Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2506.23320

A Denotational Semantics for Quantum Loops

Nicola Assolini, Alessandra Di Pierro

Published Jun 29, 2025• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Programming a quantum computer, i.e., implementing quantum algorithms on a quantum processor-based copmputer architecture, is a task that can be addressed (just as for classical computers) at different levels of abstraction. This paper proposes a denotational semantics for high-level quantum programming constructs, focusing on the conceptual meaning of quantum-controlled branching and iteration. We introduce a denotational domain where a mathematical meaning of a quantum control flow with loops can be defined, which reflects the coherent evolution of the quantum system implementing the program.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2506.23320

Related papers

Quantum Control and General Recursion Beyond the Unitary Case

Kathleen Barsse, Romain Péchoux, Simon Perdrix

Coherent control, aka quantum control, is a central concept in quantum computing that is attracting increasing attention from both the quantum foundations and quantum software communities. Defining coherent control in the presence of recursion and measurement has long been known to be a major challenge. In particular, no-go results have been established for standard semantical domains like completely positive maps. We address this problem by introducing the first quantum programming language with recursion that allows for the coherent control of arbitrary quantum operations. We equip this language with both an operational and a denotational semantics that we prove to be adequate. To design these semantics, we show that combining coherent control, recursion, and measurement crucially requires describing the evolution of subprograms in the absence of input. To address this, the operational semantics takes into account a default evolution branch, while the denotational semantics uses the concept of coherent quantum operation, based on vacuum extensions. We strengthen the validity of our approach by developing an observational equivalence: two programs are equivalent if their probability of termination is the same in any context. The denotational semantics is shown to be fully abstract with respect to this observational equivalence.

arXiv:2507.10466•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jul 14, 2025•2 citations

Quantum Control Machine: The Limits of Control Flow in Quantum Programming

Charles Yuan, Agnes Villanyi, Michael Carbin

Quantum algorithms for tasks such as factorization, search, and simulation rely on control flow such as branching and iteration that depends on the value of data in superposition. High-level programming abstractions for control flow, such as switches, loops, higher-order functions, and continuations, are ubiquitous in classical languages. By contrast, many quantum languages do not provide high-level abstractions for control flow in superposition, and instead require the use of hardware-level logic gates to implement such control flow. The reason for this gap is that whereas a classical computer supports control flow abstractions using a program counter that can depend on data, the typical architecture of a quantum computer does not analogously provide a program counter that can depend on data in superposition. As a result, the complete set of control flow abstractions that can be correctly realized on a quantum computer has not yet been established. In this work, we provide a complete characterization of the properties of control flow abstractions that are correctly realizable on a quantum computer. First, we prove that even on a quantum computer whose program counter exists in superposition, one cannot correctly realize control flow in quantum algorithms by lifting the classical conditional jump instruction to work in superposition. This theorem denies the ability to directly lift general abstractions for control flow such as the λ-calculus from classical to quantum programming. In response, we present the necessary and sufficient conditions for control flow to be correctly realizable on a quantum computer. We introduce the quantum control machine, an instruction set architecture featuring a conditional jump that is restricted to satisfy these conditions. We show how this design enables a developer to correctly express control flow in quantum algorithms using a program counter in place of logic gates.

arXiv:2304.15000•Proceedings of the ACM on Programming Languages•Apr 29, 2024•25 citations

Towards a quantum programming language

Peter Selinger

We propose the design of a programming language for quantum computing. Traditionally, quantum algorithms are frequently expressed at the hardware level, for instance in terms of the quantum circuit model or quantum Turing machines. These approaches do not encourage structured programming or abstractions such as data types. In this paper, we describe the syntax and semantics of a simple quantum programming language with high-level features such as loops, recursive procedures, and structured data types. The language is functional in nature, statically typed, free of run-time errors, and has an interesting denotational semantics in terms of complete partial orders of superoperators.

