Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2506.21173 · International Journal of Quantum Information

Disentangling tensor product structures

Antoine Soulas

Published Sep 12, 2025• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

As a contribution to the field of quantum mereology, we study how a change of tensor product structure in a finite-dimensional Hilbert space affects its entanglement properties. In particular, we ask whether, given a time-evolving state, there exists a tensor product structure in which no entanglement is generated. We give a concrete, constructive example of disentangling tensor product structure in the case of a C-NOT gate evolution between two qbits, before showing that this cannot be achieved for most time-evolving quantum states.

DOI
10.1142/s0219749925500273

Related papers

Entanglement for all quantum states

A C de la Torre, Dardo Goyeneche, L Leitao

It is shown that a state that is factorizable in the Hilbert space corresponding to some choice of degrees of freedom becomes entangled for a different choice of degrees of freedom. Therefore, entanglement is not a special case but is ubiquitous in quantum systems. Simple examples are calculated and a general proof is provided. The physical relevance of the change of tensor product structure is mentioned.

arXiv:1002.2893•European Journal of Physics•Jan 8, 2010•44 citations

On the relative quantum entanglement with respect to tensor product structure

Xulin Liu, C. P. Sun

Mathematical foundation of the novel concept of quantum tensor product by Zanardi et al is rigorously established. The concept of relative quantum entanglement is naturally introduced and its meaning is made clear both mathematically and physically. For a finite or an infinite dimensional vector space $W$ the so called tensor product partition (TPP) is introduced on $End(W)$, the set of endmorphisms of $W$, and a natural correspondence is constructed between the set of TPP's of $End(W)$ and the set of tensor product structures (TPS's) of $W$. As a byproduct, it is shown that an arbitrarily given wave function belonging to an n-dimensional Hilbert space, $n$ being not a prime number, can be interpreted as a separable state with respect to some man-made TPS, and thus a quantum entangled state of a many-body system with respect to the "God-given" TPS can be regarded as a quantum state without entanglement in some sense. The concept of standard set of observables is also introduced to probe the underlying structure of the object TPP and to establish its connection with practical physical measurement.

arXiv:quant-ph/0410245•Oct 29, 2004•5 citations

Towards a Tensor Product Structure-Grounded Mereology

Matías Daniel Pasqualini, Sebastián Fortín

This paper aims to lay some groundwork for a systematic framework for quantum mereology based on the tensor product structures (TPSs) of Hilbert space. While previous work has suggested that such a TPS-based mereology might conform to classical extensional mereology, we demonstrate that the space of all possible tensor product structures for a given Hilbert space lacks the lattice-theoretic structure characteristic of classical partitions. Specifically, we show that this space admits no canonical meet operation, thus violating the global validity of a natural extension of the weak supplementation principle. These structural features suggest that quantum mereology, even when based on TPSs, should exhibit certain non-extensional behavior: what counts as a "part" is decomposition-relative in a stronger sense, with different decompositions allowed to be mutually incompatible. The resulting picture challenges extensional interpretations of quantum composition and underscores the need for a formally richer, genuinely non-classical mereology.

Entropy•Jun 2, 2026•0 citations

Quantum mereology in finite quantum mechanics

Vladimir V. Kornyak

Any Hilbert space with composite dimension can be factored into a tensor product of smaller Hilbert spaces. This allows us to decompose a quantum system into subsystems. We propose a model based on finite quantum mechanics for a constructive study of such decompositions.

arXiv:2104.11992•Вестник Российского университета дружбы народов. Серия: Математика, информатика, физика•Nov 12, 2021•3 citations

Tensor-Product Structure and Entanglement from Resolved History Factorization: The Composite-Record Factorization of Binary Mechanics

