Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2505.06159 · Physical Review Research

Discovering quasiorder parameters in the Potts model: A bridge between machine learning and critical phenomena

Yi-Lun Du, Nan Su, Konrad Tywoniuk

Published Jan 2, 2026• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Machine-learning (ML) models trained on Ising spin configurations have demonstrated surprising effectiveness in classifying phases of Potts models, even when processing severely reduced representations that retain only two spin states. To unravel this remarkable capability, we identify a family of alternative order parameters for the q = 3 and q = 4 Potts models on a square lattice, constructed from the occupancies of secondary and minimal spin states rather than the conventional dominant-state order parameter. Through systematic finite-size scaling analyses, we demonstrate that these quantities, along with a magnetizationlike quantity derived from a reduced spin representation, accurately capture critical behavior, yielding critical temperatures and exponents consistent with established theoretical predictions and numerical benchmarks. Furthermore, we rigorously establish the fundamental relationships between these alternative (quasi)order parameters, demonstrating how they collectively encode criticality through different aspects of spin configurations. Our results clarify, within this specific setting, how reduced spin representations can retain the essential thermodynamic information needed for identifying critical behavior. Taken together, this work establishes a concrete bridge between Ising-trained ML models and critical phenomena in Potts systems by showing that Potts criticality can be encoded in more compact, nontraditional forms, thereby opening avenues for discovering analogous order parameters in broader spin systems.

DOI
10.1103/2xhf-33qp

Related papers

A Machine Learning study of the two-dimensional antiferromagnetic $Q$-state Potts model on the square lattice

Li, Shang-Wei, Huang, Kai-Wei, Chen, Chien-Ting +1 more

The critical phenomena of 2D antiferromagnetic $Q$-state Potts model on the square lattice with $Q=2,3,4,5$ and 6 are investigated using supervised neural networks (NN). Conventional supervised and unsupervised NNs either fail or have difficulty in identifying the correct critical behaviors of these models. Remarkably, despite the fact that the NNs employed here are trained with a particular fixed type training set which contains no information about the considered models (except for $Q=2$), they correctly compute the critical temperatures for the studied physical systems. Particularly, the NN outcomes suggest convincingly that the $Q=3$ model is critical only at zero temperature and $Q=4,5,6$ models remain disordered at all temperatures. Apart from the studied models, our NNs trained with exactly the same training set have successfully determined the critical temperature(s) and the nature of the associated phase transition(s) of another physical system differing dramatically from those considered here. Therefore, our NN has the potential to be a universally applicable NN model in studying phase transitions.

arXiv:2512.06762•Dec 7, 2025•0 citations

A Neural Network Study of the Phase Transitions of the 2D Antiferromagnetic q -State Potts Models on the Square Lattice

Yuan-Heng Tseng, Fu-Jiun Jiang

Abstract The critical phenomena of the 2D antiferromagnetic $q$-state Potts model on the square lattice with $q=2,3,4$ are investigated using the techniques of neural networks (NNs). In particular, an unconventional supervised NN which is trained using no information about the physics of the considered systems is employed. In addition, conventional unsupervised autoencoders (AECs) are used in our study as well. Remarkably, whereas the conventional AECs either fail or only work partially to uncover the critical phenomena of the systems associated with $q=3$ and $q=4$ investigated here, our unconventional supervised NN correctly identifies the critical behaviors of all three considered antiferromagnetic $q$-state Potts models. The results obtained in this study suggest convincingly that the applicability of our unconventional supervised NN is broader than one anticipates. In particular, when a new system is studied with our NN, it is likely that it is not necessary to conduct any training, and one only needs to examine whether an appropriate reduced representation of the original raw configurations exists, so that the same already trained NN can be employed to explore the related phase transition efficiently.

arXiv:2409.17984•Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics•Feb 20, 2025•2 citations

Smallest neural network to learn the Ising criticality

Dongkyu Kim, DH Kim

Learning with an artificial neural network encodes the system behavior in a feed-forward function with a number of parameters optimized by data-driven training. An open question is whether one can minimize the network complexity without loss of performance to reveal how and why it works. Here we investigate the learning of the phase transition in the Ising model and find that having two hidden neurons can be enough for an accurate prediction of critical temperature. We show that the networks learn the scaling dimension of the order parameter while being trained as a phase classifier, demonstrating how the machine learning exploits the Ising universality to work for different lattices of the same criticality within a single set of trainings in one lattice geometry.

arXiv:1804.02171•Physical review. E•Aug 31, 2018•59 citations

Can machine learning truly decode phase transitions? A deep dive into the Ising model with competing interactions

