Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2506.17190 · Physical Review A

Comparison of spin-qubit architectures for quantum error-correcting codes

Mauricio Gutiérrez, Juan S. Rojas-Arias, David Obando, C. Y. Chang

Published May 28, 2026• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the performance of two quantum error-correcting codes, the surface code and the Bacon-Shor code, for implementation with spin qubits in silicon. In each case, we construct a logical qubit using a planar array of quantum dots, exploring two encoding schemes: one based solely on single-electron Zeeman qubits (Loss-DiVincenzo qubits), and a hybrid approach combining Zeeman and singlet-triplet qubits. For both codes, we evaluate key performance metrics, including logical state preparation fidelity and cycle-level error correction performance, using state-of-the-art experimental parameters. Our results show that the hybrid encoding consistently outperforms the pure Zeeman-qubit implementation. By identifying the dominant error mechanisms that limit quantum error correction performance, our study highlights concrete targets for improving spin qubit hardware and provides a path toward scalable fault-tolerant architectures. In particular, we find that the logical error rate is not limited by memory errors, but rather by gate errors, especially 1- and 2-qubit gate errors.

DOI
10.1103/qlw3-xk2f

Related papers

A fault-tolerant encoding for qubit-controlled collective spins

Charlotte Franke, Dorian A. Gangloff

Quantum error correction (QEC) is indispensable for scalable quantum computing, but implementing it with minimal hardware overhead remains a central challenge. Large spin systems with collective degrees of freedom offer a promising route to reducing the control complexity of qubit architectures while retaining a large Hilbert space for fault-tolerant encoding. However, existing proposals for logical gates and QEC in spin ensembles generally rely on inefficient higher-order interactions. Here we introduce spin-N-Cat codes, which encode logical qubits in superpositions of spin-coherent states and generalize bosonic Cat codes to the modular subspaces of permutationally symmetric spin ensembles. The code corrects collective and individual dephasing, excitation, and decay errors. We also present an efficient physical realization in central-spin systems, such as a quantum dot, where encoding, decoding, and a universal, fault-tolerant, and bias-preserving gate set are implemented using only first-order interactions. Numerical simulations demonstrate high logical fidelity under dephasing and excitation-decay noise, independent of noise bias, and that full QEC cycles are feasible with realistic microscopic parameters. For the large collective spins available in quantum dots, this translates into a substantial extension of coherence time. Our results establish spin-N-Cat codes as a scalable, hardware-efficient approach to QEC in spin-based quantum architectures.

quant-pharXiv:2603.15760•Mar 18, 2026•1 citation

A Silicon Surface Code Architecture Resilient Against Leakage Errors

Zhenyu Cai, Michael A. Fogarty, Simon Schaal +3 more

Spin qubits in silicon quantum dots are one of the most promising building blocks for large scale quantum computers thanks to their high qubit density and compatibility with the existing semiconductor technologies. High fidelity single-qubit gates exceeding the threshold of error correction codes like the surface code have been demonstrated, while two-qubit gates have reached 98% fidelity and are improving rapidly. However, there are other types of error --- such as charge leakage and propagation --- that may occur in quantum dot arrays and which cannot be corrected by quantum error correction codes, making them potentially damaging even when their probability is small. We propose a surface code architecture for silicon quantum dot spin qubits that is robust against leakage errors by incorporating multi-electron mediator dots. Charge leakage in the qubit dots is transferred to the mediator dots via charge relaxation processes and then removed using charge reservoirs attached to the mediators. A stabiliser-check cycle, optimised for our hardware, then removes the correlations between the residual physical errors. Through simulations we obtain the surface code threshold for the charge leakage errors and show that in our architecture the damage due to charge leakage errors is reduced to a similar level to that of the usual depolarising gate noise. Spin leakage errors in our architecture are constrained to only ancilla qubits and can be removed during quantum error correction via reinitialisations of ancillae, which ensure the robustness of our architecture against spin leakage as well. Our use of an elongated mediator dots creates spaces throughout the quantum dot array for charge reservoirs, measuring devices and control gates, providing the scalability in the design.

arXiv:1904.10378•Quantum•Dec 9, 2019•21 citations

Erasure conversion for singlet-triplet spin qubits enables high-performance shuttling-based quantum error correction