Adam Alexander Dick

This is Paper 005 in the Anaxiomatic Mechanics / pq-Spacetime stack. It develops the emergence of tensor-product structure and entanglement within Binary Mechanics. Building on the preceding treatment of effective Hilbert-space representation, it asks why composite quantum systems are represented by tensor products and why nonseparable, entangled states naturally appear. The central claim is that tensor products are not primitive assumptions. They arise when a finite binary-mechanical boundary problem can be decomposed into separately addressable boundary regions whose completion labels can be tracked independently. In that case, the joint completion structure is represented by the tensor product of the corresponding effective Hilbert spaces. Product states require a stronger condition: the underlying resolved graph histories and their phase counts must also factor across the chosen decomposition. Entanglement appears when completion labels remain separately addressable, but the underlying history ensemble does not factor. This non-factorization may be caused by cross-boundary graph structure, shared closure constraints, polarity consistency conditions, or other finite boundary restrictions. In this view, entanglement is the effective Hilbert-space expression of a shared finite history structure rather than a mysterious additional quantum postulate. The paper also distinguishes exact tensor products from physically effective tensor-product decompositions. Exact factorization is an ideal case; in physical applications, tensor-product structure is expected to hold when cross-boundary history constraints are negligible at the scale of description. The result is a finite, graph-history account of composite quantum structure: distinguishable completion channels give effective Hilbert bases, independently addressable labels give tensor-product spaces, factorizing histories give product states, and non-factorizing histories give entanglement.

•Jun 15, 2026•0 citations

Comment on "On the emergence of preferred structures in quantum theory" by Soulas, Franzmann, and Di Biagio

Ovidiu Cristinel Stoica

This reply is also a friendly introduction to the impossibility of emergence of preferred structures from the Hamiltonian $\mathsf{H}$ and the unit vector $|ψ\rangle$ only. The obstructions to emergence are illustrated on the concrete construction of a tensor product structure (TPS) from Soulas et al., 2025 (arXiv:2512.07468v2). Soulas et al. offer their TPS as a counterexample to the proof from Stoica, 2022a (arXiv:2102.08620) that structures constructed only from $\mathsf{H}$ and $|ψ\rangle$ either contradict physical observations or can't describe them unambiguously. Soulas et al.'s construction of a unique TPS can't be both invariant and compatible with physical observations, so it can't be a counterexample. Its incompatibility becomes visible by examining how the relation between $|ψ(t)\rangle$ and the TPS, encoding the entanglement, changes in time. Therefore their TPS doesn't refute, but confirms (Stoica, 2022a). Besides this, since Soulas et al.'s method to construct preferred structures consists of choosing their invariants, by the same logic one could claim as well that the masses of elementary particles emerge uniquely just by fixing their values by hand. Soulas et al.'s construction is concrete and can illustrate the major obstructions for emergent structures, confirming them despite doing the best possible to avoid them. This makes it an excellent pedagogical tool to illustrate the trilemma, but also the relational and structural aspects of quantum theory and its symmetries.

