Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2507.15949 · Journal of High Energy Physics

Colliders are not testing locality via Bell’s inequality nor providing an unconditional proof of entanglement

Steven Adam Abel, Herbi K. Dreiner, Rhitaja Sengupta, Lorenzo Ubaldi

Published Aug 7, 2026• 29 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A bstract Recently there has been an increased interest in possible tests of locality via Bell’s inequalities, as well as separately tests of entanglement at colliders, in particular at the LHC. These have involved various physical processes, such as $$ t\overline{t} $$ t t ¯ , or τ + τ − production, or the decay of a Higgs boson to two vector bosons H → VV ∗ . We argue that none of these proposals constitute a test of locality via Bell’s inequality or promise unconditional observational evidence of entanglement. In all cases what is measured are the momenta of the final state particles. Using the construction proposed by Kasday (1971) in a different context, and adapted to collider scenarios by Abel, Dittmar, and Dreiner (1992), it is straightforward to construct a local hidden variable theory (LHVT) which exactly reproduces the data. This construction is only possible as the final state momenta all commute. We show that this LHVT satisfies Bell’s inequality or the related CHSH inequality as appropriate for all the proposed LHC collider tests in the literature. Thus a test of locality via Bell’s inequality is not possible at colliders. The LHVT is also by construction local, i.e. all correlations are separable. Thus an unconditional proof of entanglement is also inherently not possible at colliders. It can only be shown that the entanglement within the Standard Model consistently describes the data.

DOI
10.1007/jhep08(2026)067

Related papers

Bell's Inequality and τττ-Physics at LEP

Herbert Karl Dreiner

In this talk given at the TAU92 Workshop, Columbus, OH, Sept. 92, we summarize results presented in more detail in a recent paper by S. Abel, M. Dittmar and the author where we gave a general proof that Bell's inequality can not be tested at a collider experiment. In particular, a measurement of correlated tau-spins at LEP does not constitute a test of local realistic theories via Bell's inequality. The central point of the argument is that such tests, where the spins of two particles are inferred from a scattering distribution, can always be described by a local hidden variable theory. In response to questions at the workshop we go beyond the paper and show that an old experiment involving the measurement of the correlated spins of the two photons emitted in positronium decay via Compton-scattering is also not a viable test of Bell's inequality.

arXiv:hep-ph/9211203•Nov 2, 1992•17 citations

A critical appraisal of tests of locality and of entanglement versus non-entanglement at colliders

Philip Bechtle, Cedric Breuning, Herbi K. Dreiner +1 more

It has been argued more than 30 years ago that it is not possible to test locality at colliders, due to the inability to directly measure non-commutating observables such as spin components in current collider experiments. Recently, there has been a lot of phenomenological and experimental activity around testing locality via Bell-type experiments or entanglement versus non-entanglement in a collider environment. These results seem to evade the earlier no-go theorem by indirectly measuring spin correlations via their relation to angular correlations between momenta. We perform a careful study of the feasibility of such an approach. We scrutinize the relationship between spin and angular correlations in both quantum mechanics and local hidden variable theories. Our conclusion is that it is currently not possible to perform a logically coherent set of experimental measurements at colliders that would allow one to test locality or entanglement versus non-entanglement. This reaffirms the earlier no-go theorem. We stress that the no-go theorem does not apply to measurements of observables inspired from entanglement and Quantum Information Theory to test the Standard Model of particle physics.

arXiv:2507.15947•Jul 21, 2025•28 citations

Test of local realism via entangled $$\Lambda \bar{\Lambda }$$ system

M. Ablikim, Mikhail N. Achasov, P. Adlarson +97 more

The non-locality of quantum correlations is a fundamental feature of quantum theory. The Bell inequality serves as a benchmark for distinguishing between predictions made by quantum theory and local hidden variable theory (LHVT). Recent advancements in photon-entanglement experiments have addressed potential loopholes and have observed significant violations of variants of Bell inequality. However, examples of Bell inequalities violation in high energy physics are scarce. In this study, we utilize (10.087 ± 0.044) × 109 J/ψ events collected with the BES-III detector at the BEPCII collider, performing non-local correlation tests using the entangled hyperon pairs. The massive-entangled $$\Lambda \bar{\Lambda }$$ systems are formed and decay through strong and weak interactions, respectively. Through measurements of the angular distribution of $$p\bar{p}$$ in J/ψ → γηc and subsequent $${\eta }_{c}\to \Lambda (p{\pi }^{-})\bar{\Lambda }(\bar{p}{\pi }^{+})$$ cascade decays, a significant violation of LHVT predictions is observed. The exclusion of LHVT is found to be statistically significant at a level exceeding 5.2σ in the testing of three Bell-like inequalities. While Bell inequalities have been violated several times—mostly in photonic systems—their violations within particle physics experiments are less explored. Here, the BESIII Collaboration showcases Bell-violating nonlocal correlations between entangled hyperon pairs.

