The realisation of Bose-Einstein condensation under grand-canonical conditions has provided the experimental evidence for the simultaneous occurrence of macroscopic fluctuations and phase coherence of the condensate. The observation of these two features, against a consolidated tradition which wants the fluctuations to be pathological (grand-canonical catastrophe) and incompatible with spontaneous symmetry braking, calls for a comprehensive rethinking of the approach to the problem. In this paper we consider the uniform ideal gas in a box and we present an alternative conceptual framework. We show that the usually-employed Bogoliubov quasi-average construction fails to reproduce the broken-symmetry state. The observed features are accounted for by a different pattern of spontaneous symmetry breaking, characterised by condensation of fluctuations and long-range correlations of the order parameter.
The realisation of Bose-Einstein condensation under grand-canonical conditions has provided the experimental evidence for the simultaneous occurrence of macroscopic fluctuations and phase coherence of the condensate. The observation of these two features, against a consolidated tradition which wants the fluctuations to be pathological (grand-canonical catastrophe) and incompatible with spontaneous symmetry braking, calls for a comprehensive rethinking of the approach to the problem. In this paper we consider the uniform ideal gas in a box and we present an alternative conceptual framework. We show that the usually-employed Bogoliubov quasi-average construction fails to reproduce the broken-symmetry state. The observed features are accounted for by a different pattern of spontaneous symmetry breaking, characterised by condensation of fluctuations and long-range correlations of the order parameter.
Abstract Particle fluctuations in systems, exhibiting Bose–Einstein condensation, are reviewed in order to clarify the basic points that attract high interest and often confront misunderstanding. It is explained that the so-called ‘grand canonical catastrophe’, claiming the occurrence of catastrophic particle fluctuations in the condensed phase, treated by grand canonical ensemble, does not exist. What exists is the incorrect use of the grand canonical ensemble, where gauge symmetry is not broken, while the correct description of the condensed phase necessarily requires gauge symmetry breaking. The ideal Bose gas has no catastrophic condensate fluctuations, and moreover there are no condensate fluctuations at all, as soon as gauge symmetry is broken. However it does have anomalous fluctuations of uncondensed particles, which implies its instability. For interacting particles, there are no condensate fluctuations, as soon as gauge symmetry is broken, and anomalous fluctuations of uncondensed particles, when correctly calculated, do not appear. Particle fluctuations in the systems of trapped atoms are discussed. Canonical ensemble and grand canonical ensemble with broken gauge symmetry are equivalent with respect to the number of particle scaling.
Abstract Despite the long history of the theory of Bose-Einstein condensation, there exist till nowadays some slippery points that are often misunderstood and result in confusion. The report touches some of these points, explaining the following: Global gauge symmetry breaking is the necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of Bose-Einstein condensate. There is no any “grand canonical catastrophe”. The stability of the ideal Bose gas depends on the spatial dimensionality and the shape of a trap. Symmetry-broken averages cannot be neglected. The so-called “Popov approximation”, ascribed to Popov, suggesting to neglect anomalous averages, is neither an approximation nor has anything to do with Popov. There are no thermodynamically anomalous fluctuations in stable equilibrium systems. Representative statistical ensembles are equivalent.
Despite the long history of the theory of Bose-Einstein condensation, there exist till nowadays some slippery points that are often misunderstood and result in confusion. The report touches some of these points, explaining the following: Global gauge symmetry breaking is the necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of Bose-Einstein condensate. There is no any ``grand canonical catastrophe". The stability of the ideal Bose gas depends on the spatial dimensionality and the shape of a trap. Symmetry-broken averages cannot be neglected. The so-called ``Popov approximation", ascribed to Popov, suggesting to neglect anomalous averages, is neither an approximation nor has anything to do with Popov. There are no thermodynamically anomalous fluctuations in stable equilibrium systems. Representative statistical ensembles are equivalent.
Abstract Due to high current interest to Bose–Einstein condensation (BEC), the related topics, such as spontaneous gauge symmetry breaking, ergodic decomposition, and particle fluctuations, are intensively discussed in literature. These discussions, unfortunately, involve quite a number of controversies and confusions. The goal of the present brief survey is to clarify some of these confusions, concentrating on the principal points, such as the relationship between the conditions of BEC, the Bogolubov method of quasiaverages, spontaneous gauge symmetry breaking, ergodic decomposition, the presumed existence of nonthermodynamic particle fluctuations leading to the so-called ‘grand canonical catastrophe’, and the requirements for system stability.
Bose-Einstein condensation in the grand canonical ensemble admits a formulation in terms of a phase-density decomposition of the condensate mode operator ψ^0. In the presence of macroscopic condensate number fluctuations this representation presents nontrivial implications. In particular, we show that, for the ideal gas, under the assumption of a well-defined phase and a fluctuating condensate density, the square modulus of the anomalous average ⟨ψ^0⟩ can provide only a fraction of the whole condensate density ρ0 and for the grand canonical statistics of the ideal Bose gas one obtains the value ∣⟨ψ^0⟩∣2=(π/4)ρ0. The remaining part is supplemented by the (macroscopic) fluctuations of ψ^0, which become a distinctive feature of the BEC in this setting. This provides a transparent physical picture of a condensate of photons with a well-defined phase but large number fluctuations, as observed in dye-filled microcavity photon experiments. We also propose a way to access the square modulus of the anomalous average to test theoretical predictions.
The question of whether Bose-Einstein condensation involves spontaneous symmetry breaking is surprisingly controversial. We review the theory of spontaneous symmetry breaking in ferromagnets, compare it with the theory of symmetry breaking in condensates, and discuss the different viewpoints on the correspondence to experiments. These viewpoints include alternative perspectives in which we can treat condensates with fixed particle numbers, and where coherence arises from measurements. This question relates to whether condensates of quasiparticles such as polaritons can be viewed as “real” condensates. Introduction Spontaneous symmetry breaking is a deep subject in physics with long historical roots. At the most basic level, it arises in the field of cosmology. Physicists have long had an aesthetic principle that leads us to expect symmetry in the all of the basic equations of physical law. Yet the universe is manifestly full of asymmetries. How does a symmetric system acquire asymmetry merely by evolving in time? Starting in the 1950s, cosmologists began to borrow the ideas of spontaneous symmetry breaking from condensed matter physics, which were originally developed to explain spontaneous magnetization in ferromagnetic systems. Spontaneous coherence in all its forms (e.g., Bose-Einstein condensation [BEC], superconductivity, and lasing) can be viewed as another type of symmetry breaking. The Hamiltonian of the system is symmetric, yet under some conditions, the energy of the system can be reduced by putting the system into a state with asymmetry, namely, a state with a common phase for a macroscopic number of particles. The symmetry of the system implies that it does not matter what the exact choice of that phase is, as long as it is the same for all the particles. It is not obvious, however, whether the symmetry breaking which occurs in spontaneous coherence of the type seen in lasers or in Bose-Einstein condensation is the same as that seen in ferromagnetic systems. There are similarities in the systems which encourage the same view of all types of symmetry breaking, but there are also differences. In fact, there is a substantial school of thought that symmetry breaking in Bose-Einstein condensates with ultracold atoms is a “convenient fiction” (a term applied to optical coherence by Mølmer [1]).