Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2505.02894 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Upper bound on T c in a strongly coupled electron-boson superconductor

N. V. Gnezdilov, Rufus Boyack

Published Nov 19, 2025• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Migdal-Eliashberg theory of boson-mediated superconductivity contains a $\sqrt{\ensuremath{\lambda}}$ divergence in the critical temperature ${T}_{c}$ for strong electron-boson coupling $\ensuremath{\lambda}$. In the conventional Migdal-Eliashberg theory, the strong-coupling regime can be accessed only in the limit that ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{E}=\ensuremath{\lambda}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{D}/{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}_{F}\ensuremath{\ll}1$, where ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{D}$ is the Debye frequency and ${\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}_{F}$ is the Fermi energy. Here we go beyond this restriction in the context of the two-dimensional Yukawa-SYK (Y-SYK) model, which is solvable for arbitrary values of ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{E}$. We find that ${T}_{c}\ensuremath{\approx}0.18\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{D}\sqrt{\ensuremath{\lambda}}$ for large $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, provided ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{E}$ remains small, and crosses over to a universal value of ${T}_{c}\ensuremath{\approx}0.04\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}_{F}$ for large ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{E}$. The saturation of ${T}_{c}$ is due to a self-consistent account of the boson dynamics for large ${\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{E}$ and remains valid provided the vertex corrections are negligible. Depending on the value of $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, this self-consistent approach leads to pairing that describes multiple classes of quantum critical electronic systems. These results demonstrate how the $\sqrt{\ensuremath{\lambda}}$ growth of ${T}_{c}$ in Migdal-Eliashberg theory saturates to a universal value independent of $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ and ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{D}$, providing an upper bound on the critical temperature at strong electron-boson coupling.

DOI
10.1103/7zmy-xtcw

Related papers

Pairing in quantum critical systems: Transition temperature, pairing gap, and their ratio

Yiming Wu, Ar. Abanov, Andrey V. Chubukov

We compute the ratio of the pairing gap $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$ at $T=0$ and ${T}_{c}$ for a set of quantum-critical models in which the pairing interaction is mediated by a gapless boson with local susceptibility $\ensuremath{\chi}(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}})\ensuremath{\propto}1/{|\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}|}^{\ensuremath{\gamma}}$ (the $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ model). The limit $\ensuremath{\gamma}=0+$ $[\ensuremath{\chi}(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}})=log|\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}|]$ describes color superconductivity, and models with $\ensuremath{\gamma}>0$ describe superconductivity in a metal at the onset of charge or spin order. The ratio $2\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}/{T}_{c}$ has been recently computed numerically for $0<\ensuremath{\gamma}<2$ within Eliashberg theory and was found to increase with increasing $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ [T.-H. Lee et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 187003 (2018)]. We argue that the origin of the increase is the divergence of $2\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}/{T}_{c}$ at $\ensuremath{\gamma}=3$. We obtain an approximate analytical formula for $2\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}/{T}_{c}$ for $\ensuremath{\gamma}\ensuremath{\le}3$ and show that it agrees well with the numerics. We also consider in detail the opposite limit of small $\ensuremath{\gamma}$. Here we obtain the explicit expressions for ${T}_{c}$ and $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$, including numerical prefactors. We show that these prefactors depend on fermionic self-energy in a rather nontrivial way. The ratio $2\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}/{T}_{c}$ approaches the BCS value 3.53 at $\ensuremath{\gamma}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$.

arXiv:1811.02087•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 3, 2019•30 citations

Migdal-Eliashberg and SUS-$Y^2$-SYK

Dmitri V. Khveshchenko

This note addresses a number of subtle issues pertaining to the long-standing problem of strong phonon-like fermion-boson coupling. Among the central topics are the customary Migdal-Eliashberg approximation in the pertinent Schwinger-Dyson gap equation and its solutions. The previously gained insight is assessed by contrasting it against the various (non-)supersymmetric variants of the Yukawa-Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model. Also, some previously discussed (pseudo-)holographic aspects of fermion pairing in such models are commented upon.

