Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2507.06711 · Physical Review A

Two variations of quantum phase estimation for reducing circuit error rates: Application to the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd algorithm

Yonghae Lee, Minjin Choi, Youngho Min, Eunok Bae, Sunghyun Bae

Published Nov 19, 2025• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce two variations of the quantum phase estimation algorithm: quantum shifted phase estimation and quantum punctured phase estimation. The shifted method employs a bit-string left shift to discard the most significant bit and focus on lower-order phase components, and the punctured method removes qubits corresponding to known phase bits, thereby streamlining the circuit. To demonstrate the effectiveness of the two variations, we integrate them into a hybrid quantum-classical implementation of the Harrow--Hassidim--Lloyd algorithm for solving linear systems. The hybrid method leverages both quantum and classical processors to identify and remove unnecessary qubits and gates. As a result, for small-scale linear systems, our method reduces qubit and gate counts relative to previous implementations, yielding lower overall circuit error rates on current hardware. Experimental demonstrations on IBM superconducting hardware confirm the error-mitigation effectiveness on small problem instances.

DOI
10.1103/x6j4-gnww

Related papers

Solving linear systems on quantum hardware with hybrid HHL++

Romina Yalovetzky, Pierre Minssen, Dylan Herman +1 more

The limited capabilities of current quantum hardware significantly constrain the scale of experimental demonstrations of most quantum algorithmic primitives. This makes it challenging to perform benchmarking of the current hardware using useful quantum algorithms, i.e., application-oriented benchmarking. In particular, the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm is a critical quantum linear algebra primitive, but the majority of the components of HHL are far out of the reach of noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, which has led to the proposal of hybrid classical-quantum variants. The goal of this work is to further bridge the gap between proposed near-term friendly implementations of HHL and the kinds of quantum circuits that can be executed on noisy hardware. Our proposal adds to the existing literature of hybrid quantum algorithms for linear algebra that are more compatible with the current scale of quantum devices. Specifically, we propose two modifications to the Hybrid HHL algorithm proposed by Lee et al., leading to our algorithm Hybrid $$\hbox {HHL}^{++}$$ : (1) propose a novel algorithm for determining a scaling factor for the linear system matrix that maximizes the utility of the amount of ancillary qubits allocated to the phase estimation component of HHL, and (2) introduce a heuristic for compressing the HHL circuit. We demonstrate the efficacy of our work by running our modified Hybrid HHL on Quantinuum System Model H-series trapped-ion quantum computers to solve different problem instances of small-scale portfolio optimization problems, leading to the largest experimental demonstrations of HHL for an application to date.

arXiv:2110.15958•Scientific Reports•Sep 10, 2024•58 citations

Hybrid Quantum-Classical Implementation of the Harrow–Hassidim–Lloyd Algorithm: Bounded-Error Quantum Polynomial Time (BQP)-Completeness of Matrix Inversion and Error Mitigation for Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) Devices

Zefree Lazarus Mayaluri, Panda Ganapati

We propose a hybrid quantum-classical implementation of the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm for the matrix inversion (linear-systems) problem, a key subroutine in quantum computing. Rather than claiming a new complexity result, we provide an assumption-explicit proof sketch, aligned with established literature, that contextualizes matrix inversion as Bounded-Error Quantum Polynomial Time (BQP)-complete and offers reduction-based intuition via Grover-type amplitude amplification. We implement HHL for 2 × 2, 4 × 4, and 8 × 8 Hermitian matrices using Qiskit and evaluate performance using simulator-based experiments with calibrated noise models and executions on IBM Quantum and IonQ backends. To enhance robustness on Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) hardware, we integrate measurement-error mitigation, zero-noise extrapolation, and post-selection, and we quantify performance using fidelity and mean squared error. Results from noiseless simulation, calibrated-noise simulation, and real-device execution show that mitigation improves reconstruction fidelity for small Hermitian systems, particularly for deeper circuits. These findings support mitigation-aware feasibility on current NISQ devices; however, they do not establish present-day runtime advantage over optimized classical solvers. The proposed workflow is relevant to quantum optimization, quantum machine learning, and quantum chemistry, where linear-system primitives arise frequently. Future work will focus on reducing phase-estimation depth (e.g., iterative or semiclassical variants), improving compilation and benchmarking transparency, and re-evaluating larger instances on higher-fidelity hardware.