Adam Siegel, Simon Benjamin

Fast and high fidelity shuttling of spin qubits has been demonstrated in semiconductor quantum dot devices. Several architectures based on shuttling have been proposed; it has been suggested that singlet-triplet (dual-spin) qubits could be optimal for the highest shuttling fidelities. Here we present a fault-tolerant framework for quantum error correction based on such dual-spin qubits, establishing them as a natural realisation of erasure qubits within semiconductor architectures. We introduce a hardware-efficient leakage-detection protocol that automatically projects leaked qubits back onto the computational subspace, without the need for measurement feedback or increased classical control overheads. When combined with the XZZX surface code and leakage-aware decoding, we demonstrate a twofold increase in the error correction threshold and achieve orders-of-magnitude reductions in logical error rates. This establishes the singlet-triplet encoding as a practical route toward high-fidelity shuttling and erasure-based, fault-tolerant quantum computation in semiconductor devices.

quant-pharXiv:2601.10461•Jan 16, 2026•2 citations

Entangling logical qubits without physical operations

Jin Ming Koh, Anqi Gong, Andrei C. Diaconu +6 more

Fault-tolerant logical entangling gates are essential for scalable quantum computing, but are limited by the error rates and overheads of physical two-qubit gates and measurements. To address this limitation, we introduce phantom codes-quantum error-correcting codes that realize entangling gates between all logical qubits in a code block purely through relabelling of physical qubits during compilation, yielding perfect fidelity with no spatial or temporal overhead. We present a systematic study of such codes. First, we identify phantom codes using complementary numerical and analytical approaches. We exhaustively enumerate all $2.71 \times 10^{10}$ inequivalent CSS codes up to $n=14$ and identify additional instances up to $n=21$ via SAT-based methods. We then construct higher-distance phantom-code families using quantum Reed-Muller codes and the binarization of qudit codes. Across all identified codes, we characterize other supported fault-tolerant logical Clifford and non-Clifford operations. Second, through end-to-end noisy simulations with state preparation, full QEC cycles, and realistic physical error rates, we demonstrate scalable advantages of phantom codes over the surface code across multiple tasks. We observe a one-to-two order-of-magnitude reduction in logical infidelity at comparable qubit overhead for GHZ-state preparation and Trotterized many-body simulation tasks, given a modest preselection acceptance rate. Our work establishes phantom codes as a viable architectural route to fault-tolerant quantum computation with scalable benefits for workloads with dense local entangling structure, and introduces general tools for systematically exploring the broader landscape of quantum error-correcting codes.

quant-pharXiv:2601.20927•Jan 30, 2026•27 citations

Design and Simulation of Quantum Error Correction Codes for Scalable Quantum Architectures

Sai Srinivas Vellela, NagaMalleswara Rao Purimetla, A. Shri Vindhya +3 more

Quantum computing can transform a great deal and this may be in the realms of cryptography, optimisation, as well as material science. However, it requires decoherence and gate imperfection which introduces large error rates thus are difficult to implement. The solution to these problems is a fundamental skill of making computing fault-tolerant by means of Quantum Error Correction Codes (QECCs). This paper gives a comparison of three common QECCs namely Shor, Steane and Surface Codes as well as creating a new Hybrid Code by combining the most desirable characteristics of the concatenated and topological codes. The Hybrid Code was executed and tried out with the Qiskit software where real depolarising noise models were utilised. It showed better performance in terms of logical fidelity, error rate suppression, resource overhead, and execution time. The results of the simulation show that the Hybrid Code always does better than traditional codes. This means that it might be used in scalable quantum structures. The work shows how important it is to balance performance and complexity, and it gives a useful model for the next generation of quantum error correction systems.

International Conference on Innovative Data Communication Technologies and Application (ICIDCA)•Oct 6, 2025•0 citations

A manufacturable surface code architecture for spin qubits with fast transversal logic