arXiv:2605.31540•May 29, 2026•1 citation

Superconductivity out of a non-Fermi liquid: Free energy analysis

Shang-Shun Zhang, Yiming Wu, Ar. Abanov +1 more

In this paper, we present an in-depth analysis of the condensation energy ${E}_{c}$ for a superconductor in a situation when superconductivity emerges out of a non-Fermi liquid due to pairing mediated by a massless boson. This is the case for electronic-mediated pairing near a quantum-critical point in metal, for pairing in SYK-type models, and for phonon-mediated pairing in the properly defined limit, when the dressed Debye frequency vanishes. We consider a subset of these quantum-critical models, in which the pairing in a channel with a proper spatial symmetry is described by an effective $0+1$ dimensional model with the effective dynamical interaction $V({\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}}_{m})={\overline{g}}^{\ensuremath{\gamma}}/{|{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}}_{m}|}^{\ensuremath{\gamma}}$, where $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ is model-specific (the $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ model). In previous papers, we argued that the pairing in the $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ model is qualitatively different from that in a Fermi liquid, and the gap equation at $T=0$ has an infinite number of topologically distinct solutions, ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{n}({\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m})$, where an integer $n$, running between 0 and infinity, is the number of zeros of ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{n}({\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m})$ on the positive Matsubara axis. This gives rise to the set of extrema of ${E}_{c}$ at ${E}_{c,n}$, of which ${E}_{c,0}$ is the global minimum. The spectrum ${E}_{c,n}$ is discrete for a generic $\ensuremath{\gamma}<2$ but becomes continuous at $\ensuremath{\gamma}=2--0$. Here, we discuss in more detail the profile of the condensation energy near each ${E}_{c,n}$ and the transformation from a discrete to a continuous spectrum at $\ensuremath{\gamma}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}2$. We also discuss the free energy and the specific heat of the $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ model in the normal state.

arXiv:2208.13888•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 31, 2022•12 citations

Special role of the first Matsubara frequency for superconductivity near a quantum critical point: Nonlinear gap equation below Tc and spectral properties in real frequencies

Yiming Wu, Ar. Abanov, Yuxuan Wang +1 more

Near a quantum-critical point in a metal a strong fermion-fermion interaction, mediated by a soft boson, destroys fermionic coherence and also gives rise to an attraction in one or more pairing channels. The two tendencies compete with each other, and in a class of large $N$ models, where the tendency to incoherence is parametrically stronger, one would naively expect an incoherent (non-Fermi liquid) normal state behavior to persist down to $T=0$. However, this is not the case for quantum-critical systems, described by Eliashberg theory. In such systems, the part of the fermionic self-energy $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}({\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m})$, relevant for spin-singlet pairing, is large for a generic Matsubara frequency ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m}=\ensuremath{\pi}T(2m+1)$ but vanishes for fermions with ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m}=\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}\ensuremath{\pi}T$, while the pairing interaction between fermions with these two frequencies remains strong. It has been shown [Y. Wang et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 157001 (2016)] that due to this peculiarity, the onset temperature for the pairing ${T}_{p}$ is finite even at large $N$, when the scaling analysis predicts a non-Fermi liquid normal state. We consider the system behavior below ${T}_{p}$ and contrast the conventional case, when ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m}=\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}\ensuremath{\pi}T$ are not special, and the case when the pairing is induced by fermions with ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m}=\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}\ensuremath{\pi}T$. We obtain the solution of the nonlinear gap equations in Matsubara frequencies and then convert to real frequency axis and obtain the spectral function $A(k,\ensuremath{\omega})$ and the density of states $N(\ensuremath{\omega})$. In a conventional BCS-type superconductor, $A(k,\ensuremath{\omega})$ and $N(\ensuremath{\omega})$ are peaked at the gap value $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}(T)$, and the peak position shifts to a smaller $\ensuremath{\omega}$ as temperature increases towards ${T}_{p}$, i.e., the gap ``closes in.'' We show that, when the pairing is induced by fermions with ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m}=\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}\ensuremath{\pi}T$, the situation is qualitatively different from the standard BCS result. Namely, the peak in $N(\ensuremath{\omega})$ remains at a finite frequency even at $T={T}_{p}\ensuremath{-}0$, the gap just ``fills in'' near this $T$. The spectral function $A(k,\ensuremath{\omega})$ either shows almost the same ``gap filling'' behavior as the density of states, or its peak position shifts to zero frequency already at a finite $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$ (``emergent Fermi arc'' behavior), depending on the position of $\mathbf{k}$ on the Fermi surface. As an example, we compare our results with the data for the cuprates and argue that ``gap filling'' behavior holds in the antinodal region, while the ``emergent Fermi arc'' behavior holds in the nodal region.

