Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2507.04650

From Wavefunctional Entanglement to Entangled Wavefunctional Degrees of Freedom

Bhattacharya, Aniruddha

Published Jul 7, 2025• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The question of whether entanglement between photons is equivalent to entanglement between their characteristic field modes, specifically, the single-particle wavefunctions that are composed and superposed to describe particles in such modes, is a key, open problem concerning multi-partite optical degrees of freedom, and has profound implications for topics ranging from quantum foundations to quantum computation. Here, I offer a fresh, deeper, physical insight into this subtle, albeit enduring, issue by describing a situation in which the entangling interactions between optical modes, namely, the wavefunctions, can be distilled into genuine entanglement between the physical, observable properties of the photons, which are the wavefunctional degrees of freedom. This theoretical observation also highlights the salience of the measurement context, especially, of clearly disambiguating between the choice of the quantum subsystem and the decision to measure an observable along a particular axis of measurement, while quantifying and transforming quantum optical entanglement. This theoretical observation might be applied to formulate a new class of protocols for performing quantum information tasks, using entangled photons within inseparable field modes.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2507.04650

Related papers

Entanglement between dependent degrees of freedom: Quasiparticle correlations

Franziska Barkhausen, Laura Ares, Stefan Schumacher +1 more

Common notions of entanglement are based on well-separated subsystems. However, obtaining such independent degrees of freedom is not always possible because of physical constraints. In this work, we explore the notion of entanglement in the context of dependent degrees of freedom. As a physically relevant application, we specifically study quantum correlation features for quasiparticle descriptions. Those are paramount for interacting light-matter systems, utilizing excitations of fermion-boson hybrid modes. By comparing independent and dependent degrees of freedom, we uncover that certain states are nonentangled although they would be entangled when only focusing on the common, independent description, and vice versa. Therefore, insight is provided into the resourcefulness of quantum correlations within the rarely discussed context of dependent degrees of freedom for light-matter links in quantum information applications.

arXiv:2410.14290•Physical Review A•Mar 4, 2025•1 citation

Philosophy of Polarization-Path Entanglement in Quantum Optics

Artur Czerwiński

This paper explores the formal structure and philosophical implications of polarization-path entanglement in quantum optics, where different degrees of freedom of a single photon become entangled. We examine the mathematical conditions under which coherence is preserved or lost, emphasizing the role of distinguishability and information flow. The analysis is situated within major interpretational frameworks (including Copenhagen, Many-Worlds, QBism, and Bohmian mechanics) to evaluate whether such entanglement reflects physical reality or epistemic constraints. Finally, we discuss experimental realizations, relevance to quantum information processing, and open conceptual questions regarding the ontological status of single-particle entanglement.

Optics•Aug 18, 2025•2 citations

Introduction to Measurement Space and Application to Operationally Useful Entanglement and Mode Entanglement

Sebastian Meznaric

We introduce the idea that the knowable quantum reality depends not only on the state but also on measurements. Mathematically, we map the states from the ordinary Hilbert space into new states in what we call the measurement space. The state vectors in the measurement space contain only the information accessible with a particular set of measurements. The space can be used to find the operational equivalent of any information theoretic quantity. We use the formalism to define the operationally meaningful entanglement, explore its properties and apply it to mode entanglement. There we find that a mode-entangled state of a single particle has no operationally useful entanglement unless additional degrees of freedom are introduced to the system.

