Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2504.10386

Universal fault-tolerant logic with heterogeneous holographic codes

Matthew Steinberg, Junyu Fan, Jens Eisert, Sebastian Feld, A. Jahn, ChunJun Cao

Published Apr 14, 2025• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The study of holographic bulk-boundary dualities has led to the construction of novel quantum error correcting codes. Although these codes have shed new light on conceptual aspects of these dualities, they have widely been believed to lack a crucial feature of practical quantum error correction: The ability to support universal fault-tolerant quantum logic. In this work, we introduce a new class of holographic codes that realize this feature. These heterogeneous holographic codes are constructed by combining two seed codes in a tensor network on an alternating hyperbolic tiling. We show how this construction generalizes previous strategies for fault tolerance in tree-type concatenated codes, allowing one to implement non-Clifford gates fault-tolerantly on the holographic boundary. We also demonstrate that these codes allow for high erasure thresholds under a suitable heterogeneous combination of specific seed codes. Compared to previous concatenated codes, heterogeneous holographic codes achieve large overhead savings in physical qubits, e.g., a $21.8\%$ reduction for a two-layer Steane/quantum Reed-Muller combination. Unlike standard concatenated codes, we establish that the new codes can encode more than a single logical qubit per code block by applying ``black hole'' deformations with tunable rate and distance, while possessing fully addressable, universal fault-tolerant gate sets. Therefore, our work strengthens the case for the utility of holographic quantum codes for practical quantum computing.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2504.10386

Related papers

Nonuniform code concatenation for universal fault-tolerant quantum computing

Eesa Nikahd, Mehdi Sedighi, Morteza Saheb Zamani

Using transversal gates is a straightforward and efficient technique for fault-tolerant quantum computing. Since transversal gates alone cannot be computationally universal, they must be combined with other approaches such as magic state distillation, code switching, or code concatenation to achieve universality. In this paper we propose an alternative approach for universal fault-tolerant quantum computing, mainly based on the code concatenation approach proposed in [T. Jochym-O'Connor and R. Laflamme, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 010505 (2014)], but in a nonuniform fashion. The proposed approach is described based on nonuniform concatenation of the 7-qubit Steane code with the 15-qubit Reed-Muller code, as well as the 5-qubit code with the 15-qubit Reed-Muller code, which lead to two 49-qubit and 47-qubit codes, respectively. These codes can correct any arbitrary single physical error with the ability to perform a universal set of fault-tolerant gates, without using magic state distillation.

arXiv:1605.07007•Physical Review A•Sep 27, 2017•18 citations

Fault-Tolerant Conversion between the Steane and Reed-Muller Quantum Codes

Jonas T. Anderson, Guillaume Duclos-Cianci, David Poulin

Steane's 7-qubit quantum error-correcting code admits a set of fault-tolerant gates that generate the Clifford group, which in itself is not universal for quantum computation. The 15-qubit Reed-Muller code also does not admit a universal fault-tolerant gate set but possesses fault-tolerant T and control-control-Z gates. Combined with the Clifford group, either of these two gates generates a universal set. Here, we combine these two features by demonstrating how to fault-tolerantly convert between these two codes, providing a new method to realize universal fault-tolerant quantum computation. One interpretation of our result is that both codes correspond to the same subsystem code in different gauges. Our scheme extends to the entire family of quantum Reed-Muller codes.

arXiv:1403.2734•Physical Review Letters•Aug 20, 2014•188 citations

Concatenated pieceable fault-tolerant scheme for universal quantum computation

Chen Lin, Guowu Yang

As existing approaches to get around the restriction of the no-go theorem generally exhibit high ancillary qubit overhead costs, we propose a scheme for universal fault-tolerant quantum computation by using the pieceable fault-tolerant protocol and code switching techniques. In additional, by utilizing the construction of the pieceable fault-tolerant circuit, we adopt a decoding strategy based on a deep-neural-network algorithm to improve the error threshold of the non-Clifford logical gate circuit. We describe our universal construction in detail with a two-level nonuniform concatenated 25-qubit code and perform numerical simulations to analyze the depolarizing noise threshold of a given universal gate set with this code. The resources required to implement this universal gate set are also estimated to further demonstrate the efficiency of our scheme. We compare these results with the existing universal concatenation methods and conclude that our method outperforms them in terms of the lower bound of the error threshold and qubit resource overhead.