arXiv:1812.07649•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 15, 2019•38 citations

Applicability of Eliashberg theory for systems with electron-phonon and electron-electron interaction: A comparative analysis

Shang-Shun Zhang, Zachary M. Raines, Andrey V. Chubukov

The applicability of Eliashberg theory, for fermions interacting with fluctuations of a soft collective boson near a quantum-critical point (QCP) in two dimensions, remains a subject of debate. The velocity of the soft boson is comparable to the Fermi velocity. Hence, Migdal's justification of Eliashberg theory is formally not applicable. The authors argue here that some elements of Migdal's reasoning remain valid because the collective boson is overdamped, yet vertex corrections to Eliashberg theory are $O$(1). At the same time, they show that these corrections are numerically small, at least near an Ising-nematic QCP.

arXiv:2404.11820•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 24, 2024•13 citations

Superfluid stiffness within Eliashberg theory: The role of vertex corrections

Zachary M. Raines, Shang-Shun Zhang, Andrey V. Chubukov

The superfluid stiffness ${D}_{s}$($T$) is one of the key characteristics of a superconductor, determining the magnetic penetration length and, in two dimensions, the critical temperature. For Galilean invariant systems, it is known that the zero-temperature stiffness takes a universal value ${D}_{s}^{G\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}a\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}l}$ = $\frac{n}{m}$ ($T$=0), while for non-Galilean invariant systems the superfluid stiffness may be suppressed. Here, the authors demonstrate when and how vertex corrections may cancel suppression of the superfluid stiffness at strong coupling.

