Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2503.11596 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Keldysh pseudofermion functional renormalization group for quantum magnetism

Janik Potten, Yasir Iqbal, Ronny Thomale, Tobias Müller

Published Nov 17, 2025• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The functional renormalization group (FRG) approach for spin models relying on a pseudofermionic description has proven to be a powerful technique in simulating ground-state properties of strongly frustrated magnetic lattices. A drawback of the FRG framework is that it is formulated in the imaginary-time Matsubara formalism and thus only able to access static correlations, a limitation shared with most other many-body approaches. A description of the dynamical properties of magnetic systems is the key to bridging the gap between theory and neutron-scattering spectra. We take the decisive step of expanding the scope of pseudofermion FRG to the Keldysh formalism, which, while originally developed to address nonequilibrium phenomena, enables a direct calculation of the equilibrium dynamical spin structure factors on generic lattices in arbitrary dimensions. We identify the principal features characterizing the low-energy spectra of exemplary zero-, one- and two-dimensional spin-$1/2$ Heisenberg models as well as the Kitaev honeycomb model while identifying current limitations of the method that have to be improved upon.

DOI
10.1103/f26s-mjh2

Related papers

Real frequency approach to frustrated quantum magnetism using the functional renormalization group

Janik Potten

Magnetic materials with predominant antiferromagnetic couplings exhibit a wide range of phenomena arising from the interplay of quantum fluctuations, competing interactions and the underlying lattice geometry. While static properties of quantum magnets have been extensively studied and are often well understood, many of the most distinctive signatures of unconventional magnetic phases – such as fractionalization, confinement, or emergent gauge structures – are encoded in their dynamical response. Predicting these responses in strongly frustrated systems, particularly in two and three dimensions, remains a major theoretical challenge, as analytic solutions are rare and numerical methods are often limited by either dimensionality or the degree of frustration. At the same time, experimental data – e.g. from inelastic neutron scattering – is increasingly available, creating a gap between experiment and theory. To bridge this gap, we develop a real-frequency extension of the PFFRG using the Keldysh formalism, enabling dynamical observables to be computed directly without relying on a numerically unstable analytical continuation required in the Matsubara PFFRG. We derive the full set of Keldysh-indexed flow equations and perform a comprehensive symmetry analysis that is used to substantially reduce the computational effort. Benchmark calculations of the Heisenberg model on the zero-dimensional dimer, the one-dimensional spin chain, and the two-dimensional square lattice as well as the honeycomb Kitaev model show that the method is best suited for systems near the paramagnetic regime, such as quantum spin liquids. We further identify methodological limitations and outline possible extensions, including the incorporation of pseudo-Majorana particles in place of complex pseudo-Fermions, for which we also derive the corresponding flow equations and symmetry relations. With these shortcomings in mind, we apply the Keldysh PFFRG to analyze quantum spin liquid systems on the trellis lattice and the Shastry-Sutherland model and compare to a projected symmetry group approach. For the trellis lattice, the Keldysh PFFRG provides insights into which mean-field Ansätze capture the different phases together with their low-energy excitation spectra. Using optimized density-functional-theory models, we reproduce the spinon-fractionalization and deconfinement signatures observed in inelastic neutron scattering for the trellis compound \( \ce{CaCu2O3} \), and we predict the low-energy dynamical spin structure factor for \(\ce{SrCu2O3}\) and \(\ce{CaV2O5}\). In the Shastry-Sutherland model, the Keldysh PFFRG reveals the same Dirac-cone splitting predicted by the projected symmetry group approach, thereby confirming the connection between the U(1) square-lattice spin-liquid Ansatz proposed by Wen et al. [PRB 65, 165113 (2002)] and the parametrically small quantum spin liquid phase of the Shastry-Sutherland model.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Functional renormalization group approach to SU(N) Heisenberg models: Real-space renormalization group at arbitrary N