Jason D. Chadwick, Willers Yang, Joshua Viszlai +1 more

Spin qubits in silicon quantum dot arrays are a promising quantum computation platform for long-term scalability due to their small qubit footprint and compatibility with advanced semiconductor manufacturing. However, spin qubit devices face a key architectural bottleneck: the large physical footprint of readout components relative to qubits prevents a dense layout where all qubits can be measured simultaneously, complicating the implementation of quantum error correction. This challenge is offset by the platform's unique rapid shuttling capability, which can be used to transport qubits to distant readout ports. In this work, we explore the design constraints and capabilities of spin qubits in silicon and propose the SNAQ (Shuttling-capable Narrow Array of spin Qubits) surface code architecture, which relaxes the 1:1 readout-to-qubit assumption by leveraging spin shuttling to time-multiplex ancilla qubit initialization and readout. Our analysis shows that, given sufficiently high (experimentally demonstrated) qubit coherence times, SNAQ delivers an orders-of-magnitude reduction in chip area per logical qubit. Additionally, by using a denser grid of physical qubits, SNAQ enables fast transversal logic for short-distance logical operations, achieving over 10x improvement in local logical clock speed while still supporting global operations via lattice surgery. This translates to a 3.2-5.7x improvement in key Adder and Lookup fault-tolerant subroutines. Our work pinpoints critical hardware metrics and provides a compelling path toward high-performance fault-tolerant computation on near-term-manufacturable spin qubit arrays.

