protein structures using quantum computers. In this work, we introduce a more efficient quantum protein structure prediction workflow that bypasses the need for explicit Hamiltonian construction by employing a problem-agnostic ansatz. The ansatz is trained to minimize an energy-based cost function that can be efficiently computed on classical computers, eliminating the need for ancillary qubits and reducing circuit depth compared to previous Hamiltonian-based methods. This enables a more scalable approach for larger proteins and facilitates the inclusion of higher-order interactions, previously hard to achieve in quantum approaches. We validate our method by benchmarking a hardware-efficient ansatz on a large set of proteins with up to 26 amino acids, modeled on the tetrahedral, body-centered cubic, and face-centered cubic lattices, incorporating up to second-nearest-neighbor interactions. We assess the performance on both a noise-free simulator and the ibm_kingston quantum computer using a set of distinct metrics to probe different aspects of the prediction quality. These experiments push the boundaries of quantum methods for protein structure prediction, targeting sequences that are longer than those typically addressed in prior studies. Overall, the results highlight the scalability and versatility of our approach, while also identifying key areas for improvement to inform future algorithm development and hardware advancements.
Identifying minimum-energy structures of lattice proteins is a challenging discrete optimization problem. Quantum approaches such as analog quantum annealing and the gate-based quantum approximate optimization algorithm (QAOA) can address this problem after mapping it to a binary representation, which typically involves introducing penalty terms to enforce valid chain configurations. However, in this and many related problems, the use of quadratic penalty terms can be avoided by restricting the search space to independent sets in a conflict graph and using a QAOA mixer designed for the maximum independent set problem. In this work, we implement and explore this QAOA variant for lattice protein folding. Here, the objective function consists solely of the protein energy together with a simple linear bias term, without quadratic penalties. We validate this approach through classical simulations of the quantum circuits for lattice proteins of lengths N=4 and N=6. To explore larger systems, we further introduce a heuristic iterative local-search scheme, with which we successfully fold lattice proteins with lengths up to N=14 using local subgraphs with at most 26 qubits.
Quantum annealing has shown promise for finding solutions to difficult optimization problems, including protein folding. Recently, we used the D-Wave Advantage quantum annealer to explore the folding problem in a coarse-grained lattice model, the HP model, in which amino acids are classified into two broad groups: hydrophobic (H) and polar (P). Using a set of 22 HP sequences with up to 64 amino acids, we demonstrated the fast and consistent identification of the correct HP model ground states using the D-Wave hybrid quantum-classical solver. An equally relevant biophysical challenge, called the protein design problem, is the inverse of the above, where the task is to predict protein sequences that fold to a given structure. Here, we approach the design problem by a two-step procedure implemented and executed on a D-Wave machine. In the first step, we perform a pure sequence-space search by varying the type of amino acid at each sequence position, and seek sequences which minimize the HP-model energy of the target structure. After mapping this task onto an Ising spin-glass representation, we employ a hybrid quantum-classical solver to deliver energy-optimal sequences for structures with 30–64 amino acids, with a 100% success rate. In the second step, we filter the optimized sequences from the first step according to their ability to fold to the intended structure. In addition, we try solving the sequence optimization problem using only the quantum processing unit (QPU), which confines us to sizes ≤20 , due to exponentially decreasing success rates. To shed light on the pure QPU results, we investigate the effects of control errors caused by an imperfect implementation of the intended Hamiltonian on the QPU, by numerically analyzing the Schrödinger equation. We find that the simulated success rates in the presence of control noise semiquantitatively reproduce the modest pure QPU results for larger chains. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
- A study published in the international journal npj Quantum Information (Nature Portfolio) presents a resource-efficient quantum algorithm framework based on the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) for peptide and protein folding. - By translating protein folding into a tetrahedral lattice model and combining Conditional Value-at-Risk (CVaR) VQE with a classical evolutionary algorithm, the number of required qubits was drastically reduced. - It successfully folded a 7-amino acid neuropeptide using only 9 qubits on actual IBM 20-qubit quantum hardware, demonstrating its practical potential for next-generation drug discovery in the NISQ (Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum) era. [Quantum Biology Society] The protein folding problem, which involves predicting the three-dimensional structure of proteins and peptides from their primary amino acid sequence, plays a central role in various applications such as chemistry, biology, and medicine. However, as the sequence lengthens, the number of possible structures to explore explodes exponentially, making it difficult for classical computers to handle its intrinsic NP-hard complexity. Recently, a new quantum algorithm that can efficiently solve this long-standing challenge even on noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) computers has been developed, drawing the attention of the academic community. The paper titled "Resource-efficient quantum algorithm for protein folding," published in the international journal npj Quantum Information, presents an innovative computing framework for the discovery of next-generation peptide drugs. The research team of Anton Robert and Ivano Tavernelli from IBM Quantum, IBM Research - Zurich in Switzerland successfully led this groundbreaking study. ■ The Meeting of Lattice Models and Qubit Optimization Until now, attempts to introduce quantum computing to protein folding have required an unattainably high number of qubits that current, near-term quantum hardware cannot handle. To solve this, the research team converted protein folding into a tetrahedral lattice model. This model can efficiently depict the growth of a polymer chain while maintaining chemically plausible bond angles. In particular, they adopted a method of adding penalty terms to the Hamiltonian to prevent unphysical amino acid overlaps (e.g., beads occupying the same lattice site). Through this, they succeeded in drastically reducing the number of qubits required for calculation while suppressing the complexity of the algorithm to the level of O(N⁴). ■ Demonstration of Folding on Actual Quantum Hardware This algorithm maximized efficiency by combining CVaR-VQE, a variation of the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE), with a classical Differential Evolution optimizer. Applying this technique, the researchers simulated the folding of the 10-amino acid Angiotensin peptide using only 22 qubits, successfully finding the most stable energy state (native fold). Furthermore, they successfully demonstrated the folding of a 7-amino acid neuropeptide (APRLRFY) using only 9 qubits on IBM's 20-qubit quantum computer hardware. This study is a groundbreaking achievement proving that the protein folding problem, which previously required massive computing resources, can be successfully solved even in a noisy real quantum processor environment. It is expected to bring tremendous innovation to next-generation /de novo/ drug design and disease treatment research utilizing quantum computing in the future.