Finn Lasse Buessen, Dietrich Roscher, Sebastian Diehl +1 more

The pseudofermion functional renormalization group (pf-FRG) is one of the few numerical approaches that has been demonstrated to quantitatively determine the ordering tendencies of frustrated quantum magnets in two and three spatial dimensions. The approach, however, relies on a number of presumptions and approximations, in particular the choice of pseudofermion decomposition and the truncation of an infinite number of flow equations to a finite set. Here we generalize the pf-FRG approach to $\mathrm{SU}(N)$-spin systems with arbitrary $N$ and demonstrate that the scheme becomes exact in the large-$N$ limit. Numerically solving the generalized real-space renormalization group equations for arbitrary $N$, we can make a stringent connection between the physically most significant case of SU(2) spins and more accessible $\mathrm{SU}(N)$ models. In a case study of the square-lattice $\mathrm{SU}(N)$ Heisenberg antiferromagnet, we explicitly demonstrate that the generalized pf-FRG approach is capable of identifying the instability indicating the transition into a staggered flux spin liquid ground state in these models for large, but finite, values of $N$. In a companion paper [Roscher et al., Phys. Rev. B 97, 064416 (2018)] we formulate a momentum-space pf-FRG approach for $\mathrm{SU}(N)$ spin models that allows us to explicitly study the large-$N$ limit and access the low-temperature spin liquid phase.

arXiv:1711.02182•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Feb 20, 2018•39 citations

Pseudo-fermion functional renormalization group for spin models

Tobias Müller, Dominik Kiese, Nils Niggemann +5 more

Abstract For decades, frustrated quantum magnets have been a seed for scientific progress and innovation in condensed matter. As much as the numerical tools for low-dimensional quantum magnetism have thrived and improved in recent years due to breakthroughs inspired by quantum information and quantum computation, higher-dimensional quantum magnetism can be considered as the final frontier, where strong quantum entanglement, multiple ordering channels, and manifold ways of paramagnetism culminate. At the same time, efforts in crystal synthesis have induced a significant increase in the number of tangible frustrated magnets which are generically three-dimensional in nature, creating an urgent need for quantitative theoretical modeling. We review the pseudo-fermion (PF) and pseudo-Majorana (PM) functional renormalization group (FRG) and their specific ability to address higher-dimensional frustrated quantum magnetism. First developed more than a decade ago, the PFFRG interprets a Heisenberg model Hamiltonian in terms of Abrikosov pseudofermions, which is then treated in a diagrammatic resummation scheme formulated as a renormalization group flow of m-particle pseudofermion vertices. The article reviews the state of the art of PFFRG and PMFRG and discusses their application to exemplary domains of frustrated magnetism, but most importantly, it makes the algorithmic and implementation details of these methods accessible to everyone. By thus lowering the entry barrier to their application, we hope that this review will contribute towards establishing PFFRG and PMFRG as the numerical methods for addressing frustrated quantum magnetism in higher spatial dimensions.

arXiv:2307.10359•Reports on Progress in Physics•Jan 19, 2024•47 citations

Generalizations of Pseudo Majorana Functional Renormalization Group and its Application to Highly Frustrated Spin Systems

Schaden-Thillmann, Yannik

Spin systems are known for their purely interacting nature, causing them to lack a canonical perturbative limit, which usually helps to understand the fundamental physics of a system. A method that has proven effective for the description of strongly correlated systems is Functional Renormalization Group (FRG), which can be thought of as an alternative to the path integral formalism as an approach to many-body quantum mechanics. The basic concept is to cure infrared divergences by introducing a cutoff to correlation functions. Continuously lowering the infrared cutoff and hence allowing the system to occupy lower-lying energy states is called the FRG flow and is formulated in terms of differential equations. The solutions to these equations are functions which describe effective interactions between particles and hence contain information about particle correlations and thermodynamic quantities. Formulating FRG in terms of spins turns out to be a subtle endeavor, though, as the spin algebra relations are relatively complicated compared to, for example, the canonical anti-commutation relations of fermions. In order to use the advantages of FRG for spin systems, one can map spins onto fermionic operators, which leads to pseudo-fermion FRG (PFFRG), developed by Reuther and Wölfle.[198] Alter- natively, one can express spins in terms of Majorana operators, leading to pseudo- Majorana FRG (PMFRG), which has been developed by Niggemann, Sbierski, and Reuther.[163] PMFRG is particularly powerful at finite temperatures, where useful properties of Majorana operators render the method more accurate than PFFRG. In contrast to many other methods, PFFRG and PMFRG are applicable to any spin system, even frustrated ones. In this work, PMFRG is being generalized and applied to highly frustrated spin systems. In particular, spin representations in terms of Majorana operators for spins with arbitrary large spin magnitude S are being investigated and classified thoroughly, which closes a gap in the literature about the second quantization of spin operators. Moreover, it is presented how to generalize PMFRG for Heisenberg models with full SU(2) symmetry to XXZ models exhibiting only a U(1) symmetry. This opens up a wide range of interesting applications for PMFRG. An example is the XXZ model on the pyrochlore lattice, which is known to exhibit conventional long-range order but also exotic spin liquid ground states in the so-called spin ice phase. PMFRG is applied to this model, and the results are being compared to experiments. Furthermore, the entire phase diagram of the XXZ model is being mapped out. Also, the capability of PMFRG to reproduce low-energy field theory predictions and to determine critical exponents is being tested.