Physical Review A•Nov 17, 2020•5 citations

Quantum Lego Power-up: Designing Transversal Gates with Tensor Networks

ChunJun Cao, Brad Lackey

Transversal gates are the simplest form of fault-tolerant gates and are relatively easy to implement in practice. Yet designing codes that support useful transversal operations -- especially non-Clifford or addressable gates -- remains difficult within the stabilizer formalism or CSS constructions alone. We show that these limitations can be overcome using tensor-network frameworks such as the quantum lego formalism, where transversal gates naturally appear as global or localized symmetries. Within the quantum lego formalism, small codes carrying desirable symmetries can be "glued" into larger ones, with operator-flow rules guiding how logical symmetries are preserved. This approach enables the systematic construction of codes with addressable transversal single- and multi-qubit gates targeting specific logical qubits regardless of whether the gate is Clifford or not. As a proof of principle, we build new finite-rate code families that support strongly transversal $T$, $CCZ$, $SH$, and Gottesman's $K_3$ gates, structures that are challenging to realize with conventional methods. We further construct holographic and fractal-like codes that admit addressable transversal inter-, meso-, and intra-block $T$, $CS$, and $C^\ell Z$ gates. As a corollary, we demonstrate that the heterogeneous holographic Steane-Reed-Muller black hole code also supports fully addressable transversal inter- and intra-block $CZ$ gates, significantly lowering the overhead for universal fault-tolerant computation.

quant-pharXiv:2603.03542•Mar 5, 2026•5 citations

Using Concatenated Quantum Codes for Universal Fault-Tolerant Quantum Gates

Tomas Jochym-O’Connor, Raymond Laflamme

We propose a method for universal fault-tolerant quantum computation using concatenated quantum error correcting codes. The concatenation scheme exploits the transversal properties of two different codes, combining them to provide a means to protect against low-weight arbitrary errors. We give the required properties of the error correcting codes to ensure universal fault tolerance and discuss a particular example using the 7-qubit Steane and 15-qubit Reed-Muller codes. Namely, other than computational basis state preparation as required by the DiVincenzo criteria, our scheme requires no special ancillary state preparation to achieve universality, as opposed to schemes such as magic state distillation. We believe that optimizing the codes used in such a scheme could provide a useful alternative to state distillation schemes that exhibit high overhead costs.

arXiv:1309.3310•Physical Review Letters•Jan 10, 2014•99 citations

Novel Methods in Quantum Error Correction

Tomas Jochym-O’Connor

Quantum error correction is the backbone of fault-tolerant quantum computation, a necessary requirement for any large scale quantum computer. The fault-tolerance threshold theorem has long been a target for experimental precision, allowing for the possibility of reducing logical error rates to arbitrarily low levels without excessive overhead. While there are many promising fault-tolerant architectures, the path towards the most practical fault-tolerant scheme is far from decided and may vary for differing physical models. This thesis proposes new schemes for universal fault-tolerant quantum computation in both the concatenated and topological code settings. \n \nThrough the concatenation of two different error correcting codes, a set of universal fault-tolerant gates can be obtained without requiring the need for magic state distillation. A lower bound of $1.28 \\times 10^{-3}$ for the fault-tolerance threshold under circuit level depolarizing noise is obtained. Additionally, stacked codes are proposed as a means to simulate the action of a 3D topological code in 2D, allowing for the application of a universal set of transversal operations. While fault-tolerant, unfortunately the scheme does not exhibit a threshold due to the decreasing pseudo-threshold with growing code distance, yet points to potential interesting avenues for fault-tolerant computation in 2D without distillation. \n \nOne of the primary avenues to constructing fault-tolerant logical operations is through transversal operations. In this thesis, the set of single qubit logical gates that can be implemented transversally are characterized and determined to all belong to the Clifford hierarchy. Moreover, any diagonal two-qubit operation that can be applied transversally must belong to the same level of the Clifford hierarchy as the set of gates that can be implemented in the single-qubit case. \n \nThe opposite to quantum error correction is privacy, where the output of a channel is disguised from its input. The two are fundamentally related through the complementary channel construction. This thesis presents a new class of private quantum channels, expanding the existing class beyond a seemingly fundamental restriction. This yields interesting insights into the structure of quantum information and the leaking of information to external environments. Additionally, the duality is only recovered when extending the complementary channel to sufficiently high environmental dimension. \n \nFinally, the error properties of bucket brigade quantum Random Access Memory (qRAM) are assessed. It is determined that using the bucket brigade qRAM architecture for the running of Grover's algorithm necessitates reducing the error rate of the individual components to exponentially small levels for an exponential sized memory. As such, fault-tolerant architectures will likely play an essential role in the construction of such computing primitives.

