Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2504.04095 · American Journal of Physics

The asymmetric rotating saddle potential as a mechanical analog to the RF Paul trap

Aidan Carey, Laurel Barnett, Robert Hart, Anna Klales, Ali Kurmus, Louis Deslauriers

Published Jul 23, 2026• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Under specific conditions, a rotating saddle potential can confine the motion of a particle on its surface. This time-varying hyperbolic potential shares key characteristics with the RF-electric-quadrupole ion trap (RF Paul trap), making it a valuable mechanical analog. Previous work has primarily focused on symmetric saddles, characterized by equal curvatures along the trapping and anti-trapping directions. RF Paul traps, however, are asymmetric, because the degeneracy of the transverse motional modes must be lifted for laser cooling and other quantum control. In this paper, we investigate the motion of trapped particles in asymmetric rotating saddles. We demonstrate that even minor asymmetries, including those arising from manufacturing imperfections, can significantly affect particle trajectories and stability. Our analysis includes both theoretical modeling and experimental measurements. We derive the equations of motion for asymmetric saddles and solve them to explore stability and precession effects. Additionally, we present lifetime measurements of particles in saddles with varying degrees of asymmetry to map key features of the a–q stability diagram. This study underscores the importance of incorporating asymmetry into mechanical models of ion traps to better reflect real-world implementations.

DOI
10.1119/5.0274638

Related papers

Stability analysis of ion motion in asymmetric planar ion traps

Fayaz A. Shaikh, Arkadaş Özakın

Motivated by recent developments in ion trap design and fabrication, we investigate the stability of the motion of an ion in asymmetrical, planar versions of the linear Paul trap. The equations of motion of an ion in such a trap are generally coupled due to a nonzero relative angle θ between the principal axes of RF and DC fields, invalidating the assumptions behind the standard stability analysis for symmetric Paul traps. Using numerical methods, we obtain stability diagrams for the coupled system for various values of θ, generalizing the standard q-a stability diagrams. We then use multi-scale perturbation theory to obtain approximate formulas for the boundaries of the primary stability region and check our formulas against results from numerical analysis. Our results show that while the primary stability region is quite robust to changes in θ, a secondary stability region is highly variable, joining the primary stability region at the special case of θ=45°, which results in a significantly enlarged stability region for this particular angle. We conclude that while the standard stability diagrams for classical, symmetric Paul traps are not entirely accurate for asymmetric surface traps (or for other types of traps with a relative angle between the RF and DC axes), they are “safe” in the sense that operating conditions deemed stable according to standard stability plots are in fact stable for asymmetric traps, as well. By ignoring the coupling in the equations, one only underestimates the size of the primary stability region.

arXiv:1109.2160•Journal of Applied Physics•Oct 1, 2012•25 citations

Harmonic linear Paul trap: Stability diagram and effective potentials

Michael Drewsen, A. Brøner

We present the single-particle stability diagram for the radial motion in a linear Paul trap in a situation where the applied axial dc potential gives rise to a harmonic defocusing radial potential. Although most linear Paul trap experiments have been conducted in a regime where this approximation is reasonably valid, the effect of the axial confinement on the stability of the radial motion has not previously been analyzed. The defocusing effect in both radial directions leads to a stability diagram different from that of the two-dimensional quadrupole mass filter, and hence points toward new studies of few ion dynamics. Expressions for the effective or pseudopotentials for one and two charged particles are presented and discussed.

Physical Review A•Sep 11, 2000•91 citations

Implementation of a Rotationally Symmetric Ring Ion Trap and Coherent Control of Rotational States

Erik Urban

In this thesis, I present the design, implementation, and characterization of a novel, rotationally symmetric ion trap. Our compact design creates a toroidal trapping potential for charged atoms that has a radius that is much smaller than the height at which the ions are positioned above the surface of the trap. We trap ions at a height of 385~$\\mu$m and a radius of 45~$\\mu$m as expected from simulation. We demonstrate that this ring is rotationally symmetric with imperfections in the potential of much less than 3~mK. With two ions contained in a point Paul trap, we demonstrate the creation of a 100~kHz rotating ring using a rotating quadrupole. By releasing the quadrupole potential, we demonstrate the ability to create superpositions of rotational states using the modulation of the laser light produced by the classical rotation of the crystal in a symmetric potential. Superpositions of rotational states differing by up to four quanta are observed. With these rotational superpositions, we describe an experiment capable of observing the identical nature of two ions in a Coulomb crystal. By creating a rotational interferometer, one can coherently exchange two particles and observe their interference upon recombination. We describe what this interference signature would be and how particle indistinguishability would affect it. We present experimental efforts towards realizing this exchange and reflect on our unexpectedly short rotational superposition coherence times.