arXiv:2505.14988•Nature Communications•May 28, 2025•28 citations

Quantum entanglement and Bell inequality violation at colliders

Alan J. Barr, Marco E. Fabbrichesi, Roberto Floreanini B +2 more

The study of entanglement in particle physics has been gathering pace in the past few years. It is a new field that is providing important results about the possibility of detecting entanglement and testing Bell inequality at colliders for final states as diverse as top-quark, τ-lepton pairs and Λ-baryons, massive gauge bosons and vector mesons. In this review, after presenting definitions, tools and basic results that are necessary for understanding these developments, we summarize the main findings—as published by the beginning of year 2024—including analyses of experimental data in B meson decays and top-quark pair production. We include a detailed discussion of the results for both qubit and qutrits systems, that is, final states containing spin one-half and spin one particles. Entanglement has also been proposed as a new tool to constrain new particles and fields beyond the Standard Model and we introduce the reader to this promising feature as well.

arXiv:2402.07972•Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics•Jul 18, 2024•159 citations

Understanding Bell locality tests at colliders

J. A. Aguilar-Saavedra, J. A. Casas, J. M. Moreno

For decades, it has been known that local hidden variable theories cannot be disproved by collider experiments involving decaying particles. However, if these theories satisfy a small set of mild assumptions, they become testable. In particular, they can be disproved using Bell-like inequalities for $μ^+ μ^-$ and $τ^+ τ^-$ pairs.

hep-phCross-listedarXiv:2603.19389•The European Physical Journal C•Mar 23, 2026•5 citations

Can Bell inequalities be tested via scattering cross-section at colliders ?

Song Li, Wei Shen, Jin Min Yang

Abstract In current studies for testing Bell inequalities at colliders, the reconstruction of spin correlations from scattering cross-sections relies on the bilinear form of the spin correlations, but not all local hidden variable models (LHVMs) have such a property. To demonstrate that a general LHVM cannot be rule out via scattering cross-section data, we propose a specific LHVM, which can exactly duplicate the same scattering cross-section for particle production and decay as the standard quantum theory, making it indistinguishable at colliders in principle. Despite of this, we find that reconstructing spin correlations through scattering cross-sections can still exclude a broad class of LHVMs, e.g., those models employing classical spin correlations as a surrogate for quantum spin correlations.