Cureus Journal of Computer Science.•May 14, 2026•1 citation

Hybrid quantum linear equation algorithm and its experimental test on IBM Quantum Experience

Yonghae Lee, Jaewoo Joo, Soojoon Lee

We propose a hybrid quantum algorithm based on the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm for solving a system of linear equations. In this paper, we show that our hybrid algorithm can reduce a circuit depth from the original HHL algorithm by means of a classical information feed-forward after the quantum phase estimation algorithm, and the results of the hybrid algorithm are identical to those of the HHL algorithm. In addition, it is experimentally examined with four qubits in the IBM Quantum Experience setups, and the experimental results of our algorithm show higher accurate performance on specific systems of linear equations than that of the HHL algorithm.

arXiv:1807.10651•Scientific Reports•Mar 18, 2019•81 citations

Improved circuit implementation of the HHL algorithm and its simulations on QISKIT

Meng Zhang, Lihua Dong, Yong Zeng +1 more

In 2019, Yonghae Lee et al. combined the circuit implementation of the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm with a classical computer, and designed a hybrid HHL algorithm to reduce experimental errors caused by decoherence and so on. However, the improvement is achieved only in the auxiliary quantum coding phase, and no quantum resource reduction is done on the quantum phase estimation and inverse quantum phase estimation stages. At the same time, the circuit improvement illustration on a [Formula: see text] linear system just has the result and no specific process. In this paper, based on the idea of the hybrid HHL algorithm and a generic circuit of HHL algorithm, an improved circuit implementation of the HHL algorithm is proposed. The feasibility of the improved circuit implementation of the HHL algorithm is verified by IBM's qiskit. The improved circuit illustrations on a [Formula: see text] linear system show that the improved circuit implementation of the HHL algorithm can effectively reduce quantum resources without losing the fidelity of the results. Thus the improved circuit implementation of the HHL algorithm can further avoid some result errors than the existing implementation methods.

Scientific Reports•Aug 2, 2022•25 citations

Study of Error Propagation and Generation in Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) Quantum Algorithm

Anika Zaman, Hiu Yung Wong

In this paper, we study the error propagation and generation in the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) quantum algorithm runs on IBM-Q hardware with the help of a MATLAB simulator. HHL is a quantum algorithm that can provide exponential speedup over the fastest classical algorithm (conjugate gradient method) in solving systems of linear equations (SLE). However, without error correction, it cannot give correct results even in a 2-variable system due to its complexity. In this study, an HHL quantum circuit for a 2-variable SLE is implemented in IBM-Q and the error is extracted after each stage of the circuit and compared to a MATLAB simulator. We identified three major sources of errors, namely single-qubit flipping, gate infidelity, and error propagation. We also found that at the ancillary bit rotation stage, the error becomes large but the encoded solution still has high fidelity. However, the solution is mostly lost after the inverse quantum phase estimation which is necessary to extract the solution efficiently. Therefore, it is suggested that error correction resources, if limited, should be added to the second half of the circuit.

IEEE Latin American Electron Devices Conference (LAEDC)•Jul 4, 2022•16 citations

Statistical Phase Estimation and Error Mitigation on a Superconducting Quantum Processor