arXiv:2312.13392•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 5, 2024•6 citations
Migdal-Eliashberg theory of boson-mediated superconductivity contains a \ensuremathλ\sqrt{\ensuremath{\lambda}}\ensuremathλ​ divergence in the critical temperature Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ for strong electron-boson coupling \ensuremathλ\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremathλ. In the conventional Migdal-Eliashberg theory, the strong-coupling regime can be accessed only in the limit that \ensuremathλE=\ensuremathλ\ensuremathωD/\ensuremathεF\ensuremath≪1{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{E}=\ensuremath{\lambda}\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{D}/{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}_{F}\ensuremath{\ll}1\ensuremathλE​=\ensuremathλ\ensuremathωD​/\ensuremathεF​\ensuremath≪1, where \ensuremathωD{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{D}\ensuremathωD​ is the Debye frequency and \ensuremathεF{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}_{F}\ensuremathεF​ is the Fermi energy. Here we go beyond this restriction in the context of the two-dimensional Yukawa-SYK (Y-SYK) model, which is solvable for arbitrary values of \ensuremathλE{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{E}\ensuremathλE​. We find that Tc\ensuremath≈0.18\ensuremathωD\ensuremathλ{T}_{c}\ensuremath{\approx}0.18\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{D}\sqrt{\ensuremath{\lambda}}Tc​\ensuremath≈0.18\ensuremathωD​\ensuremathλ​ for large \ensuremathλ\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremathλ, provided \ensuremathλE{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{E}\ensuremathλE​ remains small, and crosses over to a universal value of Tc\ensuremath≈0.04\ensuremathεF{T}_{c}\ensuremath{\approx}0.04\phantom{\rule{0.16em}{0ex}}{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}_{F}Tc​\ensuremath≈0.04\ensuremathεF​ for large \ensuremathλE{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{E}\ensuremathλE​. The saturation of Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ is due to a self-consistent account of the boson dynamics for large \ensuremathλE{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{E}\ensuremathλE​ and remains valid provided the vertex corrections are negligible. Depending on the value of \ensuremathλ\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremathλ, this self-consistent approach leads to pairing that describes multiple classes of quantum critical electronic systems. These results demonstrate how the \ensuremathλ\sqrt{\ensuremath{\lambda}}\ensuremathλ​ growth of Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ in Migdal-Eliashberg theory saturates to a universal value independent of \ensuremathλ\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremathλ and \ensuremathωD{\ensuremath{\omega}}_{D}\ensuremathωD​, providing an upper bound on the critical temperature at strong electron-boson coupling.
We compute the ratio of the pairing gap $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$ at T=0T=0T=0 and Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ for a set of quantum-critical models in which the pairing interaction is mediated by a gapless boson with local susceptibility $\ensuremath{\chi}(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}})\ensuremath{\propto}1/{|\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}|}^{\ensuremath{\gamma}}$ (the $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ model). The limit $\ensuremath{\gamma}=0+$ $[\ensuremath{\chi}(\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}})=log|\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}|]$ describes color superconductivity, and models with $\ensuremath{\gamma}>0$ describe superconductivity in a metal at the onset of charge or spin order. The ratio $2\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}/{T}_{c}$ has been recently computed numerically for $0<\ensuremath{\gamma}<2$ within Eliashberg theory and was found to increase with increasing $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ [T.-H. Lee et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 187003 (2018)]. We argue that the origin of the increase is the divergence of $2\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}/{T}_{c}$ at $\ensuremath{\gamma}=3$. We obtain an approximate analytical formula for $2\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}/{T}_{c}$ for $\ensuremath{\gamma}\ensuremath{\le}3$ and show that it agrees well with the numerics. We also consider in detail the opposite limit of small $\ensuremath{\gamma}$. Here we obtain the explicit expressions for Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ and $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$, including numerical prefactors. We show that these prefactors depend on fermionic self-energy in a rather nontrivial way. The ratio $2\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}/{T}_{c}$ approaches the BCS value 3.53 at $\ensuremath{\gamma}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$.
Migdal-Eliashberg and SUS-Y2Y^2Y2-SYK
This note addresses a number of subtle issues pertaining to the long-standing problem of strong phonon-like fermion-boson coupling. Among the central topics are the customary Migdal-Eliashberg approximation in the pertinent Schwinger-Dyson gap equation and its solutions. The previously gained insight is assessed by contrasting it against the various (non-)supersymmetric variants of the Yukawa-Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model. Also, some previously discussed (pseudo-)holographic aspects of fermion pairing in such models are commented upon.
