Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2503.09924

Quantum Velocity Averaging (or Not...) in the Semiclassical Regime

François Golse, Jakob Möller

Published Mar 13, 2025• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This paper discusses the possibility of applying the velocity averaging theorems in [F. Golse, P.-L. Lions, B. Perthame, R. Sentis: J. Funct. Anal. 76(1):110--125, 1988] to the Wigner equation governing the quantum evolution of the Wigner transform of quantum density operators. Our first main results address the case of the Wigner function of a special class of density operators associated to mixed states, whose Hilbert-Schmidt norm is of order $\hbar^{d/2}$, where $d$ is the space dimension and $\hbar$ the reduced Planck constant. In space dimension $d=1$, we prove that the density function belongs to the Sobolev space $H^s(\mathbb R)$ for some $s>0$. In the case of pure states, we first obtain a characterization of the Wigner transform of rank-one quantum density operators, and apply this characterization (1) to analyze a rather general setting in which velocity averaging cannot apply to the Wigner functions of a family of rank-one density operators whose evolution is governed by the von Neumann equation, and (2) to obtain a quick derivation of Madelung's system of quantum hydrodynamic equations. This derivation provides a physical explanation of one key assumption used in the proof of the negative result (1) described above.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2503.09924

Related papers

Semiclassical evolution with low regularity

François Golse, Thierry Paul

We prove semiclassical estimates for the Schrödinger-von Neumann evolution with C1,1 potentials and density matrices whose square root have either Wigner functions with low regularity independent of the dimension, or matrix elements between Hermite functions having long range decay. The estimates are settled in different weak topologies and apply to initial density operators whose square root have Wigner functions 7 times differentiable, independently of the dimension. They also apply to the N-body quantum dynamics uniformly in N and to concentrating pure and mixed states without any regularity assumption. In a appendix, we finally estimate the dependence in the dimension of the constant appearing on the Calderón-Vaillancourt Theorem. Nous démontrons des estimations semi-classiques pour l'équation de Schrödinger-von Neumann avec potentiel C1,1 et des matrices densité initiales dont la racine carrée a soit une fonction de Wigner de faible régularité indépendante de la dimension, soit des éléments de matrice entre fonctions d'Hermite à décroissance lente. Les estimations sont exprimées dans diverses topologies faibles et s'appliquent à des matrices densité dont la racine carrée a une fonction de Wigner 7 fois différentiable, indépendamment de la dimension. Elles s'appliquent aussi à la dynamique quantique à N corps uniformément en N, et, sans aucune hypothèse de régularité, à des états mixtes ou purs se concentrant à la limite classique. Enfin, nous estimons dans un appendice la dépendance en la dimension de la constante apparaissant dans le théorème de Calderón-Vaillancourt.

arXiv:2011.14884•Journal de Mathématiques Pures et Appliquées•Feb 18, 2021•12 citations

Wigner Function: from Ensemble Average of Density Operator to Its One Matrix Element in Entangled Pure States

Fan Hong‐Yi

We show that the Wigner function (an ensemble average of the density operator ρ, Δ is the Wigner operator) can be expressed as a matrix element of ρ in the entangled pure states. In doing so, converting from quantum master equations to time-evolution equation of the Wigner functions seems direct and concise. The entangled states are defined in the enlarged Fock space with a fictitious freedom.

Communications in Theoretical Physics•Nov 15, 2002•2 citations

Decoherence of semiclassical Wigner functions

Alfredo M. Ozorio de Almeida

The Lindblad master equation governs the general Markovian evolution of a density operator for an open quantum system. Semiclassical Wigner functions represent density operators in phase space in terms of chords on a classical manifold, so that the amplitude and phase of each chord contribution is classically defined. Inserting such a Wigner function into a phase space version of the master equation, its explicit evolution is derived in the absence of dissipation. There results a simple extension of the unitary evolution of the semiclassical Wigner function, which does not affect the phase of each chord contribution, while dampening its amplitude exponentially. Projecting the Wigner function on to an orthogonal position or momentum basis, the dampening of long chords emerges as the exponential decay of off-diagonal elements of the density matrix.

arXiv:quant-ph/0208094•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Dec 12, 2002•16 citations

Time evolution of the Wigner function

Francisco Soto, P. Claverie

In this paper we give a partial answer to the problem: When does an initially non-negative Wigner function remain non-negative under the effect of the time evolution? We show that, for pure states, this is the case for linear systems only; to prove this we use the fact that the Wigner function is non-negative if and only if the wavefunction is Gaussian. We also prove that the Green’s solution of the evolution equation of the Wigner function, which in the framework of probability theory corresponds to the conditional probability density, takes on negative values. We utilize a theorem, about moments, borrowed from Pawula. We conclude that the Wigner phase-space formulation of quantum mechanics cannot receive a genuine probabilistic interpretation.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•May 1, 1983•22 citations

