Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2503.14776

Duality symmetry, zero energy modes and boundary spectrum of the sine-Gordon/massive Thirring model

Parameshwar R. Pasnoori, Ari Mizel, P. Azaria

Published Mar 18, 2025• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We solve the one-dimensional massive Thirring model, which is equivalent to the one-dimensional sine-Gordon model, with two types of Dirchlet boundary conditions: open boundary conditions (OBC) and twisted open boundary conditions ($\widehat{\text{OBC}}$). The system exhibits a duality symmetry which relates models with opposite bare mass parameters and boundary conditions, i.e: $m_0 \leftrightarrow - m_0$, $\text{OBC}\leftrightarrow\widehat{\text{OBC}}$. For $m_0<0$ and OBC, the system is in a trivial phase whose ground state is unique, as in the case of periodic boundary conditions. In contrast, for $m_0<0$ and $\widehat{\text{OBC}}$, the system is in a topological phase characterized by the existence of zero energy modes (ZEMs) localized at each boundary. As dictated by the duality symmetry, for $m_0>0$ and $\widehat{\text{OBC}}$, the trivial phase occurs, whereas the topological phase occurs for $m_0>0$ and OBC. In addition, we analyze the structure of the boundary excitations, finding significant differences between the attractive $(g>0)$ and the repulsive $(g<0)$ regimes.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2503.14776

Related papers

Interplay between symmetry breaking and interactions in a symmetry protected topological phase

Parameshwar R. Pasnoori, P. Azaria

We solve the one dimensional massive Thirring model or equivalently the sine-Gordon model in the repulsive regime with general Dirichlet boundary conditions, which are characterized by two boundary fields $ϕ_{L,R}$ associated with the left and right boundaries respectively. In the presence of these boundary fields, which explicitly break the charge conjugation symmetry, the system exhibits a duality symmetry which changes the sign of the mass parameter $m_0$ and shifts the values of the boundary fields by $ϕ_{L,R}\rightarrow ϕ_{L,R}+π$. When the mass parameter $m_0<0$ and the boundary fields $ϕ_{L,R}=0$, or equivalently due to duality symmetry, when the mass parameter $m_0>0$ and the boundary fields $ϕ_{L,R}=π$, the system is at a trivial point. Here, the ground state is unique just as in the case of periodic boundary conditions. In contrast, when the mass parameter $m_0<0$ and the boundary fields $ϕ_{L,R}=π$, and equivalently due to the duality symmetry, when the mass parameter $m_0>0$ and the boundary fields $ϕ_{L,R}=0$, the system is at a topological point where it exhibits a symmetry protected topological (SPT) phase, which is characterized by the existence of zero energy bound states at both the boundaries. For a given value of the mass parameter $m_0$, we find that these phases remain stable in the presence of symmetry breaking fields at the boundary, provided they are smaller than certain critical values which depend on the strength of the interactions in the bulk. Hence, we show that the stability of the SPT and trivial phases depends on the interplay of the symmetry breaking boundary field values and the bulk interaction strength.

arXiv:2506.19771•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jan 9, 2026•4 citations

The relevancy of the chiral boson to the Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless transition as a boundary effect

Hitoshi Inoue

The sine–Gordon model describes topological phase transitions in 1 + 1 systems, referred to as Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless transitions (BKTT), such as the superfluid–normal fluid, plasma–dielectric and roughening transitions. Analysing the sine–Gordon model in detail using boundary conformal field theory, we develop a new method for treating the BKTT under open boundary conditions (OBC). In particular we find that the chiral parts of the vertex operators are useful for considering the BKTT under OBC.

Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Mar 11, 2010•0 citations

Zero modes and commensurate-incommensurate transitions

C. Mantea, A. Corciovei, A. Stepanescu +1 more

There are two different results concerning the functional relationship between the chemical potential of the 1D massive Thirring model and the misfit parameter of the 1D quantum sine-Gordon model which have been reported [4-7]. In order to investigate this problem, the Jordan boson representation of fermion field operators is used to obtain the bosonized expression of the 1D massive Thirring model. The equivalence of this model with the 1D quantum sine-Gordon model is proved, all zero-mode contributions taken into account. The problem of controversial results previously reported is solved. Thereafter, by means of Bethe-Ansatz method, a new expression for the critical curve of the commensurate-incommensurate transition in the two-dimensional sine-Gordon model is found.

