Controversy surrounding the "tunnelling time problem" stems from the seeming inability of quantum mechanics to provide, in the usual way, a definition of the duration a particle is supposed to spend in a given region of space. For this reason, the problem is often approached from an "operational" angle. One such approach uses the position of the transmitted wave packet in order to infer the duration the particle spends in the barrier. Here we replace the barrier with a tuneable Mach-Zehnder interferometer (MZI). With this analogy one is able, at least in principle, to achieve any advance or delay of the wave packet sent to the chosen outgoing port. The Uncertainty Principle prevents one from combining the durations spent in each arm of the MZI into a meaningful duration when both arms are engaged. There is no justification for invoking "superluminal" or "negative" times, since the particle is able to arrive at the same position (and with a higher probability) if the same initial state propagates through only one arm of the MZI. The same is true in the case of tunnelling, where the transmitted wave packet results from destructive interference between delayed multiple copies of the free state.
A controversy surrounding the "tunnelling time problem" stems from the seeming inability of quantum mechanics to provide, in the usual way, a definition of the duration a particle is supposed to spend in a given region of space. For this reason, the problem is often approached from an "operational" angle. Typically, one tries to mimic, in a quantum case, an experiment which yields the desired result for a classical particle. One such approach is based on the use of a Larmor clock. We show that the difficulty with applying a non-perturbing Larmor clock in order to "time" a classically forbidden transition arises from the quantum Uncertainty Principle. We also demonstrate that for this reason a Larmor time (in fact, any Larmor time) cannot be interpreted as a physical time interval. We provide a theoretical description of the quantities measured by the clock.
A new variant of the packet analysis to solve the tunneling time problem for the so-called completed elastic scattering (a potential barrier of an arbitrary form is located in the finite spatial interval) is presented. In particular, we propose an explanation of the "paradoxes" of wave packet tunneling, and elaborate a rule enabling one to extract the tunneling times for a particle from the analysis of tunneling the corresponding wave packet. It is shown that the quantum ensembles of transmitted and reflected particles are statistically independent not only after the scattering but also before this event. We find the corresponding counterparts for the transmitted and reflected packets, which describe separately both scattering channels at early times, and define the expectation values of delay times for each channel. Besides, to describe jointly all particles at the stage when they cannot be divided into two independent subensembles, we find the scattering time taking into account broadening the packets. We derive the condition to be satisfied for the completed scattering. The times above are defined in terms of the well-known quantum-mechanical averages for the position and wave-number operators.
Abstract Modern atto-second experiments seek to provide an insight into a long standing question: “how much time does a tunnelling particle spend in the barrier?” Traditionally, quantum theory relates this duration to the delay with which the particle emerges from the barrier. The link between these two times is self-evident in classical mechanics, but may or may not exist in the quantum case. Here we show that it does not, and give a detailed explanation why. The tunnelling process does not lend itself to classical analogies, and its duration cannot, in general, be guessed by observing the behaviour of the transmitted particle.
The wave-packet simulation (WPS) method for calculating the time a tunneling particle spends inside a one-dimensional potential barrier is reexamined using the Feynman path-integral technique. Following earlier work by Sokolovski and Baskin [Phys. Rev. A 36, 4604 (1987)], the tunneling (or traversal) time
tpackT is defined as a matrix element of a classical nonlocal functional between two states that represent the initial and transmitted wave packets. These states do not lie on the same orbit in Hilbert space; as a result,
tpackT is complex-valued. It is shown that Re
tpackT reduces to the standard WPS result,
tphaseT, for conditions similar to those employed in the conventional WPS analysis. Similarly, Im
tpackT is shown to contain information about the energy dependence of the transmission probability. Under semiclassical conditions, Im
tpackT reduces to the well-known Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin expression for the tunneling time. It is shown there are different definitions for the traversal time of a classical moving object, whose size is comparable to the width of the region of interest. In the quantum case, these different definitions correspond to different ways of analyzing the WPS experiment. The path-integral approach demonstrates that the tunneling-time problem is one of understanding the physical significance of complex-valued off-orbit matrix elements of an operator or functional. The physical content of complex-valued tunneling times is discussed. It is emphasized that the use of complex tunneling times includes real-time approaches as a special case. Nevertheless, there is a limitation in the description of tunneling experiments using tunneling times, whether real or complex. The path-integral approach does not supply a universal traversal time, analogous to a classical time, that can be used in quantum situations. It is demonstrated that the often expressed hope of finding a well-defined and universal real tunneling time is erroneous.
We develop a new variant of the wave-packet analysis and solve the tunneling time problem for one particle. Our approach suggests an individual asymptotic description of the quantum subensembles of transmitted and reflected particles both at the final and initial stage of tunneling. We find the initial states of both subensembles, which are non-orthogonal. The latter reflects ultimately the fact that at the initial stage of tunneling it is impossible to predict whether a particle will be transmitted through or reflected off the barrier. At the same time, in this case, one can say about the to-be-transmitted and to-be-reflected subensembles of particles. We show that before the interaction of the incident packet with the barrier both the number of particles and the expectation value of the particle's momentum are constant for each subensemble. Besides, these asymptotic quantities coincide with those of the corresponding scattered subensemble. On the basis of this formalism we define individual delay times for both scattering channels. Taking into account the spreading of wave packets, we define the low bound of the scattering time to describe the whole quantum ensemble of particles. All three characteristic times are derived in terms of the expectation values of the position and momentum operators. The condition which must be fulfilled for completed scattering events is derived. We propose also the scheme of a {\it gedanken} experiment that allows one to verify our approach.
One of the controversial issues of modern quantum theory is the question of tunneling time, i.e. the time that takes a particle to move from one side of the barrier to the other side. We can classify the problems related to the tunneling time into two groups: (1) – In the first group we have a well-defined formulation and an unambiguous way of measuring the time that is related to the motion under the barrier. among these are the following examples: (a) – Oscillations of a wave packet in a double-well potential such as the period of motion in a NH 3 molecule, Sec. 25.5. (b) – Lifetime of a particle or system of particles trapped behind a barrier, and by tunneling can escape to infinity, e.g. α-decay. (c) – A lesser known, but the case of reection time which allows for an exact quantum-mechanical formulation, and will be discussed later in this chapter.