•Jan 1, 2019•2 citations

Simulation of motion of many ions in a linear Paul trap

Martin Oral, Ondřej Číp, L. Slodička

The quadrupole linear Paul trap is one of the key instruments in building highly stable atomic clocks. However, a frequency reference based on a single trapped ion is limited in stability due to the time needed for the interrogation cycle which cannot be further shortened. A promising strategy is the utilization of multiple trapped ions. The ions of the same kind then repulse each other with the Coulomb force, which is countered by the ponderomotive force of the time depended field in the trap. A few ions form a chain along the axis of a linear Paul trap. Adding more ions (a few tens or hundreds) gives rise to Coulomb crystals. We created an efficient simulation code which calculates the motion of such collections of ions in quasi-static radiofrequency fields of real linear quadrupole traps (including the micromotion). We include a model for laser cooling of the ions. The simulation tool can be used to study the formation and the dynamics of Coulomb crystals under conditions corresponding to various experimental setups.

arXiv:2112.02203•International Journal of Modern Physics A•Dec 30, 2019•2 citations

All-optical saddle trap

DANIEL RIBAS TANDEITNIK, Oscar Kremer, Felipe Almeida +3 more

The superposition of frequency-shifted Laguerre-Gauss modes can produce a rotating saddlelike intensity profile. When spinning fast enough, the optical forces produced by this structured light saddle generate a dynamically stable equilibrium point capable of trapping nanoparticles in a high vacuum, akin to a Paul trap but with its unique characteristics. We analyze the stability conditions and center-of-mass motion, dynamics and cooling of a nanoparticle levitated in the optical saddle trap. We expect the optical saddle to find applications in levitated optomechanics experiments requiring fast parametric modulation and inverted squeezing potential landscapes.

arXiv:2407.12668•Physical Review Applied•Oct 28, 2024•1 citation

Investigations on Dynamical Stability in 3D Quadrupole Ion Traps

Bogdan M. Mihalcea, Stephen Lynch

We firstly discuss classical stability for a dynamical system of two ions levitated in a 3D Radio-Frequency (RF) trap, assimilated with two coupled oscillators. We obtain the solutions of the coupled system of equations that characterizes the associated dynamics. In addition, we supply the modes of oscillation and demonstrate the weak coupling condition is inappropriate in practice, while for collective modes of motion (and strong coupling) only a peak of the mass can be detected. Phase portraits and power spectra are employed to illustrate how the trajectory executes quasiperiodic motion on the surface of torus, namely a Kolmogorov–Arnold–Moser (KAM) torus. In an attempt to better describe dynamical stability of the system, we introduce a model that characterizes dynamical stability and the critical points based on the Hessian matrix approach. The model is then applied to investigate quantum dynamics for many-body systems consisting of identical ions, levitated in 2D and 3D ion traps. Finally, the same model is applied to the case of a combined 3D Quadrupole Ion Trap (QIT) with axial symmetry, for which we obtain the associated Hamilton function. The ion distribution can be described by means of numerical modeling, based on the Hamilton function we assign to the system. The approach we introduce is effective to infer the parameters of distinct types of traps by applying a unitary and coherent method, and especially for identifying equilibrium configurations, of large interest for ion crystals or quantum logic.