Journal de Physique I•Jan 1, 1992•0 citations

Finite size corrections in the massive Thirring model

T. Fujita, H. Takahashi

We calculate for the first time the finite size corrections in the massive Thirring model. This is done by numerically solving the equations of periodic boundary conditions of the Bethe ansatz solution. It is found that the corresponding central charge extracted from the $1/L$ term is around 0.4 for the coupling constant of ${g}_{0}=\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\pi}/4$ and decreases down to zero when ${g}_{0}=\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\pi}/3.$ This is quite different from the predicted central charge of the sine-Gordon model as well as the light cone six vertex model.

arXiv:hep-th/9706061•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Sep 15, 1998•2 citations

TBA equations for excited states in the sine–Gordon model

János Balog, Árpád Hegedűs

We propose TBA integral equations for multiparticle soliton (fermion) states in the Sine-Gordon (massive Thirring) model. This is based on T-system and Y-system equations, which follow from the Bethe Ansatz solution in the light-cone lattice formulation of the model. Even and odd charge sectors are treated on an equal footing, corresponding to periodic and twisted boundary conditions, respectively. The analytic properties of the Y-system functions are conjectured on the basis of the large volume solution of the system, which we find explicitly. A simple relation between the TBA Y-functions and the counting function variable of the alternative non-linear integral equation (Destri-deVega equation) description of the model is given.

arXiv:hep-th/0304260•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jan 19, 2004•25 citations

Bulk-boundary correspondence in non-equilibrium dynamics of one-dimensional topological insulators

Philipp Jaeger

Dynamical phase transitions (DPT) are receiving a rising interest. They are known to behave analogously to equilibrium phase transitions (EPT) to a large extend. However, it is easy to see that DPT can occur in finite systems, while EPT are only possible in the thermodynamic limit. So far it is not clear how far the analogy of DPT and EPT goes. It was suggested, that there is a relation between topological phase transitions (TPT) and DPT, but many open questions remain. Typically, to study DPT, the Loschmidt echo (LE) after a quench is investigated, where DPT are visible as singularities. For one-dimensional systems, each singularity is connected to a certain critical time scale, which is given by the dispersion in the chain. In topological free-fermion models with winding numbers 0 or 1, only the LE in periodic boundary conditions (PBC) has been investigated. In open boundary conditions (OBC), these models are characterized by symmetry protected edge modes in the topologically non-trivial phase. It is completely unclear how these modes affect DPT. We investigate systems with PBC governed by multiple time scales with a Z topological invariant. In OBC, we provide numerical evidence for the presence of bulk-boundary correspondence in DPT in quenches across a TPT.

