Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:2503.09876

A New Circle Theorem for Two Dimensional Ising Spin Glasses

Chaoming Song

Published Mar 12, 2025• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Lee-Yang circle theorem revolutionized our understanding of phase transitions in ferromagnetic systems by showing that the complex zeros of partition functions lie on the unit circle, with criticality arising as these zeros approach the real axis in the thermodynamic limit. However, in frustrated systems such as antiferromagnets and spin glasses, the zeros deviate from this structure, making it challenging to extend the Lee-Yang theory to disordered systems. In this work, we establish a new circle theorem for two-dimensional Ising spin glasses, proving that the square of the partition function exhibits zeros densely packed along the unit circle. Numerical simulations on the square lattice confirm our theoretical predictions, demonstrating the validity of the circle law for quenched disorder. Furthermore, our results uncover a finite-temperature crossover in $\pm J$ spin glasses, characterized by the emergence of a spectral gap in the angular distribution of zeros. This result extends the Lee-Yang framework to disordered systems, offering new insights into spin-glass criticality.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.2503.09876

Related papers

Yang-Lee Zeros of the Antiferromagnetic Ising Model

Seung‐Yeon Kim

There exists the famous circle theorem on the Yang-Lee zeros of the ferromagnetic Ising model. However, the Yang-Lee zeros of the antiferromagnetic Ising model are much less well understood than those of the ferromagnetic model. The precise distribution of the Yang-Lee zeros of the antiferromagnetic Ising model only with nearest-neighbor interaction J on LxL square lattices is determined as a function of temperature a=e(2betaJ) (J<0), and its relation to the phase transitions is investigated. In the thermodynamic limit (L-->infinity), the distribution of the Yang-Lee zeros of the antiferromagnetic Ising model cuts the positive real axis in the complex x=e(-2betaH) plane, resulting in the critical magnetic field +/-H(c)(a), where H(c)>0 below the critical temperature a(c)=square root of 2-1. The results suggest that the value of the scaling exponent y(h) is 1 along the critical line for a<a(c).

Physical Review Letters•Sep 23, 2004•68 citations

Theorems on the Ising Model with General Spin and Phase Transition

Masuo Suzuki

The theorem of Lee and Yang has been extended to the ferromagnetic Ising model with arbitrarily mixed spin values of Sj = ½, 1, and 32, including the case of equal spin values as a special one. Namely, it has been proved that the zeros of the partition function for the above Ising model with higher spin values lie on the unit circle in the fugacity plane (or complex magnetic-field plane). Expressions for general correlation functions in Ising ferromagnets with higher spin values have been derived in terms of the above generalized theorem. By the use of these expressions, the relations among the critical indices are discussed and the same results are obtained as those predicted by the scaling-law approach.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 1968•33 citations

Density of Yang-Lee zeros in the thermodynamic limit from tensor network methods

Artur García-Sáez, Tzu-Chieh Wei

The distribution of Yang-Lee zeros in the ferromagnetic Ising model in both two and three dimensions is studied on the complex field plane directly in the thermodynamic limit via the tensor network methods. The partition function is represented as a contraction of a tensor network and is efficiently evaluated with an iterative tensor renormalization scheme. The free-energy density and the magnetization are computed on the complex field plane. Via the discontinuity of the magnetization, the density of the Yang-Lee zeros is obtained to lie on the unit circle, consistent with the Lee-Yang circle theorem. Distinct features are observed at different temperatures---below, above, and at the critical temperature. Application of the tensor network approach is also made to the $q$-state Potts models in both two and three dimensions and a previous debate on whether, in the thermodynamic limit, the Yang-Lee zeros lie on a unit circle for $q>2$ is resolved: they clearly do not lie on a unit circle except at the zero temperature. For the Potts models $(q=3,4,5,6)$ investigated in two dimensions, as the temperature is lowered the radius of the zeros at a fixed angle from the real axis shrinks exponentially towards unity with the inverse temperature.

arXiv:1508.07751•Physical Review B•Sep 17, 2015•17 citations

Yang-Lee zeros of two-dimensional nearest-neighbor antiferromagnetic Ising models: A numerical linked cluster expansion study

Mahmoud Abdelshafy, Muhammad Sedik

We study Yang-Lee zeros as they approach the thermodynamic limit of the two-dimensional (2D) nearest-neighbor antiferromagnetic Ising model on square and triangular lattices. We employ the numerical linked cluster expansion (NLCE) equipped with exact enumeration (EE) of the partition function to estimate the Laplacian of the free energy, which is proportional to the zeros density. Using a modified NLCE, where the expansion can be carried directly on the Yang-Lee zeros of the involved clusters, we estimate the density of Yang-Lee zeros in the thermodynamic limit. NLCE gives significantly more zeros than EE in the complex field plane providing more insights on how the root curves look in the thermodynamic limit. For the square lattice at $T\ensuremath{\ll}{T}_{c}$, the results suggest that two vertical lines at $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}{h}_{c}(T)$ in the complex field plane (i.e., two concentric circles in the complex fugacity plane) are the thermodynamic root curves. A similar picture is found for the triangular lattice for phase transitions at large values of magnetic field while further study is needed for phase transitions at smaller values of magnetic field. The convergence of the NLCE and (EE) calculations of the partition function to the thermodynamic limit is studied in both lattices and the temperature-field phase diagram is obtained from Yang-Lee zeros using both methods. This NLCE-based approach will facilitate the study of different types of phase transitions using Yang-Lee zeros in future research.