arXiv:1004.4854•Apr 27, 2010•1 citation

Exploring High-dimensional Hilbert spaces by Quantum Optics

Andrea Chiuri, Paolo Mataloni

In the case of mixed states ρAB of the composite system A ⊗ B, the previous relation generalizes to ρAB = ∑ k pkρ A k ⊗ρk , where pk are probabilities and ρk ’s (ρk ’s) are generic density matrix of the system A (B). The entanglement derives from “subtle” nonlocal correlations between the parts of a quantum system and combines three basic structural elements of quantum theory: the superposition principle, the quantum non-separability property and the exponential scaling of the state space with the number of partitions. This unique resource can be used to perform computational and cryptographic tasks otherwise impossible with classical systems. An entangled state shared by two or more separated parties is a valuable resource for fundamental quantum protocols, such as quantum teleportation [2], quantum computing [3] and quantum cryptography. By using entangled states we can deeply investigate the nonlocal properties of the quantum world. In fact, an entangled system exhibits correlations between two (or more) parties, which cannot be reproduced by a classical theory or, in general, by a Local Hidden Variables Theory (LHVT). Quantum optics represents an excellent experimental test bench for various novel concepts introduced within the framework of quantum information theory. Quantum states of photons, generally produced by a probabilistic process, namely spontaneous parametric down conversion (SPDC), may be easily and accurately manipulated using linear and nonlinear optical devices and measured by efficient single-photon detectors. Photonic qubits represent the typical carrier of quantum information and can be distributed over long distances, either in free-space or in low-loss optical fibers. Two-particle experiments correspond to operate with qubits belonging to a (2 × 2) Hilbert space. Many quantum information tasks and fundamental tests of quantum mechanics, such as the simulation of properties of quantum systems, the realization of quantum algorithms of increasing complexity and the investigation of the quantum world at a mesoscopic level, deal with a large number of qubits. In order to take full advantage of the possibilities offered by quantum mechanics, more qubits must be added to a quantum state. Two approaches may be followed to increase the number of qubits. The first one consists of increasing the number of entangled particles. In this way, multi-qubit entangled states are created by distributing the qubits between the particles so that each particle carries one qubit. A second strategy consists of encoding more than one qubit in each particle, by exploiting different degrees of freedom (DOFs) of the photon such as the polarization, the path, the emission time, the orbital angular momentum. This has been used to create two-photon fourand six-qubit states and up to five-photon ten-qubit graph states. The entanglement of two particles in different DOFs corresponds to socalled hyperentanglement. It is worth noting that multi-qubit hyperentanglement allows to achieve higher

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Local approach to quantum entanglement

Ho-Chih Lin

Quantum entanglement is the key property that makes quantum information theory different from its classical counterpart and is also a valuable physical resource with massive potential for technological applications. However, our understanding of entanglement is still far from com plete despite intense research activities. Like other physical resources, the first step towards exploiting them fully is to know how to quantify. There are many reasons to focus on the en tanglement of continuous-variable states since the underlying degrees of freedom of physical systems carrying quantum information are frequently continuous, rather than discrete. Much of the effort has been concentrated on Gaussian states, because these are common as the ground or thermal states of optical modes. Within this framework, many interesting topics have been stud ied and some significant progress made. Nevertheless, non-Gaussian states are also extremely important this is especially so in condensed-phase systems, where harmonic behaviour in any degree of freedom is likely to be only an approximation. So far, there is little knowledge about the quantification of entanglement in non-Gaussian states. This thesis aims to contribute to the active field of research in quantum entanglement by introducing a new approach to the analysis of entanglement, especially in continuous-variable states, and shows that it leads to the first systematic quantification of the (local) entanglement in arbitrary bipartite non-Gaussian states. By applying this local approach, many new insights can be gained. Notably, local entanglements of systems with smooth wavefunctions are fully characterised by the derived simple expressions, provided the wavefunction is known. The local (logarithmic) negativity of any two-mode mixed states can be directly computed from the closed-form formulae given. For multi-mode mixed states, this approach provides a scheme that permits much simpler numerical computation for quantifying entanglement than is generally possible from directly computing the full entanglement of the system.