Mathematical Structures in Computer Science•Aug 1, 2004•496 citations

High-level quantum structured programs as quantum registers compositions

David Chamizo, Jose Garcia-Alonso, Juan M. Murillo

Current quantum programs are mainly designed at the level of quantum gates acting on individual qubits; on a large scale and for complex problems this may involve a high cognitive load on the programmer, making the program specification nontrivial and error-prone. In this context, providing quantum programming with higher abstraction mechanisms will assist in making this task more manageable and robust against design errors. In this work, a conceptual framework is addressed following the notion of the whole quantum computation as a structure composed of quantum registers representing each an undivided entity. Thus, computation progresses through semantically well-defined transformations that act on, or entangle, quantum registers, thereby modifying the global state. Ultimately, the program reaches the desired state by following a specific composition strategy. With this in mind, high-level syntax is presented through an algebraic formalism that bridges them with their low-level semantics. Proposed syntax is based on certain well-know operations used on quantum algorithms that apply phase shifts upon logical condition satisfaction or leverage on parallel evaluation. Based solely on the formalized operations, a quantum satisfiability modulo theories (SMT) solver can be designed. At its core, this work contributes to establishing some methodological principles towards realizing a high-level quantum structured programming.

quant-pharXiv:2608.03873•Aug 5, 2026•0 citations

Towards a Quantum Calculus

Philippe Jorrand, Simon Perdrix

The aim of this paper is to introduce a general model of quantum computation, the quantum calculus: both unitary transformations and projective measurements are allowed; furthermore a complete classical control, including conditional structures and loops, is available. Complementary to its operational semantics, we introduce a pure denotational semantics for the quantum calculus. Based on probabilistic power domains [Jones, C. and G. D. Plotkin, A probabilistic powerdomain of evaluations, in: LICS, 1989, pp. 186–195. URL http://homepages.inf.ed.ac.uk/gdp/publications/Prob_Powerdomain.pdf], this pure denotational semantics associates with any description of a computation in the quantum calculus its action in a mathematical setting. Adequacy between operational and pure denotational semantics is established. Additionally to this pure denotational semantics, an observable denotational semantics is introduced. Following the work by Selinger, this observable denotational semantics is based on density matrices and super-operators. Finally, we establish an exact abstraction connection between these two semantics.

Electronic Notes in Theoretical Computer Science•Jul 1, 2008•2 citations

Denotational Semantics for Stabiliser Quantum Programs

Robert I. Booth, Cole Comfort

The stabiliser fragment of quantum theory is a foundational building block for quantum error correction, and hence for the fault-tolerant compilation of quantum programs. In this article, we develop a sound, universal, and complete denotational semantics for stabiliser operations, including measurement, classically controlled Pauli operators, and affine classical computation, thereby supporting an explicit treatment of quantum error-correcting codes. We interpret stabiliser operations as affine relations over finite fields, yielding a semantics that reflects the algebraic structure underlying stabiliser quantum error correction. Because stabiliser quantum mechanics has a well-behaved algebraic structure, our relational semantics is conceptually transparent and computationally tractable when compared to standard denotational models for general quantum programs. We demonstrate the resulting semantics by describing a small, low-level assembly language for stabiliser programs with fully abstract denotational semantics.

Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
Programming a quantum computer, i.e., implementing quantum algorithms on a quantum processor-based copmputer architecture, is a task that can be addressed (just as for classical computers) at different levels of abstraction. This paper proposes a denotational semantics for high-level quantum programming constructs, focusing on the conceptual meaning of quantum-controlled branching and iteration. We introduce a denotational domain where a mathematical meaning of a quantum control flow with loops can be defined, which reflects the coherent evolution of the quantum system implementing the program.
Coherent control, aka quantum control, is a central concept in quantum computing that is attracting increasing attention from both the quantum foundations and quantum software communities. Defining coherent control in the presence of recursion and measurement has long been known to be a major challenge. In particular, no-go results have been established for standard semantical domains like completely positive maps. We address this problem by introducing the first quantum programming language with recursion that allows for the coherent control of arbitrary quantum operations. We equip this language with both an operational and a denotational semantics that we prove to be adequate. To design these semantics, we show that combining coherent control, recursion, and measurement crucially requires describing the evolution of subprograms in the absence of input. To address this, the operational semantics takes into account a default evolution branch, while the denotational semantics uses the concept of coherent quantum operation, based on vacuum extensions. We strengthen the validity of our approach by developing an observational equivalence: two programs are equivalent if their probability of termination is the same in any context. The denotational semantics is shown to be fully abstract with respect to this observational equivalence.
Quantum algorithms for tasks such as factorization, search, and simulation rely on control flow such as branching and iteration that depends on the value of data in superposition. High-level programming abstractions for control flow, such as switches, loops, higher-order functions, and continuations, are ubiquitous in classical languages. By contrast, many quantum languages do not provide high-level abstractions for control flow in superposition, and instead require the use of hardware-level logic gates to implement such control flow. The reason for this gap is that whereas a classical computer supports control flow abstractions using a program counter that can depend on data, the typical architecture of a quantum computer does not analogously provide a program counter that can depend on data in superposition. As a result, the complete set of control flow abstractions that can be correctly realized on a quantum computer has not yet been established. In this work, we provide a complete characterization of the properties of control flow abstractions that are correctly realizable on a quantum computer. First, we prove that even on a quantum computer whose program counter exists in superposition, one cannot correctly realize control flow in quantum algorithms by lifting the classical conditional jump instruction to work in superposition. This theorem denies the ability to directly lift general abstractions for control flow such as the λ-calculus from classical to quantum programming. In response, we present the necessary and sufficient conditions for control flow to be correctly realizable on a quantum computer. We introduce the quantum control machine, an instruction set architecture featuring a conditional jump that is restricted to satisfy these conditions. We show how this design enables a developer to correctly express control flow in quantum algorithms using a program counter in place of logic gates.
We propose the design of a programming language for quantum computing. Traditionally, quantum algorithms are frequently expressed at the hardware level, for instance in terms of the quantum circuit model or quantum Turing machines. These approaches do not encourage structured programming or abstractions such as data types. In this paper, we describe the syntax and semantics of a simple quantum programming language with high-level features such as loops, recursive procedures, and structured data types. The language is functional in nature, statically typed, free of run-time errors, and has an interesting denotational semantics in terms of complete partial orders of superoperators.
Current quantum programs are mainly designed at the level of quantum gates acting on individual qubits; on a large scale and for complex problems this may involve a high cognitive load on the programmer, making the program specification nontrivial and error-prone. In this context, providing quantum programming with higher abstraction mechanisms will assist in making this task more manageable and robust against design errors. In this work, a conceptual framework is addressed following the notion of the whole quantum computation as a structure composed of quantum registers representing each an undivided entity. Thus, computation progresses through semantically well-defined transformations that act on, or entangle, quantum registers, thereby modifying the global state. Ultimately, the program reaches the desired state by following a specific composition strategy. With this in mind, high-level syntax is presented through an algebraic formalism that bridges them with their low-level semantics. Proposed syntax is based on certain well-know operations used on quantum algorithms that apply phase shifts upon logical condition satisfaction or leverage on parallel evaluation. Based solely on the formalized operations, a quantum satisfiability modulo theories (SMT) solver can be designed. At its core, this work contributes to establishing some methodological principles towards realizing a high-level quantum structured programming.
The aim of this paper is to introduce a general model of quantum computation, the quantum calculus: both unitary transformations and projective measurements are allowed; furthermore a complete classical control, including conditional structures and loops, is available. Complementary to its operational semantics, we introduce a pure denotational semantics for the quantum calculus. Based on probabilistic power domains [Jones, C. and G. D. Plotkin, A probabilistic powerdomain of evaluations, in: LICS, 1989, pp. 186–195. URL http://homepages.inf.ed.ac.uk/gdp/publications/Prob_Powerdomain.pdf], this pure denotational semantics associates with any description of a computation in the quantum calculus its action in a mathematical setting. Adequacy between operational and pure denotational semantics is established. Additionally to this pure denotational semantics, an observable denotational semantics is introduced. Following the work by Selinger, this observable denotational semantics is based on density matrices and super-operators. Finally, we establish an exact abstraction connection between these two semantics.
The stabiliser fragment of quantum theory is a foundational building block for quantum error correction, and hence for the fault-tolerant compilation of quantum programs. In this article, we develop a sound, universal, and complete denotational semantics for stabiliser operations, including measurement, classically controlled Pauli operators, and affine classical computation, thereby supporting an explicit treatment of quantum error-correcting codes. We interpret stabiliser operations as affine relations over finite fields, yielding a semantics that reflects the algebraic structure underlying stabiliser quantum error correction. Because stabiliser quantum mechanics has a well-behaved algebraic structure, our relational semantics is conceptually transparent and computationally tractable when compared to standard denotational models for general quantum programs. We demonstrate the resulting semantics by describing a small, low-level assembly language for stabiliser programs with fully abstract denotational semantics.