Nick S. Blunt, Laura Caune, Róbert Izsák +2 more

Quantum phase estimation (QPE) is a key quantum algorithm, which has been widely studied as a method to perform chemistry and solid-state calculations on future fault-tolerant quantum computers.Recently, several authors have proposed statistical alternatives to QPE that have benefits on early faulttolerant devices, including shorter circuits and better suitability for error-mitigation techniques.However, experimental investigations of the algorithm on real quantum processors are lacking.Here, we implement statistical phase estimation on Rigetti's superconducting processors.Specifically, we use a modification of the Lin and Tong [PRX Quantum 3, 010318 (2022)] algorithm with the improved Fourier approximation of Wan et al. [Phys.Rev. Lett.129, 030503 (2022)] and apply a variational-compilation technique to reduce the circuit depth.We then incorporate error-mitigation strategies including zero-noise extrapolation and readout-error mitigation with bit-flip averaging.We propose a new method to estimate energies from the statistical phase estimation data, which is found to improve the accuracy in the final energy estimates by 1-2 orders of magnitude with respect to prior theoretical bounds, reducing the cost of performing accurate phase-estimation calculations.We apply these methods to chemistry problems for active spaces up to four electrons in four orbitals, including the application of a quantum embedding method, and use them to correctly estimate energies within chemical precision.Our work demonstrates that statistical phase estimation has a natural resilience to noise, particularly after mitigating coherent errors, and can achieve far higher accuracy than suggested by previous analysis, demonstrating its potential as a valuable quantum algorithm for early fault-tolerant devices.

