Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2507.21267 · Physical Review Letters

Anomaly-Free Symmetries with Obstructions to Gauging and Onsiteability

Wilbur E. Shirley, Carolyn Zhang, Wenjie Ji, Michael Levin

Published Jan 20, 2026• 32 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present counterexamples to the lore that symmetries that cannot be gauged or made on site are necessarily anomalous. Specifically, we construct unitary, internal symmetries of two-dimensional lattice models that cannot be consistently coupled to background or dynamical gauge fields or disentangled to a tensor product of on-site operators. These symmetries are nevertheless anomaly-free in the sense that they admit symmetric, gapped Hamiltonians with unique, invertible ground states. We show that symmetries of this kind are characterized by an index [ω]∈H^{2}(G,Q_{+}), where Q_{+} is the multiplicative group of positive rational numbers labeling one-dimensional quantum cellular automata.

DOI
10.1103/zrs1-j2xd

Related papers

Disentangling Anomaly-Free Symmetries of Quantum Spin Chains

Sahand Seifnashri, Wilbur E. Shirley

We clarify the lore that anomaly-free symmetries are either on-site or can be transformed into on-site symmetries. We prove that any finite, internal, anomaly-free symmetry in a 1+1D lattice Hamiltonian system can be disentangled into an on-site symmetry by introducing ancillae and applying conjugation via a finite-depth quantum circuit. We provide an explicit construction of the disentangling circuit using Gauss's law operators and emphasize the necessity of adding ancillae. Our result establishes the converse to a generalized Lieb-Schultz-Mattis theorem by demonstrating that any anomaly-free symmetry admits a trivially gapped Hamiltonian.

arXiv:2503.09717•Physical Review Letters•Jan 15, 2026•32 citations

Anomalies on the Lattice, Homotopy of Quantum Cellular Automata, and a Spectrum of Invertible States

Alexander M. Czajka, Roman Geiko, Ryan Thorngren

We develop a rigorous topological theory of anomalies on the lattice, which are obstructions to gauging global symmetries and the existence of trivial symmetric states. We also construct $Ω$-spectra of a class of invertible states and quantum cellular automata, which allows us to classify both anomalies and symmetry protected topological phases up to blend equivalence.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2512.02105•Dec 3, 2025•23 citations

When Can Higher-Form Symmetries Be Made On Site

Yitao Feng, Yu-An Chen, Po-Shen Hsin +1 more

An internal symmetry in a lattice model is said to be onsiteable if it can be disentangled into an on-site action by introducing ancillas and conjugating with a finite-depth circuit. A standard lore holds that onsiteability is equivalent to being anomaly-free, which is indeed valid for finite 0-form symmetries in (1+1)D. However, for higher-form symmetries, these notions become inequivalent: a symmetry may be on site while still anomalous. In this Letter, we clarify the conditions for onsiteability of higher-form symmetries by proposing an equivalence between onsiteability and the possibility of higher gauging. For a finite 1-form symmetry in (2+1)D, we show that the symmetry is onsiteable if and only if its 't Hooft anomaly satisfies a specific algebraic condition that ensures the symmetry can be 1-gauged. We further demonstrate that onsiteable 1-form symmetry in (2+1)D can always be brought into transversal Pauli operators by ancillas and circuit conjugation. In generic dimensions, we derive necessary conditions for onsiteability using lattice 't Hooft anomaly of higher-form symmetry, and conjecture a general equivalence between onsiteability and possibility of higher gauging on lattices. We also identify new "lattice anomalies" intrinsic to higher-form symmetry of lattice models, obstructing on-site realization of symmetry beyond the possibility of higher gauging in continuum.

