Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2504.16838

Real Quantum Mechanics in a Kahler Space

Igor Vasil'evich Volovich

Published Apr 23, 2025• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, we demonstrate the equivalence between the complex Hilbert space and real Kahler space formulations of quantum mechanics. Complex numbers play an important role in the traditional formulation of quantum mechanics in complex Hilbert spaces. However, the necessity of complex numbers--as opposed to their mere convenience--remains a subject of debate. Several alternative formulations of quantum mechanics using real numbers have been proposed. In this paper, we demonstrate that standard quantum mechanics, formulated in a complex Hilbert space, admits an equivalent reformulation in a real Kahler space. By establishing a natural isomorphism between the operator theories of the complex Hilbert space and the real Kahler space, we prove the equivalence of the two formulations including composite system. This Kahler-space framework preserves all essential features of quantum mechanics while offering a key advantage: it inherently incorporates a Hamiltonian symplectic structure analogous to classical mechanics. This structural alignment provides a unified geometric perspective for both classical and quantum dynamics. Additionally, we show that the ergodicity of finite-dimensional quantum systems becomes manifest in this framework, resolving interpretational ambiguities present in conventional complex formulations.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2504.16838

Related papers

Notes on Real Quantum Mechanics in a Kahler Space

I. Ya. Aref’eva, Igor Vasil'evich Volovich

The necessity of complex numbers in quantum mechanics has long been debated. This paper develops a real Kahler space formulation of quantum mechanics [19], asserting equivalence to the standard complex Hilbert space framework. By mapping the complex Hilbert space ${\mathbb C}^n$ to a real Kahler space $K ^{2n}$, i.e. ${\mathbb R}^{2n}$ equipped with a metric, a symplectic structure and an automorphism, we establish a correspondence between Hermitian operators in ${\mathbb C}^n$ and real operators in $K^{2n}$. While the isomorphism appears straightforward some subtleties emerge: (i) the overcounting of composite system states under tensor products in ${\mathbb R}^{2n}$, and (ii) the double degeneracy of operator spectra in the real formulation. Through a systematic investigation of these challenges, we clarify the structural relationship between real and complex formulations, resolve ambiguities in composite system representations, and analyze spectral consequences. Our results reaffirm the equivalence of the two frameworks while highlighting nuanced distinctions with implications for foundational debates on locality, phase invariance, and the role of complex numbers in quantum theory.

arXiv:2506.07632•Jun 9, 2025•3 citations

On the properties of real quantum mechanics in Kähler Space

I. Ya. Aref’eva, I. V. Volovich

Abstract We investigate the isomorphism between the formulations of quantum mechanics in a finite-dimensional complex Hilbert space and in a real Kähler space. This investigation establishes a direct correspondence between Hermitian operators in the complex Hilbert space and real operators in the Kähler space. In this real formulation, we note the emergent property of spectral degeneracy. Moreover, we show that the structure of the Kähler space provides a natural description of composite systems in real quantum mechanics.

Theoretical and Mathematical Physics•Jul 1, 2026•0 citations

Quantum mechanics over real numbers fully reproduces standard quantum theory

Alan C. Maioli, Evaldo M. F. Curado, Jean-Pierre Gazeau

Standard quantum mechanics employs complex Hilbert spaces, but whether complex numbers are fundamental or merely convenient has long been debated. For decades, real-valued equivalents were considered mathematically possible but cumbersome. However, a highly cited 2021 result claimed that any quantum theory based on real numbers is experimentally falsifiable via network Bell experiments. Yet, it remains an open question whether this falsification applies to all real-valued theories. Here we show that this conclusion rests on an incomplete real formulation, and we present a rigorous real-valued framework that perfectly reproduces all predictions of standard quantum mechanics. We demonstrate that the standard real tensor product ($\otimes_{\mathbb{R}}$) used in previous no-go theorems is algebraically incompatible with the rich structure of conventional quantum mechanics. We present a real framework based on Kähler space and prove that it is exactly isomorphic to established quantum mechanics via an explicit bijection $γ$. The isomorphism extends to composite systems through a symplectic composition rule $\otimes^{\ks}$ that replaces the Kronecker product. Consequently, our formulation achieves the maximal $\mathrm{CHSH}_{3}$ violation of $6\sqrt{2}$ using purely real variables, demonstrating that the no-go theorem is specific to a particular real representation of states and operators and to the composition rule $\otimes_\mathbb{R}$ built upon it, neither of which extends to the present Kähler framework. These results demonstrate that complex numbers are not fundamentally required by nature; rather, they encode a deeper real geometric structure that governs quantum interference and entanglement, settling this long debate.

quant-pharXiv:2604.19482•Apr 22, 2026•6 citations

Quantum dynamics in real Hilbert space: Algebraic isomorphism and symplectic geometry of the Schrödinger equation