•Aug 24, 2016•0 citations
The study of holographic bulk-boundary dualities has led to the construction of novel quantum error correcting codes. Although these codes have shed new light on conceptual aspects of these dualities, they have widely been believed to lack a crucial feature of practical quantum error correction: The ability to support universal fault-tolerant quantum logic. In this work, we introduce a new class of holographic codes that realize this feature. These heterogeneous holographic codes are constructed by combining two seed codes in a tensor network on an alternating hyperbolic tiling. We show how this construction generalizes previous strategies for fault tolerance in tree-type concatenated codes, allowing one to implement non-Clifford gates fault-tolerantly on the holographic boundary. We also demonstrate that these codes allow for high erasure thresholds under a suitable heterogeneous combination of specific seed codes. Compared to previous concatenated codes, heterogeneous holographic codes achieve large overhead savings in physical qubits, e.g., a 21.8%21.8\%21.8% reduction for a two-layer Steane/quantum Reed-Muller combination. Unlike standard concatenated codes, we establish that the new codes can encode more than a single logical qubit per code block by applying ``black hole'' deformations with tunable rate and distance, while possessing fully addressable, universal fault-tolerant gate sets. Therefore, our work strengthens the case for the utility of holographic quantum codes for practical quantum computing.
Using transversal gates is a straightforward and efficient technique for fault-tolerant quantum computing. Since transversal gates alone cannot be computationally universal, they must be combined with other approaches such as magic state distillation, code switching, or code concatenation to achieve universality. In this paper we propose an alternative approach for universal fault-tolerant quantum computing, mainly based on the code concatenation approach proposed in [T. Jochym-O'Connor and R. Laflamme, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 010505 (2014)], but in a nonuniform fashion. The proposed approach is described based on nonuniform concatenation of the 7-qubit Steane code with the 15-qubit Reed-Muller code, as well as the 5-qubit code with the 15-qubit Reed-Muller code, which lead to two 49-qubit and 47-qubit codes, respectively. These codes can correct any arbitrary single physical error with the ability to perform a universal set of fault-tolerant gates, without using magic state distillation.
Steane's 7-qubit quantum error-correcting code admits a set of fault-tolerant gates that generate the Clifford group, which in itself is not universal for quantum computation. The 15-qubit Reed-Muller code also does not admit a universal fault-tolerant gate set but possesses fault-tolerant T and control-control-Z gates. Combined with the Clifford group, either of these two gates generates a universal set. Here, we combine these two features by demonstrating how to fault-tolerantly convert between these two codes, providing a new method to realize universal fault-tolerant quantum computation. One interpretation of our result is that both codes correspond to the same subsystem code in different gauges. Our scheme extends to the entire family of quantum Reed-Muller codes.
As existing approaches to get around the restriction of the no-go theorem generally exhibit high ancillary qubit overhead costs, we propose a scheme for universal fault-tolerant quantum computation by using the pieceable fault-tolerant protocol and code switching techniques. In additional, by utilizing the construction of the pieceable fault-tolerant circuit, we adopt a decoding strategy based on a deep-neural-network algorithm to improve the error threshold of the non-Clifford logical gate circuit. We describe our universal construction in detail with a two-level nonuniform concatenated 25-qubit code and perform numerical simulations to analyze the depolarizing noise threshold of a given universal gate set with this code. The resources required to implement this universal gate set are also estimated to further demonstrate the efficiency of our scheme. We compare these results with the existing universal concatenation methods and conclude that our method outperforms them in terms of the lower bound of the error threshold and qubit resource overhead.
