Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2505.11874

Can experimentally-accessible measures of entanglement distinguish quantum spin liquids from disorder-driven "random singlet" phases ?

Tokuro Shimokawa, Snigdh Sabharwal, Nic Shannon

Published May 17, 2025• 15 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

At the theoretical level, quantum spin liquids are distinguished from other phases of matter by their entanglement properties. However, since the usual measure of entanglement, entanglement entropy, cannot accessed in experiment, indentifying quantum spin liquids in candidate materials remains an acute problem. Here we show other, experimentally-accessible, measures of entanglement can be used to distinguish a quantum spin liquid from a competing disorder-driven "random singlet" phase, in a model of a disordered antiferromagnet on a triangular lattice. The application of these results to the triangular-lattice systems YbZnGaO$_4$, YbZn$_2$GaO$_5$ and KYbSe$_2$ is discussed.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2505.11874

Related papers

Witnessing disorder in quantum magnets

Snigdh Sabharwal, Tokuro Shimokawa, Nic Shannon

There are no clean samples in nature. Therefore, when we come to discuss the entanglement properties of quantum materials, the effects of disorder must be taken into account. This question is of particular interest for highly entangled phases, such as quantum spin liquids, which lie outside the Landau paradigm for classifying phases of matter. In this work, we explore what experimentally accessible measures, in the form of concurrence, residual tangle, and quantum Fisher information can teach us about the entanglement in the presence of disorder. As a representative example, we consider the Tomonaga-Luttinger liquids (TLL) and disorder-driven random singlet (RS) phases found in antiferromagnetic quantum spin chains. Using quantum Fisher information and residual tangle, we demonstrate that both TLL and RS phases exhibit multipartite entanglement. In the case of the RS phase, we attribute this to entanglement localized below a crossover length scale. We further show that the order of disorder average matters in calculating measures like concurrence and that this can lead to false inferences when interpreting experiments. Nonetheless, correctly interpreted, these witnesses provide useful information about the effects of disorder. We explore how information about the central charge of the TLL can be extracted from the low-temperature behavior of concurrence and conjecture that this analysis can be extended to the effective central charge of the RS phase. Finally, we establish how RS and TLL phases can be distinguished through the growth of multipartite entanglement, as witnessed by the equal-time structure factor. These results establish that, used carefully, experiments based on entanglement witnesses can provide important information about quantum spin systems in the presence of disorder.

arXiv:2407.20797•Physical Review Research•May 12, 2025•7 citations

Witnessing Entanglement in Quantum Spin Liquids

Snigdh Sabharwal

In 1935, as part of a broader debate about the interpretation of quantum mechanics, Schrödinger introduced the term “verschränkung” (entanglement) to describe the way in which mutually-exclusive experimental outcomes could be woven together in a single quantum mechanical state. Ninety years later, entanglement is no longer a philosophical curiosity but a technological resource, central to the pursuit of quantum advantage sought in the entanglement of a few hundred qubits. In the context of condensed matter physics, the most celebrated example of entanglement arises in quantum spin liquids (QSL), exotic magnetic phases where, at comparable temperatures, billions of spins can be entangled. The sharpest distinctions between conventional magnetic phases, QSL, and states driven by disorder, are expected to be found in their entanglement properties. Yet exactly what these distinctions are, or how they might be used in experiments, remains poorly understood. In this thesis, we explore how material-based imperfections such as bond disorder and finite temperature affect experimentally accessible entanglement-based diagnostics in models of quantum spin liquids (QSLs). We ask: (1) Can spin liquid states be reliably distinguished from disorder-driven phases using such diagnostics? (2) What can these experimentally accessible entanglement witnesses reveal about the microscopic structure of entanglement in QSLs? In particular, we examine the robustness of these quantum correlations under realistic conditions where thermal fluctuations are unavoidable. In addressing (1), we find that measures like concurrence become unreliable in disordered systems. In contrast, the finite temperature scaling of multipartite diagnostics such as the quantum Fisher information (QFI) provides a more effective means of distinguishing QSLs from competing disorder-dominated phases. For (2), we investigate how the finite temperature behavior of multipartite entanglement measures obtained from semidefinite programming (SDP) methods supports a two step picture for how a high temperature paramagnet crosses over into a QSL ground state. In particular, these results provide a conceptual framework that places quantitative bounds on the temperature window over which candidate materials can be expected to exhibit the characteristic physics of the QSL ground state.