arXiv:2304.05126•PRX Quantum•Dec 12, 2023•37 citations
We introduce two variations of the quantum phase estimation algorithm: quantum shifted phase estimation and quantum punctured phase estimation. The shifted method employs a bit-string left shift to discard the most significant bit and focus on lower-order phase components, and the punctured method removes qubits corresponding to known phase bits, thereby streamlining the circuit. To demonstrate the effectiveness of the two variations, we integrate them into a hybrid quantum-classical implementation of the Harrow--Hassidim--Lloyd algorithm for solving linear systems. The hybrid method leverages both quantum and classical processors to identify and remove unnecessary qubits and gates. As a result, for small-scale linear systems, our method reduces qubit and gate counts relative to previous implementations, yielding lower overall circuit error rates on current hardware. Experimental demonstrations on IBM superconducting hardware confirm the error-mitigation effectiveness on small problem instances.
The limited capabilities of current quantum hardware significantly constrain the scale of experimental demonstrations of most quantum algorithmic primitives. This makes it challenging to perform benchmarking of the current hardware using useful quantum algorithms, i.e., application-oriented benchmarking. In particular, the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm is a critical quantum linear algebra primitive, but the majority of the components of HHL are far out of the reach of noisy intermediate-scale quantum devices, which has led to the proposal of hybrid classical-quantum variants. The goal of this work is to further bridge the gap between proposed near-term friendly implementations of HHL and the kinds of quantum circuits that can be executed on noisy hardware. Our proposal adds to the existing literature of hybrid quantum algorithms for linear algebra that are more compatible with the current scale of quantum devices. Specifically, we propose two modifications to the Hybrid HHL algorithm proposed by Lee et al., leading to our algorithm Hybrid HHL++\hbox {HHL}^{++}HHL++ : (1) propose a novel algorithm for determining a scaling factor for the linear system matrix that maximizes the utility of the amount of ancillary qubits allocated to the phase estimation component of HHL, and (2) introduce a heuristic for compressing the HHL circuit. We demonstrate the efficacy of our work by running our modified Hybrid HHL on Quantinuum System Model H-series trapped-ion quantum computers to solve different problem instances of small-scale portfolio optimization problems, leading to the largest experimental demonstrations of HHL for an application to date.
We propose a hybrid quantum-classical implementation of the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm for the matrix inversion (linear-systems) problem, a key subroutine in quantum computing. Rather than claiming a new complexity result, we provide an assumption-explicit proof sketch, aligned with established literature, that contextualizes matrix inversion as Bounded-Error Quantum Polynomial Time (BQP)-complete and offers reduction-based intuition via Grover-type amplitude amplification. We implement HHL for 2 × 2, 4 × 4, and 8 × 8 Hermitian matrices using Qiskit and evaluate performance using simulator-based experiments with calibrated noise models and executions on IBM Quantum and IonQ backends. To enhance robustness on Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) hardware, we integrate measurement-error mitigation, zero-noise extrapolation, and post-selection, and we quantify performance using fidelity and mean squared error. Results from noiseless simulation, calibrated-noise simulation, and real-device execution show that mitigation improves reconstruction fidelity for small Hermitian systems, particularly for deeper circuits. These findings support mitigation-aware feasibility on current NISQ devices; however, they do not establish present-day runtime advantage over optimized classical solvers. The proposed workflow is relevant to quantum optimization, quantum machine learning, and quantum chemistry, where linear-system primitives arise frequently. Future work will focus on reducing phase-estimation depth (e.g., iterative or semiclassical variants), improving compilation and benchmarking transparency, and re-evaluating larger instances on higher-fidelity hardware.
We propose a hybrid quantum algorithm based on the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm for solving a system of linear equations. In this paper, we show that our hybrid algorithm can reduce a circuit depth from the original HHL algorithm by means of a classical information feed-forward after the quantum phase estimation algorithm, and the results of the hybrid algorithm are identical to those of the HHL algorithm. In addition, it is experimentally examined with four qubits in the IBM Quantum Experience setups, and the experimental results of our algorithm show higher accurate performance on specific systems of linear equations than that of the HHL algorithm.
In 2019, Yonghae Lee et al. combined the circuit implementation of the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) algorithm with a classical computer, and designed a hybrid HHL algorithm to reduce experimental errors caused by decoherence and so on. However, the improvement is achieved only in the auxiliary quantum coding phase, and no quantum resource reduction is done on the quantum phase estimation and inverse quantum phase estimation stages. At the same time, the circuit improvement illustration on a [Formula: see text] linear system just has the result and no specific process. In this paper, based on the idea of the hybrid HHL algorithm and a generic circuit of HHL algorithm, an improved circuit implementation of the HHL algorithm is proposed. The feasibility of the improved circuit implementation of the HHL algorithm is verified by IBM's qiskit. The improved circuit illustrations on a [Formula: see text] linear system show that the improved circuit implementation of the HHL algorithm can effectively reduce quantum resources without losing the fidelity of the results. Thus the improved circuit implementation of the HHL algorithm can further avoid some result errors than the existing implementation methods.
In this paper, we study the error propagation and generation in the Harrow-Hassidim-Lloyd (HHL) quantum algorithm runs on IBM-Q hardware with the help of a MATLAB simulator. HHL is a quantum algorithm that can provide exponential speedup over the fastest classical algorithm (conjugate gradient method) in solving systems of linear equations (SLE). However, without error correction, it cannot give correct results even in a 2-variable system due to its complexity. In this study, an HHL quantum circuit for a 2-variable SLE is implemented in IBM-Q and the error is extracted after each stage of the circuit and compared to a MATLAB simulator. We identified three major sources of errors, namely single-qubit flipping, gate infidelity, and error propagation. We also found that at the ancillary bit rotation stage, the error becomes large but the encoded solution still has high fidelity. However, the solution is mostly lost after the inverse quantum phase estimation which is necessary to extract the solution efficiently. Therefore, it is suggested that error correction resources, if limited, should be added to the second half of the circuit.
Quantum phase estimation (QPE) is a key quantum algorithm, which has been widely studied as a method to perform chemistry and solid-state calculations on future fault-tolerant quantum computers.Recently, several authors have proposed statistical alternatives to QPE that have benefits on early faulttolerant devices, including shorter circuits and better suitability for error-mitigation techniques.However, experimental investigations of the algorithm on real quantum processors are lacking.Here, we implement statistical phase estimation on Rigetti's superconducting processors.Specifically, we use a modification of the Lin and Tong [PRX Quantum 3, 010318 (2022)] algorithm with the improved Fourier approximation of Wan et al. [Phys.Rev. Lett.129, 030503 (2022)] and apply a variational-compilation technique to reduce the circuit depth.We then incorporate error-mitigation strategies including zero-noise extrapolation and readout-error mitigation with bit-flip averaging.We propose a new method to estimate energies from the statistical phase estimation data, which is found to improve the accuracy in the final energy estimates by 1-2 orders of magnitude with respect to prior theoretical bounds, reducing the cost of performing accurate phase-estimation calculations.We apply these methods to chemistry problems for active spaces up to four electrons in four orbitals, including the application of a quantum embedding method, and use them to correctly estimate energies within chemical precision.Our work demonstrates that statistical phase estimation has a natural resilience to noise, particularly after mitigating coherent errors, and can achieve far higher accuracy than suggested by previous analysis, demonstrating its potential as a valuable quantum algorithm for early fault-tolerant devices.