The Wigner representation of quantum mechanics

Valerian I. Tatarskii

Correct use of the Wigner representation of quantum mechanics, which is realized with joint distributions of quasiprobabilities in phase space, requires the use of certain specific rules and attention to a number of properties which distinguish the quasiprobability from a true probability. This paper is mainly concerned with these problems. In the Wigner representation the quantum Liouville equation appears instead of the Schroedinger equation. The solution may have no physical meaning unless it is subjected to a necessary and sufficient condition which selects an allowed class of distributions which describe quantum-mechanical pure states. This condition contains Planck's constant and imposes, besides the uncertainty relations, severe restrictions on the possible form of the Wigner function. When this condition is satisfied, one can reconstruct the wave function from the Wigner function. In the case of an oscillator, the quantization condition for the energies of the stationary states does not follow from the Liouville equation, but from this supplementary condition. Unlike the true probability density, any Wigner function (except Gaussian ones) of a pure state takes on negative values. Another important peculiarity is that the quasiprobability is not concentrated on certain hypersurfaces, but is smeared out over the entire phase space. These and other features considered in this paper should be kept in mind when using the Wigner representation in quantum-mechanical problems.

Soviet Physics Uspekhi•Apr 30, 1983•480 citations

Weyl Transform in Nonrelativistic Quantum Dynamics

Boris Leaf

The Weyl transform is applied in quantum dynamics to derive and extend Moyal's statistical theory of phase-space distributions for noncommuting coordinate and momentum operators. The distinction is made between Weyl transforms in Schrödinger and Heisenberg pictures; the general case of time-dependent Hamiltonians is considered. The Wigner function for the probability distribution in a phase space of Cartesian coordinates Q and momenta K propagates according to a conditional probability P(t, Q, K | t0, Q0, K0), which is exhibited as a Feynman path integral in phase space. Properties of P(t, Q, K | t0, Q0, K0) are developed; it is expressed in terms of the quantum generalization of the classical Liouville operator. The Weyl transform of a Heisenberg operator propagates according to P(t, Q0, K0 | t0, Q, K) which is also given as a Feynman path integral. An equation for the time evolution of Weyl transforms of Heisenberg operators is obtained, according to which the transform of Heisenberg coordinate and momentum operators obey a quantum form of Hamilton's equations of motion. If the initial density operator of the system commutes with the coordinate operator, then the state of the system is a mixture of pure coordinate states; the spectrum of the density operator in this case is continuous. For a Heisenberg operator AH(t) with Weyl transform AH(t, Q, K), the function A(t,Q)=∫dKAH(t,Q,K) is the expectation at time t of the dynamical property for a quantum system initially in a pure state of coordinate Q; it is the quantum-mechanical generalization of the dynamical property of the system along the classical trajectory in configuration space at time t. The probability amplitude for the time dependence of A(t,Q) can be expressed as a Feynman path integral with a Heisenberg Lagrangian. The amplitude of the conditional probability P(t, Q | t0, Q0) considered by Feynman is expressed as a path integral with a Schrödinger Lagrangian. The velocity in the Heisenberg Lagrangian is the negative of that in the Schrödinger Lagrangian of Feynman, but it agrees with the velocity appearing in the Hamiltonian equations. It is the Heisenberg Lagrangian that is the Lagrangian of classical dynamics. For a particle whose potential energy is a function of position, a quantum form of Newton's second law is obtained. An extension of the formalism to non-Cartesian coordinate systems is given.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•May 1, 1968•44 citations
This paper discusses the possibility of applying the velocity averaging theorems in [F. Golse, P.-L. Lions, B. Perthame, R. Sentis: J. Funct. Anal. 76(1):110--125, 1988] to the Wigner equation governing the quantum evolution of the Wigner transform of quantum density operators. Our first main results address the case of the Wigner function of a special class of density operators associated to mixed states, whose Hilbert-Schmidt norm is of order ℏd/2\hbar^{d/2}ℏd/2, where ddd is the space dimension and ℏ\hbarℏ the reduced Planck constant. In space dimension d=1d=1d=1, we prove that the density function belongs to the Sobolev space Hs(R)H^s(\mathbb R)Hs(R) for some s>0s>0s>0. In the case of pure states, we first obtain a characterization of the Wigner transform of rank-one quantum density operators, and apply this characterization (1) to analyze a rather general setting in which velocity averaging cannot apply to the Wigner functions of a family of rank-one density operators whose evolution is governed by the von Neumann equation, and (2) to obtain a quick derivation of Madelung's system of quantum hydrodynamic equations. This derivation provides a physical explanation of one key assumption used in the proof of the negative result (1) described above.
We prove semiclassical estimates for the Schrödinger-von Neumann evolution with C1,1 potentials and density matrices whose square root have either Wigner functions with low regularity independent of the dimension, or matrix elements between Hermite functions having long range decay. The estimates are settled in different weak topologies and apply to initial density operators whose square root have Wigner functions 7 times differentiable, independently of the dimension. They also apply to the N-body quantum dynamics uniformly in N and to concentrating pure and mixed states without any regularity assumption. In a appendix, we finally estimate the dependence in the dimension of the constant appearing on the Calderón-Vaillancourt Theorem. Nous démontrons des estimations semi-classiques pour l'équation de Schrödinger-von Neumann avec potentiel C1,1 et des matrices densité initiales dont la racine carrée a soit une fonction de Wigner de faible régularité indépendante de la dimension, soit des éléments de matrice entre fonctions d'Hermite à décroissance lente. Les estimations sont exprimées dans diverses topologies faibles et s'appliquent à des matrices densité dont la racine carrée a une fonction de Wigner 7 fois différentiable, indépendamment de la dimension. Elles s'appliquent aussi à la dynamique quantique à N corps uniformément en N, et, sans aucune hypothèse de régularité, à des états mixtes ou purs se concentrant à la limite classique. Enfin, nous estimons dans un appendice la dépendance en la dimension de la constante apparaissant dans le théorème de Calderón-Vaillancourt.