•May 31, 2026•0 citations

Diagnosing phases of magnetic insulators via noise magnetometry with spin qubits

Shubhayu Chatterjee, Joaquin F. Rodriguez-Nieva, Eugene Demler

Two-dimensional magnetic insulators exhibit a plethora of competing ground states, such as ordered (anti)ferromagnets, exotic quantum spin liquid states, and random singlet phases. Spin liquids, in particular, are collective phases of matter which have eluded discovery for several decades. Although there are many promising candidate materials for their realization, the central challenges for the clear diagnosis of a spin liquid has been the lack of experimental probes to access their emergent excitations. Here, the authors propose that spin qubit magnetometers grant access to these excitations and, therefore, can be used as a diagnostic of ground states in magnetic insulators.

arXiv:1810.04183•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 21, 2019•70 citations

Randomness-induced spin-liquid-like phase in the spin- 1 2 J 1 − J 2 triangular Heisenberg model

Han-Qing Wu, Shou-Shu Gong, D. N. Sheng

We study the effects of bond randomness in the spin-$1/2$ ${J}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{2}$ triangular Heisenberg model using exact diagonalization and density-matrix renormalization group. With increasing bond randomness, we identify a randomness-induced spin-liquid-like phase without any magnetic order, dimer order, spin-glass order, or valence-bond-glass order. The finite-size scaling of gaps suggests the gapless nature of both spin triplet and singlet excitations, which is further supported by the broad continuum of the dynamical spin structure factor. By studying the bipartite entanglement spectrum of the system on cylinder geometry, we identify the features of the low-lying entanglement spectrum in the spin-liquid-like phase, which may distinguish this randomness-induced spin-liquid-like phase and the intrinsic spin-liquid phase in the clean ${J}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{2}$ triangular Heisenberg model. We further discuss the nature of this spin-liquid-like phase and the indication of our results for understanding spin-liquid-like materials with triangular-lattice structure.

arXiv:1802.00935•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 28, 2019•43 citations

Some experimental schemes to identify quantum spin liquids*

Yonghao Gao, Gang Chen

Despite the apparent ubiquity and variety of quantum spin liquids in theory, experimental confirmation of spin liquids remains to be a huge challenge. Motivated by the recent surge of evidences for spin liquids in a series of candidate materials, we highlight the experimental schemes, involving the thermal Hall transport and spectrum measurements, that can result in smoking-gun signatures of spin liquids beyond the usual ones. For clarity, we investigate the square lattice spin liquids and theoretically predict the possible phenomena that may emerge in the corresponding spin liquids candidates. The mechanisms for these signatures can be traced back to either the intrinsic characters of spin liquids or the external field-driven behaviors. Our conclusion does not depend on the geometry of lattices and can broadly apply to other relevant spin liquids.

arXiv:2011.02978•Chinese Physics B•Jun 18, 2020•5 citations

Quantum spin liquids: a review

L. Savary, Leon Balents

Quantum spin liquids may be considered 'quantum disordered' ground states of spin systems, in which zero-point fluctuations are so strong that they prevent conventional magnetic long-range order. More interestingly, quantum spin liquids are prototypical examples of ground states with massive many-body entanglement, which is of a degree sufficient to render these states distinct phases of matter. Their highly entangled nature imbues quantum spin liquids with unique physical aspects, such as non-local excitations, topological properties, and more. In this review, we discuss the nature of such phases and their properties based on paradigmatic models and general arguments, and introduce theoretical technology such as gauge theory and partons, which are conveniently used in the study of quantum spin liquids. An overview is given of the different types of quantum spin liquids and the models and theories used to describe them. We also provide a guide to the current status of experiments in relation to study quantum spin liquids, and to the diverse probes used therein.