arXiv:2503.14602•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 8, 2025•2 citations

Distribution of Zeros of the Partition Function in the First and Second Order Phase Transitions: Extension of the Lee-Yang Theorem

Keiji Yamada, H. Nakano, Mamoru Yamashita

The distribution of zeros of the partition function for one-dimensional lattice system of generalized Ising spins with magnitude unity is studied, where it is assumed that the component spins interact with the nearest neighbours through a ferromagnetic coupling and each spin state has a certain degeneracy. The spin states are denoted by variable σ which can take either of three values, plus and minus unities and zero with the respective degeneracies, D(1), D(0) and D(-1), where it is assumed D(1) = D(-1). zeros of the partition function Z(ζ) of the system as exposed to an external magnetic field are studied on the ζ-plane, where ζ=exp(H) indicates the exponential function of the external field divided by temperature H and it is regarded as a complex number. The distribution of zeros is classified into three typical patterns, corresponding to the respective three regions on the plane of temperature(T) versus degneracy ratio (ρ=D(0)/D(1)): Zeros never lie on the unit circle in the region of larger ρ, all on the unit circle in the region of smaller ρ and only a part on the unit circle in the remaining region. On the basic of this result, it is expected in the case of two- or three-dimensional system that phase trasitions of first and second orders occur in tha cases of ρ larger and smaller than acritical calue ρc, respectively.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•May 1, 1981•7 citations

Zeros of the Partition Function for the Heisenberg, Ferroelectric, and General Ising Models