•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Multiloop functional renormalization group approach to quantum spin systems

Dominik Kiese, Tobias Müller, Yasir Iqbal +2 more

Renormalization group methods are well-established tools for the (numerical) investigation of the low-energy properties of correlated quantum many-body systems, allowing us to capture their scale-dependent nature. The functional renormalization group (FRG) allows us to continuously evolve a microscopic model action to an effective low-energy action as a function of decreasing energy scales via an exact functional flow equation, which is then approximated by some truncation scheme to facilitate computation. Here, we report on our implementation of multiloop FRG, an extended truncation scheme recently developed for electronic FRG calculations, within the pseudofermion functional renormalization group (pf-FRG) framework for interacting quantum spin systems. We discuss in detail the conceptual intricacies of the flow equations generated by the multiloop truncation, as well as essential refinements to the integration scheme for the resulting integrodifferential equations. To benchmark our approach, we analyze antiferromagnetic Heisenberg models on the pyrochlore, simple cubic, and face-centered cubic lattice, discussing the convergence of physical observables for higher-loop calculations and comparing with existing results where available. Combined, these methodological refinements systematically improve the pf-FRG approach to one of the numerical tools of choice when exploring frustrated quantum magnetism in higher spatial dimensions.

arXiv:2011.01269•Physical Review Research•Jun 6, 2022•56 citations

Spin-functional renormalization group for the J1J2J3 quantum Heisenberg model

Dmytro Tarasevych, Andreas Rückriegel, Savio Keupert +2 more

We use our recently developed functional renormalization group (FRG) approach for quantum spin systems to investigate the phase diagram of the frustrated ${J}_{1}{J}_{2}{J}_{3}$ quantum Heisenberg model on a cubic lattice. From a simple truncation of the hierarchy of FRG flow equations for the irreducible spin vertices, which retains only static spin fluctuations and neglects the flow of the four-spin interaction, we can estimate the critical temperature with a similar accuracy as the numerically more expensive pseudofermion FRG. In the regime where the ground state exhibits either ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic order, a more sophisticated truncation including the renormalization of the four-spin interaction as well as dynamic spin fluctuations reveals the underlying renormalization group fixed point and yields critical temperatures which deviate from the accepted values by at most $4%$.