The Lindblad master equation governs the general Markovian evolution of a density operator for an open quantum system. Semiclassical Wigner functions represent density operators in phase space in terms of chords on a classical manifold, so that the amplitude and phase of each chord contribution is classically defined. Inserting such a Wigner function into a phase space version of the master equation, its explicit evolution is derived in the absence of dissipation. There results a simple extension of the unitary evolution of the semiclassical Wigner function, which does not affect the phase of each chord contribution, while dampening its amplitude exponentially. Projecting the Wigner function on to an orthogonal position or momentum basis, the dampening of long chords emerges as the exponential decay of off-diagonal elements of the density matrix.
In this paper we give a partial answer to the problem: When does an initially non-negative Wigner function remain non-negative under the effect of the time evolution? We show that, for pure states, this is the case for linear systems only; to prove this we use the fact that the Wigner function is non-negative if and only if the wavefunction is Gaussian. We also prove that the Green’s solution of the evolution equation of the Wigner function, which in the framework of probability theory corresponds to the conditional probability density, takes on negative values. We utilize a theorem, about moments, borrowed from Pawula. We conclude that the Wigner phase-space formulation of quantum mechanics cannot receive a genuine probabilistic interpretation.
Correct use of the Wigner representation of quantum mechanics, which is realized with joint distributions of quasiprobabilities in phase space, requires the use of certain specific rules and attention to a number of properties which distinguish the quasiprobability from a true probability. This paper is mainly concerned with these problems. In the Wigner representation the quantum Liouville equation appears instead of the Schroedinger equation. The solution may have no physical meaning unless it is subjected to a necessary and sufficient condition which selects an allowed class of distributions which describe quantum-mechanical pure states. This condition contains Planck's constant and imposes, besides the uncertainty relations, severe restrictions on the possible form of the Wigner function. When this condition is satisfied, one can reconstruct the wave function from the Wigner function. In the case of an oscillator, the quantization condition for the energies of the stationary states does not follow from the Liouville equation, but from this supplementary condition. Unlike the true probability density, any Wigner function (except Gaussian ones) of a pure state takes on negative values. Another important peculiarity is that the quasiprobability is not concentrated on certain hypersurfaces, but is smeared out over the entire phase space. These and other features considered in this paper should be kept in mind when using the Wigner representation in quantum-mechanical problems.
The Weyl transform is applied in quantum dynamics to derive and extend Moyal's statistical theory of phase-space distributions for noncommuting coordinate and momentum operators. The distinction is made between Weyl transforms in Schrödinger and Heisenberg pictures; the general case of time-dependent Hamiltonians is considered. The Wigner function for the probability distribution in a phase space of Cartesian coordinates Q and momenta K propagates according to a conditional probability P(t, Q, K | t0, Q0, K0), which is exhibited as a Feynman path integral in phase space. Properties of P(t, Q, K | t0, Q0, K0) are developed; it is expressed in terms of the quantum generalization of the classical Liouville operator. The Weyl transform of a Heisenberg operator propagates according to P(t, Q0, K0 | t0, Q, K) which is also given as a Feynman path integral. An equation for the time evolution of Weyl transforms of Heisenberg operators is obtained, according to which the transform of Heisenberg coordinate and momentum operators obey a quantum form of Hamilton's equations of motion. If the initial density operator of the system commutes with the coordinate operator, then the state of the system is a mixture of pure coordinate states; the spectrum of the density operator in this case is continuous. For a Heisenberg operator AH(t) with Weyl transform AH(t, Q, K), the function A(t,Q)=∫dKAH(t,Q,K) is the expectation at time t of the dynamical property for a quantum system initially in a pure state of coordinate Q; it is the quantum-mechanical generalization of the dynamical property of the system along the classical trajectory in configuration space at time t. The probability amplitude for the time dependence of A(t,Q) can be expressed as a Feynman path integral with a Heisenberg Lagrangian. The amplitude of the conditional probability P(t, Q | t0, Q0) considered by Feynman is expressed as a path integral with a Schrödinger Lagrangian. The velocity in the Heisenberg Lagrangian is the negative of that in the Schrödinger Lagrangian of Feynman, but it agrees with the velocity appearing in the Hamiltonian equations. It is the Heisenberg Lagrangian that is the Lagrangian of classical dynamics. For a particle whose potential energy is a function of position, a quantum form of Newton's second law is obtained. An extension of the formalism to non-Cartesian coordinate systems is given.