Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2505.14375 · Annals of Physics

Approximate Wigner approach to Coulomb entanglement

Mauro Ballicchia, Clemens Etl, Mihail Nedjalkov, David K. Ferry, Hans Kosina, Josef Weinbub

Published Jan 21, 2026• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The electric interaction between two nearby evolving electrons triggers the correlation between their waves and governs the operation of logical devices called Coulomb entanglers. Of technological interest, in the presence of magnetic fields, are multi-spatial evolution scenarios beyond pure state descriptions. The two-electron density matrix becomes eight-dimensional even for two-dimensional spatial cases, and is thus computationally prohibitive. In this work, we present two new approximations of the two-electron Wigner equation that aim at computational feasibility: a BBGKY approach for reducing the number of variables and a field approximation of the Coulomb-Wigner operator. They exhibit different conceptual aspects that illustrate alternative viewpoints on entanglement: only the evolution provided by the latter model satisfies the orthodox definition of entanglement. Our analysis, based on the Fredholm integral representation of the models, allows us to develop an intuitive picture and physical insight into the process.

DOI
10.1016/j.aop.2026.170356

Related papers

A computational approach for investigating Coulomb interaction using Wigner–Poisson coupling

Majid Benam, Mauro Ballicchia, Josef Weinbub +2 more

Entangled quantum particles, in which operating on one particle instantaneously influences the state of the entangled particle, are attractive options for carrying quantum information at the nanoscale. However, fully-describing entanglement in traditional time-dependent quantum transport simulation approaches requires significant computational effort, bordering on being prohibitive. Considering electrons, one approach to analyzing their entanglement is through modeling the Coulomb interaction via the Wigner formalism. In this work, we reduce the computational complexity of the time evolution of two interacting electrons by resorting to reasonable approximations. In particular, we replace the Wigner potential of the electron-electron interaction by a local electrostatic field, which is introduced through the spectral decomposition of the potential. It is demonstrated that for some particular configurations of an electron-electron system, the introduced approximations are feasible. Purity, identified as the maximal coherence for a quantum state, is also analyzed and its corresponding analysis demonstrates that the entanglement due to the Coulomb interaction is well accounted for by the introduced local approximation.

Journal of Computational Electronics•Jan 21, 2021•12 citations

Spin operator and entanglement in quantum field theory

Kazuo Fujikawa, C. H. Oh, Chengjie Zhang

Entanglement is studied in the framework of Dyson's S-matrix theory in relativistic quantum field theory, which leads to a natural definition of entangled states of a particle-antiparticle pair and the spin operator from a Noether current. As an explicit example, the decay of a massive pseudo-scalar particle into a pair of electron and positron is analyzed. Two spin operators are extracted from the Noether current. The Wigner spin operator characterizes spin states at the rest frame of each fermion and, although not measurable in the laboratory, gives rise to a straightforward generalization of low-energy analysis of entanglement to the ultrarelativistic domain. In contrast, if one adopts a (modified) Dirac spin operator, the entanglement measured by spin correlation becomes maximal near the threshold of the decay, while the entanglement is replaced by the classical correlation for the ultrarelativistic electron-positron pair by analogy to the case of neutrinos, for which a hidden-variables type of description is possible. Chiral symmetry differentiates the spin angular momentum and the magnetic moment. The use of weak interaction that can measure helicity is suggested in the analysis of entanglement at high energies instead of a Stern-Gerlach apparatus, which is useless for the electron. A difference between the electron spin at high energies and the photon linear polarization is also noted. The Standard Model can describe all of the observable properties of leptons.

arXiv:1312.0326•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jul 22, 2014•10 citations

Gauge-invariant semidiscrete Wigner theory

Mihail Nedjalkov, Mauro Ballicchia, Robert Kosik +1 more

A gauge-invariant Wigner quantum mechanical theory is obtained by applying the Weyl-Stratonovich transform to the von Neumann equation for the density matrix. The transform reduces to the Weyl transform in the electrostatic limit, when the vector potential and thus the magnetic field are zero. Both cases involve a center-of-mass transform followed by a Fourier integral on the relative coordinate introducing the momentum variable. The latter is continuous if the limits of the integral are infinite or, equivalently, the coherence length is infinite. However, the quantum theory involves Fourier transforms of the electromagnetic field components, which imposes conditions on their behavior at infinity. Conversely, quantum systems are bounded and often very small, as is, for instance, the case in modern nanoelectronics. This implies a finite coherence length, which avoids the need to regularize nonconverging Fourier integrals. Accordingly, the momentum space becomes discrete, giving rise to momentum quantization and to a semidiscrete gauge-invariant Wigner equation. To gain insights into the peculiarities of this theory one needs to analyze the equation for specific electromagnetic conditions. We derive the evolution equation for the linear electromagnetic case and show that it significantly simplifies for a limit dictated by the long coherence length behavior, which involves momentum derivatives. In the discrete momentum picture these derivatives are presented by finite difference quantities which, together with further approximations, allow to develop a computationally feasible model that offers physical insights into the involved quantum processes. In particular, a Fredholm integral equation of the second kind is obtained, where the ``power'' of the kernel components, measuring their rate of modification of the quantum evolution, can be evaluated.