•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

PhD thesis: Modes, States, and Symmetries in quantum Optics for quantum Information and Metrology

Éloi Descamps

This thesis explores the role of modes, states, and symmetries in quantum optics, within the context of quantum information and quantum metrology. It proposes a unified framework to analyze how the modal structure of photonic fields, the statistical nature of states, and their symmetry properties determine the physical resources that can be exploited for quantum information processing and quantum parameter estimation. A first line of investigation develops a description of time-frequency degrees of freedom as continuous quantum variables, highlighting their richness for encoding and manipulating information. A second axis studies entanglement and collective variables, clarifying the link between physical resources and metrological gains, particularly in reaching ultimate precision limits. Interferometric scenarios of the Hong-Ou-Mandel type are then analyzed, and a general formalism centered on the notion of symmetry is developed. This framework enables the analysis of a broad range of situations and leads to several generalizations. Finally, the thesis examines the symmetries imposed by optical superselection rules and their consequences for the structure of quantum states and their operational performance, with the aim of providing a deeper understanding of the foundations of quantum optics.

quant-pharXiv:2607.26761•Jul 30, 2026•1 citation
The question of whether entanglement between photons is equivalent to entanglement between their characteristic field modes, specifically, the single-particle wavefunctions that are composed and superposed to describe particles in such modes, is a key, open problem concerning multi-partite optical degrees of freedom, and has profound implications for topics ranging from quantum foundations to quantum computation. Here, I offer a fresh, deeper, physical insight into this subtle, albeit enduring, issue by describing a situation in which the entangling interactions between optical modes, namely, the wavefunctions, can be distilled into genuine entanglement between the physical, observable properties of the photons, which are the wavefunctional degrees of freedom. This theoretical observation also highlights the salience of the measurement context, especially, of clearly disambiguating between the choice of the quantum subsystem and the decision to measure an observable along a particular axis of measurement, while quantifying and transforming quantum optical entanglement. This theoretical observation might be applied to formulate a new class of protocols for performing quantum information tasks, using entangled photons within inseparable field modes.
Common notions of entanglement are based on well-separated subsystems. However, obtaining such independent degrees of freedom is not always possible because of physical constraints. In this work, we explore the notion of entanglement in the context of dependent degrees of freedom. As a physically relevant application, we specifically study quantum correlation features for quasiparticle descriptions. Those are paramount for interacting light-matter systems, utilizing excitations of fermion-boson hybrid modes. By comparing independent and dependent degrees of freedom, we uncover that certain states are nonentangled although they would be entangled when only focusing on the common, independent description, and vice versa. Therefore, insight is provided into the resourcefulness of quantum correlations within the rarely discussed context of dependent degrees of freedom for light-matter links in quantum information applications.
This paper explores the formal structure and philosophical implications of polarization-path entanglement in quantum optics, where different degrees of freedom of a single photon become entangled. We examine the mathematical conditions under which coherence is preserved or lost, emphasizing the role of distinguishability and information flow. The analysis is situated within major interpretational frameworks (including Copenhagen, Many-Worlds, QBism, and Bohmian mechanics) to evaluate whether such entanglement reflects physical reality or epistemic constraints. Finally, we discuss experimental realizations, relevance to quantum information processing, and open conceptual questions regarding the ontological status of single-particle entanglement.
We introduce the idea that the knowable quantum reality depends not only on the state but also on measurements. Mathematically, we map the states from the ordinary Hilbert space into new states in what we call the measurement space. The state vectors in the measurement space contain only the information accessible with a particular set of measurements. The space can be used to find the operational equivalent of any information theoretic quantity. We use the formalism to define the operationally meaningful entanglement, explore its properties and apply it to mode entanglement. There we find that a mode-entangled state of a single particle has no operationally useful entanglement unless additional degrees of freedom are introduced to the system.
