Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2504.05842 · Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment

Exact results for spin glass criticality

Gesualdo Delfino A

Published Jun 1, 2025• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract In recent years scale invariant scattering theory provided the first exact access to the magnetic critical properties of two-dimensional statistical systems with quenched disorder. We show how the theory extends to the overlap variables entering the characterization of spin glass properties. The resulting exact fixed point equations yield both the magnetic and, for the first time, the spin glass renormalization group fixed points. For the case of the random bond Ising model, on which we focus, the spin glass subspace of solutions is found to contain a line of fixed points. We discuss the implications of the results for Ising spin glass criticality and compare with the available numerical results.

DOI
10.1088/1742-5468/ade135

Related papers

Nonuniversality in random criticality

Gesualdo Delfino A

Abstract We consider N two-dimensional Ising models coupled in the presence of quenched disorder and use scale invariant scattering theory to exactly show the presence of a line of renormalization group fixed points for any fixed value of N other than 1. We show how this result relates to perturbative studies and sheds light on numerical simulations. We also observe that the limit N → 1 may be of interest for the Ising spin glass, and point out the potential relevance for nonuniversality in other contexts of random criticality.

arXiv:2408.04548•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Jan 1, 2025•4 citations

Application of Renormalization-Group Techniques to Random Magnetic Systems.

Ciriyam Jayaprakash

"Renorma1ization-group methods have been applied in the study of quenched random magnetic systems in recent years. We begin with a brief review of second-order phase transitions in pure, homogeneous systems and also of the .. renorma1ization group framework. Then we provide an introduction to quenched random magnetic systems. Next, momentum-space methods and position-space techniques as applied to quenched random magnets are outlined and compared. Grinstein and Luther applied the Wilson-Fisher E-expansion to random n-vector models; Khme1'nitsky discovered that the random Ising model (n = 1) possessed a ""random"" fixed point of 0(squareroot(e)). This fixed point was found to have one marginal and one irrelevant operator. We have investigated the stability of this fixed point using Ca11an-Symanzik equations and renorma1ized perturbation theory. We find the fixed point stable in the next order; we have also obtained critical exponents to one higher order. Next, position-space techniques are used to study some simple model systems. In addition to critical exponents, global thermodynamic properties are determined. These calculations are based on the Migda1-Kadanoff approximate recursion relations suitably generalized to the inhomogeneous case. Firstly we study the randomly bond-dilute two-dimensional nearest- neighbor Ising model on a square lattice. Calculations give both thermal and magnetic exponents associated with the percolative fixed point. Differential recursion relations yield a phase diagram which is in quantitative agreement with all known results. Curves for the specific heat, percolation probability, and magnetization are displayed. The critical region of the specific heat becomes unobservably narrow well above the percolation threshold Pc. This provides a possible explanation for the apparent specific-heat rounding in certain experiments. We then study the Edwards-Anderson model of a spin glass. The current theoretical situation, which is far from satisfactory at present, is briefly reviewed. We treat the spin-l/2 Ising model with independently random nearestneighbor interactions in dimensionalities d = 2, 3, and 4. The phase diagram, which is in qualitative agreement with mean-field results, exhibits paramagnetic, ferromagnetic, antiferromagnetic, and spin-glass phases. The spinglass and paramagnetic phases meet along an extended second-order phase boundary, which terminates in two tricritical points. Critical and tricritical exponents are calculated. The spin-glass specific-heat exponent turns out to be large and negative, compatibly with recent experiments which show a rounded specific heat anomaly. Global specific-heat curves are also displayed for d = 2."

•Feb 1, 1979•0 citations

On the nature of the spin glass transition

Gesualdo Delfino A

Abstract We recently showed that the two-dimensional Ising spin glass allows for a line of renormalization group fixed points which explains properties observed in numerical studies. We observe that this exact result corresponds to enhancement to a one-generator continuous internal symmetry. This finally explains why no finite temperature transition to a spin glass phase is observed in two dimensions. In more than two dimensions, instead, the continuous symmetry can be broken spontaneously and yields a spin glass order parameter which, for fixed temperature and disorder strength, takes continuous values in an interval. Such a feature is shared by the order parameter of the known mean field solution of the model with infinite-range interactions, which corresponds to infinitely many dimensions.

arXiv:2511.20163•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Apr 1, 2026•2 citations

Criticality in the disordered N -color Ashkin–Teller model

Youssef Makoudi, Gesualdo Delfino A

Abstract The N -color Ashkin–Teller model corresponds to N Ising models coupled by four-spin interactions. We consider the two-dimensional case in presence of quenched disorder and use scale invariant scattering theory to determine all the solutions of the exact renormalization group fixed points equations. The weak disorder sector is characterized by a solution that, for any fixed N larger than 1, is a line of fixed points with Ising thermal exponents and continuously varying magnetic exponents. The number of fixed point solutions allowed by the symmetries of the model increases at strong disorder illustrating the growing dependence on the distributions of the two random couplings. The presence of some critical exponents which do not depend on the symmetry parameter N confirms this type of superuniversality as a peculiar feature of random criticality.