arXiv:2208.05741•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 14, 2022•10 citations
The functional renormalization group (FRG) approach for spin models relying on a pseudofermionic description has proven to be a powerful technique in simulating ground-state properties of strongly frustrated magnetic lattices. A drawback of the FRG framework is that it is formulated in the imaginary-time Matsubara formalism and thus only able to access static correlations, a limitation shared with most other many-body approaches. A description of the dynamical properties of magnetic systems is the key to bridging the gap between theory and neutron-scattering spectra. We take the decisive step of expanding the scope of pseudofermion FRG to the Keldysh formalism, which, while originally developed to address nonequilibrium phenomena, enables a direct calculation of the equilibrium dynamical spin structure factors on generic lattices in arbitrary dimensions. We identify the principal features characterizing the low-energy spectra of exemplary zero-, one- and two-dimensional spin-1/21/21/2 Heisenberg models as well as the Kitaev honeycomb model while identifying current limitations of the method that have to be improved upon.
Magnetic materials with predominant antiferromagnetic couplings exhibit a wide range of phenomena arising from the interplay of quantum fluctuations, competing interactions and the underlying lattice geometry. While static properties of quantum magnets have been extensively studied and are often well understood, many of the most distinctive signatures of unconventional magnetic phases – such as fractionalization, confinement, or emergent gauge structures – are encoded in their dynamical response. Predicting these responses in strongly frustrated systems, particularly in two and three dimensions, remains a major theoretical challenge, as analytic solutions are rare and numerical methods are often limited by either dimensionality or the degree of frustration. At the same time, experimental data – e.g. from inelastic neutron scattering – is increasingly available, creating a gap between experiment and theory. To bridge this gap, we develop a real-frequency extension of the PFFRG using the Keldysh formalism, enabling dynamical observables to be computed directly without relying on a numerically unstable analytical continuation required in the Matsubara PFFRG. We derive the full set of Keldysh-indexed flow equations and perform a comprehensive symmetry analysis that is used to substantially reduce the computational effort. Benchmark calculations of the Heisenberg model on the zero-dimensional dimer, the one-dimensional spin chain, and the two-dimensional square lattice as well as the honeycomb Kitaev model show that the method is best suited for systems near the paramagnetic regime, such as quantum spin liquids. We further identify methodological limitations and outline possible extensions, including the incorporation of pseudo-Majorana particles in place of complex pseudo-Fermions, for which we also derive the corresponding flow equations and symmetry relations. With these shortcomings in mind, we apply the Keldysh PFFRG to analyze quantum spin liquid systems on the trellis lattice and the Shastry-Sutherland model and compare to a projected symmetry group approach. For the trellis lattice, the Keldysh PFFRG provides insights into which mean-field Ansätze capture the different phases together with their low-energy excitation spectra. Using optimized density-functional-theory models, we reproduce the spinon-fractionalization and deconfinement signatures observed in inelastic neutron scattering for the trellis compound \( \ce{CaCu2O3} \), and we predict the low-energy dynamical spin structure factor for \(\ce{SrCu2O3}\) and \(\ce{CaV2O5}\). In the Shastry-Sutherland model, the Keldysh PFFRG reveals the same Dirac-cone splitting predicted by the projected symmetry group approach, thereby confirming the connection between the U(1) square-lattice spin-liquid Ansatz proposed by Wen et al. [PRB 65, 165113 (2002)] and the parametrically small quantum spin liquid phase of the Shastry-Sutherland model.
The pseudofermion functional renormalization group (pf-FRG) is one of the few numerical approaches that has been demonstrated to quantitatively determine the ordering tendencies of frustrated quantum magnets in two and three spatial dimensions. The approach, however, relies on a number of presumptions and approximations, in particular the choice of pseudofermion decomposition and the truncation of an infinite number of flow equations to a finite set. Here we generalize the pf-FRG approach to SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N)SU(N)-spin systems with arbitrary NNN and demonstrate that the scheme becomes exact in the large-NNN limit. Numerically solving the generalized real-space renormalization group equations for arbitrary NNN, we can make a stringent connection between the physically most significant case of SU(2) spins and more accessible SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N)SU(N) models. In a case study of the square-lattice SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N)SU(N) Heisenberg antiferromagnet, we explicitly demonstrate that the generalized pf-FRG approach is capable of identifying the instability indicating the transition into a staggered flux spin liquid ground state in these models for large, but finite, values of NNN. In a companion paper [Roscher et al., Phys. Rev. B 97, 064416 (2018)] we formulate a momentum-space pf-FRG approach for SU(N)\mathrm{SU}(N)SU(N) spin models that allows us to explicitly study the large-NNN limit and access the low-temperature spin liquid phase.