arXiv:2401.01162•The European Physical Journal C•Nov 21, 2024•26 citations
A bstract Recently there has been an increased interest in possible tests of locality via Bell’s inequalities, as well as separately tests of entanglement at colliders, in particular at the LHC. These have involved various physical processes, such as tt‾t\overline{t}tt t t ¯ , or τ + τ − production, or the decay of a Higgs boson to two vector bosons H → VV ∗ . We argue that none of these proposals constitute a test of locality via Bell’s inequality or promise unconditional observational evidence of entanglement. In all cases what is measured are the momenta of the final state particles. Using the construction proposed by Kasday (1971) in a different context, and adapted to collider scenarios by Abel, Dittmar, and Dreiner (1992), it is straightforward to construct a local hidden variable theory (LHVT) which exactly reproduces the data. This construction is only possible as the final state momenta all commute. We show that this LHVT satisfies Bell’s inequality or the related CHSH inequality as appropriate for all the proposed LHC collider tests in the literature. Thus a test of locality via Bell’s inequality is not possible at colliders. The LHVT is also by construction local, i.e. all correlations are separable. Thus an unconditional proof of entanglement is also inherently not possible at colliders. It can only be shown that the entanglement within the Standard Model consistently describes the data.
In this talk given at the TAU92 Workshop, Columbus, OH, Sept. 92, we summarize results presented in more detail in a recent paper by S. Abel, M. Dittmar and the author where we gave a general proof that Bell's inequality can not be tested at a collider experiment. In particular, a measurement of correlated tau-spins at LEP does not constitute a test of local realistic theories via Bell's inequality. The central point of the argument is that such tests, where the spins of two particles are inferred from a scattering distribution, can always be described by a local hidden variable theory. In response to questions at the workshop we go beyond the paper and show that an old experiment involving the measurement of the correlated spins of the two photons emitted in positronium decay via Compton-scattering is also not a viable test of Bell's inequality.
It has been argued more than 30 years ago that it is not possible to test locality at colliders, due to the inability to directly measure non-commutating observables such as spin components in current collider experiments. Recently, there has been a lot of phenomenological and experimental activity around testing locality via Bell-type experiments or entanglement versus non-entanglement in a collider environment. These results seem to evade the earlier no-go theorem by indirectly measuring spin correlations via their relation to angular correlations between momenta. We perform a careful study of the feasibility of such an approach. We scrutinize the relationship between spin and angular correlations in both quantum mechanics and local hidden variable theories. Our conclusion is that it is currently not possible to perform a logically coherent set of experimental measurements at colliders that would allow one to test locality or entanglement versus non-entanglement. This reaffirms the earlier no-go theorem. We stress that the no-go theorem does not apply to measurements of observables inspired from entanglement and Quantum Information Theory to test the Standard Model of particle physics.
Test of local realism via entangled ΛΛˉ\Lambda \bar{\Lambda }ΛΛˉ system
The non-locality of quantum correlations is a fundamental feature of quantum theory. The Bell inequality serves as a benchmark for distinguishing between predictions made by quantum theory and local hidden variable theory (LHVT). Recent advancements in photon-entanglement experiments have addressed potential loopholes and have observed significant violations of variants of Bell inequality. However, examples of Bell inequalities violation in high energy physics are scarce. In this study, we utilize (10.087 ± 0.044) × 109 J/ψ events collected with the BES-III detector at the BEPCII collider, performing non-local correlation tests using the entangled hyperon pairs. The massive-entangled ΛΛˉ\Lambda \bar{\Lambda }ΛΛˉ systems are formed and decay through strong and weak interactions, respectively. Through measurements of the angular distribution of ppˉp\bar{p}ppˉ​ in J/ψ → γηc and subsequent ηc→Λ(pπ−)Λˉ(pˉπ+){\eta }_{c}\to \Lambda (p{\pi }^{-})\bar{\Lambda }(\bar{p}{\pi }^{+})ηc​→Λ(pπ−)Λˉ(pˉ​π+) cascade decays, a significant violation of LHVT predictions is observed. The exclusion of LHVT is found to be statistically significant at a level exceeding 5.2σ in the testing of three Bell-like inequalities. While Bell inequalities have been violated several times—mostly in photonic systems—their violations within particle physics experiments are less explored. Here, the BESIII Collaboration showcases Bell-violating nonlocal correlations between entangled hyperon pairs.
The study of entanglement in particle physics has been gathering pace in the past few years. It is a new field that is providing important results about the possibility of detecting entanglement and testing Bell inequality at colliders for final states as diverse as top-quark, τ-lepton pairs and Λ-baryons, massive gauge bosons and vector mesons. In this review, after presenting definitions, tools and basic results that are necessary for understanding these developments, we summarize the main findings—as published by the beginning of year 2024—including analyses of experimental data in B meson decays and top-quark pair production. We include a detailed discussion of the results for both qubit and qutrits systems, that is, final states containing spin one-half and spin one particles. Entanglement has also been proposed as a new tool to constrain new particles and fields beyond the Standard Model and we introduce the reader to this promising feature as well.
For decades, it has been known that local hidden variable theories cannot be disproved by collider experiments involving decaying particles. However, if these theories satisfy a small set of mild assumptions, they become testable. In particular, they can be disproved using Bell-like inequalities for μ+μ−μ^+ μ^-μ+μ− and τ+τ−τ^+ τ^-τ+τ− pairs.
Abstract In current studies for testing Bell inequalities at colliders, the reconstruction of spin correlations from scattering cross-sections relies on the bilinear form of the spin correlations, but not all local hidden variable models (LHVMs) have such a property. To demonstrate that a general LHVM cannot be rule out via scattering cross-section data, we propose a specific LHVM, which can exactly duplicate the same scattering cross-section for particle production and decay as the standard quantum theory, making it indistinguishable at colliders in principle. Despite of this, we find that reconstructing spin correlations through scattering cross-sections can still exclude a broad class of LHVMs, e.g., those models employing classical spin correlations as a surrogate for quantum spin correlations.