arXiv:2605.29810•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Aug 1, 2026•0 citations

Studies in Random Ising Spin Systems

Ho Fai Cheung

We give a brief survey of Ising spin systems in the presence of random bonds or random fields. Specific calculations are done on the twodimensional short-ranged random-bond model and the three-dimensional random-field model. The phenomenological renormalization group and the transfer-matrix method are generalized to random systems and applied to the random-bond Ising model, also called the Edwards-Anderson spin-glass model. Results show that the two-dimensional Edwards-Anderson model has a spin-glass transition at zero temperature, in agreement with other calculations. We obtain an accurate estimate of the correlation-length exponent. We also find unexpectedly different critical behavior for different bond distributions. A simple renormalization-group calculation is applied to the twodimensional random-bond Ising model with non-zero-mean bond strength. Our result fails to confirm McMillan's result that there are two different critical behaviors along the ferromagnetic phase boundary. McMillan's domain-wall renormalization group is applied to the three -dimensional random-field Ising model. Numerical results show that the critical behavior of this model is controlled by a fixed point at zero temperature. The exponents are estimated. We find that, whenever there is a relevant zero-temperature fixed point, the singular part of the free energy is not of the usual form: The leading exponent that describes the renormalization-group flow towards zero temperature is relevant to the critical behavior. One of the consequences is that the hyperscaling law is modified. This new picture explains many experimental results for dilute antiferromagnets, ·which are experimental realizations of the random-field Ising model. We also discuss the possibility of a first-order transition for this model.

•Jan 1, 1986•0 citations

Exact results for the O(N ) model with quenched disorder

Gesualdo Delfino A, Noel Lamsen

Abstract We use scale invariant scattering theory to exactly determine the lines of renormalization group fixed points for O(N )-symmetric models with quenched disorder in two dimensions. Random fixed points are characterized by two disorder parameters: a modulus that vanishes when approaching the pure case, and a phase angle. The critical lines fall into three classes depending on the values of the disorder modulus. Besides the class corresponding to the pure case, a second class has maximal value of the disorder modulus and includes Nishimori-like multicritical points as well as zero temperature fixed points. The third class contains critical lines that interpolate, as N varies, between the first two classes. For positive N , it contains a single line of infrared fixed points spanning the values of N from $$ \sqrt{2}-1 $$ 2 − 1 to 1. The symmetry sector of the energy density operator is superuniversal (i.e. N -independent) along this line. For N = 2 a line of fixed points exists only in the pure case, but accounts also for the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless phase observed in presence of disorder.

