Computing band gaps of periodic materials via sample-based quantum diagonalization
Alan Duriez, Pamela Costa Carvalho, Marco Antonio Barroca, Federico Zipoli, Ben Jaderberg, Rodrigo Neumann Barros Ferreira, Kunal Sharma, Antonio Mezzacapo, Benjamin H. Wunsch, Mathias Bernhard Steiner
Abstract A key objective of computational solid-state physics is to predict electronic properties of periodic materials. However, electronic structure simulations based on density functional theory fail to predict experimental results if correlations are not properly accounted for. Here, we report a sample-based quantum diagonalization workflow for simulating electronic states of periodic materials and for predicting their band gaps. To that end, we devise a general lattice Hamiltonian representation in which material-specific, electronic interaction parameters are obtained self-consistently. Two exemplar, wide-gap materials—hafnium dioxide and zirconium dioxide—are expressed as quantum circuits that leverage the lattice representation with a materials-specific parametrization. We sample the quantum circuits on a state-of-the-art, superconducting quantum processor and diagonalize the lattice Hamiltonian in the reduced configuration subspaces with standard techniques. Our method outperforms select quantum-chemical benchmarks as well as approaches based on density functional theory, the standard reference in materials simulation of solids. Importantly, the quantum-computed band gap predictions for the two dielectrics agree with independent lab experiments. In essence, quantum-classical hybrid simulation workflows on pre-fault-tolerant quantum computers produce useful, experimentally verifiable property predictions in applied materials science.
Abstract A key objective of computational solid-state physics is to predict electronic properties of periodic materials. However, electronic structure simulations based on density functional theory fail to predict experimental results if correlations are not properly accounted for. Here, we report a sample-based quantum diagonalization workflow for simulating electronic states of periodic materials and for predicting their band gaps. To that end, we devise a general lattice Hamiltonian representation in which material-specific, electronic interaction parameters are obtained self-consistently. Two exemplar, wide-gap materials—hafnium dioxide and zirconium dioxide—are expressed as quantum circuits that leverage the lattice representation with a materials-specific parametrization. We sample the quantum circuits on a state-of-the-art, superconducting quantum processor and diagonalize the lattice Hamiltonian in the reduced configuration subspaces with standard techniques. Our method outperforms select quantum-chemical benchmarks as well as approaches based on density functional theory, the standard reference in materials simulation of solids. Importantly, the quantum-computed band gap predictions for the two dielectrics agree with independent lab experiments. In essence, quantum-classical hybrid simulation workflows on pre-fault-tolerant quantum computers produce useful, experimentally verifiable property predictions in applied materials science.
Understanding emergent many-body phenomena in correlated materials remains one of the grandest challenges in solid-state quantum chemistry calculations. The individuality of electrons diminishes as correlation increases, which leads to the emergence of new features in the system. Seeking to address such problems accurately requires the aid of non-perturbative many-body techniques as well as the corresponding high-quality basis sets. In periodic systems, a given element may be present in different spatial arrangements displaying vastly different physical and chemical properties, and an elemental basis set independent of the physical properties of materials may lead to significant simulation inaccuracies. In fact, with the rapid progress of quantum chemistry methods in condensed-phase simulations, the need for a library of reliable Gaussian basis sets explicitly designed for periodic calculations has become urgent. In the meantime, the development of parameter-free, systematic and reliable quantum chemistry methods for simultaneously treating weak and strong correlations in periodic systems has never stopped. Their ability to treat realistic solid materials needs to be tested, and the obtained results can serve as benchmarks for empirical parameter-guided solid-state calculations. In this thesis, we present numerical studies of various solid-state systems, emphasizing the design and optimization of Gaussian basis sets and assessing the band structure properties of the periodic solid systems. The work begins by introducing the theoretical framework of the electronic structure theory and presenting the fundamentals of a fully self-consistent GW approximation and the self-energy embedding theory (SEET) in Chapters 2 and 3. It continues with a description of the Gaussian basis set optimization scheme we devised for solid-state quantum chemistry calculations. The scheme we present is designed to avoid a lack of material specificity within a given basis set by simultaneously minimizing the total energy of the system and optimizing the band energies when compared to the reference plane wave calculation while accounting for the overlap matrix condition number. We compare the quality of the Gaussian basis sets generated via our method against the existing basis sets. And the optimization scheme is tested to yield improved results. We finally present a quantitative study of electronic properties of realistic materials with the treatment of Green's function based weakly correlated self-consistent GW approximation and the strongly correlated self-energy embedding theory. In the transition metal oxide BiVO3, we found the inaccurate illustration of orbitals including t_{2g} in transition metal Vanadium by DFT. Our calculation shows a systematic trend of DFT failure in illustrating both insulating and metallic solutions, demonstrating the dangers of using DFT when the experimental data is scarce.