Pushpendra Singh

This work reformulates quantum mechanics in real Hilbert space and demonstrates that the complex structure inherent to the Schrödinger equation can be fully captured by a coupled system of real-valued dynamics. By employing the standard field isomorphism of ( R 2 , + , ⋅ ) to ℂ , the real counterpart of the Schrödinger equation is derived, yielding a system of coupled real partial differential equations. This system reveals a symplectic structure where the symplectic matrix J geometrically represents the imaginary unit i , acting as a phase-space rotation operator. Time-independent solutions decouple into identical real Helmholtz equations, preserving spectral equivalence. The reformulation provides geometric insights into foundational aspects: the geometric representation of i , the emergence of probability conservation from real-component interactions, and the encoding of quantum phase relationships through the multiplicative structure of the R 2 field. This perspective reinforces connections to classical Hamiltonian mechanics and geometric quantization, suggesting that complex numbers are structural, emerging from field operations on the real plane, rather than fundamental. Building on these foundations, we present original results where quantum computation elements like qubits and gates are shown to have equivalent representations as real symplectic and special orthogonal matrices, maintaining unitary equivalence. We introduce a framework for quantum computation within a real vector space and provide a generalized protocol for generating entangled Bell states. These results offer a new perspective on the necessity of complex numbers in quantum theory, providing a framework with potential computational advantages for hybrid quantum–classical systems and enhanced geometric interpretability.

Annals of Physics•Jan 29, 2026•4 citations

Geometric Hamiltonian formulation of quantum mechanics in complex projective spaces

Davide Pastorello

In finite dimension (at least), Quantum Mechanics can be formulated as a proper Hamiltonian theory where a notion of phase space is given by the projective space P(H) constructed on the Hilbert space H of the considered quantum theory. It is well-known P(H) can be equipped with a structure of Kähler manifold, in particular we have a symplectic form and a Poisson structure; Quantum dynamics can be described in terms of a Hamiltonian vector field on P(H). In this paper, exploiting the notion and properties of so-called frame functions, I describe a general prescription for associating quantum observables to real functions on P(H), classical-like observables, and quantum states to probability densities on P(H), Liouville densities, in order to obtain a complete and meaningful Hamiltonian formulation of a finite-dimensional quantum theory.

International Journal of Geometric Methods in Modern Physics•Jun 12, 2015•8 citations

QUANTUM PHASE SPACE FORMULATION OF SCHRÖDINGER MECHANICS

Renzo Cirelli, Alessandro Manià, Livio Pizzocchero B

We develop a geometrical approach to Schrödinger quantum mechanics, alternative to the usual one, which is based on linear and algebraic structures such as Hilbert spaces, operator algebras, etc. The starting point of this approach is the Kähler structure possessed by the set of the pure states of a quantum system. The Kähler manifold of the pure states is regarded as a “quantum phase space”, conceptually analogous to the phase space of a classical hamiltonian system, and all the constituents of the conventional formulation, in particular the algebraic structure of the observables, are reproduced using a suitable “Kähler formalism”. We also show that the probabilistic character of the measurement process in quantum mechanics and the uncertainty principle are contained in the geometrical structure of the quantum phase space. Finally, we obtain a characterization for quantum phase spaces which can be interpreted as a statement of uniqueness for Schrödinger quantum mechanics.