Abstract For decades, frustrated quantum magnets have been a seed for scientific progress and innovation in condensed matter. As much as the numerical tools for low-dimensional quantum magnetism have thrived and improved in recent years due to breakthroughs inspired by quantum information and quantum computation, higher-dimensional quantum magnetism can be considered as the final frontier, where strong quantum entanglement, multiple ordering channels, and manifold ways of paramagnetism culminate. At the same time, efforts in crystal synthesis have induced a significant increase in the number of tangible frustrated magnets which are generically three-dimensional in nature, creating an urgent need for quantitative theoretical modeling. We review the pseudo-fermion (PF) and pseudo-Majorana (PM) functional renormalization group (FRG) and their specific ability to address higher-dimensional frustrated quantum magnetism. First developed more than a decade ago, the PFFRG interprets a Heisenberg model Hamiltonian in terms of Abrikosov pseudofermions, which is then treated in a diagrammatic resummation scheme formulated as a renormalization group flow of m-particle pseudofermion vertices. The article reviews the state of the art of PFFRG and PMFRG and discusses their application to exemplary domains of frustrated magnetism, but most importantly, it makes the algorithmic and implementation details of these methods accessible to everyone. By thus lowering the entry barrier to their application, we hope that this review will contribute towards establishing PFFRG and PMFRG as the numerical methods for addressing frustrated quantum magnetism in higher spatial dimensions.
Spin systems are known for their purely interacting nature, causing them to lack a canonical perturbative limit, which usually helps to understand the fundamental physics of a system. A method that has proven effective for the description of strongly correlated systems is Functional Renormalization Group (FRG), which can be thought of as an alternative to the path integral formalism as an approach to many-body quantum mechanics. The basic concept is to cure infrared divergences by introducing a cutoff to correlation functions. Continuously lowering the infrared cutoff and hence allowing the system to occupy lower-lying energy states is called the FRG flow and is formulated in terms of differential equations. The solutions to these equations are functions which describe effective interactions between particles and hence contain information about particle correlations and thermodynamic quantities. Formulating FRG in terms of spins turns out to be a subtle endeavor, though, as the spin algebra relations are relatively complicated compared to, for example, the canonical anti-commutation relations of fermions. In order to use the advantages of FRG for spin systems, one can map spins onto fermionic operators, which leads to pseudo-fermion FRG (PFFRG), developed by Reuther and Wölfle.[198] Alter- natively, one can express spins in terms of Majorana operators, leading to pseudo- Majorana FRG (PMFRG), which has been developed by Niggemann, Sbierski, and Reuther.[163] PMFRG is particularly powerful at finite temperatures, where useful properties of Majorana operators render the method more accurate than PFFRG. In contrast to many other methods, PFFRG and PMFRG are applicable to any spin system, even frustrated ones. In this work, PMFRG is being generalized and applied to highly frustrated spin systems. In particular, spin representations in terms of Majorana operators for spins with arbitrary large spin magnitude S are being investigated and classified thoroughly, which closes a gap in the literature about the second quantization of spin operators. Moreover, it is presented how to generalize PMFRG for Heisenberg models with full SU(2) symmetry to XXZ models exhibiting only a U(1) symmetry. This opens up a wide range of interesting applications for PMFRG. An example is the XXZ model on the pyrochlore lattice, which is known to exhibit conventional long-range order but also exotic spin liquid ground states in the so-called spin ice phase. PMFRG is applied to this model, and the results are being compared to experiments. Furthermore, the entire phase diagram of the XXZ model is being mapped out. Also, the capability of PMFRG to reproduce low-energy field theory predictions and to determine critical exponents is being tested.
Renormalization group methods are well-established tools for the (numerical) investigation of the low-energy properties of correlated quantum many-body systems, allowing us to capture their scale-dependent nature. The functional renormalization group (FRG) allows us to continuously evolve a microscopic model action to an effective low-energy action as a function of decreasing energy scales via an exact functional flow equation, which is then approximated by some truncation scheme to facilitate computation. Here, we report on our implementation of multiloop FRG, an extended truncation scheme recently developed for electronic FRG calculations, within the pseudofermion functional renormalization group (pf-FRG) framework for interacting quantum spin systems. We discuss in detail the conceptual intricacies of the flow equations generated by the multiloop truncation, as well as essential refinements to the integration scheme for the resulting integrodifferential equations. To benchmark our approach, we analyze antiferromagnetic Heisenberg models on the pyrochlore, simple cubic, and face-centered cubic lattice, discussing the convergence of physical observables for higher-loop calculations and comparing with existing results where available. Combined, these methodological refinements systematically improve the pf-FRG approach to one of the numerical tools of choice when exploring frustrated quantum magnetism in higher spatial dimensions.
We use our recently developed functional renormalization group (FRG) approach for quantum spin systems to investigate the phase diagram of the frustrated J1J2J3{J}_{1}{J}_{2}{J}_{3}J1​J2​J3​ quantum Heisenberg model on a cubic lattice. From a simple truncation of the hierarchy of FRG flow equations for the irreducible spin vertices, which retains only static spin fluctuations and neglects the flow of the four-spin interaction, we can estimate the critical temperature with a similar accuracy as the numerically more expensive pseudofermion FRG. In the regime where the ground state exhibits either ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic order, a more sophisticated truncation including the renormalization of the four-spin interaction as well as dynamic spin fluctuations reveals the underlying renormalization group fixed point and yields critical temperatures which deviate from the accepted values by at most 44%4.