Transversal gates are the simplest form of fault-tolerant gates and are relatively easy to implement in practice. Yet designing codes that support useful transversal operations -- especially non-Clifford or addressable gates -- remains difficult within the stabilizer formalism or CSS constructions alone. We show that these limitations can be overcome using tensor-network frameworks such as the quantum lego formalism, where transversal gates naturally appear as global or localized symmetries. Within the quantum lego formalism, small codes carrying desirable symmetries can be "glued" into larger ones, with operator-flow rules guiding how logical symmetries are preserved. This approach enables the systematic construction of codes with addressable transversal single- and multi-qubit gates targeting specific logical qubits regardless of whether the gate is Clifford or not. As a proof of principle, we build new finite-rate code families that support strongly transversal TTT, CCZCCZCCZ, SHSHSH, and Gottesman's K3K_3K3​ gates, structures that are challenging to realize with conventional methods. We further construct holographic and fractal-like codes that admit addressable transversal inter-, meso-, and intra-block TTT, CSCSCS, and CℓZC^\ell ZCℓZ gates. As a corollary, we demonstrate that the heterogeneous holographic Steane-Reed-Muller black hole code also supports fully addressable transversal inter- and intra-block CZCZCZ gates, significantly lowering the overhead for universal fault-tolerant computation.
We propose a method for universal fault-tolerant quantum computation using concatenated quantum error correcting codes. The concatenation scheme exploits the transversal properties of two different codes, combining them to provide a means to protect against low-weight arbitrary errors. We give the required properties of the error correcting codes to ensure universal fault tolerance and discuss a particular example using the 7-qubit Steane and 15-qubit Reed-Muller codes. Namely, other than computational basis state preparation as required by the DiVincenzo criteria, our scheme requires no special ancillary state preparation to achieve universality, as opposed to schemes such as magic state distillation. We believe that optimizing the codes used in such a scheme could provide a useful alternative to state distillation schemes that exhibit high overhead costs.
Quantum error correction is the backbone of fault-tolerant quantum computation, a necessary requirement for any large scale quantum computer. The fault-tolerance threshold theorem has long been a target for experimental precision, allowing for the possibility of reducing logical error rates to arbitrarily low levels without excessive overhead. While there are many promising fault-tolerant architectures, the path towards the most practical fault-tolerant scheme is far from decided and may vary for differing physical models. This thesis proposes new schemes for universal fault-tolerant quantum computation in both the concatenated and topological code settings. \n \nThrough the concatenation of two different error correcting codes, a set of universal fault-tolerant gates can be obtained without requiring the need for magic state distillation. A lower bound of 1.28times10−31.28 \\times 10^{-3}1.28times10−3 for the fault-tolerance threshold under circuit level depolarizing noise is obtained. Additionally, stacked codes are proposed as a means to simulate the action of a 3D topological code in 2D, allowing for the application of a universal set of transversal operations. While fault-tolerant, unfortunately the scheme does not exhibit a threshold due to the decreasing pseudo-threshold with growing code distance, yet points to potential interesting avenues for fault-tolerant computation in 2D without distillation. \n \nOne of the primary avenues to constructing fault-tolerant logical operations is through transversal operations. In this thesis, the set of single qubit logical gates that can be implemented transversally are characterized and determined to all belong to the Clifford hierarchy. Moreover, any diagonal two-qubit operation that can be applied transversally must belong to the same level of the Clifford hierarchy as the set of gates that can be implemented in the single-qubit case. \n \nThe opposite to quantum error correction is privacy, where the output of a channel is disguised from its input. The two are fundamentally related through the complementary channel construction. This thesis presents a new class of private quantum channels, expanding the existing class beyond a seemingly fundamental restriction. This yields interesting insights into the structure of quantum information and the leaking of information to external environments. Additionally, the duality is only recovered when extending the complementary channel to sufficiently high environmental dimension. \n \nFinally, the error properties of bucket brigade quantum Random Access Memory (qRAM) are assessed. It is determined that using the bucket brigade qRAM architecture for the running of Grover's algorithm necessitates reducing the error rate of the individual components to exponentially small levels for an exponential sized memory. As such, fault-tolerant architectures will likely play an essential role in the construction of such computing primitives.