•May 24, 2017•1 citation
We solve the one-dimensional massive Thirring model, which is equivalent to the one-dimensional sine-Gordon model, with two types of Dirchlet boundary conditions: open boundary conditions (OBC) and twisted open boundary conditions (OBC^\widehat{\text{OBC}}OBC). The system exhibits a duality symmetry which relates models with opposite bare mass parameters and boundary conditions, i.e: m0↔−m0m_0 \leftrightarrow - m_0m0​↔−m0​, OBC↔OBC^\text{OBC}\leftrightarrow\widehat{\text{OBC}}OBC↔OBC. For m0<0m_0<0m0​<0 and OBC, the system is in a trivial phase whose ground state is unique, as in the case of periodic boundary conditions. In contrast, for m0<0m_0<0m0​<0 and OBC^\widehat{\text{OBC}}OBC, the system is in a topological phase characterized by the existence of zero energy modes (ZEMs) localized at each boundary. As dictated by the duality symmetry, for m0>0m_0>0m0​>0 and OBC^\widehat{\text{OBC}}OBC, the trivial phase occurs, whereas the topological phase occurs for m0>0m_0>0m0​>0 and OBC. In addition, we analyze the structure of the boundary excitations, finding significant differences between the attractive (g>0)(g>0)(g>0) and the repulsive (g<0)(g<0)(g<0) regimes.
We solve the one dimensional massive Thirring model or equivalently the sine-Gordon model in the repulsive regime with general Dirichlet boundary conditions, which are characterized by two boundary fields ϕL,Rϕ_{L,R}ϕL,R​ associated with the left and right boundaries respectively. In the presence of these boundary fields, which explicitly break the charge conjugation symmetry, the system exhibits a duality symmetry which changes the sign of the mass parameter m0m_0m0​ and shifts the values of the boundary fields by ϕL,R→ϕL,R+πϕ_{L,R}\rightarrow ϕ_{L,R}+πϕL,R​→ϕL,R​+π. When the mass parameter m0<0m_0<0m0​<0 and the boundary fields ϕL,R=0ϕ_{L,R}=0ϕL,R​=0, or equivalently due to duality symmetry, when the mass parameter m0>0m_0>0m0​>0 and the boundary fields ϕL,R=πϕ_{L,R}=πϕL,R​=π, the system is at a trivial point. Here, the ground state is unique just as in the case of periodic boundary conditions. In contrast, when the mass parameter m0<0m_0<0m0​<0 and the boundary fields ϕL,R=πϕ_{L,R}=πϕL,R​=π, and equivalently due to the duality symmetry, when the mass parameter m0>0m_0>0m0​>0 and the boundary fields ϕL,R=0ϕ_{L,R}=0ϕL,R​=0, the system is at a topological point where it exhibits a symmetry protected topological (SPT) phase, which is characterized by the existence of zero energy bound states at both the boundaries. For a given value of the mass parameter m0m_0m0​, we find that these phases remain stable in the presence of symmetry breaking fields at the boundary, provided they are smaller than certain critical values which depend on the strength of the interactions in the bulk. Hence, we show that the stability of the SPT and trivial phases depends on the interplay of the symmetry breaking boundary field values and the bulk interaction strength.
The sine–Gordon model describes topological phase transitions in 1 + 1 systems, referred to as Berezinskii–Kosterlitz–Thouless transitions (BKTT), such as the superfluid–normal fluid, plasma–dielectric and roughening transitions. Analysing the sine–Gordon model in detail using boundary conformal field theory, we develop a new method for treating the BKTT under open boundary conditions (OBC). In particular we find that the chiral parts of the vertex operators are useful for considering the BKTT under OBC.
There are two different results concerning the functional relationship between the chemical potential of the 1D massive Thirring model and the misfit parameter of the 1D quantum sine-Gordon model which have been reported [4-7]. In order to investigate this problem, the Jordan boson representation of fermion field operators is used to obtain the bosonized expression of the 1D massive Thirring model. The equivalence of this model with the 1D quantum sine-Gordon model is proved, all zero-mode contributions taken into account. The problem of controversial results previously reported is solved. Thereafter, by means of Bethe-Ansatz method, a new expression for the critical curve of the commensurate-incommensurate transition in the two-dimensional sine-Gordon model is found.
We calculate for the first time the finite size corrections in the massive Thirring model. This is done by numerically solving the equations of periodic boundary conditions of the Bethe ansatz solution. It is found that the corresponding central charge extracted from the 1/L1/L1/L term is around 0.4 for the coupling constant of ${g}_{0}=\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\pi}/4$ and decreases down to zero when ${g}_{0}=\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\pi}/3.$ This is quite different from the predicted central charge of the sine-Gordon model as well as the light cone six vertex model.
We propose TBA integral equations for multiparticle soliton (fermion) states in the Sine-Gordon (massive Thirring) model. This is based on T-system and Y-system equations, which follow from the Bethe Ansatz solution in the light-cone lattice formulation of the model. Even and odd charge sectors are treated on an equal footing, corresponding to periodic and twisted boundary conditions, respectively. The analytic properties of the Y-system functions are conjectured on the basis of the large volume solution of the system, which we find explicitly. A simple relation between the TBA Y-functions and the counting function variable of the alternative non-linear integral equation (Destri-deVega equation) description of the model is given.
Dynamical phase transitions (DPT) are receiving a rising interest. They are known to behave analogously to equilibrium phase transitions (EPT) to a large extend. However, it is easy to see that DPT can occur in finite systems, while EPT are only possible in the thermodynamic limit. So far it is not clear how far the analogy of DPT and EPT goes. It was suggested, that there is a relation between topological phase transitions (TPT) and DPT, but many open questions remain. Typically, to study DPT, the Loschmidt echo (LE) after a quench is investigated, where DPT are visible as singularities. For one-dimensional systems, each singularity is connected to a certain critical time scale, which is given by the dispersion in the chain. In topological free-fermion models with winding numbers 0 or 1, only the LE in periodic boundary conditions (PBC) has been investigated. In open boundary conditions (OBC), these models are characterized by symmetry protected edge modes in the topologically non-trivial phase. It is completely unclear how these modes affect DPT. We investigate systems with PBC governed by multiple time scales with a Z topological invariant. In OBC, we provide numerical evidence for the presence of bulk-boundary correspondence in DPT in quenches across a TPT.