arXiv:2510.23701•Physical Review Letters•Apr 27, 2026•16 citations

Fermionic Anomalies of Finite Symmetries on Lattices

Ameya Chavda, Ryohei Kobayashi

We develop a lattice characterization of fermionic 't Hooft anomalies of finite internal symmetries in one and two spatial dimensions, formulated in terms of obstructions to symmetric short-range-entangled (SRE) states. We consider lattice systems formed by tensor product of onsite fermionic and bosonic local degrees of freedom, and finite internal symmetry given by a central extension $\mathbb Z_2^F\to G_f\to G_b$. We extract a hierarchy of fermionic anomaly indices for a given symmetry operator in both (1+1)D and (2+1)D. In (1+1)D, an exact lattice symmetry is characterized by a pair of cohomological data $(n_2,ν_3)$. For $G_f=G_b\times\mathbb Z_2^F$, we further show that a symmetry with trivial lattice anomaly indices $(n_2,ν_3)$ is onsiteable and hence admits a symmetric SRE state, establishing that these indices faithfully detect the lattice anomaly. Comparing with continuum fermionic QFT, we find that exact lattice symmetries do not realize the additional $H^1(BG_b,\mathbb Z_2)$ anomaly layer in continuum QFT. In particular, for $G_b=\mathbb Z_2$, exact lattice symmetries realize only the even $\mathbb Z_4$ subgroup of the continuum $\mathbb Z_8$ classification. In (2+1)D, we identify three successive anomaly layers of cohomological data $(n_2,n_3,ν_4)$. We show that a nontrivial value of any layer obstructs a symmetric SRE state. For $G_f=G_b\times\mathbb Z_2^F$, it also forbids a symmetric invertible state. We also construct a non-onsite $\mathbb Z_4^F$ lattice symmetry in (2+1)D with nontrivial lattice anomaly index that forbids any symmetric invertible states with $c_-\in\mathbb{Z}$, therefore forbids any invertible states compatible with onsite $\mathbb{Z}_4^F$ symmetry. Our results motivate a systematic study of which continuum anomalies admit exact microscopic lattice realizations.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2608.12455•Aug 14, 2026•2 citations

Remarks on invertible phases with non-onsite symmetry

Ryohei Kobayashi, Kansei Inamura, Ken Shiozaki

We study invertible phases protected by non-onsite symmetries carrying nontrivial lattice anomaly indices. While lattice anomalies are usually viewed as obstructions to symmetric short-range-entangled (SRE) states, we show that anomalous lattice symmetries can nevertheless admit invertible phases that are not SRE, and can moreover shift the set of symmetry-compatible invertible phases. In particular, we consider a fermionic $\mathbb Z_4^F$ symmetry in (2+1) dimensions. For an onsite $\mathbb Z_4^F$ symmetry, symmetric invertible phases have integer chiral central charge $c_-\in\mathbb Z$, whereas a non-onsite symmetry with nontrivial lattice anomaly index obstructs all such phases despite having trivial continuum 't Hooft anomaly. We resolve this by constructing an exact exponentially quasi-local $\mathbb Z_4^F$ symmetry of a $p+ip$ superconductor with $c_-=1/2$. We compute its lattice anomaly, and find that the symmetry indeed forbids $c_-\in \mathbb{Z}$ invertible states. The allowed invertible phases are consequently shifted to $c_-\in\mathbb Z+1/2$. By gauging the fermion parity of the $p+ip$ superconductor, one obtains an Ising topological order enriched by a $\mathbb Z_4$ symmetry. We describe the corresponding symmetry structure in terms of a fusion 2-category. We further show that the $p+ip$ state admits an enlarged non-onsite $U(1)^f$ symmetry, providing an analogue of fractional quantum Hall response in an invertible phase. This non-onsite $U(1)^f$ symmetry again forbids Chern insulators carrying $c_-\in\mathbb{Z}$, while being compatible with invertible states with $c_-\in\mathbb{Z}+1/2$. This result motivates a systematic study of new classes of invertible phases and spin liquids enriched by non-onsite symmetries.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2609.12042•Sep 14, 2026•1 citation

Remarks on non-invertible symmetries on a tensor product Hilbert space in 1+1 dimensions

Kansei Inamura

We propose an index of non-invertible symmetry operators in 1+1 dimensions and discuss its relation to the realizability of non-invertible symmetries on the tensor product of finite dimensional on-site Hilbert spaces on the lattice. Our index generalizes the Gross-Nesme-Vogts-Werner index of invertible symmetry operators represented by quantum cellular automata (QCAs). Assuming that all fusion channels of symmetry operators have the same index, we show that the fusion rules of finitely many symmetry operators on a tensor product Hilbert space can agree, up to QCAs, only with those of weakly integral fusion categories. We also discuss an attempt to establish an index theory for non-invertible symmetries within the framework of tensor networks. To this end, we first propose a general class of matrix product operators (MPOs) that describe non-invertible symmetries on a tensor product Hilbert space. These MPOs, which we refer to as topological injective MPOs, include all invertible symmetries, non-anomalous fusion category symmetries, and the Kramers-Wannier symmetries for finite abelian groups. For topological injective MPOs, we construct the defect Hilbert spaces and the corresponding sequential quantum circuit representations. We also show that all fusion channels of topological injective MPOs have the same index if there exist fusion and splitting tensors that satisfy appropriate conditions. The existence of such fusion and splitting tensors has not been proven in general, although we construct them explicitly for all examples of topological injective MPOs listed above.