Masuo Suzuki, Michael Ellis Fisher

The Lee-Yang theorem for the zeros of the partition function of a ferromagnetic Ising model with real pair spin interactions is extended to general Ising models with complex many-spin interactions (satisfying appropriate ``ferromagnetic'' and spin inversion symmetry conditions). When many-spin interactions are present, all zeros lie on the imaginary Hz-axis for sufficiently low (but fixed) T, but, in general, some leave the imaginary axis as T → ∞. The extended Ising theorem is used to prove the same result for a Heisenberg system of arbitrary spin with the real anisotropic pair interaction Hamiltonian Hij=−(JijzSizSjz+JijxSixSjx+JijySiySjy)in an arbitrary transverse field (Hx, Hy) under the ``ferromagnetic'' condition Jijz≥|Jijx| and Jijz≥|Jijy|. The analyticity of the limiting free energy of such a Heisenberg ferromagnet and the absence of a phase transition are thereby established for all (real) nonzero magnetic fields Hz. The Ising theorem is also applied to hydrogen-bonded ferroelectric models to prove, in particular, that the zeros for the KDP model lie on the imaginary electric field axis for all T below the transition temperature Tc.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 1971•178 citations
The Lee-Yang circle theorem revolutionized our understanding of phase transitions in ferromagnetic systems by showing that the complex zeros of partition functions lie on the unit circle, with criticality arising as these zeros approach the real axis in the thermodynamic limit. However, in frustrated systems such as antiferromagnets and spin glasses, the zeros deviate from this structure, making it challenging to extend the Lee-Yang theory to disordered systems. In this work, we establish a new circle theorem for two-dimensional Ising spin glasses, proving that the square of the partition function exhibits zeros densely packed along the unit circle. Numerical simulations on the square lattice confirm our theoretical predictions, demonstrating the validity of the circle law for quenched disorder. Furthermore, our results uncover a finite-temperature crossover in ±J\pm J±J spin glasses, characterized by the emergence of a spectral gap in the angular distribution of zeros. This result extends the Lee-Yang framework to disordered systems, offering new insights into spin-glass criticality.
There exists the famous circle theorem on the Yang-Lee zeros of the ferromagnetic Ising model. However, the Yang-Lee zeros of the antiferromagnetic Ising model are much less well understood than those of the ferromagnetic model. The precise distribution of the Yang-Lee zeros of the antiferromagnetic Ising model only with nearest-neighbor interaction J on LxL square lattices is determined as a function of temperature a=e(2betaJ) (J<0), and its relation to the phase transitions is investigated. In the thermodynamic limit (L-->infinity), the distribution of the Yang-Lee zeros of the antiferromagnetic Ising model cuts the positive real axis in the complex x=e(-2betaH) plane, resulting in the critical magnetic field +/-H(c)(a), where H(c)>0 below the critical temperature a(c)=square root of 2-1. The results suggest that the value of the scaling exponent y(h) is 1 along the critical line for a<a(c).
The theorem of Lee and Yang has been extended to the ferromagnetic Ising model with arbitrarily mixed spin values of Sj = ½, 1, and 32, including the case of equal spin values as a special one. Namely, it has been proved that the zeros of the partition function for the above Ising model with higher spin values lie on the unit circle in the fugacity plane (or complex magnetic-field plane). Expressions for general correlation functions in Ising ferromagnets with higher spin values have been derived in terms of the above generalized theorem. By the use of these expressions, the relations among the critical indices are discussed and the same results are obtained as those predicted by the scaling-law approach.
The distribution of Yang-Lee zeros in the ferromagnetic Ising model in both two and three dimensions is studied on the complex field plane directly in the thermodynamic limit via the tensor network methods. The partition function is represented as a contraction of a tensor network and is efficiently evaluated with an iterative tensor renormalization scheme. The free-energy density and the magnetization are computed on the complex field plane. Via the discontinuity of the magnetization, the density of the Yang-Lee zeros is obtained to lie on the unit circle, consistent with the Lee-Yang circle theorem. Distinct features are observed at different temperatures---below, above, and at the critical temperature. Application of the tensor network approach is also made to the qqq-state Potts models in both two and three dimensions and a previous debate on whether, in the thermodynamic limit, the Yang-Lee zeros lie on a unit circle for q>2q>2q>2 is resolved: they clearly do not lie on a unit circle except at the zero temperature. For the Potts models (q=3,4,5,6)(q=3,4,5,6)(q=3,4,5,6) investigated in two dimensions, as the temperature is lowered the radius of the zeros at a fixed angle from the real axis shrinks exponentially towards unity with the inverse temperature.
We study Yang-Lee zeros as they approach the thermodynamic limit of the two-dimensional (2D) nearest-neighbor antiferromagnetic Ising model on square and triangular lattices. We employ the numerical linked cluster expansion (NLCE) equipped with exact enumeration (EE) of the partition function to estimate the Laplacian of the free energy, which is proportional to the zeros density. Using a modified NLCE, where the expansion can be carried directly on the Yang-Lee zeros of the involved clusters, we estimate the density of Yang-Lee zeros in the thermodynamic limit. NLCE gives significantly more zeros than EE in the complex field plane providing more insights on how the root curves look in the thermodynamic limit. For the square lattice at $T\ensuremath{\ll}{T}_{c}$, the results suggest that two vertical lines at $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}{h}_{c}(T)$ in the complex field plane (i.e., two concentric circles in the complex fugacity plane) are the thermodynamic root curves. A similar picture is found for the triangular lattice for phase transitions at large values of magnetic field while further study is needed for phase transitions at smaller values of magnetic field. The convergence of the NLCE and (EE) calculations of the partition function to the thermodynamic limit is studied in both lattices and the temperature-field phase diagram is obtained from Yang-Lee zeros using both methods. This NLCE-based approach will facilitate the study of different types of phase transitions using Yang-Lee zeros in future research.
The distribution of zeros of the partition function for one-dimensional lattice system of generalized Ising spins with magnitude unity is studied, where it is assumed that the component spins interact with the nearest neighbours through a ferromagnetic coupling and each spin state has a certain degeneracy. The spin states are denoted by variable σ which can take either of three values, plus and minus unities and zero with the respective degeneracies, D(1), D(0) and D(-1), where it is assumed D(1) = D(-1). zeros of the partition function Z(ζ) of the system as exposed to an external magnetic field are studied on the ζ-plane, where ζ=exp(H) indicates the exponential function of the external field divided by temperature H and it is regarded as a complex number. The distribution of zeros is classified into three typical patterns, corresponding to the respective three regions on the plane of temperature(T) versus degneracy ratio (ρ=D(0)/D(1)): Zeros never lie on the unit circle in the region of larger ρ, all on the unit circle in the region of smaller ρ and only a part on the unit circle in the remaining region. On the basic of this result, it is expected in the case of two- or three-dimensional system that phase trasitions of first and second orders occur in tha cases of ρ larger and smaller than acritical calue ρc, respectively.
The Lee-Yang theorem for the zeros of the partition function of a ferromagnetic Ising model with real pair spin interactions is extended to general Ising models with complex many-spin interactions (satisfying appropriate ``ferromagnetic'' and spin inversion symmetry conditions). When many-spin interactions are present, all zeros lie on the imaginary Hz-axis for sufficiently low (but fixed) T, but, in general, some leave the imaginary axis as T → ∞. The extended Ising theorem is used to prove the same result for a Heisenberg system of arbitrary spin with the real anisotropic pair interaction Hamiltonian Hij=−(JijzSizSjz+JijxSixSjx+JijySiySjy)in an arbitrary transverse field (Hx, Hy) under the ``ferromagnetic'' condition Jijz≥|Jijx| and Jijz≥|Jijy|. The analyticity of the limiting free energy of such a Heisenberg ferromagnet and the absence of a phase transition are thereby established for all (real) nonzero magnetic fields Hz. The Ising theorem is also applied to hydrogen-bonded ferroelectric models to prove, in particular, that the zeros for the KDP model lie on the imaginary electric field axis for all T below the transition temperature Tc.