Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2506.16525 · Physical Review Research

Update of Hartree-Fock theory for Hubbard-like models

Edwin Langmann A, Jonatan Lenells

Published Apr 25, 2026• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We show that the standard textbook description of (restricted) Hartree-Fock theory for (Fermi) Hubbard-like models is in need of an update, and we present such an update allowing us to correct basic and established results in the condensed matter physics literature that are qualitatively wrong. Our update amounts to adding a test that reliably checks the thermodynamic stability of solutions of Hartree-Fock equations. This stability test makes it possible to detect, by simple means and with certainty, regions in phase space where the model exhibits mixed phases where two conventional phases coexist and translation invariance is broken in complicated ways; in such a mixed phase, unconventional physics is to be expected. Our results show that mixed phases are ubiquitous in Hubbard-like models in arbitrary dimensions.

DOI
10.1103/qyz3-cwmn

Related papers

Mixed phases in a Fermi--Hubbard model describing altermagnetism

Edwin Langmann A, Jonatan Lenells

We study an extension of the 2D Fermi--Hubbard model, which was recently introduced in [Das et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 263402 (2024)] and shown to describe altermagnetism that can be studied in cold atom systems. Using an updated Hartree--Fock method that can detect instabilities towards phase separation, we show that the model is in a mixed phase in large parts of the parameter regime at half-filling. We argue that the occurrence of a mixed phase is an indication of exotic physics which, in this model, occurs in parameter regimes accessible in cold atom experiments.

arXiv:2506.16503•Jun 19, 2025•1 citation

On the Hartree-Fock phase diagram for the two-dimensional Hubbard model

Christophe Charlier, Edwin Langmann A, Jonatan Lenells

We propose an analytical method for the construction of Hartree-Fock phase diagrams for the (fermion) Hubbard model and various generalizations thereof. Such phase diagrams are traditionally constructed numerically, but we argue that, by using asymptotic techniques, it is possible to obtain analytic formulas approximating the curves separating the different phases to very high accuracy. To illustrate the new method, we apply it to the two-dimensional Hubbard model on the square lattice at zero temperature. This yields formulas for the Hartree-Fock phase boundaries that agree with, but also improve on, earlier numerical results. In particular, our results provide the first rigorous proof of the existence of mixed phases in this model.

arXiv:2512.20441•Dec 23, 2025•1 citation

Comparison of mean-field theories of an extended Hubbard model

S. N. Coppersmith, P. B. Littlewood

Models of strongly interacting Fermi systems are sufficiently intractable that simple mean-field approximations (typically Hartree-Fock) are often employed to obtain qualitative insight into their properties, and also to set parameter values by comparing with band-structure calculations. However, if the correlations are accounted for with use of more sophisticated (but still mean-field-like) methods, qualitative changes in charge densities and magnetic properties can result. We compare four ``mean-field'' approximations for an extended Hubbard model and show that they yield quite different results. Implications for the choice of model for high-temperature superconductors are discussed.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Sep 1, 1990•3 citations

The two-dimensional Hubbard model in the Hartree-Fock approximation

Fernando O. Freire, Cláudio Andrade Macedo

The students interested in the study of strongly correlated electron systems normally feel, in the beginning  of their studies, a great difficulty in understanding the complex correlations of these systems. We consider  that for these students it is very important to have texts that analyze pedagogically the theoretical research  methods of the subject. We show how to determine the thermodynamic properties of the Hubbard model  for the two-dimensional square lattice, utilizing the Hartree-Fock approximation. All the procedures and  peculiarities which lead to the determination of the thermodynamic properties and to the comprehension  of the meaning of the Hartree-Fock approximation applied to models of strongly correlated electron  systems are pedagogically presented in detail. We obtain the magnetization, the magnetic susceptibility,  the internal energy, the specific heat, and also a magnetic phase diagram of the studied system. Our  approach clearly shows that the use of the Hartree-Fock approximation, in this case, is very simple.