Diazirines and diazo compounds are widely employed as photoreactive precursors for generating carbenes, key intermediates in chemical biology and materials science. However, computationally modeling their reaction pathways remains challenging due to the need for large active spaces and the requirement to accurately capture excited-state surfaces along with transition states and conical intersections. In this work, we utilize a hybrid quantum-classical workflow for investigating carbene formation in representative diazirine-diazomethane systems. Our approach leverages Sample-based Quantum Diagonalization (SQD) and its extended variant, Extended Sample-based Quantum Diagonalization (Ext-SQD), for ground- and excited-state analysis, combined with classical tools for geometry optimization, active-space selection, and diagnostic evaluation. Quantum computations were carried out on superconducting quantum processors, and results for both aliphatic and aryl-substituted diazirine-diazomethane pairs were benchmarked against established classical methods, including density functional theory (DFT), coupled cluster with singles and doubles (CCSD), complete active space configuration interaction (CASCI), and selected configuration interaction (SCI). SQD achieves accuracy surpassing the chemical accuracy threshold for nearly all stationary points on the potential energy surface of parent diazirine relative to the CASCI(12,10) reference, and remains close to chemical accuracy for phenyl-substituted diazirine in a (30,30) active space, with an average deviation of 1.1 kcal/mol relative to the SCI benchmark. SQD closely follows CASCI and SCI trends, showing consistent agreement. The findings demonstrate the promise of quantum computing frameworks in modeling photochemical transformations of electronically complex and pharmacologically relevant molecules.
Quantum-chemical simulations are essential for predicting energies of chemical reactions. Accurately solving the many-body Schrödinger equation for reagent and product states of most relevant chemical processes is, however, unfeasible. Quantum computing offers a pathway for predicting energies of correlated electronic systems with localized interactions. Here, we apply a quantum embedding approach for investigating oxygen reduction reactions at the electrode surface in Lithium batteries, a representative example of energetic analysis in localized chemical reactions. We employ an active space selection method based on density difference analysis for identifying the orbitals involved in the reaction. Leveraging the Local Unitary Cluster Jastrow ansatz for state preparation, the active-space orbitals are then processed on a quantum computer. As quantum algorithms, we use Sample-based Quantum Diagonalization, SQD, and its extended version, Ext-SQD, which integrates electronic excitations into the quantum-selected electronic configuration subspace. The largest configurations are represented by quantum circuits mapped onto 80 qubits of an IBM Heron R2 quantum processing unit. For up to 12 orbitals, we are able to benchmark the quantum-computed reaction energies against results obtained with Complete Active Space Configuration Interaction. For benchmarking results in active spaces as large as 32 orbitals, we resort to Heat-Bath Configuration Interaction and Coupled Cluster Singles and Doubles calculations, respectively. At 27 orbitals, the Ext-SQD results exhibit prediction accuracy improvements with regard to the standard, quantum-chemical reference methods that remain computationally feasible at that scale. The results indicate the potential of sample-based quantum diagonalization for performing high-accuracy reaction modeling in chemistry and materials science.
Development of quantum architectures during the last decade has inspired hybrid classical-quantum algorithms in physics and quantum chemistry that promise simulations of fermionic systems beyond the capability of modern classical computers, even before the era of quantum computing fully arrives. Strong research efforts have been recently made to obtain minimal depth quantum circuits which could accurately represent chemical systems. Here, we show that unprecedented methods used in quantum chemistry, designed to simulate molecules on quantum processors, can be extended to calculate properties of periodic solids. In particular, we present minimal depth circuits implementing the variational quantum eigensolver algorithm and successfully use it to compute the band structure of silicon on a quantum machine for the first time. We are convinced that the presented quantum experiments performed on cloud-based platforms will stimulate more intense studies towards scalable electronic structure computation of advanced quantum materials.
Quantum computation offers a promising path towards efficient calculations of the electronic structure of correlated materials. The properties of iron-based materials, which are key for advancing geological and astrophysical understanding, are notoriously difficult to calculate with classical computers. However, despite the many recent advances in quantum computing on near intermediate scale quantum hardware, a full treatment of the electronic structure of high-Z atoms or molecules remains challenging. Here, we investigate the ground-state properties of molecular FeO and Fe2O2 model Hamiltonians using classical exact diagonalization, Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE), and Sample-based Quantum Diagonalization (SQD). The experimental quintet ground state of FeO is recovered classically and with quantum algorithms, while a nonet ground state is recovered for Fe2O2. Although raw VQE does not achieve chemical accuracy for the ground state of FeO or Fe2O2, SQD with two connectivity shells recovers the exact ground energy for both molecules utilizing remarkably few quantum computational resources. Overall, our results indicate that abinitio-informed low-energy models of correlated materials, combined with SQD, offer a new alternative for scaling up calculations of ground-state properties of strongly correlated solids on existing quantum hardware.
We present a quantum-classical hybrid algorithm that simulates electronic structures of periodic systems such as ground states and quasiparticle band structures. By extending the unitary coupled cluster (UCC) theory to describe crystals in arbitrary dimensions, for a hydrogen chain, we numerically demonstrate that the UCC ansatz implemented on a quantum circuit can be successfully optimized with a small deviation from the exact diagonalization over the entire range of the potential energy curves. Furthermore, by using the quantum subspace expansion method, in which we truncate the Hilbert space within the linear response regime from the ground state, the quasiparticle band structure is computed as charged excited states. Our work establishes a powerful interface between the rapidly developing quantum technology and modern material science.