In the case of mixed states ρAB of the composite system A ⊗ B, the previous relation generalizes to ρAB = ∑ k pkρ A k ⊗ρk , where pk are probabilities and ρk ’s (ρk ’s) are generic density matrix of the system A (B). The entanglement derives from “subtle” nonlocal correlations between the parts of a quantum system and combines three basic structural elements of quantum theory: the superposition principle, the quantum non-separability property and the exponential scaling of the state space with the number of partitions. This unique resource can be used to perform computational and cryptographic tasks otherwise impossible with classical systems. An entangled state shared by two or more separated parties is a valuable resource for fundamental quantum protocols, such as quantum teleportation [2], quantum computing [3] and quantum cryptography. By using entangled states we can deeply investigate the nonlocal properties of the quantum world. In fact, an entangled system exhibits correlations between two (or more) parties, which cannot be reproduced by a classical theory or, in general, by a Local Hidden Variables Theory (LHVT). Quantum optics represents an excellent experimental test bench for various novel concepts introduced within the framework of quantum information theory. Quantum states of photons, generally produced by a probabilistic process, namely spontaneous parametric down conversion (SPDC), may be easily and accurately manipulated using linear and nonlinear optical devices and measured by efficient single-photon detectors. Photonic qubits represent the typical carrier of quantum information and can be distributed over long distances, either in free-space or in low-loss optical fibers. Two-particle experiments correspond to operate with qubits belonging to a (2 × 2) Hilbert space. Many quantum information tasks and fundamental tests of quantum mechanics, such as the simulation of properties of quantum systems, the realization of quantum algorithms of increasing complexity and the investigation of the quantum world at a mesoscopic level, deal with a large number of qubits. In order to take full advantage of the possibilities offered by quantum mechanics, more qubits must be added to a quantum state. Two approaches may be followed to increase the number of qubits. The first one consists of increasing the number of entangled particles. In this way, multi-qubit entangled states are created by distributing the qubits between the particles so that each particle carries one qubit. A second strategy consists of encoding more than one qubit in each particle, by exploiting different degrees of freedom (DOFs) of the photon such as the polarization, the path, the emission time, the orbital angular momentum. This has been used to create two-photon fourand six-qubit states and up to five-photon ten-qubit graph states. The entanglement of two particles in different DOFs corresponds to socalled hyperentanglement. It is worth noting that multi-qubit hyperentanglement allows to achieve higher
Quantum entanglement is the key property that makes quantum information theory different from its classical counterpart and is also a valuable physical resource with massive potential for technological applications. However, our understanding of entanglement is still far from com plete despite intense research activities. Like other physical resources, the first step towards exploiting them fully is to know how to quantify. There are many reasons to focus on the en tanglement of continuous-variable states since the underlying degrees of freedom of physical systems carrying quantum information are frequently continuous, rather than discrete. Much of the effort has been concentrated on Gaussian states, because these are common as the ground or thermal states of optical modes. Within this framework, many interesting topics have been stud ied and some significant progress made. Nevertheless, non-Gaussian states are also extremely important this is especially so in condensed-phase systems, where harmonic behaviour in any degree of freedom is likely to be only an approximation. So far, there is little knowledge about the quantification of entanglement in non-Gaussian states. This thesis aims to contribute to the active field of research in quantum entanglement by introducing a new approach to the analysis of entanglement, especially in continuous-variable states, and shows that it leads to the first systematic quantification of the (local) entanglement in arbitrary bipartite non-Gaussian states. By applying this local approach, many new insights can be gained. Notably, local entanglements of systems with smooth wavefunctions are fully characterised by the derived simple expressions, provided the wavefunction is known. The local (logarithmic) negativity of any two-mode mixed states can be directly computed from the closed-form formulae given. For multi-mode mixed states, this approach provides a scheme that permits much simpler numerical computation for quantifying entanglement than is generally possible from directly computing the full entanglement of the system.
This thesis explores the role of modes, states, and symmetries in quantum optics, within the context of quantum information and quantum metrology. It proposes a unified framework to analyze how the modal structure of photonic fields, the statistical nature of states, and their symmetry properties determine the physical resources that can be exploited for quantum information processing and quantum parameter estimation. A first line of investigation develops a description of time-frequency degrees of freedom as continuous quantum variables, highlighting their richness for encoding and manipulating information. A second axis studies entanglement and collective variables, clarifying the link between physical resources and metrological gains, particularly in reaching ultimate precision limits. Interferometric scenarios of the Hong-Ou-Mandel type are then analyzed, and a general formalism centered on the notion of symmetry is developed. This framework enables the analysis of a broad range of situations and leads to several generalizations. Finally, the thesis examines the symmetries imposed by optical superselection rules and their consequences for the structure of quantum states and their operational performance, with the aim of providing a deeper understanding of the foundations of quantum optics.