Maninder Kaur, Ying Wai Li, Dilina Perera +1 more

We investigate phase transitions in the two-dimensional Ising model with competing nearest-neighbor (NN) and next-nearest-neighbor (NNN) interactions, where the NNN coupling generates a degenerate superantiferromagnetic (SAF) ground state, by combining machine-learning methods with Monte Carlo simulations and finite-size scaling (FSS). Going beyond earlier studies, we show that unsupervised learning can recover order-parameter and Binder cumulant analogs that obey FSS. Principal component analysis (PCA) reveals the two-component structure of the SAF order parameter, and k-means clustering is used to visualize qualitative differences between ordered and disordered configurations in the principal-component space. A fully connected neural network (FCNN), trained without prior knowledge of the order parameter or the critical temperature, learns the strength of SAF stripe ordering and uses it as the internal feature for phase classification. FSS of thermodynamic observables, the PCA-derived quantity, and the FCNN output yields consistent estimates of the critical temperature and correlation-length exponent. These results demonstrate that machine learning can decode ordering patterns, extract meaningful order-parameter analogs, and reproduce critical behavior in frustrated Ising systems.

Physical review. E•May 19, 2026•1 citation

Improving CFT Operators Using Machine Learning

Lior Oppenheim, Snir Gazit, Zohar Ringel

Finite-size effects limit the accuracy with which conformal data can be extracted from lattice simulations of critical systems. While action improvement suppresses some corrections to scaling, it does not address operator-dependent effects arising from imperfect lattice representations of continuum conformal fields. In this work, we propose a data-driven method for improving lattice operators themselves, constructing estimators with enhanced overlap with the corresponding primary operators of the continuum conformal field theory. We identify improved lattice representations of leading spin and energy operators in three two-dimensional critical systems: the Ising model, the q = 3 Potts model, and the dilute q = 3 Potts model. In all cases, the resulting operators exhibit reduced corrections to scaling and yield more accurate estimates of scaling dimensions compared to conventional lattice choices. The code and analysis workflows used to produce these results are made available in an accompanying GitHub repository.

arXiv:2605.28929•May 27, 2026•0 citations

Thermodynamics and feature extraction by machine learning

Shotaro Shiba, Dimitrios Giataganas

Machine learning methods are powerful in distinguishing different phases of matter in an automated way and provide a new perspective on the study of physical phenomena.We train a restricted Boltzmann machine (RBM) on data constructed with spin configurations sampled from the Ising Hamiltonian at different values of temperature and external magnetic field using Monte Carlo methods.From the trained machine we obtain the flow of iterative reconstruction of spin state configurations to faithfully reproduce the observables of the physical system.We find that the flow of the trained RBM approaches the spin configurations of the maximal possible specific heat which resemble the near-criticality region of the Ising model.In the special case of the vanishing magnetic field the trained RBM converges to the critical point of the renormalization group (RG) flow of the lattice model.Our results suggest an explanation of how the machine identifies the physical phase transitions, by recognizing certain properties of the configuration like the maximization of the specific heat, instead of associating directly the recognition procedure with the RG flow and its fixed points.Then from the reconstructed data we deduce the critical exponent associated with the magnetization to find satisfactory agreement with the actual physical value.We assume no prior knowledge about the criticality of the system and its Hamiltonian.