quant-pharXiv:2512.07131•Dec 9, 2025•7 citations
We investigate the performance of two quantum error-correcting codes, the surface code and the Bacon-Shor code, for implementation with spin qubits in silicon. In each case, we construct a logical qubit using a planar array of quantum dots, exploring two encoding schemes: one based solely on single-electron Zeeman qubits (Loss-DiVincenzo qubits), and a hybrid approach combining Zeeman and singlet-triplet qubits. For both codes, we evaluate key performance metrics, including logical state preparation fidelity and cycle-level error correction performance, using state-of-the-art experimental parameters. Our results show that the hybrid encoding consistently outperforms the pure Zeeman-qubit implementation. By identifying the dominant error mechanisms that limit quantum error correction performance, our study highlights concrete targets for improving spin qubit hardware and provides a path toward scalable fault-tolerant architectures. In particular, we find that the logical error rate is not limited by memory errors, but rather by gate errors, especially 1- and 2-qubit gate errors.
Quantum error correction (QEC) is indispensable for scalable quantum computing, but implementing it with minimal hardware overhead remains a central challenge. Large spin systems with collective degrees of freedom offer a promising route to reducing the control complexity of qubit architectures while retaining a large Hilbert space for fault-tolerant encoding. However, existing proposals for logical gates and QEC in spin ensembles generally rely on inefficient higher-order interactions. Here we introduce spin-N-Cat codes, which encode logical qubits in superpositions of spin-coherent states and generalize bosonic Cat codes to the modular subspaces of permutationally symmetric spin ensembles. The code corrects collective and individual dephasing, excitation, and decay errors. We also present an efficient physical realization in central-spin systems, such as a quantum dot, where encoding, decoding, and a universal, fault-tolerant, and bias-preserving gate set are implemented using only first-order interactions. Numerical simulations demonstrate high logical fidelity under dephasing and excitation-decay noise, independent of noise bias, and that full QEC cycles are feasible with realistic microscopic parameters. For the large collective spins available in quantum dots, this translates into a substantial extension of coherence time. Our results establish spin-N-Cat codes as a scalable, hardware-efficient approach to QEC in spin-based quantum architectures.
Spin qubits in silicon quantum dots are one of the most promising building blocks for large scale quantum computers thanks to their high qubit density and compatibility with the existing semiconductor technologies. High fidelity single-qubit gates exceeding the threshold of error correction codes like the surface code have been demonstrated, while two-qubit gates have reached 98% fidelity and are improving rapidly. However, there are other types of error --- such as charge leakage and propagation --- that may occur in quantum dot arrays and which cannot be corrected by quantum error correction codes, making them potentially damaging even when their probability is small. We propose a surface code architecture for silicon quantum dot spin qubits that is robust against leakage errors by incorporating multi-electron mediator dots. Charge leakage in the qubit dots is transferred to the mediator dots via charge relaxation processes and then removed using charge reservoirs attached to the mediators. A stabiliser-check cycle, optimised for our hardware, then removes the correlations between the residual physical errors. Through simulations we obtain the surface code threshold for the charge leakage errors and show that in our architecture the damage due to charge leakage errors is reduced to a similar level to that of the usual depolarising gate noise. Spin leakage errors in our architecture are constrained to only ancilla qubits and can be removed during quantum error correction via reinitialisations of ancillae, which ensure the robustness of our architecture against spin leakage as well. Our use of an elongated mediator dots creates spaces throughout the quantum dot array for charge reservoirs, measuring devices and control gates, providing the scalability in the design.
Fast and high fidelity shuttling of spin qubits has been demonstrated in semiconductor quantum dot devices. Several architectures based on shuttling have been proposed; it has been suggested that singlet-triplet (dual-spin) qubits could be optimal for the highest shuttling fidelities. Here we present a fault-tolerant framework for quantum error correction based on such dual-spin qubits, establishing them as a natural realisation of erasure qubits within semiconductor architectures. We introduce a hardware-efficient leakage-detection protocol that automatically projects leaked qubits back onto the computational subspace, without the need for measurement feedback or increased classical control overheads. When combined with the XZZX surface code and leakage-aware decoding, we demonstrate a twofold increase in the error correction threshold and achieve orders-of-magnitude reductions in logical error rates. This establishes the singlet-triplet encoding as a practical route toward high-fidelity shuttling and erasure-based, fault-tolerant quantum computation in semiconductor devices.
Fault-tolerant logical entangling gates are essential for scalable quantum computing, but are limited by the error rates and overheads of physical two-qubit gates and measurements. To address this limitation, we introduce phantom codes-quantum error-correcting codes that realize entangling gates between all logical qubits in a code block purely through relabelling of physical qubits during compilation, yielding perfect fidelity with no spatial or temporal overhead. We present a systematic study of such codes. First, we identify phantom codes using complementary numerical and analytical approaches. We exhaustively enumerate all 2.71×10102.71 \times 10^{10}2.71×1010 inequivalent CSS codes up to n=14n=14n=14 and identify additional instances up to n=21n=21n=21 via SAT-based methods. We then construct higher-distance phantom-code families using quantum Reed-Muller codes and the binarization of qudit codes. Across all identified codes, we characterize other supported fault-tolerant logical Clifford and non-Clifford operations. Second, through end-to-end noisy simulations with state preparation, full QEC cycles, and realistic physical error rates, we demonstrate scalable advantages of phantom codes over the surface code across multiple tasks. We observe a one-to-two order-of-magnitude reduction in logical infidelity at comparable qubit overhead for GHZ-state preparation and Trotterized many-body simulation tasks, given a modest preselection acceptance rate. Our work establishes phantom codes as a viable architectural route to fault-tolerant quantum computation with scalable benefits for workloads with dense local entangling structure, and introduces general tools for systematically exploring the broader landscape of quantum error-correcting codes.
Quantum computing can transform a great deal and this may be in the realms of cryptography, optimisation, as well as material science. However, it requires decoherence and gate imperfection which introduces large error rates thus are difficult to implement. The solution to these problems is a fundamental skill of making computing fault-tolerant by means of Quantum Error Correction Codes (QECCs). This paper gives a comparison of three common QECCs namely Shor, Steane and Surface Codes as well as creating a new Hybrid Code by combining the most desirable characteristics of the concatenated and topological codes. The Hybrid Code was executed and tried out with the Qiskit software where real depolarising noise models were utilised. It showed better performance in terms of logical fidelity, error rate suppression, resource overhead, and execution time. The results of the simulation show that the Hybrid Code always does better than traditional codes. This means that it might be used in scalable quantum structures. The work shows how important it is to balance performance and complexity, and it gives a useful model for the next generation of quantum error correction systems.
Spin qubits in silicon quantum dot arrays are a promising quantum computation platform for long-term scalability due to their small qubit footprint and compatibility with advanced semiconductor manufacturing. However, spin qubit devices face a key architectural bottleneck: the large physical footprint of readout components relative to qubits prevents a dense layout where all qubits can be measured simultaneously, complicating the implementation of quantum error correction. This challenge is offset by the platform's unique rapid shuttling capability, which can be used to transport qubits to distant readout ports. In this work, we explore the design constraints and capabilities of spin qubits in silicon and propose the SNAQ (Shuttling-capable Narrow Array of spin Qubits) surface code architecture, which relaxes the 1:1 readout-to-qubit assumption by leveraging spin shuttling to time-multiplex ancilla qubit initialization and readout. Our analysis shows that, given sufficiently high (experimentally demonstrated) qubit coherence times, SNAQ delivers an orders-of-magnitude reduction in chip area per logical qubit. Additionally, by using a denser grid of physical qubits, SNAQ enables fast transversal logic for short-distance logical operations, achieving over 10x improvement in local logical clock speed while still supporting global operations via lattice surgery. This translates to a 3.2-5.7x improvement in key Adder and Lookup fault-tolerant subroutines. Our work pinpoints critical hardware metrics and provides a compelling path toward high-performance fault-tolerant computation on near-term-manufacturable spin qubit arrays.