cond-mat.str-elCross-listedarXiv:2602.12053•SciPost Physics•Feb 13, 2026•11 citations
We present counterexamples to the lore that symmetries that cannot be gauged or made on site are necessarily anomalous. Specifically, we construct unitary, internal symmetries of two-dimensional lattice models that cannot be consistently coupled to background or dynamical gauge fields or disentangled to a tensor product of on-site operators. These symmetries are nevertheless anomaly-free in the sense that they admit symmetric, gapped Hamiltonians with unique, invertible ground states. We show that symmetries of this kind are characterized by an index [ω]∈H^{2}(G,Q_{+}), where Q_{+} is the multiplicative group of positive rational numbers labeling one-dimensional quantum cellular automata.
We clarify the lore that anomaly-free symmetries are either on-site or can be transformed into on-site symmetries. We prove that any finite, internal, anomaly-free symmetry in a 1+1D lattice Hamiltonian system can be disentangled into an on-site symmetry by introducing ancillae and applying conjugation via a finite-depth quantum circuit. We provide an explicit construction of the disentangling circuit using Gauss's law operators and emphasize the necessity of adding ancillae. Our result establishes the converse to a generalized Lieb-Schultz-Mattis theorem by demonstrating that any anomaly-free symmetry admits a trivially gapped Hamiltonian.
We develop a rigorous topological theory of anomalies on the lattice, which are obstructions to gauging global symmetries and the existence of trivial symmetric states. We also construct ΩΩΩ-spectra of a class of invertible states and quantum cellular automata, which allows us to classify both anomalies and symmetry protected topological phases up to blend equivalence.
An internal symmetry in a lattice model is said to be onsiteable if it can be disentangled into an on-site action by introducing ancillas and conjugating with a finite-depth circuit. A standard lore holds that onsiteability is equivalent to being anomaly-free, which is indeed valid for finite 0-form symmetries in (1+1)D. However, for higher-form symmetries, these notions become inequivalent: a symmetry may be on site while still anomalous. In this Letter, we clarify the conditions for onsiteability of higher-form symmetries by proposing an equivalence between onsiteability and the possibility of higher gauging. For a finite 1-form symmetry in (2+1)D, we show that the symmetry is onsiteable if and only if its 't Hooft anomaly satisfies a specific algebraic condition that ensures the symmetry can be 1-gauged. We further demonstrate that onsiteable 1-form symmetry in (2+1)D can always be brought into transversal Pauli operators by ancillas and circuit conjugation. In generic dimensions, we derive necessary conditions for onsiteability using lattice 't Hooft anomaly of higher-form symmetry, and conjecture a general equivalence between onsiteability and possibility of higher gauging on lattices. We also identify new "lattice anomalies" intrinsic to higher-form symmetry of lattice models, obstructing on-site realization of symmetry beyond the possibility of higher gauging in continuum.
We develop a lattice characterization of fermionic 't Hooft anomalies of finite internal symmetries in one and two spatial dimensions, formulated in terms of obstructions to symmetric short-range-entangled (SRE) states. We consider lattice systems formed by tensor product of onsite fermionic and bosonic local degrees of freedom, and finite internal symmetry given by a central extension Z2F→Gf→Gb\mathbb Z_2^F\to G_f\to G_bZ2F​→Gf​→Gb​. We extract a hierarchy of fermionic anomaly indices for a given symmetry operator in both (1+1)D and (2+1)D. In (1+1)D, an exact lattice symmetry is characterized by a pair of cohomological data (n2,ν3)(n_2,ν_3)(n2​,ν3​). For Gf=Gb×Z2FG_f=G_b\times\mathbb Z_2^FGf​=Gb​×Z2F​, we further show that a symmetry with trivial lattice anomaly indices (n2,ν3)(n_2,ν_3)(n2​,ν3​) is onsiteable and hence admits a symmetric SRE state, establishing that these indices faithfully detect the lattice anomaly. Comparing with continuum fermionic QFT, we find that exact lattice symmetries do not realize the additional H1(BGb,Z2)H^1(BG_b,\mathbb Z_2)H1(BGb​,Z2​) anomaly layer in continuum QFT. In