arXiv:2208.09208•Physical Review A•Nov 22, 2022•10 citations

Wigner localization in two and three dimensions: An ab initio approach

Miguel Escobar Azor, Estefania Alves, Stefano Evangelisti +1 more

In this work, we investigate the Wigner localization of two interacting electrons at very low density in two and three dimensions using the exact diagonalization of the many-body Hamiltonian. We use our recently developed method based on Clifford periodic boundary conditions with a renormalized distance in the Coulomb potential. To accurately represent the electronic wave function, we use a regular distribution in space of Gaussian-type orbitals and we take advantage of the translational symmetry of the system to efficiently calculate the electronic wave function. We are thus able to accurately describe the wave function up to very low density. We validate our approach by comparing our results to a semi-classical model that becomes exact in the low-density limit. With our approach, we are able to observe the Wigner localization without ambiguity.

arXiv:2107.05321•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Sep 28, 2021•12 citations

DYNAMICS OF ENTANGLEMENT FOR TWO-ELECTRON ATOMS

Omar Osenda, Pablo Serra, Sabre Kais

We studied the dynamics of the entanglement for two electron atoms with initial states created from a superposition of the eigenstates of the two-electron Hamiltonian. We present numerical evidence that the pairwise entanglement for the two electrons evolves in a way that is strongly related with the time evolution of the Coulombic interaction between the two electrons.

International Journal of Quantum Information•Apr 1, 2008•8 citations

Computational Aspects of the One Body Reduced Density Matrix Functional Theory

Nicolas G. Cartier

From drug design to material science, computational chemistry has become a valuable tool for many fields of applications in the past decades. Quantum chemistry in particular, can provide accurate descriptions of molecules and solids by relying on principles of quantum mechanics with the Schrödinger equation at its core. Unfortunately this equation becomes prohibitively expensive to solve for systems made of more than a few electrons and one has to rely on other approaches. Among the most popular is Density Functional Theory, relatively inexpensive and exact in principle. One has, however, to introduce approximations in practice, deteriorating its accuracy for challenging, so-called strongly correlated, systems. On the contrary, other methods like CASSCF remain reliable for these systems, but although cheaper than the solution of the Schrödinger equation, remain too expensive for extended systems. There is therefore room for methods in between, that could handle large correlated systems with reasonable accuracy. One such method is the One Body Reduced Density Matrix (1-RDM) Functional Theory (RDMFT), based on the fact that an electronic system can, in principle exactly, be described by its 1-RDM only. Although its theory dates back to the 1970s, computational hindrances have prevented this method from shining so far. Indeed, computations in RDMFT rely on a constrained optimization of the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the 1-RDM, that can be reformulated as an unconstrained optimization by parameterizing the latter but in both cases suffers from convergence problems. In this thesis, the role of this parametrization is analyzed and motivates a now second order optimization algorithm, which improves the convergence speed by two orders of magnitude w.r.t. the state of the art algorithm. This understanding of the problem also inspires an alternative approach with the 1-RDM as the optimization variable. This however requires the development of new approximations and a first investigation in that direction, based on Machine Learning is performed. Lastly, a generalization of the method to excited states is attempted, highlighting some key computational challenges.