arXiv:1810.08179•Physical Review Research•Sep 15, 2020•63 citations
Machine-learning (ML) models trained on Ising spin configurations have demonstrated surprising effectiveness in classifying phases of Potts models, even when processing severely reduced representations that retain only two spin states. To unravel this remarkable capability, we identify a family of alternative order parameters for the q = 3 and q = 4 Potts models on a square lattice, constructed from the occupancies of secondary and minimal spin states rather than the conventional dominant-state order parameter. Through systematic finite-size scaling analyses, we demonstrate that these quantities, along with a magnetizationlike quantity derived from a reduced spin representation, accurately capture critical behavior, yielding critical temperatures and exponents consistent with established theoretical predictions and numerical benchmarks. Furthermore, we rigorously establish the fundamental relationships between these alternative (quasi)order parameters, demonstrating how they collectively encode criticality through different aspects of spin configurations. Our results clarify, within this specific setting, how reduced spin representations can retain the essential thermodynamic information needed for identifying critical behavior. Taken together, this work establishes a concrete bridge between Ising-trained ML models and critical phenomena in Potts systems by showing that Potts criticality can be encoded in more compact, nontraditional forms, thereby opening avenues for discovering analogous order parameters in broader spin systems.
A Machine Learning study of the two-dimensional antiferromagnetic QQQ-state Potts model on the square lattice
The critical phenomena of 2D antiferromagnetic QQQ-state Potts model on the square lattice with Q=2,3,4,5Q=2,3,4,5Q=2,3,4,5 and 6 are investigated using supervised neural networks (NN). Conventional supervised and unsupervised NNs either fail or have difficulty in identifying the correct critical behaviors of these models. Remarkably, despite the fact that the NNs employed here are trained with a particular fixed type training set which contains no information about the considered models (except for Q=2Q=2Q=2), they correctly compute the critical temperatures for the studied physical systems. Particularly, the NN outcomes suggest convincingly that the Q=3Q=3Q=3 model is critical only at zero temperature and Q=4,5,6Q=4,5,6Q=4,5,6 models remain disordered at all temperatures. Apart from the studied models, our NNs trained with exactly the same training set have successfully determined the critical temperature(s) and the nature of the associated phase transition(s) of another physical system differing dramatically from those considered here. Therefore, our NN has the potential to be a universally applicable NN model in studying phase transitions.
Abstract The critical phenomena of the 2D antiferromagnetic qqq-state Potts model on the square lattice with q=2,3,4q=2,3,4q=2,3,4 are investigated using the techniques of neural networks (NNs). In particular, an unconventional supervised NN which is trained using no information about the physics of the considered systems is employed. In addition, conventional unsupervised autoencoders (AECs) are used in our study as well. Remarkably, whereas the conventional AECs either fail or only work partially to uncover the critical phenomena of the systems associated with q=3q=3q=3 and q=4q=4q=4 investigated here, our unconventional supervised NN correctly identifies the critical behaviors of all three considered antiferromagnetic qqq-state Potts models. The results obtained in this study suggest convincingly that the applicability of our unconventional supervised NN is broader than one anticipates. In particular, when a new system is studied with our NN, it is likely that it is not necessary to conduct any training, and one only needs to examine whether an appropriate reduced representation of the original raw configurations exists, so that the same already trained NN can be employed to explore the related phase transition efficiently.
Learning with an artificial neural network encodes the system behavior in a feed-forward function with a number of parameters optimized by data-driven training. An open question is whether one can minimize the network complexity without loss of performance to reveal how and why it works. Here we investigate the learning of the phase transition in the Ising model and find that having two hidden neurons can be enough for an accurate prediction of critical temperature. We show that the networks learn the scaling dimension of the order parameter while being trained as a phase classifier, demonstrating how the machine learning exploits the Ising universality to work for different lattices of the same criticality within a single set of trainings in one lattice geometry.
We investigate phase transitions in the two-dimensional Ising model with competing nearest-neighbor (NN) and next-nearest-neighbor (NNN) interactions, where the NNN coupling generates a degenerate superantiferromagnetic (SAF) ground state, by combining machine-learning methods with Monte Carlo simulations and finite-size scaling (FSS). Going beyond earlier studies, we show that unsupervised learning can recover order-parameter and Binder cumulant analogs that obey FSS. Principal component analysis (PCA) reveals the two-component structure of the SAF order parameter, and k-means clustering is used to visualize qualitative differences between ordered and disordered configurations in the principal-component space. A fully connected neural network (FCNN), trained without prior knowledge of the order parameter or the critical temperature, learns the strength of SAF stripe ordering and uses it as the internal feature for phase classification. FSS of thermodynamic observables, the PCA-derived quantity, and the FCNN output yields consistent estimates of the critical temperature and correlation-length exponent. These results demonstrate that machine learning can decode ordering patterns, extract meaningful order-parameter analogs, and reproduce critical behavior in frustrated Ising systems.
Finite-size effects limit the accuracy with which conformal data can be extracted from lattice simulations of critical systems. While action improvement suppresses some corrections to scaling, it does not address operator-dependent effects arising from imperfect lattice representations of continuum conformal fields. In this work, we propose a data-driven method for improving lattice operators themselves, constructing estimators with enhanced overlap with the corresponding primary operators of the continuum conformal field theory. We identify improved lattice representations of leading spin and energy operators in three two-dimensional critical systems: the Ising model, the q = 3 Potts model, and the dilute q = 3 Potts model. In all cases, the resulting operators exhibit reduced corrections to scaling and yield more accurate estimates of scaling dimensions compared to conventional lattice choices. The code and analysis workflows used to produce these results are made available in an accompanying GitHub repository.
Machine learning methods are powerful in distinguishing different phases of matter in an automated way and provide a new perspective on the study of physical phenomena.We train a restricted Boltzmann machine (RBM) on data constructed with spin configurations sampled from the Ising Hamiltonian at different values of temperature and external magnetic field using Monte Carlo methods.From the trained machine we obtain the flow of iterative reconstruction of spin state configurations to faithfully reproduce the observables of the physical system.We find that the flow of the trained RBM approaches the spin configurations of the maximal possible specific heat which resemble the near-criticality region of the Ising model.In the special case of the vanishing magnetic field the trained RBM converges to the critical point of the renormalization group (RG) flow of the lattice model.Our results suggest an explanation of how the machine identifies the physical phase transitions, by recognizing certain properties of the configuration like the maximization of the specific heat, instead of associating directly the recognition procedure with the RG flow and its fixed points.Then from the reconstructed data we deduce the critical exponent associated with the magnetization to find satisfactory agreement with the actual physical value.We assume no prior knowledge about the criticality of the system and its Hamiltonian.