arXiv:1802.07151•Journal of High Energy Physics•Apr 1, 2018•13 citations
Abstract In recent years scale invariant scattering theory provided the first exact access to the magnetic critical properties of two-dimensional statistical systems with quenched disorder. We show how the theory extends to the overlap variables entering the characterization of spin glass properties. The resulting exact fixed point equations yield both the magnetic and, for the first time, the spin glass renormalization group fixed points. For the case of the random bond Ising model, on which we focus, the spin glass subspace of solutions is found to contain a line of fixed points. We discuss the implications of the results for Ising spin glass criticality and compare with the available numerical results.
Abstract We consider N two-dimensional Ising models coupled in the presence of quenched disorder and use scale invariant scattering theory to exactly show the presence of a line of renormalization group fixed points for any fixed value of N other than 1. We show how this result relates to perturbative studies and sheds light on numerical simulations. We also observe that the limit N → 1 may be of interest for the Ising spin glass, and point out the potential relevance for nonuniversality in other contexts of random criticality.
"Renorma1ization-group methods have been applied in the study of quenched random magnetic systems in recent years. We begin with a brief review of second-order phase transitions in pure, homogeneous systems and also of the .. renorma1ization group framework. Then we provide an introduction to quenched random magnetic systems. Next, momentum-space methods and position-space techniques as applied to quenched random magnets are outlined and compared. Grinstein and Luther applied the Wilson-Fisher E-expansion to random n-vector models; Khme1'nitsky discovered that the random Ising model (n = 1) possessed a ""random"" fixed point of 0(squareroot(e)). This fixed point was found to have one marginal and one irrelevant operator. We have investigated the stability of this fixed point using Ca11an-Symanzik equations and renorma1ized perturbation theory. We find the fixed point stable in the next order; we have also obtained critical exponents to one higher order. Next, position-space techniques are used to study some simple model systems. In addition to critical exponents, global thermodynamic properties are determined. These calculations are based on the Migda1-Kadanoff approximate recursion relations suitably generalized to the inhomogeneous case. Firstly we study the randomly bond-dilute two-dimensional nearest- neighbor Ising model on a square lattice. Calculations give both thermal and magnetic exponents associated with the percolative fixed point. Differential recursion relations yield a phase diagram which is in quantitative agreement with all known results. Curves for the specific heat, percolation probability, and magnetization are displayed. The critical region of the specific heat becomes unobservably narrow well above the percolation threshold Pc. This provides a possible explanation for the apparent specific-heat rounding in certain experiments. We then study the Edwards-Anderson model of a spin glass. The current theoretical situation, which is far from satisfactory at present, is briefly reviewed. We treat the spin-l/2 Ising model with independently random nearestneighbor interactions in dimensionalities d = 2, 3, and 4. The phase diagram, which is in qualitative agreement with mean-field results, exhibits paramagnetic, ferromagnetic, antiferromagnetic, and spin-glass phases. The spinglass and paramagnetic phases meet along an extended second-order phase boundary, which terminates in two tricritical points. Critical and tricritical exponents are calculated. The spin-glass specific-heat exponent turns out to be large and negative, compatibly with recent experiments which show a rounded specific heat anomaly. Global specific-heat curves are also displayed for d = 2."
Abstract We recently showed that the two-dimensional Ising spin glass allows for a line of renormalization group fixed points which explains properties observed in numerical studies. We observe that this exact result corresponds to enhancement to a one-generator continuous internal symmetry. This finally explains why no finite temperature transition to a spin glass phase is observed in two dimensions. In more than two dimensions, instead, the continuous symmetry can be broken spontaneously and yields a spin glass order parameter which, for fixed temperature and disorder strength, takes continuous values in an interval. Such a feature is shared by the order parameter of the known mean field solution of the model with infinite-range interactions, which corresponds to infinitely many dimensions.
Abstract The N -color Ashkin–Teller model corresponds to N Ising models coupled by four-spin interactions. We consider the two-dimensional case in presence of quenched disorder and use scale invariant scattering theory to determine all the solutions of the exact renormalization group fixed points equations. The weak disorder sector is characterized by a solution that, for any fixed N larger than 1, is a line of fixed points with Ising thermal exponents and continuously varying magnetic exponents. The number of fixed point solutions allowed by the symmetries of the model increases at strong disorder illustrating the growing dependence on the distributions of the two random couplings. The presence of some critical exponents which do not depend on the symmetry parameter N confirms this type of superuniversality as a peculiar feature of random criticality.
We give a brief survey of Ising spin systems in the presence of random bonds or random fields. Specific calculations are done on the twodimensional short-ranged random-bond model and the three-dimensional random-field model. The phenomenological renormalization group and the transfer-matrix method are generalized to random systems and applied to the random-bond Ising model, also called the Edwards-Anderson spin-glass model. Results show that the two-dimensional Edwards-Anderson model has a spin-glass transition at zero temperature, in agreement with other calculations. We obtain an accurate estimate of the correlation-length exponent. We also find unexpectedly different critical behavior for different bond distributions. A simple renormalization-group calculation is applied to the twodimensional random-bond Ising model with non-zero-mean bond strength. Our result fails to confirm McMillan's result that there are two different critical behaviors along the ferromagnetic phase boundary. McMillan's domain-wall renormalization group is applied to the three -dimensional random-field Ising model. Numerical results show that the critical behavior of this model is controlled by a fixed point at zero temperature. The exponents are estimated. We find that, whenever there is a relevant zero-temperature fixed point, the singular part of the free energy is not of the usual form: The leading exponent that describes the renormalization-group flow towards zero temperature is relevant to the critical behavior. One of the consequences is that the hyperscaling law is modified. This new picture explains many experimental results for dilute antiferromagnets, ·which are experimental realizations of the random-field Ising model. We also discuss the possibility of a first-order transition for this model.
Abstract We use scale invariant scattering theory to exactly determine the lines of renormalization group fixed points for O(N )-symmetric models with quenched disorder in two dimensions. Random fixed points are characterized by two disorder parameters: a modulus that vanishes when approaching the pure case, and a phase angle. The critical lines fall into three classes depending on the values of the disorder modulus. Besides the class corresponding to the pure case, a second class has maximal value of the disorder modulus and includes Nishimori-like multicritical points as well as zero temperature fixed points. The third class contains critical lines that interpolate, as N varies, between the first two classes. For positive N , it contains a single line of infrared fixed points spanning the values of N from 2−1 \sqrt{2}-1 2​−1 2 − 1 to 1. The symmetry sector of the energy density operator is superuniversal (i.e. N -independent) along this line. For N = 2 a line of fixed points exists only in the pure case, but accounts also for the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless phase observed in presence of disorder.