International Journal of Modern Physics A•May 20, 1991•18 citations
In this paper, we demonstrate the equivalence between the complex Hilbert space and real Kahler space formulations of quantum mechanics. Complex numbers play an important role in the traditional formulation of quantum mechanics in complex Hilbert spaces. However, the necessity of complex numbers--as opposed to their mere convenience--remains a subject of debate. Several alternative formulations of quantum mechanics using real numbers have been proposed. In this paper, we demonstrate that standard quantum mechanics, formulated in a complex Hilbert space, admits an equivalent reformulation in a real Kahler space. By establishing a natural isomorphism between the operator theories of the complex Hilbert space and the real Kahler space, we prove the equivalence of the two formulations including composite system. This Kahler-space framework preserves all essential features of quantum mechanics while offering a key advantage: it inherently incorporates a Hamiltonian symplectic structure analogous to classical mechanics. This structural alignment provides a unified geometric perspective for both classical and quantum dynamics. Additionally, we show that the ergodicity of finite-dimensional quantum systems becomes manifest in this framework, resolving interpretational ambiguities present in conventional complex formulations.
The necessity of complex numbers in quantum mechanics has long been debated. This paper develops a real Kahler space formulation of quantum mechanics [19], asserting equivalence to the standard complex Hilbert space framework. By mapping the complex Hilbert space Cn{\mathbb C}^nCn to a real Kahler space K2nK ^{2n}K2n, i.e. R2n{\mathbb R}^{2n}R2n equipped with a metric, a symplectic structure and an automorphism, we establish a correspondence between Hermitian operators in Cn{\mathbb C}^nCn and real operators in K2nK^{2n}K2n. While the isomorphism appears straightforward some subtleties emerge: (i) the overcounting of composite system states under tensor products in R2n{\mathbb R}^{2n}R2n, and (ii) the double degeneracy of operator spectra in the real formulation. Through a systematic investigation of these challenges, we clarify the structural relationship between real and complex formulations, resolve ambiguities in composite system representations, and analyze spectral consequences. Our results reaffirm the equivalence of the two frameworks while highlighting nuanced distinctions with implications for foundational debates on locality, phase invariance, and the role of complex numbers in quantum theory.
Abstract We investigate the isomorphism between the formulations of quantum mechanics in a finite-dimensional complex Hilbert space and in a real Kähler space. This investigation establishes a direct correspondence between Hermitian operators in the complex Hilbert space and real operators in the Kähler space. In this real formulation, we note the emergent property of spectral degeneracy. Moreover, we show that the structure of the Kähler space provides a natural description of composite systems in real quantum mechanics.
Standard quantum mechanics employs complex Hilbert spaces, but whether complex numbers are fundamental or merely convenient has long been debated. For decades, real-valued equivalents were considered mathematically possible but cumbersome. However, a highly cited 2021 result claimed that any quantum theory based on real numbers is experimentally falsifiable via network Bell experiments. Yet, it remains an open question whether this falsification applies to all real-valued theories. Here we show that this conclusion rests on an incomplete real formulation, and we present a rigorous real-valued framework that perfectly reproduces all predictions of standard quantum mechanics. We demonstrate that the standard real tensor product (⊗R\otimes_{\mathbb{R}}⊗R​) used in previous no-go theorems is algebraically incompatible with the rich structure of conventional quantum mechanics. We present a real framework based on Kähler space and prove that it is exactly isomorphic to established quantum mechanics via an explicit bijection γγγ. The isomorphism extends to composite systems through a symplectic composition rule $\otimes^{\ks}$ that replaces the Kronecker product. Consequently, our formulation achieves the maximal CHSH3\mathrm{CHSH}_{3}CHSH3​ violation of 626\sqrt{2}62​ using purely real variables, demonstrating that the no-go theorem is specific to a particular real representation of states and operators and to the composition rule ⊗R\otimes_\mathbb{R}⊗R​ built upon it, neither of which extends to the present Kähler framework. These results demonstrate that complex numbers are not fundamentally required by nature; rather, they encode a deeper real geometric structure that governs quantum interference and entanglement, settling this long debate.
This work reformulates quantum mechanics in real Hilbert space and demonstrates that the complex structure inherent to the Schrödinger equation can be fully captured by a coupled system of real-valued dynamics. By employing the standard field isomorphism of ( R 2 , + , ⋅ ) to ℂ , the real counterpart of the Schrödinger equation is derived, yielding a system of coupled real partial differential equations. This system reveals a symplectic structure where the symplectic matrix J geometrically represents the imaginary unit i , acting as a phase-space rotation operator. Time-independent solutions decouple into identical real Helmholtz equations, preserving spectral equivalence. The reformulation provides geometric insights into foundational aspects: the geometric representation of i , the emergence of probability conservation from real-component interactions, and the encoding of quantum phase relationships through the multiplicative structure of the R 2 field. This perspective reinforces connections to classical Hamiltonian mechanics and geometric quantization, suggesting that complex numbers are structural, emerging from field operations on the real plane, rather than fundamental. Building on these foundations, we present original results where quantum computation elements like qubits and gates are shown to have equivalent representations as real symplectic and special orthogonal matrices, maintaining unitary equivalence. We introduce a framework for quantum computation within a real vector space and provide a generalized protocol for generating entangled Bell states. These results offer a new perspective on the necessity of complex numbers in quantum theory, providing a framework with potential computational advantages for hybrid quantum–classical systems and enhanced geometric interpretability.
In finite dimension (at least), Quantum Mechanics can be formulated as a proper Hamiltonian theory where a notion of phase space is given by the projective space P(H) constructed on the Hilbert space H of the considered quantum theory. It is well-known P(H) can be equipped with a structure of Kähler manifold, in particular we have a symplectic form and a Poisson structure; Quantum dynamics can be described in terms of a Hamiltonian vector field on P(H). In this paper, exploiting the notion and properties of so-called frame functions, I describe a general prescription for associating quantum observables to real functions on P(H), classical-like observables, and quantum states to probability densities on P(H), Liouville densities, in order to obtain a complete and meaningful Hamiltonian formulation of a finite-dimensional quantum theory.
We develop a geometrical approach to Schrödinger quantum mechanics, alternative to the usual one, which is based on linear and algebraic structures such as Hilbert spaces, operator algebras, etc. The starting point of this approach is the Kähler structure possessed by the set of the pure states of a quantum system. The Kähler manifold of the pure states is regarded as a “quantum phase space”, conceptually analogous to the phase space of a classical hamiltonian system, and all the constituents of the conventional formulation, in particular the algebraic structure of the observables, are reproduced using a suitable “Kähler formalism”. We also show that the probabilistic character of the measurement process in quantum mechanics and the uncertainty principle are contained in the geometrical structure of the quantum phase space. Finally, we obtain a characterization for quantum phase spaces which can be interpreted as a statement of uniqueness for Schrödinger quantum mechanics.