quant-pharXiv:2603.07674•Mar 10, 2026•2 citations
As a contribution to the field of quantum mereology, we study how a change of tensor product structure in a finite-dimensional Hilbert space affects its entanglement properties. In particular, we ask whether, given a time-evolving state, there exists a tensor product structure in which no entanglement is generated. We give a concrete, constructive example of disentangling tensor product structure in the case of a C-NOT gate evolution between two qbits, before showing that this cannot be achieved for most time-evolving quantum states.
Mathematical foundation of the novel concept of quantum tensor product by Zanardi et al is rigorously established. The concept of relative quantum entanglement is naturally introduced and its meaning is made clear both mathematically and physically. For a finite or an infinite dimensional vector space WWW the so called tensor product partition (TPP) is introduced on End(W)End(W)End(W), the set of endmorphisms of WWW, and a natural correspondence is constructed between the set of TPP's of End(W)End(W)End(W) and the set of tensor product structures (TPS's) of WWW. As a byproduct, it is shown that an arbitrarily given wave function belonging to an n-dimensional Hilbert space, nnn being not a prime number, can be interpreted as a separable state with respect to some man-made TPS, and thus a quantum entangled state of a many-body system with respect to the "God-given" TPS can be regarded as a quantum state without entanglement in some sense. The concept of standard set of observables is also introduced to probe the underlying structure of the object TPP and to establish its connection with practical physical measurement.
This paper aims to lay some groundwork for a systematic framework for quantum mereology based on the tensor product structures (TPSs) of Hilbert space. While previous work has suggested that such a TPS-based mereology might conform to classical extensional mereology, we demonstrate that the space of all possible tensor product structures for a given Hilbert space lacks the lattice-theoretic structure characteristic of classical partitions. Specifically, we show that this space admits no canonical meet operation, thus violating the global validity of a natural extension of the weak supplementation principle. These structural features suggest that quantum mereology, even when based on TPSs, should exhibit certain non-extensional behavior: what counts as a "part" is decomposition-relative in a stronger sense, with different decompositions allowed to be mutually incompatible. The resulting picture challenges extensional interpretations of quantum composition and underscores the need for a formally richer, genuinely non-classical mereology.
This is Paper 005 in the Anaxiomatic Mechanics / pq-Spacetime stack. It develops the emergence of tensor-product structure and entanglement within Binary Mechanics. Building on the preceding treatment of effective Hilbert-space representation, it asks why composite quantum systems are represented by tensor products and why nonseparable, entangled states naturally appear. The central claim is that tensor products are not primitive assumptions. They arise when a finite binary-mechanical boundary problem can be decomposed into separately addressable boundary regions whose completion labels can be tracked independently. In that case, the joint completion structure is represented by the tensor product of the corresponding effective Hilbert spaces. Product states require a stronger condition: the underlying resolved graph histories and their phase counts must also factor across the chosen decomposition. Entanglement appears when completion labels remain separately addressable, but the underlying history ensemble does not factor. This non-factorization may be caused by cross-boundary graph structure, shared closure constraints, polarity consistency conditions, or other finite boundary restrictions. In this view, entanglement is the effective Hilbert-space expression of a shared finite history structure rather than a mysterious additional quantum postulate. The paper also distinguishes exact tensor products from physically effective tensor-product decompositions. Exact factorization is an ideal case; in physical applications, tensor-product structure is expected to hold when cross-boundary history constraints are negligible at the scale of description. The result is a finite, graph-history account of composite quantum structure: distinguishable completion channels give effective Hilbert bases, independently addressable labels give tensor-product spaces, factorizing histories give product states, and non-factorizing histories give entanglement.
This reply is also a friendly introduction to the impossibility of emergence of preferred structures from the Hamiltonian H\mathsf{H}H and the unit vector ∣ψ⟩|ψ\rangle∣ψ⟩ only. The obstructions to emergence are illustrated on the concrete construction of a tensor product structure (TPS) from Soulas et al., 2025 (arXiv:2512.07468v2). Soulas et al. offer their TPS as a counterexample to the proof from Stoica, 2022a (arXiv:2102.08620) that structures constructed only from H\mathsf{H}H and ∣ψ⟩|ψ\rangle∣ψ⟩ either contradict physical observations or can't describe them unambiguously. Soulas et al.'s construction of a unique TPS can't be both invariant and compatible with physical observations, so it can't be a counterexample. Its incompatibility becomes visible by examining how the relation between ∣ψ(t)⟩|ψ(t)\rangle∣ψ(t)⟩ and the TPS, encoding the entanglement, changes in time. Therefore their TPS doesn't refute, but confirms (Stoica, 2022a). Besides this, since Soulas et al.'s method to construct preferred structures consists of choosing their invariants, by the same logic one could claim as well that the masses of elementary particles emerge uniquely just by fixing their values by hand. Soulas et al.'s construction is concrete and can illustrate the major obstructions for emergent structures, confirming them despite doing the best possible to avoid them. This makes it an excellent pedagogical tool to illustrate the trilemma, but also the relational and structural aspects of quantum theory and its symmetries.