particular, for Gb=Z2G_b=\mathbb Z_2Gb​=Z2​, exact lattice symmetries realize only the even Z4\mathbb Z_4Z4​ subgroup of the continuum Z8\mathbb Z_8Z8​ classification. In (2+1)D, we identify three successive anomaly layers of cohomological data (n2,n3,ν4)(n_2,n_3,ν_4)(n2​,n3​,ν4​). We show that a nontrivial value of any layer obstructs a symmetric SRE state. For Gf=Gb×Z2FG_f=G_b\times\mathbb Z_2^FGf​=Gb​×Z2F​, it also forbids a symmetric invertible state. We also construct a non-onsite Z4F\mathbb Z_4^FZ4F​ lattice symmetry in (2+1)D with nontrivial lattice anomaly index that forbids any symmetric invertible states with c−∈Zc_-\in\mathbb{Z}c−​∈Z, therefore forbids any invertible states compatible with onsite Z4F\mathbb{Z}_4^FZ4F​ symmetry. Our results motivate a systematic study of which continuum anomalies admit exact microscopic lattice realizations.
We study invertible phases protected by non-onsite symmetries carrying nontrivial lattice anomaly indices. While lattice anomalies are usually viewed as obstructions to symmetric short-range-entangled (SRE) states, we show that anomalous lattice symmetries can nevertheless admit invertible phases that are not SRE, and can moreover shift the set of symmetry-compatible invertible phases. In particular, we consider a fermionic Z4F\mathbb Z_4^FZ4F​ symmetry in (2+1) dimensions. For an onsite Z4F\mathbb Z_4^FZ4F​ symmetry, symmetric invertible phases have integer chiral central charge c−∈Zc_-\in\mathbb Zc−​∈Z, whereas a non-onsite symmetry with nontrivial lattice anomaly index obstructs all such phases despite having trivial continuum 't Hooft anomaly. We resolve this by constructing an exact exponentially quasi-local Z4F\mathbb Z_4^FZ4F​ symmetry of a p+ipp+ipp+ip superconductor with c−=1/2c_-=1/2c−​=1/2. We compute its lattice anomaly, and find that the symmetry indeed forbids c−∈Zc_-\in \mathbb{Z}c−​∈Z invertible states. The allowed invertible phases are consequently shifted to c−∈Z+1/2c_-\in\mathbb Z+1/2c−​∈Z+1/2. By gauging the fermion parity of the p+ipp+ipp+ip superconductor, one obtains an Ising topological order enriched by a Z4\mathbb Z_4Z4​ symmetry. We describe the corresponding symmetry structure in terms of a fusion 2-category. We further show that the p+ipp+ipp+ip state admits an enlarged non-onsite U(1)fU(1)^fU(1)f symmetry, providing an analogue of fractional quantum Hall response in an invertible phase. This non-onsite U(1)fU(1)^fU(1)f symmetry again forbids Chern insulators carrying c−∈Zc_-\in\mathbb{Z}c−​∈Z, while being compatible with invertible states with c−∈Z+1/2c_-\in\mathbb{Z}+1/2c−​∈Z+1/2. This result motivates a systematic study of new classes of invertible phases and spin liquids enriched by non-onsite symmetries.
We propose an index of non-invertible symmetry operators in 1+1 dimensions and discuss its relation to the realizability of non-invertible symmetries on the tensor product of finite dimensional on-site Hilbert spaces on the lattice. Our index generalizes the Gross-Nesme-Vogts-Werner index of invertible symmetry operators represented by quantum cellular automata (QCAs). Assuming that all fusion channels of symmetry operators have the same index, we show that the fusion rules of finitely many symmetry operators on a tensor product Hilbert space can agree, up to QCAs, only with those of weakly integral fusion categories. We also discuss an attempt to establish an index theory for non-invertible symmetries within the framework of tensor networks. To this end, we first propose a general class of matrix product operators (MPOs) that describe non-invertible symmetries on a tensor product Hilbert space. These MPOs, which we refer to as topological injective MPOs, include all invertible symmetries, non-anomalous fusion category symmetries, and the Kramers-Wannier symmetries for finite abelian groups. For topological injective MPOs, we construct the defect Hilbert spaces and the corresponding sequential quantum circuit representations. We also show that all fusion channels of topological injective MPOs have the same index if there exist fusion and splitting tensors that satisfy appropriate conditions. The existence of such fusion and splitting tensors has not been proven in general, although we construct them explicitly for all examples of topological injective MPOs listed above.