In this paper, we present an in-depth analysis of the condensation energy Ec{E}_{c}Ec​ for a superconductor in a situation when superconductivity emerges out of a non-Fermi liquid due to pairing mediated by a massless boson. This is the case for electronic-mediated pairing near a quantum-critical point in metal, for pairing in SYK-type models, and for phonon-mediated pairing in the properly defined limit, when the dressed Debye frequency vanishes. We consider a subset of these quantum-critical models, in which the pairing in a channel with a proper spatial symmetry is described by an effective 0+10+10+1 dimensional model with the effective dynamical interaction $V({\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}}_{m})={\overline{g}}^{\ensuremath{\gamma}}/{|{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Omega}}}_{m}|}^{\ensuremath{\gamma}}$, where $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ is model-specific (the $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ model). In previous papers, we argued that the pairing in the $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ model is qualitatively different from that in a Fermi liquid, and the gap equation at T=0T=0T=0 has an infinite number of topologically distinct solutions, ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{n}({\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m})$, where an integer nnn, running between 0 and infinity, is the number of zeros of ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{n}({\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m})$ on the positive Matsubara axis. This gives rise to the set of extrema of Ec{E}_{c}Ec​ at Ec,n{E}_{c,n}Ec,n​, of which Ec,0{E}_{c,0}Ec,0​ is the global minimum. The spectrum Ec,n{E}_{c,n}Ec,n​ is discrete for a generic $\ensuremath{\gamma}<2$ but becomes continuous at $\ensuremath{\gamma}=2--0$. Here, we discuss in more detail the profile of the condensation energy near each Ec,n{E}_{c,n}Ec,n​ and the transformation from a discrete to a continuous spectrum at $\ensuremath{\gamma}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}2$. We also discuss the free energy and the specific heat of the $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ model in the normal state.
Near a quantum-critical point in a metal a strong fermion-fermion interaction, mediated by a soft boson, destroys fermionic coherence and also gives rise to an attraction in one or more pairing channels. The two tendencies compete with each other, and in a class of large NNN models, where the tendency to incoherence is parametrically stronger, one would naively expect an incoherent (non-Fermi liquid) normal state behavior to persist down to T=0T=0T=0. However, this is not the case for quantum-critical systems, described by Eliashberg theory. In such systems, the part of the fermionic self-energy $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}({\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m})$, relevant for spin-singlet pairing, is large for a generic Matsubara frequency ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m}=\ensuremath{\pi}T(2m+1)$ but vanishes for fermions with ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m}=\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}\ensuremath{\pi}T$, while the pairing interaction between fermions with these two frequencies remains strong. It has been shown [Y. Wang et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 157001 (2016)] that due to this peculiarity, the onset temperature for the pairing Tp{T}_{p}Tp​ is finite even at large NNN, when the scaling analysis predicts a non-Fermi liquid normal state. We consider the system behavior below Tp{T}_{p}Tp​ and contrast the conventional case, when ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m}=\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}\ensuremath{\pi}T$ are not special, and the case when the pairing is induced by fermions with ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m}=\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}\ensuremath{\pi}T$. We obtain the solution of the nonlinear gap equations in Matsubara frequencies and then convert to real frequency axis and obtain the spectral function $A(k,\ensuremath{\omega})$ and the density of states $N(\ensuremath{\omega})$. In a conventional BCS-type superconductor, $A(k,\ensuremath{\omega})$ and $N(\ensuremath{\omega})$ are peaked at the gap value $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}(T)$, and the peak position shifts to a smaller $\ensuremath{\omega}$ as temperature increases towards Tp{T}_{p}Tp​, i.e., the gap ``closes in.'' We show that, when the pairing is induced by fermions with ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{m}=\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}\ensuremath{\pi}T$, the situation is qualitatively different from the standard BCS result. Namely, the peak in $N(\ensuremath{\omega})$ remains at a finite frequency even at $T={T}_{p}\ensuremath{-}0$, the gap just ``fills in'' near this TTT. The spectral function $A(k,\ensuremath{\omega})$ either shows almost the same ``gap filling'' behavior as the density of states, or its peak position shifts to zero frequency already at a finite $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$ (``emergent Fermi arc'' behavior), depending on the position of k\mathbf{k}k on the Fermi surface. As an example, we compare our results with the data for the cuprates and argue that ``gap filling'' behavior holds in the antinodal region, while the ``emergent Fermi arc'' behavior holds in the nodal region.
The applicability of Eliashberg theory, for fermions interacting with fluctuations of a soft collective boson near a quantum-critical point (QCP) in two dimensions, remains a subject of debate. The velocity of the soft boson is comparable to the Fermi velocity. Hence, Migdal's justification of Eliashberg theory is formally not applicable. The authors argue here that some elements of Migdal's reasoning remain valid because the collective boson is overdamped, yet vertex corrections to Eliashberg theory are OOO(1). At the same time, they show that these corrections are numerically small, at least near an Ising-nematic QCP.
The superfluid stiffness Ds{D}_{s}Ds​(TTT) is one of the key characteristics of a superconductor, determining the magnetic penetration length and, in two dimensions, the critical temperature. For Galilean invariant systems, it is known that the zero-temperature stiffness takes a universal value ${D}_{s}^{G\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}a\phantom{\rule{0}{0ex}}l}$ = nm\frac{n}{m}mn​ (TTT=0), while for non-Galilean invariant systems the superfluid stiffness may be suppressed. Here, the authors demonstrate when and how vertex corrections may cancel suppression of the superfluid stiffness at strong coupling.