arXiv:1904.13393•Applied Sciences•Mar 25, 2021•17 citations
Under specific conditions, a rotating saddle potential can confine the motion of a particle on its surface. This time-varying hyperbolic potential shares key characteristics with the RF-electric-quadrupole ion trap (RF Paul trap), making it a valuable mechanical analog. Previous work has primarily focused on symmetric saddles, characterized by equal curvatures along the trapping and anti-trapping directions. RF Paul traps, however, are asymmetric, because the degeneracy of the transverse motional modes must be lifted for laser cooling and other quantum control. In this paper, we investigate the motion of trapped particles in asymmetric rotating saddles. We demonstrate that even minor asymmetries, including those arising from manufacturing imperfections, can significantly affect particle trajectories and stability. Our analysis includes both theoretical modeling and experimental measurements. We derive the equations of motion for asymmetric saddles and solve them to explore stability and precession effects. Additionally, we present lifetime measurements of particles in saddles with varying degrees of asymmetry to map key features of the a–q stability diagram. This study underscores the importance of incorporating asymmetry into mechanical models of ion traps to better reflect real-world implementations.
Motivated by recent developments in ion trap design and fabrication, we investigate the stability of the motion of an ion in asymmetrical, planar versions of the linear Paul trap. The equations of motion of an ion in such a trap are generally coupled due to a nonzero relative angle θ between the principal axes of RF and DC fields, invalidating the assumptions behind the standard stability analysis for symmetric Paul traps. Using numerical methods, we obtain stability diagrams for the coupled system for various values of θ, generalizing the standard q-a stability diagrams. We then use multi-scale perturbation theory to obtain approximate formulas for the boundaries of the primary stability region and check our formulas against results from numerical analysis. Our results show that while the primary stability region is quite robust to changes in θ, a secondary stability region is highly variable, joining the primary stability region at the special case of θ=45°, which results in a significantly enlarged stability region for this particular angle. We conclude that while the standard stability diagrams for classical, symmetric Paul traps are not entirely accurate for asymmetric surface traps (or for other types of traps with a relative angle between the RF and DC axes), they are “safe” in the sense that operating conditions deemed stable according to standard stability plots are in fact stable for asymmetric traps, as well. By ignoring the coupling in the equations, one only underestimates the size of the primary stability region.
We present the single-particle stability diagram for the radial motion in a linear Paul trap in a situation where the applied axial dc potential gives rise to a harmonic defocusing radial potential. Although most linear Paul trap experiments have been conducted in a regime where this approximation is reasonably valid, the effect of the axial confinement on the stability of the radial motion has not previously been analyzed. The defocusing effect in both radial directions leads to a stability diagram different from that of the two-dimensional quadrupole mass filter, and hence points toward new studies of few ion dynamics. Expressions for the effective or pseudopotentials for one and two charged particles are presented and discussed.
In this thesis, I present the design, implementation, and characterization of a novel, rotationally symmetric ion trap. Our compact design creates a toroidal trapping potential for charged atoms that has a radius that is much smaller than the height at which the ions are positioned above the surface of the trap. We trap ions at a height of 385~mu\\mumum and a radius of 45~mu\\mumum as expected from simulation. We demonstrate that this ring is rotationally symmetric with imperfections in the potential of much less than 3~mK. With two ions contained in a point Paul trap, we demonstrate the creation of a 100~kHz rotating ring using a rotating quadrupole. By releasing the quadrupole potential, we demonstrate the ability to create superpositions of rotational states using the modulation of the laser light produced by the classical rotation of the crystal in a symmetric potential. Superpositions of rotational states differing by up to four quanta are observed. With these rotational superpositions, we describe an experiment capable of observing the identical nature of two ions in a Coulomb crystal. By creating a rotational interferometer, one can coherently exchange two particles and observe their interference upon recombination. We describe what this interference signature would be and how particle indistinguishability would affect it. We present experimental efforts towards realizing this exchange and reflect on our unexpectedly short rotational superposition coherence times.
The quadrupole linear Paul trap is one of the key instruments in building highly stable atomic clocks. However, a frequency reference based on a single trapped ion is limited in stability due to the time needed for the interrogation cycle which cannot be further shortened. A promising strategy is the utilization of multiple trapped ions. The ions of the same kind then repulse each other with the Coulomb force, which is countered by the ponderomotive force of the time depended field in the trap. A few ions form a chain along the axis of a linear Paul trap. Adding more ions (a few tens or hundreds) gives rise to Coulomb crystals. We created an efficient simulation code which calculates the motion of such collections of ions in quasi-static radiofrequency fields of real linear quadrupole traps (including the micromotion). We include a model for laser cooling of the ions. The simulation tool can be used to study the formation and the dynamics of Coulomb crystals under conditions corresponding to various experimental setups.
The superposition of frequency-shifted Laguerre-Gauss modes can produce a rotating saddlelike intensity profile. When spinning fast enough, the optical forces produced by this structured light saddle generate a dynamically stable equilibrium point capable of trapping nanoparticles in a high vacuum, akin to a Paul trap but with its unique characteristics. We analyze the stability conditions and center-of-mass motion, dynamics and cooling of a nanoparticle levitated in the optical saddle trap. We expect the optical saddle to find applications in levitated optomechanics experiments requiring fast parametric modulation and inverted squeezing potential landscapes.
We firstly discuss classical stability for a dynamical system of two ions levitated in a 3D Radio-Frequency (RF) trap, assimilated with two coupled oscillators. We obtain the solutions of the coupled system of equations that characterizes the associated dynamics. In addition, we supply the modes of oscillation and demonstrate the weak coupling condition is inappropriate in practice, while for collective modes of motion (and strong coupling) only a peak of the mass can be detected. Phase portraits and power spectra are employed to illustrate how the trajectory executes quasiperiodic motion on the surface of torus, namely a Kolmogorov–Arnold–Moser (KAM) torus. In an attempt to better describe dynamical stability of the system, we introduce a model that characterizes dynamical stability and the critical points based on the Hessian matrix approach. The model is then applied to investigate quantum dynamics for many-body systems consisting of identical ions, levitated in 2D and 3D ion traps. Finally, the same model is applied to the case of a combined 3D Quadrupole Ion Trap (QIT) with axial symmetry, for which we obtain the associated Hamilton function. The ion distribution can be described by means of numerical modeling, based on the Hamilton function we assign to the system. The approach we introduce is effective to infer the parameters of distinct types of traps by applying a unitary and coherent method, and especially for identifying equilibrium configurations, of large interest for ion crystals or quantum logic.