•Feb 22, 2026•0 citations
The electric interaction between two nearby evolving electrons triggers the correlation between their waves and governs the operation of logical devices called Coulomb entanglers. Of technological interest, in the presence of magnetic fields, are multi-spatial evolution scenarios beyond pure state descriptions. The two-electron density matrix becomes eight-dimensional even for two-dimensional spatial cases, and is thus computationally prohibitive. In this work, we present two new approximations of the two-electron Wigner equation that aim at computational feasibility: a BBGKY approach for reducing the number of variables and a field approximation of the Coulomb-Wigner operator. They exhibit different conceptual aspects that illustrate alternative viewpoints on entanglement: only the evolution provided by the latter model satisfies the orthodox definition of entanglement. Our analysis, based on the Fredholm integral representation of the models, allows us to develop an intuitive picture and physical insight into the process.
Entangled quantum particles, in which operating on one particle instantaneously influences the state of the entangled particle, are attractive options for carrying quantum information at the nanoscale. However, fully-describing entanglement in traditional time-dependent quantum transport simulation approaches requires significant computational effort, bordering on being prohibitive. Considering electrons, one approach to analyzing their entanglement is through modeling the Coulomb interaction via the Wigner formalism. In this work, we reduce the computational complexity of the time evolution of two interacting electrons by resorting to reasonable approximations. In particular, we replace the Wigner potential of the electron-electron interaction by a local electrostatic field, which is introduced through the spectral decomposition of the potential. It is demonstrated that for some particular configurations of an electron-electron system, the introduced approximations are feasible. Purity, identified as the maximal coherence for a quantum state, is also analyzed and its corresponding analysis demonstrates that the entanglement due to the Coulomb interaction is well accounted for by the introduced local approximation.
Entanglement is studied in the framework of Dyson's S-matrix theory in relativistic quantum field theory, which leads to a natural definition of entangled states of a particle-antiparticle pair and the spin operator from a Noether current. As an explicit example, the decay of a massive pseudo-scalar particle into a pair of electron and positron is analyzed. Two spin operators are extracted from the Noether current. The Wigner spin operator characterizes spin states at the rest frame of each fermion and, although not measurable in the laboratory, gives rise to a straightforward generalization of low-energy analysis of entanglement to the ultrarelativistic domain. In contrast, if one adopts a (modified) Dirac spin operator, the entanglement measured by spin correlation becomes maximal near the threshold of the decay, while the entanglement is replaced by the classical correlation for the ultrarelativistic electron-positron pair by analogy to the case of neutrinos, for which a hidden-variables type of description is possible. Chiral symmetry differentiates the spin angular momentum and the magnetic moment. The use of weak interaction that can measure helicity is suggested in the analysis of entanglement at high energies instead of a Stern-Gerlach apparatus, which is useless for the electron. A difference between the electron spin at high energies and the photon linear polarization is also noted. The Standard Model can describe all of the observable properties of leptons.
A gauge-invariant Wigner quantum mechanical theory is obtained by applying the Weyl-Stratonovich transform to the von Neumann equation for the density matrix. The transform reduces to the Weyl transform in the electrostatic limit, when the vector potential and thus the magnetic field are zero. Both cases involve a center-of-mass transform followed by a Fourier integral on the relative coordinate introducing the momentum variable. The latter is continuous if the limits of the integral are infinite or, equivalently, the coherence length is infinite. However, the quantum theory involves Fourier transforms of the electromagnetic field components, which imposes conditions on their behavior at infinity. Conversely, quantum systems are bounded and often very small, as is, for instance, the case in modern nanoelectronics. This implies a finite coherence length, which avoids the need to regularize nonconverging Fourier integrals. Accordingly, the momentum space becomes discrete, giving rise to momentum quantization and to a semidiscrete gauge-invariant Wigner equation. To gain insights into the peculiarities of this theory one needs to analyze the equation for specific electromagnetic conditions. We derive the evolution equation for the linear electromagnetic case and show that it significantly simplifies for a limit dictated by the long coherence length behavior, which involves momentum derivatives. In the discrete momentum picture these derivatives are presented by finite difference quantities which, together with further approximations, allow to develop a computationally feasible model that offers physical insights into the involved quantum processes. In particular, a Fredholm integral equation of the second kind is obtained, where the ``power'' of the kernel components, measuring their rate of modification of the quantum evolution, can be evaluated.
In this work, we investigate the Wigner localization of two interacting electrons at very low density in two and three dimensions using the exact diagonalization of the many-body Hamiltonian. We use our recently developed method based on Clifford periodic boundary conditions with a renormalized distance in the Coulomb potential. To accurately represent the electronic wave function, we use a regular distribution in space of Gaussian-type orbitals and we take advantage of the translational symmetry of the system to efficiently calculate the electronic wave function. We are thus able to accurately describe the wave function up to very low density. We validate our approach by comparing our results to a semi-classical model that becomes exact in the low-density limit. With our approach, we are able to observe the Wigner localization without ambiguity.
From drug design to material science, computational chemistry has become a valuable tool for many fields of applications in the past decades. Quantum chemistry in particular, can provide accurate descriptions of molecules and solids by relying on principles of quantum mechanics with the Schrödinger equation at its core. Unfortunately this equation becomes prohibitively expensive to solve for systems made of more than a few electrons and one has to rely on other approaches. Among the most popular is Density Functional Theory, relatively inexpensive and exact in principle. One has, however, to introduce approximations in practice, deteriorating its accuracy for challenging, so-called strongly correlated, systems. On the contrary, other methods like CASSCF remain reliable for these systems, but although cheaper than the solution of the Schrödinger equation, remain too expensive for extended systems. There is therefore room for methods in between, that could handle large correlated systems with reasonable accuracy. One such method is the One Body Reduced Density Matrix (1-RDM) Functional Theory (RDMFT), based on the fact that an electronic system can, in principle exactly, be described by its 1-RDM only. Although its theory dates back to the 1970s, computational hindrances have prevented this method from shining so far. Indeed, computations in RDMFT rely on a constrained optimization of the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the 1-RDM, that can be reformulated as an unconstrained optimization by parameterizing the latter but in both cases suffers from convergence problems. In this thesis, the role of this parametrization is analyzed and motivates a now second order optimization algorithm, which improves the convergence speed by two orders of magnitude w.r.t. the state of the art algorithm. This understanding of the problem also inspires an alternative approach with the 1-RDM as the optimization variable. This however requires the development of new approximations and a first investigation in that direction, based on Machine Learning is performed. Lastly, a generalization of the method to excited states is attempted, highlighting some key computational challenges.