arXiv:1601.03742•Reports on Progress in Physics•Nov 8, 2016•2,287 citations
At the theoretical level, quantum spin liquids are distinguished from other phases of matter by their entanglement properties. However, since the usual measure of entanglement, entanglement entropy, cannot accessed in experiment, indentifying quantum spin liquids in candidate materials remains an acute problem. Here we show other, experimentally-accessible, measures of entanglement can be used to distinguish a quantum spin liquid from a competing disorder-driven "random singlet" phase, in a model of a disordered antiferromagnet on a triangular lattice. The application of these results to the triangular-lattice systems YbZnGaO4_44​, YbZn2_22​GaO5_55​ and KYbSe2_22​ is discussed.
There are no clean samples in nature. Therefore, when we come to discuss the entanglement properties of quantum materials, the effects of disorder must be taken into account. This question is of particular interest for highly entangled phases, such as quantum spin liquids, which lie outside the Landau paradigm for classifying phases of matter. In this work, we explore what experimentally accessible measures, in the form of concurrence, residual tangle, and quantum Fisher information can teach us about the entanglement in the presence of disorder. As a representative example, we consider the Tomonaga-Luttinger liquids (TLL) and disorder-driven random singlet (RS) phases found in antiferromagnetic quantum spin chains. Using quantum Fisher information and residual tangle, we demonstrate that both TLL and RS phases exhibit multipartite entanglement. In the case of the RS phase, we attribute this to entanglement localized below a crossover length scale. We further show that the order of disorder average matters in calculating measures like concurrence and that this can lead to false inferences when interpreting experiments. Nonetheless, correctly interpreted, these witnesses provide useful information about the effects of disorder. We explore how information about the central charge of the TLL can be extracted from the low-temperature behavior of concurrence and conjecture that this analysis can be extended to the effective central charge of the RS phase. Finally, we establish how RS and TLL phases can be distinguished through the growth of multipartite entanglement, as witnessed by the equal-time structure factor. These results establish that, used carefully, experiments based on entanglement witnesses can provide important information about quantum spin systems in the presence of disorder.
In 1935, as part of a broader debate about the interpretation of quantum mechanics, Schrödinger introduced the term “verschränkung” (entanglement) to describe the way in which mutually-exclusive experimental outcomes could be woven together in a single quantum mechanical state. Ninety years later, entanglement is no longer a philosophical curiosity but a technological resource, central to the pursuit of quantum advantage sought in the entanglement of a few hundred qubits. In the context of condensed matter physics, the most celebrated example of entanglement arises in quantum spin liquids (QSL), exotic magnetic phases where, at comparable temperatures, billions of spins can be entangled. The sharpest distinctions between conventional magnetic phases, QSL, and states driven by disorder, are expected to be found in their entanglement properties. Yet exactly what these distinctions are, or how they might be used in experiments, remains poorly understood. In this thesis, we explore how material-based imperfections such as bond disorder and finite temperature affect experimentally accessible entanglement-based diagnostics in models of quantum spin liquids (QSLs). We ask: (1) Can spin liquid states be reliably distinguished from disorder-driven phases using such diagnostics? (2) What can these experimentally accessible entanglement witnesses reveal about the microscopic structure of entanglement in QSLs? In particular, we examine the robustness of these quantum correlations under realistic conditions where thermal fluctuations are unavoidable. In addressing (1), we find that measures like concurrence become unreliable in disordered systems. In contrast, the finite temperature scaling of multipartite diagnostics such as the quantum Fisher information (QFI) provides a more effective means of distinguishing QSLs from competing disorder-dominated phases. For (2), we investigate how the finite temperature behavior of multipartite entanglement measures obtained from semidefinite programming (SDP) methods supports a two step picture for how a high temperature paramagnet crosses over into a QSL ground state. In particular, these results provide a conceptual framework that places quantitative bounds on the temperature window over which candidate materials can be expected to exhibit the characteristic physics of the QSL ground state.
Two-dimensional magnetic insulators exhibit a plethora of competing ground states, such as ordered (anti)ferromagnets, exotic quantum spin liquid states, and random singlet phases. Spin liquids, in particular, are collective phases of matter which have eluded discovery for several decades. Although there are many promising candidate materials for their realization, the central challenges for the clear diagnosis of a spin liquid has been the lack of experimental probes to access their emergent excitations. Here, the authors propose that spin qubit magnetometers grant access to these excitations and, therefore, can be used as a diagnostic of ground states in magnetic insulators.
We study the effects of bond randomness in the spin-1/21/21/2 ${J}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{2}$ triangular Heisenberg model using exact diagonalization and density-matrix renormalization group. With increasing bond randomness, we identify a randomness-induced spin-liquid-like phase without any magnetic order, dimer order, spin-glass order, or valence-bond-glass order. The finite-size scaling of gaps suggests the gapless nature of both spin triplet and singlet excitations, which is further supported by the broad continuum of the dynamical spin structure factor. By studying the bipartite entanglement spectrum of the system on cylinder geometry, we identify the features of the low-lying entanglement spectrum in the spin-liquid-like phase, which may distinguish this randomness-induced spin-liquid-like phase and the intrinsic spin-liquid phase in the clean ${J}_{1}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{2}$ triangular Heisenberg model. We further discuss the nature of this spin-liquid-like phase and the indication of our results for understanding spin-liquid-like materials with triangular-lattice structure.
Despite the apparent ubiquity and variety of quantum spin liquids in theory, experimental confirmation of spin liquids remains to be a huge challenge. Motivated by the recent surge of evidences for spin liquids in a series of candidate materials, we highlight the experimental schemes, involving the thermal Hall transport and spectrum measurements, that can result in smoking-gun signatures of spin liquids beyond the usual ones. For clarity, we investigate the square lattice spin liquids and theoretically predict the possible phenomena that may emerge in the corresponding spin liquids candidates. The mechanisms for these signatures can be traced back to either the intrinsic characters of spin liquids or the external field-driven behaviors. Our conclusion does not depend on the geometry of lattices and can broadly apply to other relevant spin liquids.
Quantum spin liquids may be considered 'quantum disordered' ground states of spin systems, in which zero-point fluctuations are so strong that they prevent conventional magnetic long-range order. More interestingly, quantum spin liquids are prototypical examples of ground states with massive many-body entanglement, which is of a degree sufficient to render these states distinct phases of matter. Their highly entangled nature imbues quantum spin liquids with unique physical aspects, such as non-local excitations, topological properties, and more. In this review, we discuss the nature of such phases and their properties based on paradigmatic models and general arguments, and introduce theoretical technology such as gauge theory and partons, which are conveniently used in the study of quantum spin liquids. An overview is given of the different types of quantum spin liquids and the models and theories used to describe them. We also provide a guide to the current status of experiments in relation to study quantum spin liquids, and to the diverse probes used therein.