Scientia Plena•Jan 1, 2008•0 citations

Hartree–Fock and random phase approximation theories in a many-fermion solvable model

Giampaolo Co', Stefano De Leo

We present an ideal system of interacting fermions where the solutions of the many-body Schrödinger equation can be obtained without making approximations. These exact solutions are used to test the validity of two many-body effective approaches, the Hartree–Fock and the random phase approximation theories. The description of the ground state done by the effective theories improves with increasing number of particles.

arXiv:1601.02418•Modern Physics Letters A•Oct 13, 2015•8 citations

Hartree Fock and RPA studies of the Hubbard model

F. Guinea, E. Louis, José Antonio Vergés

The applicability of the Hartree-Fock and random phase approximations to models of strongly correlated electrons is discussed. The 2D Hubbard model is analyzed. An antiferromagnetic phase (at half filling) and Fermi liquid behavior (at low electron densities) are found. In addition, the system shows an unconventional regime near half filling. It is characterized by the formation of spin and charge textures. Local magnetic moments and spin waves are also present, and the quasiparticle pole at the Fermi energy vanishes. The charge excitation spectrum is gapless. The overall features resemble those of the 1D Luttinger liquid.

arXiv:cond-mat/9401057•Jan 26, 1994•1 citation
We show that the standard textbook description of (restricted) Hartree-Fock theory for (Fermi) Hubbard-like models is in need of an update, and we present such an update allowing us to correct basic and established results in the condensed matter physics literature that are qualitatively wrong. Our update amounts to adding a test that reliably checks the thermodynamic stability of solutions of Hartree-Fock equations. This stability test makes it possible to detect, by simple means and with certainty, regions in phase space where the model exhibits mixed phases where two conventional phases coexist and translation invariance is broken in complicated ways; in such a mixed phase, unconventional physics is to be expected. Our results show that mixed phases are ubiquitous in Hubbard-like models in arbitrary dimensions.
We study an extension of the 2D Fermi--Hubbard model, which was recently introduced in [Das et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 263402 (2024)] and shown to describe altermagnetism that can be studied in cold atom systems. Using an updated Hartree--Fock method that can detect instabilities towards phase separation, we show that the model is in a mixed phase in large parts of the parameter regime at half-filling. We argue that the occurrence of a mixed phase is an indication of exotic physics which, in this model, occurs in parameter regimes accessible in cold atom experiments.
We propose an analytical method for the construction of Hartree-Fock phase diagrams for the (fermion) Hubbard model and various generalizations thereof. Such phase diagrams are traditionally constructed numerically, but we argue that, by using asymptotic techniques, it is possible to obtain analytic formulas approximating the curves separating the different phases to very high accuracy. To illustrate the new method, we apply it to the two-dimensional Hubbard model on the square lattice at zero temperature. This yields formulas for the Hartree-Fock phase boundaries that agree with, but also improve on, earlier numerical results. In particular, our results provide the first rigorous proof of the existence of mixed phases in this model.
Models of strongly interacting Fermi systems are sufficiently intractable that simple mean-field approximations (typically Hartree-Fock) are often employed to obtain qualitative insight into their properties, and also to set parameter values by comparing with band-structure calculations. However, if the correlations are accounted for with use of more sophisticated (but still mean-field-like) methods, qualitative changes in charge densities and magnetic properties can result. We compare four ``mean-field'' approximations for an extended Hubbard model and show that they yield quite different results. Implications for the choice of model for high-temperature superconductors are discussed.
The students interested in the study of strongly correlated electron systems normally feel, in the beginning  of their studies, a great difficulty in understanding the complex correlations of these systems. We consider  that for these students it is very important to have texts that analyze pedagogically the theoretical research  methods of the subject. We show how to determine the thermodynamic properties of the Hubbard model  for the two-dimensional square lattice, utilizing the Hartree-Fock approximation. All the procedures and  peculiarities which lead to the determination of the thermodynamic properties and to the comprehension  of the meaning of the Hartree-Fock approximation applied to models of strongly correlated electron  systems are pedagogically presented in detail. We obtain the magnetization, the magnetic susceptibility,  the internal energy, the specific heat, and also a magnetic phase diagram of the studied system. Our  approach clearly shows that the use of the Hartree-Fock approximation, in this case, is very simple.
The applicability of the Hartree-Fock and random phase approximations to models of strongly correlated electrons is discussed. The 2D Hubbard model is analyzed. An antiferromagnetic phase (at half filling) and Fermi liquid behavior (at low electron densities) are found. In addition, the system shows an unconventional regime near half filling. It is characterized by the formation of spin and charge textures. Local magnetic moments and spin waves are also present, and the quasiparticle pole at the Fermi energy vanishes. The charge excitation spectrum is gapless. The overall features resemble those of the 1D Luttinger liquid.